Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
This paper has been looked at by Tusenfem somewhere. From memory, he said the first nine sections were ancient, well known stuff, and section 10 was bobbins. Or words to that effect. It was also the subject of a post by Brian Koberlein:
https://briankoberlein.com/2015/01/30/known-unknowns/

I also think it was this paper that Self-Sim was discussing on the 'EU, has there ever been.......' thread. Just more looks like a.......
[qimg]http://www.kickvick.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/cutest-bunny-rabbits-a-19.jpg[/qimg]

....stuff from the EU's chief electric woomeister.


So Donald Scott was bang on the money with maths and all!

And poor Brian could not have been and more wrong, if he or you UNDERSTOOD what is being said.

Doppler shift, :boggled:
 
Repeats the Birkeland currents lie from his many comet delusions

26 March 2018: Repeats the Birkeland currents lie from his many comet delusions.

26 March 2018: Argument by insulting an astrophysicist (Brian Koberlein).
Known Unknowns is Brian Koberlein using the measured properties of the planetary nebula M2-9 to show how ignorant Donald Scott is. A z-pinch would have current and so material passing through M2-9 from one side to the other. The real world has material flowing out from the center of M2-9.

28 March 2018: Reveals even more ignorance with being confused about Doppler shift!
Doppler shift is high school level science. Anyone who knows abut how police radar guns work knows about Doppler shift. Anyone who has listened to a passing car knows Doppler shift. What is worse the article has a link that explains Doppler shift :eye-poppi!
Known Unknowns by Brian Koberlein
But this is one of those cases where there is a clear prediction from the EU model. That is, the flow of plasma is through the pinch. This means if you look at the Doppler shift of light coming from the nebula you should clearly see that the material flows in on one side and out on the other. The standard red giant model makes a very different prediction. It says the Doppler measurements should show material flowing out from the center on both sides. It turns out we’ve made Doppler observations of M2-9, and sure enough it agrees with the standard red giant model.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.
 
Last edited:
How many times am I going to have to repeat the same things before it penetrates your brain? Plenty of ice. It isn't hidden. It was blasted out of Tempel 1, it was floating around Hartley 2, it is lying all around 67P as bits fallen off cliffs, etc, etc. Now quit with your pathetic, deliberate lying, and address the ice.


Oh dear.

There are other viable options for the 1um pure ice, no dust, that even “jets” of “super volatiles” can not remove as has been observed at 67P. The comet we had been orbiting for quite some time as opposed to Tempel 1 and Hartly 2.

The key here is the size of the water ice. Plenty of water vapour being released from the hydrated minerals that constitutes the ROCK that is a comets nucleus. Though there is no single source there are many pathways to get OH, H2O, especially in the intense electric fields found around and on comets.

Plus there is a major over estimation of the ‘outgassing” rate. This has also been shown to you.

As has been shown.


So Hartly 2 is a special comet (not) or you’ve got your foot on the exaggerator!

What was the bulk density of Hartley 2 again. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Ignorance of the existence of Google (or a bulk density delusion?)

...What was the bulk density of Hartley 2 again. :rolleyes:
26 March 2018: Ignorance of the existence of Google (or a bulk density delusion?) :eye-poppi!
Shape, density, and geology of the nucleus of Comet 103P/Hartley 2
Data from the Extrasolar Planet Observation and Deep Impact Extended Investigation (EPOXI) mission show Comet 103P/Hartley 2 is a bi-lobed, elongated, nearly axially symmetric comet 2.33 km in length. Surface features are primarily small mounds <40 m across, irregularly-shaped smooth areas on the two lobes, and a smooth but variegated region forming a “waist” between the two lobes. Assuming parts of the comet body approach the shape of an equipotential surface, the mean density of Hartley 2 is modeled to be 200–400 kg m−3. Such a mean density suggests mass loss per orbit of >1%. The shape may be the evolutionary product of insolation, sublimation, and temporary deposition of materials controlled by the object’s complex rotation.
That makes Comet 103P/Hartley 2 ices and dust.
 
Last edited:
This paper has been looked at by Tusenfem somewhere. From memory, he said the first nine sections were ancient, well known stuff, and section 10 was bobbins. Or words to that effect. It was also the subject of a post by Brian Koberlein:
https://briankoberlein.com/2015/01/30/known-unknowns/

I also think it was this paper that Self-Sim was discussing on the 'EU, has there ever been.......' thread. Just more looks like a.......
[qimg]http://www.kickvick.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/cutest-bunny-rabbits-a-19.jpg[/qimg]

....stuff from the EU's chief electric woomeister.

Talking about bunnies...

A University of Maryland-led study published in the 17 June issue of the journal Science described an analysis of the mission. Key findings from the mission include: (1) the smooth, relatively inactive waist of the peanut shaped comet has probably been re-deposited; (2) Hartley 2 spins around one axis, but also tumbles around a different axis; and (3) on its larger, rougher ends, the comet's surface contains glittering, blocky objects that are about 165 feet (50 meters) high and 260 feet (80 meters) wide (as big as a 16-story building). Moreover, these objects appear to be two to three times more reflective than the surface average

Looks like "ice".
 
Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper

Uh-oh rc, ...
Replies to
22 March 2018: Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper.

22 March 2018: A lie about the definition of a ouble layer being a potential drop.

22 March 2018: A "discharge from the nucleus" lie about a Laako paper.

with:
26 March 2018: Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper
The definition is
1, "A double layer is a structure in a plasma consisting of two parallel layers of opposite electrical charge" and
2. "typically ten Debye lengths".
The potential drop is a consequence of the charge separation and falls on one side of the DL, rises on the other side.
Laako only reports a potential drop.
The Debye length of comet coma may be ~10 meters - that potential drop is over 10,000 kilometers.

26 March 2018: A "multiple double layers" delusions about a Laako paper with one 10,000 km wide layer.
Even if that paper is an observation of the one and only DL ever found it is 1 DL.
 
Last edited:
A "You do agree MHD is violated..." lie

26 March 2018: A "You do agree MHD is violated..." lie.

I do not agree with any of your assertions unless you cite textbooks or other credible scientific sources. Otherwise your track record means that the assertion is very probably a lie.
778 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 22 March 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

I know that there are some phenomena that MHD does not cover, e.g. double layers.
MHD covers field aligned currents, Birkeland currents, flux tube/ropes, flux transfer events.
 
778 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 22 March 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

  1. 22 March 2018: Lies about comet jets again and an insane Rosetta probe delusion.
  2. 22 March 2018: And yet another interpret and "rock" lie.
  3. 22 March 2018: Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets.
  4. 22 March 2018: Lies about a C.-G. Fälthammar paper to detail from his comet and sun delusions.
  5. 22 March 2018: Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper.
  6. 22 March 2018: A lie about the definition of a )double layer being a potential drop.
  7. 22 March 2018: A "discharge from the nucleus" lie about a Laako paper.
  8. 26 March 2018: A blatant lie about an invalid Scott paper to emphasize his many comets delusions.
  9. 26 March 2018: A couple of lies about a Mendis paper.
  10. 26 March 2018: A Hessa et. al. paper lie to derail from his many comets delusions.
  11. 26 March 2018: Repeating a "MHD does not apply" lie does not make it true.
  12. 26 March 2018: A lie that quasi-neutrality is "ideal plasma".
  13. 26 March 2018: Acknowledges that he is lying about DLs :eye-poppi!
  14. 26 March 2018: Lies about DLs at comets, comet jets and published papers even suggesting his electric comet delusions.
  15. 26 March 2018: A lie that Scott's paper even mentions comets.
  16. 26 March 2018: A lie that Birkeland currents were found by the RPC team in the tail of 67P.
  17. 26 March 2018: Repeats the Birkeland currents lie from his many comet delusions.
  18. 26 March 2018: Argument by insulting an astrophysicist (Brian Koberlein).
  19. 28 March 2018: Reveals even more ignorance with being confused about Doppler shift!
  20. 26 March 2018: Repeats the lie about the deluded about the Sun Scott and his invalid paper predicting cometary Birkeland currents.
  21. 26 March 2018: Ignorance of the existence of Google (or a bulk density delusion?) :eye-poppi!
  22. 26 March 2018: Adds "blocky objects" to his bedrock = real rock etc. for comets made of ices and dusk lie.
  23. 26 March 2018: Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper
  24. 26 March 2018: A "multiple double layers" delusion about a Laako paper with one 10,000 km wide layer.
  25. 26 March 2018: A "You do agree MHD is violated..." lie.
 
Seriously, wouldn't it be so much easier if you could just stay at home in front of your computer making stuff up?

Ah, those were the days! But now we have excellent and critical plasma physicists like Sol88 to check up on what we do, so we now really need to look at the data, instead of just drawing something by hand.
 
The key here is the size of the water ice. Plenty of water vapour being released from the hydrated minerals that constitutes the ROCK that is a comets nucleus. Though there is no single source there are many pathways to get OH, H2O, especially in the intense electric fields found around and on comets.

Lol. No, it isn't key to anything. Which idiot told you this garbage? The vapour comes from ice that we can see, and detect. Whichever nutjob told you this rubbish needs to grow a pair, and write up this unscientific rubbish. It wasn't the same loon that thinks solar wind H+ is going to magically combine with non-existent O- was it? Trust me, he's another one that couldn't find his own backside with an extra pair of hands. How are you getting water out of hydrated minerals? Just magically seeping out, is it? And then turning into ice in an environment that is too warm for it to form? Dear me, the desperation of the Velikovskian loons knows no bounds. Lern to scienz.
 
Last edited:
Plenty of water vapour being released from the hydrated minerals that constitutes the ROCK that is a comets nucleus.

What rock? When was this found? More lies. And which water vapour? I thought the liar Thornhill told us that it was OH, magically made by solar wind H+ hurtling into non-existent O-. This is the problem when you tell so many lies - you end up forgetting which lies you've told, and end up catching yourself out. So, what is Thornhill's latest lie, so that we know which one we are dealing with?
 
And poor Brian could not have been and more wrong, if he or you UNDERSTOOD what is being said.

Doppler shift,

Sorry. like to explain? The two lobes are leaving the central star. How is that a z-pinch? Want me to draw a picture for you? Or link to the paper? Stop lying.
 
Perhaps we could stick to science, instead of fantasy. Difficult when discussing a 'hypothesis' that is born of pure fantasy (i.e. Velikovsky), but let's at least try;

So, EU ists, how are you getting the hydrated minerals to give up their water vapour, so that it can be detected in the coma?

How is it then magically turning into ice? What is it condensing upon? Not the dust, that is too warm. Any clues?

What is the original source of this hydrated material? Earth? Mars? Venus? Please, do give us a clue, because we can then put this claim to the test by comparing the D/H ratios of the cometary H2O, and the ratios found on Earth, for instance.

Where are you getting the CO2 from? What carbon isotopic ratios should we expect, based on where the electric looniverse thinks comets originated? Ditto with nitrogen. How should these isotopic ratios vary between comets, meteorites and planets? And why?
 
Comets and Cometary Missions

Oh, it has to be in YOUR acceptable peer reviewed journal. Ok :thumbsup:
Thanks.

So, 1980 (!), and in "COSPAR Colloquia Series" ("Space Research Proceedings of the Open Meetings of the Working Groups on Physical Sciences of the Twenty-Second Plenary Meeting of COSPAR Bangalore, India 29 May – 9 June 1979").

I note that the Scott "paper" you referenced does not cite Mendis (1980).

irrelevant sources??? Like I said, lack of vision and independent thinking on your part.

There are birkeland current/s in the plasma tail of comets!

<snip>
There may, indeed, be "birkeland current/s in the plasma tail of comets"; however, this seems to be irrelevant to the question I asked. Perhaps you'd like to explain?
 
Last edited:
^^^^^^

Charge carrying Double Layers of various strengths, thickness and frequencies and distance from the nucleus, Birkeland currents of various lengths, strengths, widths and coherent-ness (force free and collisionless ) is the ELECTRIC COMET.

At the “head” all sorts of funky variable energy, electrodynamic, plasma, complicated math stuff going on including the production of all species detected. The H2O produced from the dissociation of hydrated minerals and non hydrated minerals, recombining to spontaneously form pure water ice of 1um. Of course along with ALL the other guff they’ve detected.

So i’d say Thornhill has got a portion correct, Dr Annariba same boat and I’d hazard a guess that if Talbotts right and comets and asteroids were machined off of Mar’s surface and within “human” recorded history, then HYDRATED MINERALS could safely be thrown into the mix.

Mars did have an ocean once yeah? Water at least pretty ubiquitous in the solar system.

And because this would be released from the surface of a comet in various amounts in response to the top paragraph on electrical/plasma interaction onto/into said ROCK, as mainly excited Water ions...

And I’d guess snaffle an election from some where, drop in energy and increase in density and not sublimate but crystallise spontaneously, into pure 1um water ice!!

To then either “frost’ up onto the nucleus in places or be lost to space.

I reckon anyway’s from what i’ve been reading.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom