Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
But comets are dirtysnowballs, so we are looking at dustysnow here and NOT rock.

So interesting we see no sublimation and even if there was....

Same paper

The comet activity is associated with the liberation of particles from its surface by the sublimation of the abundant volatile ices. We then investigate whether a size segregation produced by these activities could explain the observed pebble population (size in the mm-cm range). MUPUS indicates strengths far larger than typical gas pressures caused by the sublimation of the ices (Spohn et al. 2015). This would imply that the dust grains cannot be currently detached from the surface seen by Philae by the gas pressure of the sublimating ices.

Is that not what Skorov is saying also here?

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

???
 
But comets are dirtysnowballs, so we are looking at dustysnow here and NOT rock.

So interesting we see no sublimation and even if there was....

No, you keep on forgetting what the dirtysnowball model is, even though I have quoted it from Whipple several times, and it is in my review paper, which I know you have:

Whipple 1950 Abstract said:
The nucleus is visualized as a conglomerate of ices, such as H2O, NH3, CH4, C02 or CO, (C2N2?), and other possible materials volatile at room temperature,combined in a conglomerate with meteoric materials, all initially at extremely low temperatures ( <50° K).
Vaporization of the ices by externally applied solar radiation leaves an outer matrix of nonvolatile insulating meteoric material

I am (not really) sure that you can find out what meteoritic material is.
 
More irrelevance from Sol, that has already been covered multiple times. Yes, Philae did detect water. It was, obviously, the highest abundance molecule detected.

CHO-bearing organic compounds at the surface of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko revealed by Ptolemy
Wright, I. P. et al.
http://science.sciencemag.org/conte...df?ijkey=aHBmOfK2h1kKQ&keytype=ref&siteid=sci

Secondly, as already pointed out a squillion times, CASSE/ SESAME did not detect anything remotely rock-like in the hammering from MUPUS.

Thirdly, Skorov and co-authors are ascribing the smaller grains to spin-up and fragmentation in the coma.

In short, there is nothing to see here. Merely repeating the same nonsense multiple times, is not going to resurrect the debunked, discredited electric comet woo.
Ever heard the 'Dead Parrot' sketch? Guess which role you're playing?
 
No, you keep on forgetting what the dirtysnowball model is, even though I have quoted it from Whipple several times, and it is in my review paper, which I know you have:



I am (not really) sure that you can find out what meteoritic material is.

But just a thin layer of dust shuts off sublimation!

So you have a conundrum!
 
But just a thin layer of dust shuts off sublimation!

So you have a conundrum!

Nope. It just means that there is ice not far from the surface. This is obviously the case, as patches of it can be resolved on the surface. Some of them rather large. That includes CO2 ice, as well as H2O ice. I'm sure I don't need to link to all that again, do I?
 
No, you keep on forgetting what the dirtysnowball model is, even though I have quoted it from Whipple several times, and it is in my review paper, which I know you have

Or, indeed, any interested party could simply read Whipple's paper:

A Comet Model. I. The Acceleration of Comet Encke.
Whipple, F. L. (1950)
http://adsbit.harvard.edu//full/1950ApJ...111..375W/0000375.000.html

Remarkable, given the lack of observations at the time, how accurate the model was. Conversely, 56 years later, despite having far more data and observations to work with, Wallace & Gromit managed to get things so horribly wrong!
That would be due to the fact that Whipple was a qualified scientist, and the aforementioned woo merchants aren't. There is a lesson in there, somewhere.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Insanity of agreeing that comets have densities < water

Oh, ok then...
29 January 2018 Sol88: Insanity of agreeing that comets have densities that are less than that of water and going onto his comets are rocks delusions!

29 January 2018 Sol88: Regurgitation of the lie that ices and dust comet papers support his comets are rocks delusions.

29 January 2018 Sol88: Usual lie that ices do not exist ("ice") to derail from his comets are rocks delusions

19 January 2018 Sol88: Not understanding what classic means to derail from his comet delusions.
 
15 December 2014: Electric comets still do not exist!

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

Over 2 years and counting of fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.

The parroting of the Thunderbolt cult ignorance, delusions and lies in this thread alone (continuation of a thread that is now 8 years of delusions from Sol88)
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.

603 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 18 January 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 18 January 2018 Sol88: The idiocy of "dogma" raises its ugly head which is ironic from the unthinking cult follower of actual dogma !
  2. 18 January 2018 Sol88: Repeats the lie that any problems with the working comet model is support for his comet delusions.
  3. 19 January 2018 Sol88: His insistence of writing posts full of ignorance, delusions and lies and recording them not spam.
  4. 19 January 2018 Sol88: Idiotic questions to derail from is comet delusions with the stupidity of not knowing that scientific models can be revised when new data is collected.
  5. 19 January 2018 Sol88: Lies about what he quotes from Yu. V. Skorov.
  6. 19 January 2018 Sol88: A lie of "confusion" about basic English to derail from his comet delusions.
  7. 19 January 2018 Sol88: Outgassing rate lies to derail from his comet delusions.
  8. 19 January 2018 Sol88: Persists in the lie that any problems with the working comet model are support for his comet delusions.
  9. 19 January 2018 Sol88: Lies about an ices and dust paper again.
  10. 19 January 2018 Sol88: A lie about Hu, X. et al to derail from his comet delusions.
  11. 19 January 2018 Sol88: Not understanding what classic means to derail from his comet delusions.
  12. 19 January 2018 Sol88: Lies about my post which was about real comets not the insane electric comet delusions.
  13. 29 January 2018 Sol88: Insanity of agreeing that comets have densities that are less than that of water and going onto his comets are rocks delusions!
  14. 29 January 2018 Sol88: Regurgitation of the lie that ices and dust comet papers support his comets are rocks delusions.
  15. 29 January 2018 Sol88: Usual lie that ices do not exist ("ice") to derail from his comets are rocks delusions.
 
Cheers rc, some good stuff there! :rolleyes:

Anywhoo, change of tack.

Let’s discuccs, shall we?

An investigation into potential causes of the anomalistic feature observed by the Rosetta Alice spectrograph around 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

abstract
The Alice far-ultraviolet spectrograph in operation around the comet 67P/Churyumov– Gerasimenko on the Rosetta spacecraft experiences an anomalistic feature (AF) that is ubiquitous at comet separations less than 450 km. This feature is highly temporally variable and displays no relation to any studied parameters with the exception of comet separation. This paper tests several possible causes with simulations and finds that positive ions produce a partial explanation for the anomaly, but still finds no definitive source of the AF.

Chameleon and may suggest the possibility that the instrument is immersed in a nano/micrograin or charged particle environment, some of which may pass through the Alice slit.

7. Conclusion
The Chameleon AF has provided an interesting puzzle for the Alice team to solve and has proven difficult to characterize, but currently, its impact on the science mis- sion is minimal. The wide spread of the Chameleon's counts will likely mean an inability to detect any Ne 736 Å and will likely cause issues with the O 834 Å emission line as well. Simulations of ion and of dust in the Alice instrument to determine the source of the Chameleon produced promising results from the positive ion simula- tions that partially explain the AF, but these are not con- clusive results and need to be pursued further. For future
UVS missions to unique environments in terms of dust, ions, and electrons, more research into this AF will deter- mine if there are possible instrument enhancements that could mitigate the appearance of the Chameleon.

Mmmmm..interesting...
Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity

abstract
We have investigated through simulation the electrostatic charging of the nucleus of Comet 67P/Chur- yumov–Gerasimenko during periods of weak outgassing activity. Specifically, we have modeled the surface potential and electric field at the surface of the nucleus during the initial Rosetta rendezvous at 3.5 AU and the release of the Philae lander at 3 AU. We have also investigated the possibility of dust acceleration and ejection above the nucleus due to electrostatic forces. Finally, we discuss these modeling results in the context of possible observations by instruments on both the Rosetta orbiter and the Philae lander.

Maybe connected?
 
Cheers rc, some good stuff there! :rolleyes:

Anywhoo, change of tack.

Let’s discuccs, shall we?

An investigation into potential causes of the anomalistic feature observed by the Rosetta Alice spectrograph around 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko







Mmmmm..interesting...
Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity



Maybe connected?

Nope. One paper is about possible electrostatic charging of dust at LARGE heliocentric distances. The other is about an anomaly with the ALICE spectrograph at ALL distances.
And I didn't even need to re-read the papers to know that.
 
Nope. One paper is about possible electrostatic charging of dust at LARGE heliocentric distances. The other is about an anomaly with the ALICE spectrograph at ALL distances.
And I didn't even need to re-read the papers to know that.


Ahhhh, I see the problem here, in your books dust charging is only “possible”! :confused:

The dust IS charged not possibly. :thumbsup:

And the charged dust moving off the surface in “jets” constitutes an electric current.

Just a straight up question for you jd116, Captain Swoop, is the dust charged?

From the nucleus out to all distances measured by probes so far.
 
Sol88: Lies about the contents of papers to derail from his comet delusions

Ahhhh, I see the problem here,....
30 January 2018 Sol88: Lies about the contents of papers to derail from his comet delusions.

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity is a possible mechanism which has never been detected at a comet.
ETA: And only possible at large distances from the Sun when there are no jets (see his later "jets" idiocy).

An investigation into potential causes of the anomalistic feature observed by the Rosetta Alice spectrograph around 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko is an anomaly in the Alice spectrograph that might be caused by charged particles entering the instrument.

Neither paper is about his comet delusions.
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.

30 January 2018 Sol88: The irreverent fantasy that the Rosetta spacecraft took measurements at the comet nucleus.
The Rosetta spacecraft took measurements during its orbits of the comet nucleus which were tens of kilometers away from the comet nucleus.

And the charged dust moving off the surface in “jets” constitutes an electric current.
30 January 2018 Sol88: Lies about his comet delusions where jets are electrical discharges, not charged dust.

30 January 2018 Sol88: A "jet" lie when we see jets of neutral gas from sublimating ices and no charged dust from the surface.

30 January 2018 Sol88: Insane charged dust question to derail from his comet delusions.
He knows that we have detected charged and neutral dust in the coma of 67P so of course there is charged and neutral dust in the coma of 67P :jaw-dropp!
This is the real world where sunlight and solar wind collisions charge neutral grains of dust.

Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Three-dimensional kinetic modeling of the neutral and charged dust in the coma of Rosetta's target comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
 
Last edited:
Ahhhh, I see the problem here, in your books dust charging is only “possible”! :confused:

YOU linked to the electrostatic charging of dust on the NUCLEUS paper.. If you'd bothered to read even the title of that paper, you will see that it is possible only at LARGE HELIOCENTRIC DISTANCES.

The dust IS charged not possibly. :thumbsup:

Not on the nucleus at lower heliocentric distances. Read the paper.

And the charged dust moving off the surface in “jets” constitutes an electric current.

Lol. A) It isn't charged when leaving the nucleus at low heliocentric distances.
B) Even if it were, it does not constitute a current! Dear me.
C) If there were a current, do you not think it would be measured?

Just a straight up question for you jd116, Captain Swoop, is the dust charged?

Not on the nucleus at low heliocentric distances.

From the nucleus out to all distances measured by probes so far.

Nope.
 
YOU linked to the electrostatic charging of dust on the NUCLEUS paper.. If you'd bothered to read even the title of that paper, you will see that it is possible only at LARGE HELIOCENTRIC DISTANCES.



Not on the nucleus at lower heliocentric distances. Read the paper.



Lol. A) It isn't charged when leaving the nucleus at low heliocentric distances.
B) Even if it were, it does not constitute a current! Dear me.
C) If there were a current, do you not think it would be measured?



Not on the nucleus at low heliocentric distances.



Nope.

Jeez, your are bloody good. :D

No instrument on Rosetta is capable of measuring these nanograins, but they are able to constrain the parameters of the larger dust particles that the nanograins most likely originate from. GIADA has observed “fluffy” dust particles [3], that might be sensitive to the spacecraft's potential, and could create a mechanism to supply low charge nanograins.
An investigation into potential causes of the anomalistic feature observed by the Rosetta Alice spectrograph around 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Such insight, jd116.

What does the GIADA instrument observe?

4.Discussion

Fluffy particles are porous aggregates of submicron grains pro-.ducedfromthenucleus Theyrangeinsizefrom0.2to2.5mmandtheirequivalentbulkdensityisupto1kgm−3.They are charged,fragmented,and decelerated by the spacecraft negative potential and enter GIADA in showers of fragments at speeds<1ms−1(Fulle etal.,2015a).
GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Righto then.

What about the COSSIMA instrument?

The shattered cometary dust particles are composed of subgrains that are tens of micrometres in diameter [13]. The interaction of the cometary particles with the spacecraft electric eld due to its potential of the order of up to 20V has been described as a process potentially causing the disruption of cometary dust particles prior to collection and/or detection resulting in particle showers as the particles approach the negative potential of the spacecraft [14]. Dust particles and surfaces being exposed to the local plasma, electrical and magnetic elds and solar radiation are charged and interact with the local plasma environment by a balance of the various charging currents [15]. Dust particle charging is assumed to cause cometary particle fragmentation in the coma, but has not been observed in the dust particle uxes of comet 67P [12,16]. The capacity and electrical conductivity of dust particles are material properties applied in the modelling of dustplasma interactions and the potential ejection of dust particles due to electrostatic forces from the nucleus surface [17,18].
Mechanical and electrostatic experiments with dust particles collected in the inner comaofcomet67PbyCOSIMA onboard Rosetta

And you are still comfy with centrifugal “spin up” of dust, jd116?


Mmmmm, ok then.
 
Last edited:
Jeez, your are bloody good. :D

An investigation into potential causes of the anomalistic feature observed by the Rosetta Alice spectrograph around 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Such insight, jd116.

What does the GIADA instrument observe?

GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Righto then.

What about the COSSIMA instrument?

Mechanical and electrostatic experiments with dust particles collected in the inner comaofcomet67PbyCOSIMA onboard Rosetta

And you are still comfy with centrifugal “spin up” of dust, jd116?


Mmmmm, ok then.

More irrelevance. Try to actually read what you quote, it would save the rest of us having to continually correct you. Nowhere, in any of those papers, is any reference made to the particles being charged at the nucleus. The fluffy grains, in particular, can become charged in the coma plasma "by cold solar wind ions and electrons, photoelectrons, coma electrons, and the secondary electrons induced by hot and cold plasma components."

DENSITY AND CHARGE OF PRISTINE FLUFFY PARTICLES FROM COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV–GERASIMENKO
Fulle, M. et al
http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/2041-8205/802/1/L12/meta

They are then further negatively charged and fragmented due to the spacecraft negative potential.
This method of charging dust in the coma has been known about for some time. It isn't a new discovery that requires any sort of explanation from woo merchants whose credibilty (such as it was!) has been shattered by this mission. I'm sure you can find Mendis writing about this in the 80s.

As for ALICE, they concluded that it could be dust causing the AF, however;
"This paper tests several possible causes with simulations and finds that positive ions produce a partial explanation for the anomaly, but still finds no definitive source of the AF."

So, ions look a better bet.

In short, there is absolutely nothing going on here that requires anything in the scientifically inept EC model to explain it.
 
Okay, let's see what the geniuses Wallace & Gromit have to say about the dust, shall we? Particularly as this thread is about the 'electric comet';

The primary distinction between comet and asteroid surfaces is that electrical arcing and “electrostatic cleaning” of the comet nucleus will leave little or no dust or debris on the surface during the active phase, even if a shallow layer of dust may be attracted back to the nucleus electrostatically as the comet becomes dormant in its retreat to more remote regions.

So, I'm kind of surprised that Sol wants to draw attention to yet another failed prediction from the EC model. What on Earth did Thornie think was causing sunlight to reflect and therefore reveal the dusty coma? What was he doing when all the Halley papers were being released? Etc, etc. Looks like wilful ignorance and scientific ineptitude to me.

EDIT:
Just for clarity, can we now confirm that we are no longer discussing T & T's EC model? What we are now discussing, is Sol 88's EC model. Yes?
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Usual lies to derail from his comet delusions.

Stupid and irrelevant comments on papers snipped leaving nothing :eye-poppi!
31 January 2018 Sol88: Usual lies to derail from his comet delusions.

31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie that the "anomalistic feature" paper is relevant to jonesdave116's post which is not about nanoparticles .

31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie that the "anomalistic feature" paper is about charged dust from the nucleus.

31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie about the GIADA instrument observations which are not charged dust from the nucleus.
He shows just how deluded he is by quoting just that :eye-poppi!
4.Discussion

Fluffy particles are porous aggregates of submicron grains produced from the nucleus They range in size from 0.2 to 2.5mm and their equivalent bulk density is up to 1kgm−3. They are charged ,fragmented, and decelerated by the spacecraft negative potential and enter GIADA in showers of fragments at speeds<1ms−1 (Fulle etal.,2015a).
This is fluffy particles that are charged by the spacecraft negative potential tens of kilometers from the nucleus.

31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie about the third paper which is not about charged dust from the nucleus (large grains being charged up in the coma and fragmenting).

31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie that jonesdave116's post is about centrifugal spin up of dust.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom