Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Seems ions go in, electrons go out?

No, ions go out, electrons go out, but electrons (thousends times lighter than ions) go faster, and get decelearated by the ambipolar electric field that is created because of the difference in outward velocity of the ions and electrons.

You really don't read the papers, in which these explanations are give, do you?

Laura Berčič specifically writes in the sentence after the one you bolded

Both populations display a consistent anti-sunward velocity component.
 
Last edited:
So what are the solar wind electrons up to? Or the cometary electrons at this time?

Charge separation you said.

Read Kevin Heritier's paper, which you already quoted at some point (but did not understand)

I did not say charge separation.
 
The second population gained most of its energy in the close vicinity of the nucleus where cometary ions largely dominate and where the acceleration appears to be driven by an ambipo- lar electric field. The ion motion in the yz-plane is radially away from the comet independent of the solar wind electric field direc- tion. This population thus comes from a part of the coma where the local ambipolar electric field governs the ion motion, and the solar wind electric field has much less influence.

solar wind electric eld has much less inuence. In agreement with Behar et al. (2016a) and Nilsson et al. (2017), the present observations point towards the existence of an additional electric eld accelerating all cometary ions towards the anti-sunward direction. The data thus suggest, that there is a third electric eld in the vicinity of the comet, in addition to the solar wind and ionospheric ambipolar electric elds, affecting both the cometary ion populations.

Nested double layers!

Kinetic plasma effects!

Dirty snowball said ‘nuff’n ‘bout that!
 
Last edited:
No, ions go out, electrons go out, but electrons (thousends times lighter than ions) go faster, and get decelearated by the ambipolar electric field that is created because of the difference in outward velocity of the ions and electrons.

You really don't read the papers, in which these explanations are give, do you?

Laura Berčič specifically writes in the sentence after the one you bolded

Really you say? :rolleyes:

Charge separation, you say?

Ions go anti sunward??? Toward the nucleus?? Like there a big current somewhere driving a potential difference.
 
Last edited:
Really you say? :rolleyes:

Charge separation, you say?

Ions go anti sunward??? Toward the nucleus?? Like there a big current somewhere driving a potential difference.

you do know we are on terminator orbits, I hope?
And if electrons and ions move in the same direction there will be little current, if any.
And a current cannot "drive a potential difference".
 
Last edited:
So your saying, with a straight face, the sublimation of subsurface ice “stops” the solar wind?

That one?

Hint, think Kinetic plasma effects.

:D

I'm not saying it - real scientists with access to the data are saying it, and it has been known about for decades. Giotto stopped detecting solar wind H+ at ~ 60 000 km. It was similarly observed in the AMPTE artificial comet experiments in '84. It has been well known that the solar wind disappeared at 67P around perihelion, from roughly April to January. This was known at the time, and was reported at the time. Why is it news to you?
 
Usual lies (charge separation happens in the real world of any ionized gas)

So charge separation does happen around an ELECTRIC COMET
27 June 2018: Usual lies (charge separation happens in the real world of any ionized gas, e.g. plasma).
His delusion of an electric comet = not even any plams areund it :eye-poppi!

27 June 2018: Usual lies about the Lakkso paper (no "kinetic plasma structure", no double layers)

27 June 2018: Lies about double layers and the SAFIRE project.
A double layer is not a capacitor. No "Transforming Capacitor " at his link.
 
Yet another "serious problem for the standard model" lie about the solar wind

Which also raises a serious problem for the standard model!
27 June 2018: Yet another "serious problem for the standard model" lie (about solar wind deflection by comets).

What tusenfem wrote:
You still don't get it, do you?
The kinetic effects are e.g. the deflection of the solar wind in the neighbourhood of the comet, which creates the differently directed magnetic field in the near tail, which has nothing to do with any "electric comet".
That deflection of the solar wind in the neighborhood of the comet is supported by deflection of the solar wind in the neighborhood of the comet in Mass-loading of the solar wind at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Observations and modelling :jaw-dropp!

The abstract makes clear that during low nucleus activity, the solar wind is deflected, "whereas there is little deceleration of the solar wind".

27 June 2018: A "solar wind is not slowing down" lie about a Behar et.al. paper (they state "little deceleration").

27 June 2018: A "unexpected from a sublimating dirtysnowball" lie about a Behar et.al. paper using a sublimating comet nucleus model.

27 June 2018: A "puts paid to "draping"" lie about a Behar et.al. paper supports "the differently directed magnetic field in the near tail".
 
Last edited:
Idiotic post when the cited paper is that solar wind stops

So your saying, with a straight face, the sublimation of subsurface ice “stops” the solar wind?
27 June 2018: Idiotic post when the cited paper is that solar wind stops (a cavity formed around 67P)!
The birth and growth of a solar wind cavity around a comet - Rosetta observations by Behar, E. et al.
The Rosetta mission provided detailed observations of the growth of a cavity in the solar wind around comet 67P/CG. As the comet approached the Sun, the plasma of cometary origin grew enough in density and size to present an obstacle to the solar wind. Our results demonstrate how the initial slight perturbations of the solar wind prefigure the formation of a solar wind cavity, with a particular interest placed on the discontinuity (solar wind cavity boundary) passing over the spacecraft. The slowing down and heating of the solar wind can be followed and understood in terms of single particle motion. We propose a simple geometric illustration that accounts for the observations, and shows how a cometary magnetosphere is seeded from the gradual steepening of an initially slight solar wind perturbation. A perspective is given concerning the difference between the diamagnetic cavity and the solar wind cavity

Even more idiotic when this known comet behavior has been mentioned previously in this thread. The paper is that we now have detailed observations of the formation of a solar wind cavity.
 
Last edited:
A lie about his "Where are the currents?" highlighting of a jonesdave116 post

No currents you say???
27 June 2018: A lie about his "Where are the currents?" highlighting of a jonesdave116 post.

Errrr, no. There was no electric woo. And you don't understand what kinetic effects means. Point us to the observed electric woo that was causing non-existent O- ions to be electrically machined from non-existent rock, to somehow create water (lol). Simple. Two years worth of data. Where is it? Where are the DLs? Where are the currents? Where is the EDM (lol)? None of it happened. Ergo, the electric comet woo is as dead now as it was when the impactor excavated far too big a crater at Tempel 1, and threw out thousands of tonnes of ice. You are still batting zero, and are still clueless about science. Which is why you believe this garbage in the first place. Correct?
jonesdave116 is clearly asking where are the currents (and DLs and EDM!) that the electric comet delusions require. This is not a statement that there are no currents.
 
A "Kinetic plasma effects" lie about a Berčič et.al. paper on cometary ion dynamics

Or this paper:

Cometary ion dynamics observed in the close vicinity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during the intermediate activity period

L. Berčič1,2, E. Behar2,1, H. Nilsson2,1, G. Nicolaou2,4, G. Stenberg Wieser2, M. Wieser2 and C. Goetz3
27 June 2018: A "Kinetic plasma effects" lie about a Berčič et.al. paper on cometary ion dynamics

Kinetic effects in plasma is on scales where the plasma acts as neutral particles :eye-poppi.
 
Last edited:
Deluded lies about a Berčič et.al. paper on cometary ion dynamics (no DLs at all!)

Nested double layers! ...
27 June 2018: Deluded lies about a Berčič et.al. paper on cometary ion dynamics (no DLs or kinetic effects at all!)

What he quotes is about the driving of ions and electrons by electric fields.

The second population gained most of its energy in the close vicinity of the nucleus where cometary ions largely dominate and where the acceleration appears to be driven by an ambipo- lar electric field. The ion motion in the yz-plane is radially away from the comet independent of the solar wind electric field direc- tion. This population thus comes from a part of the coma where the local ambipolar electric field governs the ion motion, and the solar wind electric field has much less influence.
No DLs or kinetic effects in that quote = a lie.

solar wind electric eld has much less inuence. In agreement with Behar et al. (2016a) and Nilsson et al. (2017), the present observations point towards the existence of an additional electric eld accelerating all cometary ions towards the anti-sunward direction. The data thus suggest, that there is a third electric eld in the vicinity of the comet, in addition to the solar wind and ionospheric ambipolar electric elds, affecting both the cometary ion populations
No DLs or kinetic effects in that quote a lie.

The absence of DLs or kinetic effects in what he quotes gives the deluded part of the lies.
 
Last edited:
you do know we are on terminator orbits, I hope?
And if electrons and ions move in the same direction there will be little current, if any.
And a current cannot "drive a potential difference".

Sorry spell checked, the currents are driven by the potential differences.

My bad (iPads bad):blush:

Reckon we’d tally up the total ions moving anti sunward to the total amount of electrons and you’d have a net current.

This also makes up the potential difference, the double layer or a ambipolar electric field.

These fields can obviously get quite large in both extent and potential difference.
 
Last edited:
I'm not saying it - real scientists with access to the data are saying it, and it has been known about for decades. Giotto stopped detecting solar wind H+ at ~ 60 000 km. It was similarly observed in the AMPTE artificial comet experiments in '84. It has been well known that the solar wind disappeared at 67P around perihelion, from roughly April to January. This was known at the time, and was reported at the time. Why is it news to you?

Because the DOUBLE LAYERS/PLASMA SHEATHS/AMBIPOLAR ELECTRIC FIELDS do a far more efficient job ELECTRICALY. :D

Asymmetric “outgassing” of the nucleus from subsurface ice, sounds like more faireytales from the dirtysnowball (Whipple) camp
 
Because the DOUBLE LAYERS/PLASMA SHEATHS/AMBIPOLAR ELECTRIC FIELDS do a far more efficient job ELECTRICALY. :D

Asymmetric “outgassing” of the nucleus from subsurface ice, sounds like more faireytales from the dirtysnowball (Whipple) camp

Sorry, you burke? What is showing up in the data, dear? Zilch, yes? When are you cretins going to get it through your thick skulls that none of this scientifically impossible woo actually happened? How dumb do you need to be? Sol88; are you teaching your children this complete and utter sh1te? Are they going to grow up as thick as you? Heaven help them, eh?
 
Asymmetric outgassing stupidity to derail from his many comet delusions

Asymmetric “outgassing” of the nucleus from subsurface ice, sounds like more faireytales from the dirtysnowball (Whipple) camp
27 June 2018: Asymmetric outgassing stupidity to derail from his many comet delusions

This is not about outgassing:
I'm not saying it - real scientists with access to the data are saying it, and it has been known about for decades. Giotto stopped detecting solar wind H+ at ~ 60 000 km. It was similarly observed in the AMPTE artificial comet experiments in '84. It has been well known that the solar wind disappeared at 67P around perihelion, from roughly April to January. This was known at the time, and was reported at the time. Why is it news to you?


Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Because the DOUBLE LAYERS/PLASMA SHEATHS/AMBIPOLAR ELECTRIC FIELDS do a far more efficient job ELECTRICALY. :D

Asymmetric “outgassing” of the nucleus from subsurface ice, sounds like more faireytales from the dirtysnowball (Whipple) camp


Eejit. Seriously. Did the person that wrote that ever get beyond primary school science? Bloody unlikely, I'd say.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom