Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
I will have to read it, to find out what "strong" magnetic field is, ah I found it, the sphere has 7 kGauss surface field! The strongest magnetic field found in space at a comet is 270 nT which is 2.7 mGauss, so I am dubious about their interplation, but like I said I need to read it better.

This sounds a lot like when Zeuuzzz used to promote the EU and how it created galaxy structures, never mind that the measured field strength is 10,000 - 1050 weaker than would be needed.
 
Feel free to back it up, quote the section where this is stated.
More than happy to! :)

I know you are fluent in English, but perhaps not in Deutsch or Pitjantjatjara; to read and understand Fälthammar's paper, one needs to be fluent in a different language, Science.

So let me start by asking you how familiar you think you are with Science? In particular what are "Maxwell's equations"? This is a central Science concept, as necessary for understanding Fälthammar's paper as "verb-subject agreement" is for understanding English (or Deutsch or Pitjantjatjara).
 
Yeah very good.

SAFIRE don't! thru empirical science and NOT theoretical science.

If you are a betting man empirical science wins hands down EVERY time.



http://www.safirefilm.com/science/ewExternalFiles/SAFIRE-Phase-Three.pdf

So...my moneys on empirical science!
Very cool, Sol88, very cool! :)

I can see where you're going with this, and hat's off to you for it.

One day a comet will strike the copper wire which connects the Sun to whatever it is which powers it (well outside the solar system) - just like the copper wire which connects the metal ball in SAFIRE to the mains - and it will become an Electric Comet! :D
 
Well the SAFIRE team are doing empirical science, so you can do your song and dance but that’s what they are doing.

<snip>
[EU acolyte hat on]

Yeah, that's rite Solly boy, attem!

But you gotta be careful, these mainstreamers are a cunning bunch.

They say they have wizzy labs full of plasma experiments - like the Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory - which do "empirical science" non-stop. But we know it's all a con, cos they talk big about creating magnetic reconnections in those plasmas. Clearly no one there has read pre-eminent EU scientist, MM's totall demolision of magnet reconnections, in a thread in this very part of ISF! :jaw-dropp

So I reckon those SAFIRE blokes should re-do their experiment, without the copper wire, cos the Sun obviously doesn't have a copper wire coming out of it.

[EU acolyte hat off]
;)
 
So let me start by asking you how familiar you think you are with Science? In particular what are "Maxwell's equations"? This is a central Science concept, as necessary for understanding Fälthammar's paper as "verb-subject agreement" is for understanding English (or Deutsch or Pitjantjatjara).

The interesting thing about Fälthammar and EU, from my perspective, is that they rarely refer to him. And yet there he was as the heir apparent to Alfven's plasma cosmology. A former co-author, friend and colleague, and succeeded him as Professor of Plasma Physics at the Royal Institute in Sweden. Bigs Alfie up every chance he gets. And yet, doesn't invoke exploding double layers to account for solar flares (or anything else that I can remember). Does invoke magnetic reconnection both in the magnetosphere, and on the Sun. He was one of the PIs on the Cluster mission before his retirement, and obviously was well aware of the findings of that mission re MRx.
So, having written that down, maybe it's not so surprising that they rarely mention him! I know for a fact that he must have been open to the idea of MRx being possible at least as early as 1979, seven years before Alfven supposedly trashed it in an address to a conference. And yet a decade prior to that, Alfven can be seen to suggest that 'magnetic merging' is 'possible'.
I'm wondering if the EU-ists really know what Alfven was actually saying? They treat MRx as if it is one of the seven deadly sins, as pronounced by one of their gods. All very strange.
 
Last edited:
Lies about the electric sun insanity to detail from his comet delusions

22 March 2018: Lies about the electric sun insanity to detail from his comet delusions.
A growing list of Electric Sun delusions and lies mindlessly parroted and written by Sol88.
+ A blatant lie of an assumption of a "thermonuclear bomb contained by gravity"


10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.

778 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 22 March 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
 
Last edited:
"Vega 1 and 2 " lie and insult to add to his many comet and sun delusions and lies

Vega 1 and 2 detected the electric comet back in the 80’s but the moanstream have their craniums wedged so firmly.
22 March 2018: "Vega 1 and 2 " lie and insult to add to his many comet and sun delusions and lies

778 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 22 March 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

7 electric sun delusions and lies mindlessly parroted and written by Sol88
 
Last edited:
7 delusions and lies mindlessly parroted and written by Sol88

7 electric sun delusions and lies mindlessly parroted and written by Sol88.
  1. The delusion that the temperature of the solar corona is not explained by mainstream solar physics.
  2. Repeated lies that the ignorant and deluded electric sun idea can explain the temperature of the corona.
    No mechanism cited. Not even one calculation of the corona temperature :eye-poppi!
  3. He is ignorant about the Sun, i.e. that all stable stars need a central heat source to be stable + the Sun without a central heat source = a white dwarf.
    This is: The true insanity of the electric sun delusion is that it makes the Sun into a white dwarf :eye-poppi!
  4. He has the delusion that the inane SAFIRE experiment will say anything about the Sun.
  5. Repeats the mainstream has no explanation lie again with a link to coronal heating problem that lists the proposed solutions and their evidence.
  6. A lie that images of magnetic braids are electric currents.
    Images of the Sun's million degree corona, including images of the magnetic braids (left hand side).
  7. A blatant lie of an assumption of a "thermonuclear bomb contained by gravity".
    This is the real Sun that he is so deluded about.
 
Last edited:
A lie about the SAFIRE experiment which is on the solar atmosphere

Yes they did and it was cooler than the photosphere. So the moanstream have a coronal heating problem!!!!
The next thing to add to 7 electric sun delusions and lies mindlessly parroted and written by Sol88

He lies about the SAFIRE project which is the "Stellar Atmospheric Function in Regulation Experiment".

He should not be demented enough to think that the SAFIRE team are measuring the temperature of plasma inside their metal sphere. On the other hand, there is the contents of this thread :p!
 
Lies about comet jets again + an insane Rosetta probe delusion

Well the jets are not powered via subsurface pressure chambers of “gas” rocketing the nucleus in non keperlerian motion when the same affect is happening to the Rosetta probe.
22 March 2018: Lies about comet jets again and an insane Rosetta probe delusion.
This is the old lie about "subsurface pressure chambers" when there was 1 paper suggesting chambers to direct the sublimated gases to form highly collimated jets - not all jets.

It is an insane delusion that the Rosetta spacecraft has sublimating ices and subsurface pressure chambers making jets. The Rosetta spacecraft had normal rockets that places it into orbit around Comet 67P and changed that orbit occasionally.
 
And yet another interpret and "rock: lie

And the mainstream interpret that as 533kg/m3 for ROCK.
22 March 2018: And yet another interpret and "rock" lie.
The mainstream measured the density of Comet 67P to be 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3 which makes it impossible for the comet to be rock.
 
And of what relevance are they? Are they supposed to create the EDM (LOL) that failed to matrialise? What do you want them to do? Turn H+ into H2O? Make rock appear to be icy dust? Please do explain.

SIGNIFICANCE OF MAGNETIC-FIELD ALIGNED ELECTRIC FIELDS

Magnetic-field aligned electric fields are important for three main reasons.

1. Magnetic-field aligned electric fields provide a very efficient means of accelerating charged particles. Charged particles can gain energy only by interaction with electric fields, because the magnetic force is always transverse to the velocity vector and can do no work. The acceleration can take place in a multi-step stochastic fashion by interaction with for example wave electric fields, or in a single step by falling through a potential drop. In the magnetosphere both kinds of acceleration takes place, as well as combinations of them, including Fermi-like acceleration (Perri et al. 2009). But by far the fastest acceleration possible is falling through a magnetic-field aligned electric field. From the aurora we know that such fast acceleration can and does take place in cosmic plasma. It has been argued that electrostatic acceleration cannot work, because the electrostatic field is conservative (Bryant, 2007). As explained by Haerendel (2007), this is based on a misunderstanding. The electrostatic acceleration region is only part of an electric circuit that also includes a dynamo region with an electromotive force or a finite curl of the electric field.

2. Magnetic-field aligned electric fields make possible rapid release of magnetically stored energy. In collisionless plasmas, current flows most easily along the magnetic field lines. A potential drop in the path of the current can extremely efficiently energize the current carries at the expense of the magnetic field energy in the dynamo region.

3. Magnetic-field aligned electric fields allow violation of the frozen field condition. The concept of frozen in magnetic field greatly simplifies thinking about plasma dynamics and is therefore frequently used. It has sometimes led to reasoning in terms of “moving magnetic field lines”. But the strict definition of the frozen field condition does not in any way imply that the field lines themselves “move”. It only prescribes that two elements of plasma that are at one instant of time on a common magnetic field line, shall be on a common magnetic field line at any other time.

Cosmic plasmas are often assumed to be subject to the frozen field condition. But if magnetic-field aligned electric fields can exist in the cosmic plasma, as we now know they do, the frozen field condition can be violated, which of course has profound consequences for the dynamics of the plasma.
The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe C.-G. Fälthammar

So yeah, important.


along with Fälthammar interpretaion of
RECONNECTION
A special kind of violation of the frozen field condition is the process of reconnection.

and it doe's not involve
Under normal conditions, the magnetic field lines inside plasmas don't break or merge with other field lines. But sometimes, as field lines get close to each other, the entire pattern changes and everything realign into a new configuration. The amount of energy released can be formidable. Magnetic reconnection taps into the stored energy of the magnetic field, converting it into heat and kinetic energy that sends particles streaming out along the field lines.

Sounds a lot more like "crossing the streams" and less like snapping and merging magnetic field lines!

So, tusenfem do you now understand that I understand that MHD does not apply at the plasma "boundaries" found around ALL comets visited so far.

On the basis of generally accepted theories, it was believed that the nearly collisionless cosmic plasma would behave essentially as an ideal MHD medium. As a consequence, the electric field was considered to be a secondary parameter of little importance, and magnetic field aligned electric fields, for brevity often called “parallel” electric fields, were considered impossible. Therefore, the role of electric fields and especially of magnetic-field aligned electric fields, which are now considered to be of crucial importance, was disregarded.

So anything that claims MHD is highly suspect!
 
2425yqp.jpg
[/IMG] H.LAAKSO

Tusenfem,
the dc electric field exhibits a
large gradient (the total potential drop overt he layer is -135 kV),

That by definition is a double layer, multiple double layers at that.

Just like SAFIRE found!

Also interesting is the below graph
24nkyz6.jpg



That is the discharge from the nucleus thru the various DOUBLE LAYERS to the solar wind!

You call them "draped field lines lead to so-called nested draping ..."

When indeed they are double layers!
 
Last edited:
The interesting thing about Fälthammar and EU, from my perspective, is that they rarely refer to him. And yet there he was as the heir apparent to Alfven's plasma cosmology. A former co-author, friend and colleague, and succeeded him as Professor of Plasma Physics at the Royal Institute in Sweden. Bigs Alfie up every chance he gets. And yet, doesn't invoke exploding double layers to account for solar flares (or anything else that I can remember). Does invoke magnetic reconnection both in the magnetosphere, and on the Sun. He was one of the PIs on the Cluster mission before his retirement, and obviously was well aware of the findings of that mission re MRx.
So, having written that down, maybe it's not so surprising that they rarely mention him! I know for a fact that he must have been open to the idea of MRx being possible at least as early as 1979, seven years before Alfven supposedly trashed it in an address to a conference. And yet a decade prior to that, Alfven can be seen to suggest that 'magnetic merging' is 'possible'.
I'm wondering if the EU-ists really know what Alfven was actually saying? They treat MRx as if it is one of the seven deadly sins, as pronounced by one of their gods. All very strange.

Although he had introduced it himself, he described the concept of frozen field lines as easily misleading and, especially in his later years, strongly warned against its use (Alfvén, 1976).

but Tusenfem still does!
 
Lies about a C.-G. Fälthammar paper to detail from his comet and sun delusions

The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe C.-G. Fälthammar
22 March 2018: Lies about a C.-G. Fälthammar paper to detail from his comet and sun delusions.

What he quotes is Fälthammar stating that there are conditions where the magnetic field lines inside plasmas break or merge with other field lines. This is simple English. A sentence starting "But..." is stating an exception or exceptions to the previous sentence.
Magnetosphere-ionosphere interactions as a key to the plasma Universe by Fälthammar, C.-G.; Brenning, N (1995)
Under normal conditions, the magnetic field lines inside plasmas don't break or merge with other field lines. But sometimes, as field lines get close to each other, the entire pattern changes and everything realign into a new configuration. The amount of energy released can be formidable. Magnetic reconnection taps into the stored energy of the magnetic field, converting it into heat and kinetic energy that sends particles streaming out along the field lines.

There are also things called textbooks :eye-poppi.
Cosmic Plasma Physics by B.V. Somov
Section 4.4.2 Reconnection in Vacuum (the next section is Reconnection in Plasma)
 
Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper

That by definition is a double layer, multiple double layers at that.
22 March 2018: Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper.

22 March 2018: A lie about the definition of a [URL="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_layer_(plasma_physics)double layer[/URL] being a potential drop.
The definition is "A double layer is a structure in a plasma consisting of two parallel layers of opposite electrical charge." and "typically ten Debye lengths". The potential drop is a consequence of the charge separation and falls on one side of the DL, rises on the other side. Laako only reports a potential drop.

22 March 2018: A "discharge from the nucleus" lie about a Laako paper.
The graphs are about the comet coma starting at ~24 kilometers from the surface. This is above the nucleus.
The comet coma is a plasma. Plasma conduct. Thus no discharges which need the breakdown of a dielectric medium.
 
Last edited:
Cosmic plasmas are often assumed to be subject to the frozen field condition. But if magnetic-field aligned electric fields can exist in the cosmic plasma, as we now know they do, the frozen field condition can be violated, which of course has profound consequences for the dynamics of the plasma.

Errr, yes, we know. You cannot have MRx in ideal MHD! That is Falthammar's point, and it has gone right over your head! The MRx that Falthammar is describing is the same MRx that Tusenfem describes, or pretty much any other plasma physicist. Of which the EU cult have none. If you don't think he's describing reconnection, then have a look at the people he often references in regard to it; off the top of my head - Hesse & Schindler, Birn, and his oft times co-author Mozer. So, I'm afraid that the man who sat at the right hand side of one of your god's, is telling EUists that they are wrong. Reconnection happens.
As for DLs, I know of no scientist who has ever invoked them on the sunward side of a comet. Mendis proposed that they were possible in the tail, but this has not been seen. And there is no way of mistaking nested draping for DLs! Even I can work that out.
 
but Tusenfem still does!
Well duh :jaw-dropp!

Even Alfvén did not deny that there were cases where the frozen-in field approximation could be used. The laws of physics did not change between the 1980's and today. The frozen-in field approximation in ideal MHD still needs as much caution as before. The approximation can still be used in the appropriate cases.

tusenfem is a working plasma physicist. He has the expertise to know whether to use the frozen-in field approximation + ideal MHD or whether to use more general MHD that Alfvén was possibly ignorant about because he died before it was developed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom