Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
How do you explain the density if it's rock?

Sorry did they take into account transmission thru the plasma around the comet?

they used a global outgassing rate.

The fact the probe itself was charged?

Seems they have just used a very mathamagical "Best Estimate" guess. METHOD

but your 533 kg/m3 best guess is in trouble
The
67P nucleus has a dust-to-water mass ratio of six from 3.6 au to
perihelion (Rotundi et al. 2015; Fulle et al. 2016). At perihelion and
just after, the dust-to-water mass ratio ranges from 6 to 100 (Fulle
et al. 2016).
Unexpected and significant findings in comet
67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view



And the fact Philae "bounced" of the surface twice, MUPUS-PEN could not make any headway into the surface of the comet and the spectral slope was red and the big one IT LOOKS LIKE ROCK.

Other wise, why doe the well consolidated material, your dirty ice, not sublimate? Even after all these years there is still no explination.

The description of the surface as well consolidated material which by the very definition is not "fluffy and porous" along with "layered bedrock", lack of any large voids and the fact the nucleus is homogeneous with most of the dust
mass in compact particles of 2000 kgm−3 on average (Rotundi et al.
2015), makes the density questionable, to say the least.

There is less and less "ice" to "save" the dirtysnowball!
 

I seem to remember discussions about mHz oscillations, I'd have to look for the paper again. But it is long as I remember and I have my own papers and abstracts to finish that I want to send to my co-authors before christmas
 
I've read the paper.

You are either toying with us or you MUST tow the party line to be able to put food on the table!

Could you imagine if Rosetta was able to cross these current layers, double layers and plasma instabilities at a more perpendicular angle!

145kv Potential drop a lot? Seems to me that's a lot of ooomph to give to a particle!

We could move onto the the dust in that paper, Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley, some very interesting findings there.

Have you read the paper jd116, the man, self sim, jean tate?
 
I've read the paper.

Well then if you have read it, then give a summary.

You are either toying with us or you MUST tow the party line to be able to put food on the table!

whatever ...

Could you imagine if Rosetta was able to cross these current layers, double layers and plasma instabilities at a more perpendicular angle!

What does this even mean?!?!
If you would read my current sheet paper then you would see how they are crossed.
You cannot cross an instability "more perpendicular".

145kv Potential drop a lot? Seems to me that's a lot of ooomph to give to a particle!

Seems like a large value, but like I say it has been years since I read that paper, so ...

We could move onto the the dust in that paper, Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley, some very interesting findings there.

you can move onto anything you see fit.
 
Last edited:
Dancing David called it!

because a magic fairy created electric comets and solves all their issues
never mind observed mass and volume
:D

Sorry did they take into account transmission thru the plasma around the comet?

they used a global outgassing rate.

The fact the probe itself was charged?

Seems they have just used a very mathamagical "Best Estimate" guess. METHOD


Here’s the abstract from Sol's link:

Cometary nuclei consist mostly of dust and water ice1. Previous observations have found nuclei to be low-density and highly porous bodies2,3,4, but have only moderately constrained the range of allowed densities because of the measurement uncertainties. Here we report the precise mass, bulk density, porosity and internal structure of the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko on the basis of its gravity field. The mass and gravity field are derived from measured spacecraft velocity perturbations at fly-by distances between 10 and 100 kilometres. The gravitational point mass is GM = 666.2 ± 0.2 cubic metres per second squared, giving a mass M = (9,982 ± 3) × 109 kilograms. Together with the current estimate of the volume of the nucleus5, the average bulk density of the nucleus is 533 ± 6 kilograms per cubic metre. The nucleus appears to be a low-density, highly porous (72–74 per cent) dusty body, similar to that of comet 9P/Tempel 12,3. The most likely composition mix has approximately four times more dust than ice by mass and two times more dust than ice by volume. We conclude that the interior of the nucleus is homogeneous and constant in density on a global scale without large voids. The high porosity seems to be an inherent property of the nucleus material.


Sounds like the density was determined through measurements, not magic or guessing. But when you don’t understand 7th grade science and are afraid of simple math it probably is, as Arthur C. Clarke noted, indistinguishable from magic. Note the references to high porosity, in addition to the 0.533 gm/cc density.

but your 533 kg/m3 best guess is in trouble Unexpected and significant findings in comet
67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view


Please explain what your dust to water ratio quote was about. It sounds like a reference to outgassing and, if so, has nothing to do with comet density . My guess is you’ll ignore this question.

And the fact Philae "bounced" of the surface twice, MUPUS-PEN could not make any headway into the surface of the comet and the spectral slope was red and the big one IT LOOKS LIKE ROCK.

Other wise, why doe the well consolidated material, your dirty ice, not sublimate? Even after all these years there is still no explination.


All debunked long ago in this thread. Pretending it hasn’t been is dishonest.

The description of the surface as well consolidated material which by the very definition is not "fluffy and porous" along with "layered bedrock", lack of any large voids and the fact the nucleus is homogeneous with most of the dust
mass in compact particles of 2000 kgm−3 on average (Rotundi et al.
2015), makes the density questionable, to say the least.

There is less and less "ice" to "save" the dirtysnowball!


I know I’ve corrected you at least once when you presented particle density figures and tried to pass them off as the bulk density of the comet. I know others here have corrected you on separate occasions. So when you do it again, it means you’re either uneducable or being dishonest.
 
Last edited:
Your insinuation of fraud is despicable. I think you owe tusenfem an apology.

Fraud? Ignorance? Gullibility? Institutional blindness?

Not sure which one you mean?

When asked about double layers at a comet is was a resounding NO WAY!!!!

but


Second transition at 360,000 km on Vega1
The former gradientcorresponds to a potential drop of ~50kV over the current layer .According to these observation the thicknes of the current layer is about 10,000 km.

Interestingly most dust grains observed as sudden spikes in the
L2 data, are detected within M1 (Figure1 4);see also Laakso et al.
[ 1989]. This indicates that the dust grains are electrically charged
and coupled with cometary plasma. For comparison Vaisberg et
al. [1986] detected the first dust particle at a cometocentric distance of 320,000 km.

The thickness of the CP (COMETOPAUSE)is ~10,000 km. It has a positively charged outer surface and a negatively
charged inner surface. This value corresponds to a potential drop of 50-100 kV.

Current Layer at 54,000 km on Vega I
the thickness of which was about 7000 km.
A sudden burst of energetic ions( >40 keV) was also measured between the discontinuities given above
According to these measurement the total potential drop over the boundary is of the order of 135 kV.

Being electrically charged dust particles are confined within the current layer.
Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley H Laakso

When mentioned in connection with

11 Conclusions This first study of current sheets in the coma of 67P/CG shows that strong rotations of the draped magnetic field occur that are similar to those observed during earlier mis sions at comet 1P/Halley. A relatively quiet solar wind period during of one of the early pyramidal orbits, 2 - 9 June, showed reasonably “well behaved” nested draping with some rotations of the field direction from sunward to anti-sunward and vice versa. The esti mated current densities during the rotations are below that determined for the boundary of the diamagnetic cavity and below estimates for the maximum using measured electron densities and velocities. Rotations with a strong “guide field” do not show a electron density peak near Bx = 0, whereas “regular” rotations, where Bm ! 0 show a centrally peaking density. The current sheets cannot be considered boundaries between different plasma populations and there is no indication of accelerated ions generated by magnetic reconnection.
Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko’s coma M. Volwerk1, G. H. Jones2;3, T. Broiles4, J. Burch5, C. Carr6, A. J. Coates2;3, E. Cupido6, M.
3 Delva1, N. J. T. Edberg7, A. Eriksson7, C. Goetz8, R. Goldstein5, P. Henri9, H. Madanian10,
H. Nilsson11, I. Richter8, K. Schwingenschuh1, G. StenbergWieser11and K.-H. Glassmeier8



Someone's wrong Fred Burfle??? Who?
 
and when the electric fields on the cometary surface remove dust and accelerate it off of the nucleus.....
Dust particles hit the spacecraft with velocities of the order of 75-80 kms and are vaporized and ionized /10/, giving rise to plasma clouds which expand isotropically with the velocity of the ions and to current which are detected by the probes.
IMPACTS OF LARGE DUST PARTICLES ON THE VEGA SPACECRAFT
H. Laakso, R. Grard, A. Pedersen and 0. Schwehm

THE ELECTRIC COMET!!!!

Did you ever talk with Laakso Tusenfem?
 
Dancing David called it!
Here’s the abstract from Sol's link:

​


Sounds like the density was determined through measurements, not magic or guessing. But when you don’t understand 7th grade science and are afraid of simple math it probably is, as Arthur C. Clarke noted, indistinguishable from magic. Note the references to high porosity, in addition to the 0.533 gm/cc density.




Please explain what your dust to water ratio quote was about. It sounds like a reference to outgassing and, if so, has nothing to do with comet density . My guess is you’ll ignore this question.




All debunked long ago in this thread. Pretending it hasn’t been is dishonest.




I know I’ve corrected you at least once when you presented particle density figures and tried to pass them off as the bulk density of the comet. I know others here have corrected you on separate occasions. So when you do it again, it means you’re either uneducable or being dishonest.

I, unfortunately for you Fred Burfle, do understand that. What you have is a HUGE problem with your density guess.

See bolded.

Paint me a picture of how you envisage using the below MAINSTREAM ASSUMPTIONS, the material the comets is made of???
A large dust-to-water mass ratio implies that the nucleus matrix is non-volatile, so that ground-based experiments (Gr¨un et al. 1993) and thermo-physical models of cometary nuclei (Prialnik, Benkoff & Podolak 2004), assuming an ice matrix, may provide misleading results: they should be repeated assuming a refractory matrix, which has micro-properties far from ices. The larger the dust-to-water ratio, the larger the porosity required to fit the observed nucleus bulk density. The RSI (P¨atzold et al. 2016) and the CONSERT (Kofman et al. 2015) experiments exclude macro-porosity at scales above 100 m. CONSERT experiment provides a micro-porosity between 75 per cent and 85 per cent (Kofman et al. 2015). Hapke models provide a surface porosity of 87 per cent (Fornasier et al. 2015).
Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

You are smart enough to realize the bulk porosity of 87 per cent (Fornasier et al. 2015), is a dirtysnowball model KILLER! How in the real world can you measure, even using Doppler shifts in the RSI, the density of a comet when the Philea probe returned results that falsify that assumption!

This was known some time ago
There is as yet no reason to abandon our intuitive estimates that cometary densities should be near 1g/cm3 based on the dirty snowball model of Whipple (1950). A secure value of the density
of any cometary nucleus must await a spacecraft rendezvous with that nucleus.
On the Density of Halley's Comet S. J. PEALE


Houston, the mainstream have a problem!
 
Last edited:
Fraud? Ignorance? Gullibility? Institutional blindness?

Not sure which one you mean?

When asked about double layers at a comet is was a resounding NO WAY!!!!

but


Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley H Laakso

When mentioned in connection with

Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko’s coma M. Volwerk1, G. H. Jones2;3, T. Broiles4, J. Burch5, C. Carr6, A. J. Coates2;3, E. Cupido6, M.
3 Delva1, N. J. T. Edberg7, A. Eriksson7, C. Goetz8, R. Goldstein5, P. Henri9, H. Madanian10,
H. Nilsson11, I. Richter8, K. Schwingenschuh1, G. StenbergWieser11and K.-H. Glassmeier8



Someone's wrong Fred Burfle??? Who?

And neither paper mentions double layers.
EC/ES/EU people should finally get it into their minds that every double layer is an electric field but not every electric field is a double layer.
 
The thickness of the CP (COMETOPAUSE)is ~10,000 km. It has a positively charged outer surface and a negatively
charged inner surface. This value corresponds to a potential drop of 50-100 kV.

What would the super duper plasma physicist best describe the above as?
 
Sol88: Lies about a charge distribution being a double layer

What would the super duper plasma physicist best describe the above as?
Any one can answer:
22 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about a charge distribution being a double layer.
As he knows, the scales of double layers according to Hannes Alfvén and textbooks are a few tens of Debye lengths. The Debye length of comet coma is not listed but is likely to be less than ~10 meters as in the solar wind (Debye length decreases with increasing density) :jaw-dropp!
 
Sol88: Insults tusenfem and lies about tusenfem's "No EC-electric fields" post

22 December 2017 Sol88: Insults tusenfem and lies about tusenfem's "No EC-electric fields" post.

This is that the electric field between the Sun and comets in his comet delusions has never been detected at comets. The electric fields that have been detected at comets are those expected fro the interaction between the solar wind and neutral atoms and grains being ejected from a comet.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Sol88: A lie about a magnetic signature of comet tail paper being an answer

22 December 2017 Sol88: A lie about a magnetic signature of comet tail paper being an answer to a question.

22 December 2017 Sol88: Stupidity that the length of comet tails somehow means comets are made of rock.
That comets have gas tails and often dust tails is predicted by the "dirty snowball" model and matches observations.
 
Any one can answer:
22 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about a charge distribution being a double layer.
As he knows, the scales of double layers according to Hannes Alfvén and textbooks are a few tens of Debye lengths. The Debye length of comet coma is not listed but is likely to be less than ~10 meters as in the solar wind (Debye length decreases with increasing density) :jaw-dropp!

So, rc, you are completely clueless :blush:

Do you actually have any idea? I thought we’d ask the expert!

You know, just to make things clear. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom