Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
snip



every dl is an electric field but not every electric field is a dl. also in a dl the electric field is basicalky constant, and at halley it changes a lot.

well that is all i will type on my tablet

The direction of the dc field suggests that the outer boundary of the CP is positively charged, while the inner boundary is negatively charged

Since when does an electric field have the above????

This electric field IS a DOUBLE LAYER! :D

This was found in your non classical draping as well!
 
Last edited:
Why would I? It's not relevant to anything I said, nor does it support your central claim about the nature of comets.



tusenfem gave a description of when and why MHD doesn't work. You have consistently failed to describe how comets meet those conditions. Furthermore, the inapplicability of MHD to some plasmas cannot turn ice into rock.



Yeah, no. That's really not what tusenfem is saying. It's most definitely not an actual rock.

MHD works for your maths, full stop.

I know it's nice to think of the interplanetary plasma is overall quasi-neutral and the magnetic fields are "frozen" in.

Like I said "step back" far enough and there are no trees just a forest!
 
I don't really care. What do the authors say? And, as I asked, what do you think it is doing? EDM (lol)? Glow discharges (lol)? Turning ice and dust into rock? Please tell me what relevance this has to Thornhill's loopy, unscientific woo.


:thumbsup:

Well done champ, well done!

It's ok if you do not understand.
 
Usual DLs at comets idiocy and electric field stupidity

Since when does an electric field have the above????
12 April 2018: Usual DLs at comets idiocy and electric field stupidity.
Electric fields are produced by any charges.
"outer boundary of the CP is positively charged" and has an electric field.
"the inner boundary is negatively charged" and has an electric field.
There is a direct current (dc) and it has an electric field.
 
:thumbsup:

Well done champ, well done!

It's ok if you do not understand.

So answer the question - what is it doing that has any relevance to Thornhill's woo? Stop evading and obfuscating and just answer a question truthfully for once.
 
Lies about Ziggurat's post, MHD and plasma

MHD works for your maths, full stop.
12 April 2018: Lies about Ziggurat's post, MHD and plasma

Ziggurat's post is that MHD is irrelevant to the electric comet because MHD does not turn ice into rock :jaw-dropp!

MHD works because it includes the properties of plasma, i.e. they are gas and are ionized :eye-poppi!
All plasma is quasi-neutral.
Magnetic fields being frozen is a good approximation used for appropriate plasma.
 
Lies about jonesdave116's post where he understands Thornhill's unscientific woo

It's ok if you do not understand.
12 April 2018: Lies about jonesdave116's post where he understands Thornhill's loopy, unscientific woo (electric comet, etc.).

jonesdave116's post states that he does not care about Sol88's DL fantasy. He cares about what the authors say (there are no DLs in the paper). Even if the DL fantasy was true, there is no evidence that DLs have anything to do with Thornhill's comet delusions such as EDM of nuclei surfaces. DLs do not turn ices into rock :jaw-dropp!

So we have a pathetic attempt yet again to derail with MHD and DL from his many comet delusions.
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, that MHD has anything to do with these delusions, cannot link DLs to his delusions.
 
Last edited:
ice to rock????

well done you mob!

the SAFIRE team are finding out plenty on DL's and the biggest one, in the context of comets, is they are a proof the comets is of a lesser potential than the of the solar wind.

i.e comets are rock discharging into the solar wind plasma, an ELECTRIC COMET.

Energy transfer: Double layers fascilitate the transfer of electrical energy into kinetic energy, dW/dt=I.ΔV where I is the electric current dissipating energy into a double layer with a voltage drop of ΔV. Alfvén points out that the current may well consist exclusively of low-energy particles.[43] Torvén et al. also report that plasma may spontaneously transfer magnetically stored energy into kinetic energy by electric double layers

Particle acceleration: The potential drop across the double layer will accelerate electrons and positive ions in opposite directions. The magnitude of the potential drop determines the acceleration of the charged particles. In strong double layers, this will result in beams or jets of charged particles.

including the negatively charged nano dust accelerated off of the surface!


So unfortunately, for you, they are an integral part of the electric comet.
 
ice to rock????

That's the alchemy you're trying to achieve, not us.

the SAFIRE team are finding out plenty on DL's

That's nice. All their findings still support the obvious conclusion that comets are primarily ice. I'm not sure why you struggle with this concept, it's not like electromagnetic and plasma phenomena cannot happen around ice.

and the biggest one, in the context of comets, is they are a proof the comets is of a lesser potential than the of the solar wind.

i.e comets are rock discharging into the solar wind plasma, an ELECTRIC COMET.

Nope, doesn't follow. Not in any way, shape, or form.
 
Nope. No rock, no discharges. Fail.

Looks like we'll see, ay!

The classical model of comets as dirty ice balls (Whipple 1950) has
focused most models of comets on ices. The more we visit comets,
the dustier they appear. With 67P’s dust-to-water ratio of 6 (and
possibly larger), it is now necessary to spend much more time in
modelling the non-volatile matrices with a modest content of ices
inside. Jean-Pierre Bibring proposes a new word naming this stuff,
‘organic(e)s’, where the modest content of ices (within brackets)
well summarizes the dominant non-volatile component. Between
the sizes of 0.1 and 1 mm, 99 per cent of the dust mass is in the
form of compact particles, denser than the nucleus. This implies
that much of the nucleus mass is in the form of mineral aggregates
(silicates and sulfides), so that a better definition may be ‘mineral
organic(e)s’.

Even if the nucleus were composed of pure ice from a
depth of 1.5 cm downwards, the entire surface of 67P would release
a negligible water fraction of that observed (Gulkis et al. 2015;
Keller et al. 2015b). This proves that all the water-vapour is coming
from the uppermost surface layer thinner than 1 cm

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

There are serious doubts being raised in the mainstream community on validity of the Whipple model!
 
There are serious doubts being raised in the mainstream community on validity of the Whipple model!

No there aren't. And Whipple's model is decades old, and from a time before we'd even visited a comet. That changed in 1986, in case you missed it. Why are you still using Whipple's model, when it is 30 years out of date? Mind you, it was a damn sight more accurate than the laughable nonsense concocted by T & T, who had access to data that Whipple never had, and still managed to make a laughing stock of themselves. EDM!! (lol).
 
Looks like we'll see, ay!





Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

There are serious doubts being raised in the mainstream community on validity of the Whipple model!


I also fail to see how any of the pieces you quoted lend any credence to the already debunked EC woo. Remember, dust and ice don't help you at all. Wal told us there we be very little dust due to electrostatic cleaning, and that there'd be no ice, and the comet would be rock. That looks like three strikes right there.
 
wow that must be magic i performed, because i only use magnetometer data

The current did’nt change direction then?

Oh ok then...:thumbsup:

What does make the interplanetary magnetic field change direction wrt “non classical draping” then tusenfem?
 
I also fail to see how any of the pieces you quoted lend any credence to the already debunked EC woo. Remember, dust and ice don't help you at all. Wal told us there we be very little dust due to electrostatic cleaning, and that there'd be no ice, and the comet would be rock. That looks like three strikes right there.

Ok, then you’ve got me I give up!


Comets ARE indeed made of fluffy dust and ice left over from the formation of the solar system....:eusa_liar:
 
The current did’nt change direction then?

Oh ok then...:thumbsup:

What does make the interplanetary magnetic field change direction wrt “non classical draping” then tusenfem?

what current??????..

the imf changes direction and usually there are like 4 sectors in tne imf, pointing outward and inward alternatingly, driven by the large scale magnetic field topology of tne sun

this has nothing to do with non-classical draping, which is caused by cometary ion pick up, acceleration by the solar wind convective electric field and solar wind deflection by momentum conservation and the solar wind magnetic field following the deflected ions (see koenders et al, 2016)
 
No there aren't. And Whipple's model is decades old, and from a time before we'd even visited a comet. That changed in 1986, in case you missed it. Why are you still using Whipple's model, when it is 30 years out of date? Mind you, it was a damn sight more accurate than the laughable nonsense concocted by T & T, who had access to data that Whipple never had, and still managed to make a laughing stock of themselves. EDM!! (lol).


So what model do you (mainstream) use then jd116?

You seem a lot more up to speed than me.

The one proposed in the paper were we forget about the ice and model it on silicates and sulfides?

11 CONCLUSIONS The classical model of comets as dirty ice balls (Whipple 1950)has focused most models of comets on ices. The more we visit comets, the dustier they appear. With 67P’s dust-to-water ratio of 6 (and possibly larger), it is now necessary to spend much more time in modelling the non-volatile matrices with a modest content of ices inside. Jean-Pierre Bibring proposes a new word naming this stuff, ‘organic(e)s’, where the modest content of ices (within brackets) well summarizes the dominant non-volatile component. Between the sizes of 0.1 and 1 mm, 99 per cent of the dust mass is in the form of compact particles, denser than the nucleus. This implies that much of the nucleus mass is in the form of mineral aggregates (silicates and suldes), so that a better denition may be ‘mineral organic(e)s’
 
what current??????..

the imf changes direction and usually there are like 4 sectors in tne imf, pointing outward and inward alternatingly, driven by the large scale magnetic field topology of tne sun

this has nothing to do with non-classical draping, which is caused by cometary ion pick up, acceleration by the solar wind convective electric field and solar wind deflection by momentum conservation and the solar wind magnetic field following the deflected ions (see koenders et al, 2016)

Let her rip sport, we are all ears.

What causes the change of direction of the imf useing MHD?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom