Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bit confused by this statement jean Tate perhaps you maybe able to help.

I'll certainly try.

Are you able to make a list with all the viable cometary models presented AFTER Whipples icy conglomerate model (the dirtysnowball).

This is a field of astronomy/space science about which I know very little, so take the following with a grain of salt.

Since 1950, what Whipple presented in his paper has been a basis for many different models. And since spacecraft started flying near comets, many new models have been published, with scopes that go beyond Whipple's, and some which are quite narrow in scope.

As I really only have knowledge of Whipples model and the Electric comet model.

Have you heard the expression "chalk and cheese"? Other than that you have chosen to use the word "model" for what you earlier today (my time) presented as the "ELECTRIC COMET model" (my shorthand), the two have ~nothing in common. At ~any level.

So are there any other viable models of comets you know of?

I was totally unaware that the "ELECTRIC COMET model" is viable, in any sense of the word!

Perhaps we could discuss them in this thread.

I have no intention of discussing anything other than whatever electric comet model you choose to present. In this thread. At least until you change your mind about SAFIRE.

If there is no other viable model(mainstream) peer reviewed Yada yada yada and the electric comet is our (crackpot pseudo-science) model and whipples model is wrong, is that still a false dichotomy?

Yes.
 
A "Measurements of fireball onset" paper + pertinent reading lie

23 April 2018: A "Measurements of fireball onset" paper + pertinent reading lie.
No "comet" in the abstract means that it is a lie that this paper is relevant to this thread.

N.B. Any mention of the SAFIRE experiment in relation to comets is by definition a lie because the SAFIRE experiment is a deluded model of the Sun.
 
"the premise is" lies by missing out the real delusions, etc.

Comets are rocky objects with minimal to no “ice/s”, seeking electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma!
23 April 2018: "the premise is" lies by missing out the real delusions, etc.
We have the usual lie of ices in quotes.
We have the usual lie of "rocky" when comets are observed not to be rocky (density, etc.).
We have the usual lie of minimal or no ices when comet densities tell us that the % of ices is not "minimal". E.g. 67P is 17% ice.
We have the usual lie about fundamental physics - a plasma conducts and so is in "electrical equilibrium" with its contents.

The lie by omission includes "these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently" :eye-poppi!
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Thanks Sol88.

Just to be 100% clear: we can put SAFIRE aside, at least for now, at least in this thread?


So, no external sources you want to cite?

Fine. Here's what we have so far (please correct anything that is inaccurate or wrong; please add anything that is missing):

The ELECTRIC COMET model is as follows:
1) comets are rocky objects
2) they have minimal to no "ice/s"
3) they seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma
4) they are discharging in the solar wind.




I am more than happy to discuss the ELECTRIC COMET model as I have summarized it (caveat: pending any amendments etc you wish to make). I will do so from what I consider to be a science-based approach. I will not discuss anything else: no other models, no ELECTRIC SUN, etc.

In fact, let me start by asking you for some clarifications:

a) the Moon is a rocky object, with minimal to no "ice/s"; yet we do not call it a comet, how come?
b) ditto for Mercury, Venus, Mars, Phobos, Deimos, and (most) asteroids
c) while there certainly are rocks on the Moon, much - perhaps nearly - all its surface is actually dust. Less certainly, the surfaces of Eros and Itokawa seem similar in the sense that there may be few, if any, rocks not covered by dust (and much of the surfaces of both may be quite deep dust). So, clarification question: what do you mean by "rocky"?

In this instance we can call rock as consolidated dust with a density of the compact dust grains measured by GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Compact and dense particles with bulk density constrained in the range(1.9±1.1)×103kgm−3(Rotundietal.2015;Fulleetal.2015b)andsizes(80to800µm)

This should also be reflected in the bulk density (I believe RSI to be flawed) but the bulk density is not a constraint on the electric comet.

What IS important for the rock is, it is a different potential than the surrounding plasma.

What effect, using standard mainstream plasma physics, would we expect to see from such a scenario?

I say it would form a Langmuir sheath around it, as per standard mainstream plasma physics?
 
Last edited:
Points out how insanely deluded the SAFIRE project and ELECTRIC SUN are

SAFIRE are in the lab doing empirical science, not theoretical math, that the Sun(and all stars) are not powered by internal fusion but externally, this is the premise of the ELECTRIC SUN.
23 April 2018: Points out how insanely deluded the SAFIRE project and ELECTRIC SUN are :eye-poppi.
We detect solar neutrinos and no gamma rays from fusion inside the Sun.
The Sun without an internal heat source is a white dwarf star.
 
A "consolidated dust" is rock in the electric comet lie

In this instance we can call rock as consolidated dust with a density of the compact dust grains measured by GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
23 April 2018: A "consolidated dust" as rock in the electric comet lie

The electric comet delusion includes that comets are actual rock blasted from the surface of the Earth. This partially comes from the documented liar Wal Thornhill, e.g. When Asteroids Become Comets but there are plenty of other "comets are similar to asteroids because they were both blasted from planets" fantasies.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Last edited:
A "RSI is flawed" delusion since he lists no flaws

This should also be reflected in the bulk density (I believe RSI to be flawed) but the bulk density is not a constraint on the electric comet.
23 April 2018: A "RSI is flawed" delusion since he lists no flaws.

RSI
RSI (Radio Science Investigation). Frequency shifts in the spacecraft's radio signals will be used to measure the mass and gravity of the comet nucleus in order to deduce its density and internal structure, to define the comet's orbit, and to study its inner coma. RSI has already determined the mass and density of the asteroid Lutetia during the flyby in 2010, and studied the solar corona during the periods when the spacecraft, as seen from Earth, was passing behind the Sun (in 2006 and 2010).
RSI measured the density of the asteroid Lutetia to be 3.4 ± 0.3 g/cm³.
RSI measured the mass of 67P and the volume of 67P gave its density as 532±7 kg m-3.
The global shape, density and rotation of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from preperihelion Rosetta/OSIRIS observations
 
"predicts a Langmuir sheath from a potential difference" ignorance

I say it would form a Langmuir sheath around it, as per standard mainstream plasma physics?
23 April 2018: "mainstream plasma physics predicts a Langmuir sheath from a potential difference" ignorance.

This is a Langmuir sheath or Debye sheath. It is produced when there is a sink of plasma, e.g. the wall of a container. That creates a potential difference over a few Debye lengths. For a comet nucleus that was a sink (metallic?), any sheath would be a few tens or maybe hundreds of meters thick. Real comets though are made of fairly insulating ices and dust. The formation of a sheath is doubtful. Any such sheath would be real physics and irrelevant to his comet delusions.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Thanks.
In this instance we can call rock as consolidated dust with a density of the compact dust grains measured by GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Compact and dense particles with bulk density constrained in the range(1.9±1.1)×103kgm−3(Rotundietal.2015;Fulleetal .2015b)andsizes(80to800µm)

Can you provide that reference in a more easily accessed form please (such as a URL)? I think your copy/paste did not work to faithfully reproduce what is actually in whatever document you took it from.

Also, do you mean that, in the ELECTRIC COMET model, "rocky" means rock, and/or consolidated dust (with density ...)? Or that "rocky" means consolidated dust (etc) only?

This should also be reflected in the bulk density (I believe RSI to be flawed) but the bulk density is not a constraint on the electric comet.
Got it.

Except that it may be in conflict with your previous statement (it depends on what the source you quoted actually says).

What IS important for the rock is, it is a different potential than the surrounding plasma.

OK. However, I think you need to quantify "a different potential" and to better define "the surrounding plasma".

After all, 10-99 V could be such a difference, as could 1099 V. And "surrounding" could be as far away as merely 10-6m, or 106m.

Not sure if you addressed my request for clarification a) and b); let me rephrase them:

Per the ELECTRIC COMET model, all comets are rocky. However, not all rocky bodies are comets. (let's put aside "ice/s" for the purpose of my clarification question). How come?

What effect, <snip>

Let's not get ahead of ourselves, shall we?

I haven't yet had a chance to ask you about 2) they have minimal to no "ice/s"! :)
 
Thanks.


Can you provide that reference in a more easily accessed form please (such as a URL)? I think your copy/paste did not work to faithfully reproduce what is actually in whatever document you took it from.

Also, do you mean that, in the ELECTRIC COMET model, "rocky" means rock, and/or consolidated dust (with density ...)? Or that "rocky" means consolidated dust (etc) only?


Got it.

Except that it may be in conflict with your previous statement (it depends on what the source you quoted actually says).



OK. However, I think you need to quantify "a different potential" and to better define "the surrounding plasma".

After all, 10-99 V could be such a difference, as could 1099 V. And "surrounding" could be as far away as merely 10-6m, or 106m.

Not sure if you addressed my request for clarification a) and b); let me rephrase them:

Per the ELECTRIC COMET model, all comets are rocky. However, not all rocky bodies are comets. (let's put aside "ice/s" for the purpose of my clarification question). How come?



Let's not get ahead of ourselves, shall we?

I haven't yet had a chance to ask you about 2) they have minimal to no "ice/s"! :)

  1. Per the ELECTRIC COMET model, all comets are rocky. However, not all rocky bodies are comets. (let's put aside "ice/s" for the purpose of my clarification question). How come?
I don't know? lets investigate shall we?

  1. OK. However, I think you need to quantify "a different potential" and to better define "the surrounding plasma". After all, 10-99 V could be such a difference, as could 1099 V. And "surrounding" could be as far away as merely 10-6m, or 106m.
The potential difference is anything you want except zero and the plasma surrounding the comet starts at the surface and ends at the heliopause.
 
@ Jean Tate

Just a question for some background, what's your knowledge level wrt plasma?
 
The potential difference is anything you want except zero and the plasma surrounding the comet starts at the surface and ends at the heliopause.

This is why we can't take you seriously.

1) What you or anyone else wants has nothing to do with what actually is.
2) You think currents drive some significant processes here, including the formation of water from rock. How can that happen at an arbitrary voltage? It cannot. There's got to be some minimum threshold voltage to make it happen, and there's got to be some voltage that's too large (ie, it would do MORE than what's observed).
3) Since you can measure some voltage (even if really small) between almost anything, your criteria are unfalsifiable. Which means your theory isn't a scientific theory.

If you don't even know the sign of the voltage that your theory requires, let alone an order-of-magnitude extimate, it isn't even a theory at all. It's just a mythology. It's capable of explaining everything, but it even explains self-contradictory things (like opposite voltage differentials driving the same phenomenon), and therefore it has no predictive power or usefulness.
 
2) You think currents drive some significant processes here, mainly current carrying double layers! including the formation of water from rock. How can that happen at an arbitrary voltage? It cannot. There's got to be some minimum threshold voltage to make it happen, and there's got to be some voltage that's too large (ie, it would do MORE than what's observed).

My bold

28mhz5.jpg



Perhaps you can tell me why you doubt the double layers can not exist at/around a comet?
 
Last edited:
2) You think currents drive some significant processes here, mainly current carrying double layers!

You know why I made that image? Because you apparently believe double layers are capable of doing anything. That's why you don't need to assign any actual physical parameters to anything, because it doesn't matter. Magic has no constraints.
 
You know why I made that image? Because you apparently believe double layers are capable of doing anything. That's why you don't need to assign any actual physical parameters to anything, because it doesn't matter. Magic has no constraints.

So you believe there are no double layers at comets.
 
881 items of ignorance, idiocy, delusions and lies, 29 August 2016 - 23 April 2018

826 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 13 April 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 13 April 2018: A "no electric currents" lie about tusenfem's post.
  2. 13 April 2018: A lie that Don Scott detailed anything at all (let alone first!) about comets or their tails
  3. 13 April 2018: A lie that a Don Scott quote is about comets or their tails
  4. 16 April 2018: Comet current system and DL lies
  5. 16 April 2018: Still cannot understand the stupidity of citing ices and dust papers to support delusions about comets made of rock, etc.
  6. 16 April 2018: Lies about the electric comet delusions which has no DLs releasing oxygen.
  7. 16 April 2018: Sol88's personal delusion of DLs, diamagnetic cavity, etc.
  8. 16 April 2018: Totally stupid ""ices all mixed forgather" questions to derail from his many comet delusions.
  9. 16 April 2018: Repeats his lie about Scott's deluded paper being about comets.
  10. 16 April 2018: A "helical tail structures observed" from Birkeland currents lie.
  11. 16 April 2018: The lie that the SAFIRE experiment is on comets.
  12. 16 April 2018: Abysmal stupidity about the Rosetta mission (not sent to do 1 measurement!)
  13. 16 April 2018: Usual "falsified Whipple’s model" lie.
  14. 16 April 2018: A "Not what is said by Mendis" lie.
  15. 16 April 2018: Repeats the stupidity of citing a ices and dust comet paper (by D. A. Mendis).
  16. 16 April 2018: Usual Birkeland current and DL lies.
  17. 16 April 2018: Irrelevant MHD delusion (just their measured density says comets are not rocks).
  18. 16 April 2018: Repeats the le that Whipple's model was wrong.
  19. 16 April 2018: An insane question to derail from his many comets delusions.
  20. 16 April 2018: Usual lies about ices and dust papers (Gombosi et. al.)
  21. 16 April 2018: An insane "No viable model for “jets”" lie.
  22. 16 April 2018: A "Close to a comet the dust is negatively charged" lie.
  23. 16 April 2018: Argument by insult and lies (no papers support his many comet delusions).
  24. 16 April 2018: The problem is that most of his posts are lies about mainstream, ices and dust comet papers.
  25. 16 April 2018: The insanity of Wal Thornhill's documented for almost 8 years and obvious lies of confirmed comet predictions.
  26. 17 April 2018: A "smattering of dust" lie about the working model of comets.
  27. 17 April 2018: A lie that Rosetta has shown anything about his lie of a model.
  28. 17 April 2018: A "know before hand to as hard as rock" double lie.
  29. 18 April 2018: Wants astronomer to be as insanely deluded as him about comets.
  30. 18 April 2018: A "comets are harder then expected" partial lie
  31. 18 April 2018: Cites an article on comets made of ices and dust and lies about it.
  32. 18 April 2018: A delusion that Saturn powers the Sun
  33. 18 April 2018: A delusion that magnetic ropes are a "type of power line".
  34. 18 April 2018: Cannot understand that a title is not an article.
  35. 18 April 2018: Citing a clearly deluded Scott paper on Birkeland currents.
  36. 18 April 2018: A lie about his "i’d say more along these type of power lines" post
  37. 18 April 2018: A lie that a Interstellar Boundary Explorer paper is relevant to SAFIRE.
  38. 20 April 2018: Still deluded about the "Unexpected and significant findings" comet paper
  39. 20 April 2018: A lie about the MUPUS-PEN results which sates "dust-ice layer".
  40. 20 April 2018: A "well consolidated material, bedrock" lie about the return sample from Wild 2 (dust grains!)
  41. 20 April 2018: Lies again about an ices and dust comet paper (Beth and Galand)
  42. 20 April 2018: A "All double layers are electric fields" lie when replying to a "ambipolar electric field" post.
  43. 20 April 2018: A ignorant question showing his inability to read and understand science.
  44. 20 April 2018: A "plasma expert" lie when all that is needed is English.
  45. 20 April 2018: Repeats his "double layers found at Halley...As found by Laakso" lie.
  46. 23 April 2018: Idiotic Whipple questions to derail from his many comet delusions and waste other posters time.
  47. 23 April 2018: A Whipple assumed lie about a "Whipple's Comet Model" paper.
  48. 23 April 2018: An irrelevant "Measurements of fireball onset" paper + pertinent reading lie.
  49. 23 April 2018: "the premise is" lies by missing out the real delusions, etc.
  50. 23 April 2018: Points out how insanely deluded the SAFIRE project and ELECTRIC SUN are :eye-poppi.
  51. 23 April 2018: A "consolidated dust" as rock in the electric comet lie
  52. 23 April 2018: A "RSI is flawed" delusion since he lists no flaws.
  53. 23 April 2018: A lie about the electric comet which constrains bulk density of be that of rock (~3 g/cc).
  54. 23 April 2018: "mainstream plasma physics predicts a Langmuir sheath from a potential difference" ignorance.
  55. 23 April 2018: Lies about Ziggurat's question which was not about Sol88's delusions on double layers.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom