Evolutionary advantage of Type 2 Diabetes?

Cart/horse? With all of those soft tissue problems, is it any wonder I don't feel like running a marathin? I did do much better when gobbling Ibuprofen, but kidney limitations took that off the table. And I think I left kidney disease off the list .Nah, it's a result of a genetic variation. Genes is why so few people manage to actually lose weight, and even fewer can keep it off. And see post 6 above, after a whole year only half of the subjects managed to get off the meds.

Also same post link, 150 genes related to diabetes, doesn't matter. It's not quantity, it's quality. Hmmm, I wonder which genes the two groups had? Controlled w/ d&e, not controllable with d&e? The data could show a uselessness to your advise for half the patients?

Genes effect EVERYTHING- mood, intellect, size,endurance, strength, digestion, libido,even whether we like rutabagas. Problem is that at this point science has picked all the low hanging fruit- the one-to-ones of genotype<->phenotype. Next it needs to figure out which combination of several of those 150 genetic variants cause YOUR diabetes.

There are some 1:1 genetic probs related to diabetes, like defects in the insulin receptor. But much of the resistance is caused by variations of metabolic defects. Say, a defect in a gene for making COQ10. Then your body can't burn fats, they build up in your cells, causing not only poor endurance, bur the fats get in the way, clogging your insulin receptors. "If you think you understand metabolism, you missed something."

That COQ10 gene is named COQ2, I am homozygous for a defect there. Treatable with COQ10 supplements, a gram per day. That gene is in 11% of the population. (I bet it is one of the 150 cited) Many other defects are about that percentage. Having two such defects makes you 1/100, three 1/1,000. four 1/10,000. We each have 40 million to pick 4 from. We are all unique, baby. Our treatment can not be "one size fits all".

Yeah... the whole "genetics" argument. Genetics that only come into play in the last half century, in societies where people have essentially unlimited access to food, eat too much, and don't exercise enough... Also, why bring up weight loss? That's a diet thing, based on the choices someone makes.

Are some people more predisposed to acquiring diabetes? Probably.

Still doesn't change the fact that type 2 is rare among people of a healthy weight. Kind of like gout, it's a disease of overindulgence.

But good news! It seems that evolution is selecting against obesity, and by extension, diabetes. Besides obese people being less attractive mates, obese women are less likely to conceive, and more likely to suffer complications during pregnancy.
 
Even if people were susceptible to type 2 diabetes, it's only relatively recently in evolutionary terms that we have enough of a calorie surplus for people to go on and develop in in any appreciable numbers.


Is that literally true, the calorie surplus thing? (It may well be common knowledge ; my own awareness about this is only sketchy.) If that is so, then it seems the solution is simple : just keep your calorific input below surplus level (while taking care to get in enough nutrients). Do you think that simple measure would be ample, that no further drugs would be needed?


Then there's the question of whether it strikes early enough to have an impact on breeding success. If I've already passed on my genes successfully at 25, it really doesn't matter that much whether I get sick at 55 from an evolutionary perspective.


This needn’t necessarily be the case. Like I’d tried to express, in a probably unfortunate attempt at a joke earlier on here : Males, men, are able to reproduce much later into life than women. And both life expectancy and general health for humans have shot up in these recent times, when compared with earlier centuries and earlier millennia. Given that, even older males would, nowadays, often be capable of reproducing.

Diabetes doesn’t always strike at 55, it often sets in very much earlier than that. I have no clue what the median age might be, but I’d guess (based on nothing more than my own personal anecdotal observations) that it might be closer to 40 than to 55. But even if we take a higher number, say 50 years, or even for that matter 55 years, that does not, for the male at least, rule out reproduction. (And obviously, should the median turn out to be 45 years, say, instead of 55, then the prospects for the male to reproduce become that much stronger, that much likelier.)


The treatment of type 2 diabetes through diet and exercise is so very recent that it cannot have had an evolutionary effect in any case.


Are we sure of this?

I’m no evolutionary biologist, just an amateur -- in fact not even that, I’m just a sketchily informed dabbler in these discussions -- so absolutely I could be wrong, wholly wrong. But my understanding is that mutations are passed on from generation to generation. So, if the diabetes gene (if I may call it that) is indeed of benefit, then it may well have already, in these few decades, started getting passed on successfully.

Perhaps this isn’t measurable yet, because as you say this is so very recent : but could it be that the process has already started, and may become evident two or three (or ten) generations down the line?

For that matter, might it be that this has already started making itself felt? Perhaps we can actually measure this, already (even if we cannot actually isolate this effect)? Perhaps the higher incidence of diabetes at this time (than in other and earlier times) has in some measure something to do with this? Sure, there are a host of other factors, but can we say for sure that this also (the successful passing of the genes) might not be one factor, among others, for the explosion of diabetes cases in our times?

I have no view about whether diabetes really is a thing in terms of evolution (I don’t have enough subject knowledge to form my own view), but I’d be interested to know if you (or anyone else) can say with certainty that such relatively recent trends are definitely outside the scope of what might influence evolution. My instinctive view, my (ill-informed) intuition, says otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Is that literally true, the calorie surplus thing? (It may well be common knowledge ; my own awareness about this is only sketchy.) If that is so, then it seems the solution is simple : just keep your calorific input below surplus level (while taking care to get in enough nutrients). Do you think that simple measure would be ample, that no further drugs would be needed?

Yes it does work, and in the case of my mother it took the loss of her foot, two heart attacks and another seven years for her to actually engage in controlling her diet.

Controlling diets can be difficult even when the individual is interested in it.

Then the low cost of processed carbohydrates impacts others, also out bodies have many interesting mechanism that make processed carbohydrates seem preferable.
 
Two very recent studies:

A carbohydrate-reduced high-protein diet acutely decreases postprandial and diurnal glucose excursions in type 2 diabetes patients.

Effect of dietary carbohydrate restriction on glycemic control in adults with diabetes: A systematic review and meta-analysis.


And a very recent Danish study: Vægttab før puberteten reducerer risikoen for type2 diabetes, "Weight loss before puberty reduces the risk of type-2 diabetes"

ETA: I found the Danish study in English:
OVERWEIGHT A high body mass index (BMI) and overweight during childhood increase the risk of developing type 2 diabetes later in life. But now researchers from SUND and the Capital Region of Denmark have shown that this only applies to persons who continue to be overweight during puberty or later.
Weight Loss Before Puberty Reduces the Risk of Type 2 Diabetes (Apr. 5, 2018)
 
Last edited:
what about type 1 diabetes, that generally killed people before they reproduced in the past. Without inject able insulin there would be few adult type 1 diabetics reproducing.
why the hell is that still around?
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
what about type 1 diabetes, that generally killed people before they reproduced in the past. Without inject able insulin there would be few adult type 1 diabetics reproducing.
why the hell is that still around?


No idea! Random mutations? It was a real killer!

With no effective treatment aside from a semi-starvation diet, a diabetic's outlook appeared grim. Before 1922, diabetic children rarely lived a year after diagnosis, five percent of adults died within two years, and less than 20 percent lived more than ten (Berger 57). Untreated diabetics faced blindness, loss of limbs, kidney failure, stroke, heart attack and death (Yuwiler 12).
Diabetes Before Insulin

See also: Treatments for Diabetes in the Pre-Insulin Era
 
The key is reproductive success, considering that as far as we know most Type II diabetes seems associated with high carbohydrate diets and low levels of exercise, why would it have been selected out of the population in the past, prior to the 1970s?

Most people who develop Type II diabetes are capable of reproduction and many do reproduce, that is all that matters in evolution, a negative trait must impact reproduction and cause individuals to not reproduce.

My mother did not develop Type II diabetes until 20 years after she had three children

Indeed - and she'd have been old enough to look after her grandchildren (assuming that she and her kids would have typically started breeding around 15). But more to the point she wouldn't have had a lifetime with plenty. That is *very* new.
 
Is that literally true, the calorie surplus thing? (It may well be common knowledge ; my own awareness about this is only sketchy.) If that is so, then it seems the solution is simple : just keep your calorific input below surplus level (while taking care to get in enough nutrients). Do you think that simple measure would be ample, that no further drugs would be needed?

Well without birth control, the population would increase until limited by one of Malthus's four horsemen.

So times of plenty would be temporary, as the population would just increase.
 
what about type 1 diabetes, that generally killed people before they reproduced in the past. Without inject able insulin there would be few adult type 1 diabetics reproducing.
why the hell is that still around?

Way back when I read E O Wilson's Sociobiology, he had a discussion of ways that genes for apparently disadvantageous traits could remain in the gene pool. Included were I think 5 or 6 mechanisms, including genetic drift, new mutations that continue to replenish the gene, genes that are beneficial when possessing a single copy but disadvantageous when possessing two copies (like sickle cell anemia), and some others that I'm not remembering. I found the discussion quite eye opening.
 
Type 1 is an auto-immune disease, where in you immune system attacks the beta cells in your pancreas. Beta cells produce insulin. Other than the high sugars, totally different disease tahn T2. But there are genes for T1 too.

And fyi, I have been T2 since my mid 20s. 40 years now. And big but not obese as a youngster. I was getting some acromegaly symptoms BEFORE turning obese and diabetic. Which in m,y mind makes me thing Insulin Resistance as a genetic thing, see the OP.
 
Frinstance, diet and exercise ARE THE BEST TREATMENT. Because taking insulin only exacerbates the pseudo-acromegaly.


This guy, professor Arne Astrup, is the leader of the Copenhagen University Institute of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports, and in Dansk Skeptica we have an excellent cooperation with him whenever breatharianism rears its ugly face: He always lets us repeat his offer to have their claims tested at the institute! :) (So far, they've never returned our calls!)
For a couple of years, Arne Astrup and his team(s) have known and documented that recently diagnosed diabetes can be cured with diet and exercise:

Newly discovered type 2 diabetes can be cured with the proper diet and exercise - we know this, but is research being done to find out how we can implement this knowledge in the actual treatment of diabetes type 2? No, it's more or less hopeless to get money for this - rejection after rejection, but we do not stop :) - But knowing this, one may be concerned about whether the non-pharmacological treatment is completely overlooked in the new diabetes-treatment centers.
Social Democrats demand insight into billion kroner present from Novo


The problem is that pharma giant Novo Nordisk, a producer of insulin, also has a ‘charitable’ branch, Novo Nordisk Foundation, which supports research in diabetes treatment. It has financed several centers for diabetes treatment in Denmark, but since there’s not a lot of profit for shareholders in teaching people to diet and exercise, they focus exclusively on the medicinal treatment of diabetes type 2!!!

That’s Big Pharma for you.


Diabetes type 2 and evolution:
How Type 2 Diabetes Survived Evolution (Science Life, Mar. 7, 2013)
The Evolutionary Benefit of Insulin Resistance (Pub Med, Dec. 31, 2012)
 
Last edited:
Yes it does work, and in the case of my mother it took the loss of her foot, two heart attacks and another seven years for her to actually engage in controlling her diet.

Controlling diets can be difficult even when the individual is interested in it.

Then the low cost of processed carbohydrates impacts others, also out bodies have many interesting mechanism that make processed carbohydrates seem preferable.


I’m sorry about your mother, David, and hope she’s doing better now.

Just to clarify, in your mother’s case, did she finally shift to a less-than-surplus diet, calorie-wise, and was this enough to take care of her situation, the diabetes part I mean, even in that advanced stage? Or does she need to take medication for her diabetes, over and above her changed diet?
 


Thanks for the link, dann.

They give out the average age as 54. Of course, there are qualifications : this applies only to US, to being with ; plus they talk about differences between age of onset and diagnosis. But the short answer is 54.

That would mean, I suppose, that passing this on to the next generation becomes far less likely. You can technically procreate at 54 if you’re a man, but in practice probably not so much, not in large enough numbers for this to make a difference.
 


The evidence seems clear enough there. A low-carb diet is definitely good for you if you have diabetes. Thanks for posting those links.

This part, that a low-sugar low-carb diet is good for you if you have diabetes, is common knowledge I suppose, even among those who, like me, don’t really know too much about this issue.

But if a low-carolie sub-surplus diet (low-carb, certainly, but sub-surplus in calorie terms, that added qualification seems crucial) is enough to take care of diabetes, and over time removes the need for medication, well then this is most certainly not common knowledge : at least, I do know people who have diabetes, and none of them follow or, so far as I know, are even aware of this option.
 
Well without birth control, the population would increase until limited by one of Malthus's four horsemen.

So times of plenty would be temporary, as the population would just increase.


I hate to kill your joke by asking you to explain it, but I have to ask : Where does not using birth control come in here, in this context?
 
But remember that exercise is also extremely important if you want to get rid of diabetes or pre-diabetes.
And it appears to be one of those cases where alt. med. might be right: Big Pharma doesn't want you to know about this! (But if you're pushing homeopathic remedies for diabetes or similar nonsense, that's one thing they have in common!)
Exercise prescription for patients with type 2 diabetes and pre-diabetes: A position statement from Exercise and Sport Science Australia (Journal of Science in Medicine and Sport, Jan. 2012, Volume 15, Issue 1, Pages 25–31)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom