There is No God (And You Know It)

That's not my hypothesis. My hypothesis is a God that cannot be observed because he does not want to be observed, but does serve a function.

-Bri

When a psychic tells Randi that "negative vibes from skeptics" are cancelling his powers so they don't work, do we go with that theory, or do we assume he doesn't actually have those powers?

When religions believed a god or gods were behind everything from storms to earthquakes to droughts the form of our bodies to the placement of government officials, yet science over the centuries shows otherwise, and the religious say, well, God must be hiding deliberately because he highly values belief without proof, do we go with that theory, or do we assume there isn't actually a god?
 
The statement wasn't that God couldn't reasonably exist, it was that it's impossible for him to exist (i.e. "There is no God" not "There probably is no God"). You have yet to provide evidence to back up the statement "There is no God." I don't think that I could calculate the probability of God's existance based on the arguments you have provided thus far.

I'm asking a question a little off-center from the thread's title. Please answer.

Then unless you can provide evidence that souls can't exist, you cannot provide evidence that the deist God can't exist.

That's not my point. My point is that we have no reason whatsoever to posit the existence of souls, and without them your hypothesis that God's function is, in part, to judge us (presumably, after death) fails.

An incomplete theory at best. Not to say that we won't come up with a "complete" theory someday, but it's certainly possible that we won't.

Again, besides the point. The theory does not require God, and fits the facts.
 
There are "compatibilist" arguments that claim that some form of free will is possible even if determinism is true. Most of the arguments seem to change the definition of what most people consider to be "free will" in order to resolve moral delimmas that seem to arise from determinism, such as the question of how we can be responsible for what we do if we have no choice to do otherwise.

Here is a good article on the subject.

Ossai isn't quite correct in implying that Christians are compatibilists. Most Christians don't believe in determinism.

Well, personnally I don't see how we can have free will in the classical sense if everything happens in a pre-determined way. Though, as I've said before, from our point of view it doesn't change anything because we can't tell in advance what's going to happen.
 
Belz...
A completely deterministic universe in which the people have free will.
That doesn't even make sense. Where did you get that idea ?
Again, ask the Christians.
For a specific example the Southern Baptist preach about god’s divine plan and how it comes to fruition and how god intervenes to make it so, but then turn around and blame the current state of the world (bad, evil, immoral, etc) on people and how they sin against god (freewill).


Bri
If you choose evil, then you are in no way increasing the good in the world.
Does the same thing apply to god?

Without free will, you can't make any choices at all. So prove that the world would be exactly the same with or without free will.
Easy. God wants it this way.

Because we haven't yet, and possibly can't. You asked me to give you possible purposes for God, and creating life might be one of them. Prove that it's not.
You’re attempting to shift the burden here. You are the one proclaiming that god’s purpose is the creation of life, therefore it’s up to you to prove it not someone else to disprove it.

Then unless you can provide evidence that souls can't exist, you cannot provide evidence that the deist God can't exist.
See shifting burden above.

How is "little Timmy's" suffering any different from the suffering of any other innocent human being?
It’s not. Little Timmy is being used as just a specific instead of a general example.

Why did you place the word "little" in front of Timmy's name when you had already made it clear that Timmy was a child?
That’s a gaming related story that developed over many sessions and campaigns. You’re probably not interested in hearing it.

Ossai isn't quite correct in implying that Christians are compatibilists. Most Christians don't believe in determinism.
I didn’t say ALL Christians.

Beerina Nicely stated. :clap:

Ossai
 
I read the link, it presents nothing new or insightful. Foreknowledge, doesn’t even have to be divine, and freewill are mutually exclusive.
It's not supposed to be anything new. It's an overview of the historical development and current state of philosophy on that topic. What it reveals is that no one has yet been able clearly to demonstrate that foreknowledge and freedom are mutually exclusive. Saying that this question has been resolved doesn't make it so.

Close but no cigar.
God is said to have the trait omnibenevolent.
God orders his followers to bash in the heads of enemy babies with great joy, which is sadistic.
Therefore you have an omnibenevolent sadist.
Again, this is another variation on the problem of evil, which cannot be proved to result in a logical contradiction for reasons already evoked in this thread, including, among others, the so-called "Agnostic Thesis" discussed above.

As I mentioned earlier, professional atheologians have pretty much given up on the logical problem of evil. You're flogging a dead argument.

An you’ve just trumped omniscience.
No, Ossai. Omniscience does not require an agent to make sense of the instrinsically meaningless any more than omnipotence requires an agent to be able to bring about the intrinsically impossible. I said it earlier: no amount of knowledge helps one figure out a square circle. Applying additional information, even total information, to the problem does not get one any closer to doing so.
 
Again, ask the Christians.
For a specific example the Southern Baptist preach about god’s divine plan and how it comes to fruition and how god intervenes to make it so, but then turn around and blame the current state of the world (bad, evil, immoral, etc) on people and how they sin against god (freewill).

Oh, I'm not saying that no one claims it to be possible. I'm just saying it doesn't make sense.
 
When a psychic tells Randi that "negative vibes from skeptics" are cancelling his powers so they don't work, do we go with that theory, or do we assume he doesn't actually have those powers?

Your point is well-taken. Unfortunately, we cannot assume a definitive answer in either case. Randi's tests cannot prove that psychic powers don't exist. Randi does a "calibration" test in most cases (with the targets exposed, etc) in order to avoid the claim that "negative vibes" produced the results, but that doesn't mean that he can prove otherwise. Negative vibes or not, the person being tested cannot collect the million unless he passes the test (the burden of proof for a specific claim is placed on the person taking the test).

When religions believed a god or gods were behind everything from storms to earthquakes to droughts the form of our bodies to the placement of government officials, yet science over the centuries shows otherwise, and the religious say, well, God must be hiding deliberately because he highly values belief without proof, do we go with that theory, or do we assume there isn't actually a god?

Unfortunately, science has never shown otherwise. Science cannot test the untestable, and by most accounts is not concerned with the existance of God.

There are many reasons for why God might not want us to know for certain that he exists (we've already discussed some of them).

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Talk about strawmen!! You're funny. You're assuming that, without God, there can be no free will. How is that ? I asked how a universe WITH a God be different than one WITHOUT one. How can we assume that free will cannot exist without God ? You made that assertion, not I.

No, no, no. I misunderstood your question. Yes, it is possible that we might have free will without God (although science indicates that we don't). You asked for purposes that God might serve, and I said that God's purpose might be to provide free will. Then I thought you were asking what the difference would be in a world in which we had free will and a world in which there was no free will, but apparently that wasn't your question.

I'm sorry, I don't have to answer a logical fallacy.

Again, you asked what purpose God might serve, and I said that he might serve the purpose of creating life. I also said that science has yet to create life, and possibly never will. I don't see the fallacy there. Please don't cry "fallacy" unless you can at least identify the fallacy.

Understanding weather implies controlling it ? I don't even see how controlling implies understanding, so you'll forgive me if I don't understand your assertion, here.

Where did I use the word "understanding?" Again, you asked what purpose God might serve, and I said he might serve the purpose of creating earthquakes and tornadoes (i.e. controlling the weather). You implied that God could not create earthquakes and tornados because "we know exactly what causes them." I said that science does not currently know all of the factors that cause earthquakes and tornadoes, and cannot science cannot prove that God doesn't cause them.

-Bri
 
I'm asking a question a little off-center from the thread's title. Please answer.

I thought I had. You asked:

...would you consider that some of the arguments I've already used show that the existence of God is less likely than his non-existence ?

I replied:

I don't think that I could calculate the probability of God's existance based on the arguments you have provided thus far.

Are you asking about my personal beliefs or are you asking about the quality of the evidence you've provided?

That's not my point. My point is that we have no reason whatsoever to posit the existence of souls, and without them your hypothesis that God's function is, in part, to judge us (presumably, after death) fails.

That's not my hypothesis. You said here:

"I think it's possible to prove that God doesn't exist beyond reasonable doubt. Unless we alter "God" in a way that he's not God anymore.

I said that if you accept that the deist God is "God" then please provide evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that the deist God doesn't exist. True enough, the notion of a God that judges us after we die would likely involve a human soul of some sort, so part of your evidence might be evidence that there is no human soul. The fact that you don't "posit the existance of a human soul" isn't evidence that there is no human soul.

Again, besides the point. The theory does not require God, and fits the facts.

I completely agree (I never disagreed with that). Theories that involve God also fit the facts.

-Bri
 
You’re attempting to shift the burden here. You are the one proclaiming that god’s purpose is the creation of life, therefore it’s up to you to prove it not someone else to disprove it.

I claimed no such thing. Belz asked for possible purposes for God's existance. I never claimed it to be true, only that it was possibly true.

See shifting burden above.

Again, the burden of proof was on Belz to provide evidence that the deist God doesn't exist as he claimed could be done. He might choose to do so by disproving the existance of the human soul, but the burden of proof would be on him to disprove it, not on me to prove it.

It’s not. Little Timmy is being used as just a specific instead of a general example.

You purposely chose examples that involved children even though they are no different than the general example of human suffering that was already discussed.

I didn’t say ALL Christians.

I'm sorry, when you said "ask the Christians" I didn't realize you were referring only to certain ones.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Again, you asked what purpose God might serve, and I said that he might serve the purpose of creating life. I also said that science has yet to create life, and possibly never will. I don't see the fallacy there. Please don't cry "fallacy" unless you can at least identify the fallacy.

Shifting the burden of proof is a fallacy. Circular reasoning is a fallacy. Argument from ignorance is a fallacy. Three fallacies in one post. You said I had to prove it. You're trying to support the idea that God is responsible for life by saying life isn't explained, etc.

Where did I use the word "understanding?" Again, you asked what purpose God might serve, and I said he might serve the purpose of creating earthquakes and tornadoes (i.e. controlling the weather). You implied that God could not create earthquakes and tornados because "we know exactly what causes them." I said that science does not currently know all of the factors that cause earthquakes and tornadoes, and cannot science cannot prove that God doesn't cause them.

You said that we don't know all the causes BECAUSE we can't MAKE tornadoes. I disagree. I don't see a necessity to be able to reproduce a phenomenon in order to understand it.
 
I said that if you accept that the deist God is "God" then please provide evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that the deist God doesn't exist. True enough, the notion of a God that judges us after we die would likely involve a human soul of some sort, so part of your evidence might be evidence that there is no human soul. The fact that you don't "posit the existance of a human soul" isn't evidence that there is no human soul.

True. But the essence of what I said is that souls are completely unnecessary to the functionning of the universe (as we know it, of course.) If they're unnecessary, then positing their existence seems rather unreasonable. And in that case, the idea that God might exist, in part, to judge souls, is suspect because now we need an unsupported assumption to support our assumption!
 
If you choose evil, then you are in no way increasing the good in the world.-Bri
On the contrary, if I choose the evil of allowing a cancer suffering child to suffer greatly in chemotherapy then I am certainly increasing the good in the world - especially if the therapy works.

Similarly if some natural evil occurs I must assume that it will have a good consequence or God would not allow it.

Moreover it must have some good consequence that could not have been attained any other way - God would not have chosen an evil means to a good end if He could have chosen a good means to the same end.

So by the ostensible evil of not preventing some natural evil I must be increasing the good in the world.
 
Here I think you may be assuming that a defense suited to the problem of natural evil necessarily applies to the problem of moral evil.

Bri was hypothesizing that every apparent natural evil may, thanks to God, ultimately result in a net good. Yet this hypothesis does not imply that an omnibenevolent God must (or is logically able to) parlay every distinct moral evil into a net good, as I see it. With respect to moral evil, God's benevolence arguably only requires that the created universe be superior to possible universes without free agency. It does not require that the universe be better off than it would have been had you not chosen to do evil. The greater good may have been served by your freedom to choose, but that doesn't mean that if God exists, each of your choices will serve good ends.
Consider the situation where a man is dying from a severe asthmatic attack and I have the means to save his life by reaching his medicine.

But I don't do this, but merely watch him die. I have committed a moral evil right?

But God did not do anything either to prevent the man from dying. Since God is morally perfect then the natural evil of his attack must have some sufficiently good consequent. Moreover this must have been some good that could not have been achieved without this ostensibly evil means (otherwise God would not have used an evil means).

I don't have to know what this consequent is, I only need to know of God's moral perfection to know that there is some sufficiently good consequent and therefore my inaction is as morally good as God's.

...

Now consider the situation where I have foreknowledge of a murder and the ability to prevent it. Again I do nothing. Again God does likewise.

We cannot now suppose that this moral evil has a specific good consequence but nevertheless we know for certain that God's inaction in the matter was morally impeccable. So why then was my inaction blameworthy?

Again it does not matter that I cannot comprehend God's motives or ultimate good that God's inaction served - I know both to be impeccable because I know that God is morally perfect.

So does this mean that there is some action that would be morally good if God did it, but would be morally wrong if I did it, given that we have the same intentions and knowledge of the moral consequences?
 
Shifting the burden of proof is a fallacy. Circular reasoning is a fallacy. Argument from ignorance is a fallacy. Three fallacies in one post. You said I had to prove it. You're trying to support the idea that God is responsible for life by saying life isn't explained, etc.

I did none of those things, and I said none of those things. You said that you could prove beyond a reasonable doubt that there is no God, so I asked you to prove it. I never tried to support the idea that God is responsible for life by saying life isn't explained. At your request for possible purposes for God, I answered that one possible purpose of God might be to create life. In response to another question, I stated that science cannot currently create life.

Thanks for the lively conversation, but when someone starts throwing out random fallacies, it's time to call it quits.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
On the contrary, if I choose the evil of allowing a cancer suffering child to suffer greatly in chemotherapy then I am certainly increasing the good in the world - especially if the therapy works.

How is treating a cancer patient evil? You're pretending as though you don't know the difference between good and evil, but I'm fairly sure that you do.

Similarly if some natural evil occurs I must assume that it will have a good consequence or God would not allow it.

Why is a natural disaster evil? Yes, perhaps it is for the greater good.

Moreover it must have some good consequence that could not have been attained any other way - God would not have chosen an evil means to a good end if He could have chosen a good means to the same end.

Again, what God does is presumably for the greater good, and therefore isn't evil. So what? As humans, we cannot know what the greater good is, so we cannot pretend to do something for the greater good that we know is evil.

So by the ostensible evil of not preventing some natural evil I must be increasing the good in the world.

Not necessarily. Like I said, we don't know what the ultimate good is, but we do know the difference between good and evil human behavior. Perhaps God causes natural disasters in order to provide us the opportunity to help others. Perhaps that's a greater good than a world with no natural disasters. Perhaps human suffering by itself isn't evil (when it's for the greater good), but human choices can be evil (i.e. one person causing suffering to another person is evil) since only God can know what is for the greater good.

You don't know that any of these things aren't true, and therefore cannot prove that an omnibenevolent God cannot exist.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Consider the situation where a man is dying from a severe asthmatic attack and I have the means to save his life by reaching his medicine.

But I don't do this, but merely watch him die. I have committed a moral evil right?

But God did not do anything either to prevent the man from dying. Since God is morally perfect then the natural evil of his attack must have some sufficiently good consequent. Moreover this must have been some good that could not have been achieved without this ostensibly evil means (otherwise God would not have used an evil means).

I don't have to know what this consequent is, I only need to know of God's moral perfection to know that there is some sufficiently good consequent and therefore my inaction is as morally good as God's.

...

Now consider the situation where I have foreknowledge of a murder and the ability to prevent it. Again I do nothing. Again God does likewise.

We cannot now suppose that this moral evil has a specific good consequence but nevertheless we know for certain that God's inaction in the matter was morally impeccable. So why then was my inaction blameworthy?

Again it does not matter that I cannot comprehend God's motives or ultimate good that God's inaction served - I know both to be impeccable because I know that God is morally perfect.

So does this mean that there is some action that would be morally good if God did it, but would be morally wrong if I did it, given that we have the same intentions and knowledge of the moral consequences?

By this line of thought, there is no action or inaction that is not prevented by God that is not ultimately good - thereby meaning that there IS no good or evil in the Universe, except that good and evil defined by man.

In other words, ultimate good and ultimate evil are defined in this example by natural (God allows it) and unnatural (God prevents it). Or, within the paradigm of our universe, possible and impossible.

Hence, human morality cannot be based upon ultimate morality, but must instead be formed around other concepts.
 
I did none of those things, and I said none of those things. You said that you could prove beyond a reasonable doubt that there is no God, so I asked you to prove it. I never tried to support the idea that God is responsible for life by saying life isn't explained. At your request for possible purposes for God, I answered that one possible purpose of God might be to create life. In response to another question, I stated that science cannot currently create life.

Indeed you provided various roles God could play. I merely explained why they didn't work. They you shifted the burden of proof, as though now I had to prove that God doesn't exist. The purpose of our discussion, at that point, was YOU trying to show that God COULD exist by providing functions for him to accomplish. So far you haven't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom