Thanks.
Sorry my bad. Lets narrow the scope once again shall we.
Not “ice” per say but Volatiles, all of them.
And let’s use something easy....say like, square meters.
Ummmmmm.... I thought you said you had read the paper you linked to?
What would you like to call the consolidated “stuff” then jean tate?
Sol88, we seem to be having a communication problem. From my end, I'm simply getting more and more confused. Let me try to explain.
We're starting with Whipple (1950), right? Specifically the "dirty snowball model of comets" (though you won't find the first two in the paper, at least I didn't), right?
Well, to me, Whipple makes it very clear that there's considerable variation when it comes to comets. He specifically discusses several comets and how they are different (and not) from each other, in terms of observational data. He also makes it clear (to me at least) that what he discusses is a general framework, a model of comets that has several components, each of which may (will) vary, from comet to comet. If only in physical size ... but actually over several other physical variables.
And that, to me, is just what I'd expect, from any scientist.
So, if we're going to discuss 67P only (we are, right?), surely we need to
start with at least some range of estimates of the various physical variables that comprise the Whipple model, as they apply to 67P, right?
But you won't find anything like that in Whipple (1950), if only because 67P was discovered in 1969. OK, so where to find such?
One possible source: EU central, and references therein. I looked, but came up empty ... lots of huffing and puffing about "the dirty snowball model", but nothing even vaguely quantitative, and nothing specific to 67P.
Oh, and as I think you ended up figuring out, one reason why I kept on banging on about "ice" is Whipple (1950) ... H
2O is important, but is not alone.
