Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
As this is new thread with new lurkers, maybe you could give a layman’s rundown on the above equation?
 
I was browsing astro-ph last night, as I often do, and came across A Majority of Solar Wind Intervals Support Ion-Driven Instabilities.

Seems to me this deals a death blow to the Electric Sun (ES) idea, and shows the SAFIRE experiment to be total codswallop (hattip to ferd; lovely word).

But I'm not the expert on ES or SAFIRE that you so obviously are, Sol88. So I'd like you to take a look at this and give me your professional opinion: do you agree that it makes mincemeat out of ES?

Where the death blow, Jean Tate?
 
As this is new thread with new lurkers, maybe you could give a layman’s rundown on the above equation?
Let me have a go ...

It says that if you've done some physics at university undergrad level, you'll immediately recognize that
a) Sol88 has ~zero understanding of electricity,
b) the Sun is not powered by giant Birkeland currents,
c) SAFIRE (and plasma balls) have nothing to teach anyone except an EU zealot/acolyte (at least, not about the Sun).

How'd I do? :p
 
I was browsing astro-ph last night, as I often do, and came across A Majority of Solar Wind Intervals Support Ion-Driven Instabilities.

Seems to me this deals a death blow to the Electric Sun (ES) idea, and shows the SAFIRE experiment to be total codswallop (hattip to ferd; lovely word).

But I'm not the expert on ES or SAFIRE that you so obviously are, Sol88. So I'd like you to take a look at this and give me your professional opinion: do you agree that it makes mincemeat out of ES?
Where the death blow, Jean Tate?
What?!?! :jaw-dropp

Didn't you read it? :eek:

Sorry Sol88, I'm not your servant, and I have no desire to even try to be your teacher ... unless and until I see some evidence of a serious intent to learn something about electricity.
 
We know hydrogen fuses in conditions of sufficient heat and pressure (such as occur in the sun).

If something other than fusion powers the sun, something must be preventing fusion from occurring in the sun. But, what?
 
Sol88 said:
Allright, let her rip sport. Tell us all about the magnetic fields and the intense flow of electric current inside coronal loops.
Maxwell-Ampère's Law

curl(B) = mu0 J + c-2 dE/dt
JeanTate said:
Sol88 said:
As this is new thread with new lurkers, maybe you could give a layman’s rundown on the above equation?
Let me have a go ...

It says that if you've done some physics at university undergrad level, you'll immediately recognize that
a) Sol88 has ~zero understanding of electricity,
b) the Sun is not powered by giant Birkeland currents,
c) SAFIRE (and plasma balls) have nothing to teach anyone except an EU zealot/acolyte (at least, not about the Sun).

How'd I do? :p
Sol88, I've been a bit harsh with you on this, my apologies.

I'd like to help you understand electricity, which you need to do before you can understand plasmas.

So, in the equation ("Law") tusenfem posted, what do each of the letters (symbols) stand for?

To help you out, here is an informative webpage (and site): Ampere-Maxwell. Note that what tusenfem wrote has only letters from the standard 26-symbol alphabet (52 if you count capitals), plus two numbers and two math symbols; on the webpage I provided a link to there are several Greek letters, and some symbols that are neither Greek nor standard alphabet (including at least one diacritic). Also note that whether something is written in bold font or not has important meaning.

Looking forward to seeing you take your first steps to understanding electricity! :)
 
haha ha good one sport!

You may have noticed my interest in the electric comet thread? Once the data proves it’s not a sublimating dirtysnowball and they HAVE to look at a new model and that PLASMA plays a far more important role than previously believed.

You have your priorities backwards. The power source for the sun is far larger, and far more significant, than any comet. Figuring that out should be easier to do, and is more important as well.

Hello SAFIRE and the electric Sun!

Then we can move on from there and find the power source.


Though if your interested on the best lead and can stomach a little more thunderbolts, thev’e got a good lead going!

The thunderdolts crowd are clueless. They still think Juergens' model (which trivial calculations show would cause the sun to explode) is valid.


You know what ENA stands for? Energetic Neutral Atoms. By definition, that's not going to carry a current. Furthermore, which direction are these atoms moving? Away from the sun. To the extent that they transmit power, they transmit it away from the sun, not to it. They are, therefore, powered BY the sun, and cannot be even a small contributor of power TO the sun.

This is so completely wrong one wonders why you ever thought it would help your case. I suspect you just did a google search for some random plasma/electric terms, and threw up a result without actually understanding anything about it.

Kinda looks familiar. Your smart i’m Sure you’ll get the picture

The question is, will you figure it out? Signs point to "no".
 
We know hydrogen fuses in conditions of sufficient heat and pressure (such as occur in the sun).

If something other than fusion powers the sun, something must be preventing fusion from occurring in the sun. But, what?

28mhz5.jpg
 
A whole mess of general EU posts were moved off to AAH. Please keep to the topic of SAFIRE here. There are plenty of EU/EC threads to discuss the more general aspects of that school of thought.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
Effect of the convective field on weakly outgassing comets A. Beth 1⋆ and M. Galand 1

In reality, the convective electric field does not act alone but is combined with the ambipolar electric field which counteracts its effect. Indeed, in order to ensure the quasi-neutrality of the plasma, the ambipolar electric field is set up to prevent electrons from escaping the cometary ionosphere. Further investigations should be carried out to assess the combined effect of both electric field on the cometary ionosphere. For instance, the kinetic modelling of the coma, solving the Vlasov-Maxwell equations through a particle-in-cell approach as presented by Deca et al. (2017), could improve our understanding in such a situation.


Pretty much the death knell for the dirty snowball model. What do you think Jean Tate?
 
Last edited:
Effect of the convective field on weakly outgassing comets A. Beth 1⋆ and M. Galand 1

Pretty much the death knell for the dirty snowball model. What do you think Jean Tate?

you quote has nothing to do with your "dirty snowball"
it has everything to do with a weakly outgassing comet
 
Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 3AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data H. Madanian1, T. E. Cravens1, A. Rahmati1, R. Goldstein2, J. Burch2, A. I. Eriksson3, N. J. T. Edberg3, P. Henri4, K. Mandt2, G. Clark5, M. Rubin6, T. Broiles2, and N. L. Reedy


Three processes must be operating near the nucleus: (1) collisional cooling of suprathermal electrons through electron-neutral collisions, (2) confinement of the electrons near the nucleus by an ambipolar electric field, and (3) enhancement of the fluxes due to compression of the electron gas near the nucleus. We also showed that at 3 AU within 100 km from the nucleus, cooling of suprathermal electrons through electron-neutral collisions becomes significant and a population of cold thermal electrons begins to build up, which is also confined by the ambipolar electric field.

Are you able to tell the lurkers a little on ambipolar electric fields wrt comets, tusenfem?

Just so we are all reading from the same page.
 
Effect of the convective field on weakly outgassing comets A. Beth 1⋆ and M. Galand 1




Pretty much the death knell for the dirty snowball model. What do you think Jean Tate?
The most important thing I think about your post is this: I really do not know what you mean by "the dirty snowball model". :)
 
The most important thing I think about your post is this: I really do not know what you mean by "the dirty snowball model". :)

As in the widely accepted mainstream model proposed by Whipple.



In 1950, Fred Lawrence Whipple proposed that rather than being rocky objects containing some ice, comets were icy objects containing some dust and rock.[153] This "dirty snowball" model soon became accepted and appeared to be supported by the observations of an armada of spacecraft (including the European Space Agency's Giotto probe and the Soviet Union's Vega 1 and Vega 2) that flew through the coma of Halley's Comet in 1986, photographed the nucleus, and observed jets of evaporating material.[154]
See COMETS
 
Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 3AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data H. Madanian1, T. E. Cravens1, A. Rahmati1, R. Goldstein2, J. Burch2, A. I. Eriksson3, N. J. T. Edberg3, P. Henri4, K. Mandt2, G. Clark5, M. Rubin6, T. Broiles2, and N. L. Reedy

Are you able to tell the lurkers a little on ambipolar electric fields wrt comets, tusenfem?

Just so we are all reading from the same page.

you mean "can i explain stuff to you"
read the paper, it is explained was an ambipolar electric field is
 
Still deluded about the "Unexpected and significant findings" comet paper

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view
20 April 2018: Still deluded about the "Unexpected and significant findings" comet paper
What he quotes again (:eek:) is the past focus on comets made of more ices and dust, the last decade or so observations of comets with more dust than ices and a suggested name for the material made of more dust than ices.

20 April 2018: Lies about the MUPUS-PEN results.
He has read the abstract of the results: A sintered near-surface microporous dust-ice layer with a porosity of 30 to 65% is consistent with the data. :eye-poppi!

20 April 2018: A "well consolidated material, bedrock" lie about the return sample from Wild 2
Stardust collected dust from the comet coma.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Last edited:
Lies again about an ices and dust comet paper (Beth and Galand)

Effect of the convective field on weakly outgassing comets A. Beth 1⋆ and M. Galand 1
20 April 2018: Lies again about an ices and dust comet paper (Beth and Galand)

This is a paper on the "dirty snowball model" and the effect of the convective field on the gases emitted from sublimating ices on weakly outgassing comets.

The only relevance is that these lies make the insane electric comet delusions even more insane.
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.
+ an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom