Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok, we’ll narrow the scope. What was the percentage of surface ice on 67P?

What counts as the surface? You haven't defined that, even though JeanTate specifically asked you to.

Therfore all the rest of the “ice” required of whipples model is subsurface. Under some form of consolidated non-volatile/organicly layer and ,at least visually, the consolidated “stuff” is very rocky like, so we could call it rock?

No, we cannot. OK, we can, but it's foolish to do so, so let's not. Visually, it is indistinguishable from chocolate cake frosting. But I am confident that it is not, in fact, chocolate cake frosting. We need more evidence than that picture to determine its composition and structure.
 
The bit that’s right up hard against the plasma.

Chocolate cake frosting! ‘spose that’d fit in with the “Deep fried ice cream” model thought up ways back.
 
Last edited:
Thanks.
Ok, we’ll narrow the scope. What was the percentage of surface ice on 67P?

Yada Yada yada....
"ice", as in H2O? or including stuff like CO2?

"percentage"? Of what? As in, a percentage is a ratio, of "a" over "b", say; what are "a" and "b" in your question?

Therfore all the rest of the “ice” required of whipples model is subsurface. Under some form of consolidated non-volatile/organicly layer and ,at least visually, the consolidated “stuff” is very rocky like, so we could call it rock?
Again, you're gonna have to help me out a bit ...

"required of whipples model" - I am unaware of any estimate of the amount of "ice" (however expressed) that "whipples model" "requires" of the comet 67P. Can you please point me to a source where something like that is presented (hopefully along with the steps taken to produce such an estimate)?

"at least visually, the consolidated “stuff” is very rocky like, so we could call it rock" - I think we've been down this road before ... depending on what next winter brings (and my travels then), perhaps I could post some images of "some form of consolidated non-volatile/organicly layer" atop (compacted) snow? I can be certain that, "at least visually, the consolidated “stuff” is very rocky like", yet we would just as certainly not "call it rock"! :p
 
The bit that’s right up hard against the plasma.

That's the outside edge of the surface. What defines the inside edge of the surface? It has some depth, it's not monatomically thin, right? Surely you aren't contending that comets are shells filled with plasma.
 
Thanks.

"ice", as in H2O? or including stuff like CO2?

"percentage"? Of what? As in, a percentage is a ratio, of "a" over "b", say; what are "a" and "b" in your question?


Again, you're gonna have to help me out a bit ...

"required of whipples model" - I am unaware of any estimate of the amount of "ice" (however expressed) that "whipples model" "requires" of the comet 67P. Can you please point me to a source where something like that is presented (hopefully along with the steps taken to produce such an estimate)?

"at least visually, the consolidated “stuff” is very rocky like, so we could call it rock" - I think we've been down this road before ... depending on what next winter brings (and my travels then), perhaps I could post some images of "some form of consolidated non-volatile/organicly layer" atop (compacted) snow? I can be certain that, "at least visually, the consolidated “stuff” is very rocky like", yet we would just as certainly not "call it rock"! :p

Sorry my bad. Lets narrow the scope once again shall we.

Not “ice” per say but Volatiles, all of them.

And let’s use something easy....say like, square meters.

Ummmmmm.... I thought you said you had read the paper you linked to?




What would you like to call the consolidated “stuff” then jean tate?
 
Last edited:
That's the outside edge of the surface. What defines the inside edge of the surface? It has some depth, it's not monatomically thin, right? Surely you aren't contending that comets are shells filled with plasma.

Inside edge?

I’m mean if you wanna play games, take any point on the surface draw a line, where it hits that outside surface again that defines the depth!

But for this little exercise I think i’ll define it has a having a depth on the order of maximum solar infrared radiation, thermal, penetration depth as a whole over the nucleus. And since water is the molecule in question, the depth it takes that thermal wave to penetrate to get water ice to sublimate.

And because we are talking “visual” again in relation to the rocky looking surface, we are not talking a gentle wafting of vapour through pores in the subsurface during sublimation, if we take the many “jet” photos now available of 67P.

So let’s be generous and say depth of 20cm
 
Last edited:
Thanks.
Sorry my bad. Lets narrow the scope once again shall we.

Not “ice” per say but Volatiles, all of them.

And let’s use something easy....say like, square meters.

Ummmmmm.... I thought you said you had read the paper you linked to?




What would you like to call the consolidated “stuff” then jean tate?
Sol88, we seem to be having a communication problem. From my end, I'm simply getting more and more confused. Let me try to explain.

We're starting with Whipple (1950), right? Specifically the "dirty snowball model of comets" (though you won't find the first two in the paper, at least I didn't), right?

Well, to me, Whipple makes it very clear that there's considerable variation when it comes to comets. He specifically discusses several comets and how they are different (and not) from each other, in terms of observational data. He also makes it clear (to me at least) that what he discusses is a general framework, a model of comets that has several components, each of which may (will) vary, from comet to comet. If only in physical size ... but actually over several other physical variables.

And that, to me, is just what I'd expect, from any scientist.

So, if we're going to discuss 67P only (we are, right?), surely we need to start with at least some range of estimates of the various physical variables that comprise the Whipple model, as they apply to 67P, right?

But you won't find anything like that in Whipple (1950), if only because 67P was discovered in 1969. OK, so where to find such?

One possible source: EU central, and references therein. I looked, but came up empty ... lots of huffing and puffing about "the dirty snowball model", but nothing even vaguely quantitative, and nothing specific to 67P.

Oh, and as I think you ended up figuring out, one reason why I kept on banging on about "ice" is Whipple (1950) ... H2O is important, but is not alone. :p
 
So, if we're going to discuss 67P only (we are, right?), surely we need to start with at least some range of estimates of the various physical variables that comprise the Whipple model, as they apply to 67P, right?

Get back to me when you find out the estimates Whipple used.

This may help your search though.

http://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1989ESASP.302...39K

Did you happen across the percentage of surface area, in m2, of water ice on the
nucleus of 67P?

If not, maybe you could use the active areas as a proxy for surface ice?
 
So, if we're going to discuss 67P only (we are, right?), surely we need to start with at least some range of estimates of the various physical variables that comprise the Whipple model, as they apply to 67P, right?
Get back to me when you find out the estimates Whipple used.

<snip>
Um, Sol88, are you trolling me?

Please re-read my post ... Whipple cannot possibly have even attempted to estimate values for physical variables, because he cannot possibly have known about 67P in 1950.

Also, you are the one who wishes to explore this! :(

Here's how you phrased it: "From your understanding of Whipples paper, jean tate and the data returned from the majority of missions to comet nuclei to date, would it be fair to say the majority of ice is of the subsurface type?"

Ball is in your court, mate.
 
Appears whipple didn’t even estimate the ice to dust ratio on/at any comet. He assumed.

http://adsbit.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/n...=0&data_type=GIF&type=SCREEN_VIEW&classic=YES

So how would you like to move forward jean Tate?

All comets are assumed to be “mostly” ice with “some” dust.

This is how the Philea lander was designed, to attach onto the surface of a comet beacause they are known, from Whipple to be “mostly” ice.

So without getting into semantics,
"percentage"? Of what? As in, a percentage is a ratio, of "a" over "b", say; what are "a" and "b" in your question?

Percentage of water ice in m2 over the total m2 of the nucleus?

To the point, with all the data returned from all missions do YOU think a new model maybe in order?
 
Last edited:
The SAFIRE thread including those posts previously moved to AAH has been merged with this Electric Comet thread. It appears to the mod team that all the discussions are intertwined to the point where enforcing a separation is not meaningful.
Posted By: Loss Leader
 
Intertwined. Thank you mobs, mods.

As far as intertwined goes, this new paper is a real rip snorter!


Measurements of fireball onset

The measurements validate the simulations and models in which fireball onset was predicted to follow from the trapping of electrons born from electron impact ionization within a potential well created by a buildup of ions in the sheath. The experimental measurements also demonstrate transient features following the onset that were not present in previous simulations. New simulation results are presented which demonstrate that these features are associated with the abruptness of the voltage step used to initiate fireball onset. An abrupt step in the anode bias causes rapid displacement of ions and an associated plasma potential response following the sheath and fireball expansion.

Never heard them called “fireballs” before...

And some further pertinent reading...

Suprathermal electron environment of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: Observations from the Rosetta Ion and Electron Sensor

Charged particle signatures of the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Cold and warm electrons at comet 67P

Dynamic unmagnetized plasma in the diamagnetic cavity around comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Near-surface expanding ionosphere of comet 67P

Observations of high-plasma density region in the inner coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during early activity

The birth and growth of a solar wind cavity around a comet –Rosetta observations

Just for starters...
 
Here's a strange idea: why don't we spend our time, in this thread, discussing "The Electric Comet Theory"? And SAFIRE? And how the two are intertwined?

Taking my own suggestion to heart, here's what I've found re the former:


Yep, crickets. There is no such thing! :jaw-dropp And, unlike the Norwegian Blue (him wat waz pinin' for the fjords), it is not dead ... because it has never existed.

That also deals with "intertwined": you can't twine with something which does not exist.

That leaves SAFIRE. And the (dozen or so?) questions I've asked Sol88 about it (Sol88 seems to be the only ISF member who feels SAFIRE has any value, other than as a source of revenue for T&T). Maybe you'd be so kind as to actually answer these questions, Sol88?

Of course, I could be wrong (I often am, and prepared to admit it, unlike TT&S, for example) ... so Sol88, why don't you help us all by citing a source in which "The Electric Comet Theory" is presented?

Thanks a bunch, cobber.
 
Intertwined. Thank you mobs, mods.

As far as intertwined goes, this new paper is a real rip snorter!


Measurements of fireball onset



Never heard them called “fireballs” before...

And some further pertinent reading...

Suprathermal electron environment of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: Observations from the Rosetta Ion and Electron Sensor

Charged particle signatures of the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Cold and warm electrons at comet 67P

Dynamic unmagnetized plasma in the diamagnetic cavity around comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Near-surface expanding ionosphere of comet 67P

Observations of high-plasma density region in the inner coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during early activity

The birth and growth of a solar wind cavity around a comet –Rosetta observations

Just for starters...
Um, no.

If any of that has any relevance to "The Electric Comet Theory" or to SAFIRE, you really should state what that relevance is. Explicitly.

May I recommend that you do so, by first citing a source (or sources) in which "The Electric Comet Theory" is presented? Or/and, a source (or sources) which shows that SAFIRE is about comets (or fireballs)?

Otherwise, aren't you wasting our - and your - time?
 
Um, no.

If any of that has any relevance to "The Electric Comet Theory" or to SAFIRE, you really should state what that relevance is. Explicitly.

May I recommend that you do so, by first citing a source (or sources) in which "The Electric Comet Theory" is presented? Or/and, a source (or sources) which shows that SAFIRE is about comets (or fireballs)?

Otherwise, aren't you wasting our - and your - time?

The relevance is...

28mhz5.jpg

Thanks ziggurat! Love it!
 
Last edited:
Um, you're trolling (again), right?

Nothing about "The Electric Comet Theory", or SAFIRE, there.

But perhaps you see the relevance as something like:

Mainstream is RONG! THEREFORE TT&S are RITE!!

If so - and I await your comments on this - it is a clear, and very obvious, example of the logical fallacy called "false dichotomy" (there are several other names too). And as such, it has no place in this, the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology section of the ISF (IMHO, of course).

Certainly, one of the worst mistakes you can make, in science, is to allow a false dichotomy in, even if it's hidden (though I doubt it's all that hidden in this case).
 
Last edited:
The relevance is...

[qimg]https://i.imgflip.com/28mhz5.jpg[/qimg]
Ah right, I get it! Thanks for being so explicit. :thumbsup:

You are, in fact, not discussing "The Electric Comet Theory" (or SAFIRE) at all. :jaw-dropp

Rather, you are relying (entirely?) on a false dichotomy.

Yes?
 
Ah right, I get it! Thanks for being so explicit. :thumbsup:

You are, in fact, not discussing "The Electric Comet Theory" (or SAFIRE) at all. :jaw-dropp

Rather, you are relying (entirely?) on a false dichotomy.

Yes?


How much surface “ice” did you say there was, jean Tate?

Must of missed that post.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom