Sol88
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2009
- Messages
- 8,437
You've been told. You need 100+ gigavolts. Now, where is it?
And how are you going to measure that jd116?
big multimeter?
You've been told. You need 100+ gigavolts. Now, where is it?
And how are you going to measure that jd116?
big multimeter?![]()
Errrm, given that that sort of voltage would tear the comet apart, not to mention Philae, then we know it isn't there. Correct?
but but but....![]()
Reconnection happens (though slightly different in the EU) but it will be found to be a standard KINETIC PLASMA EFFECT !
Electron beams are real, electric fields are real, double layers and KINETIC PLASMA EFFECTS are real!
and that me 'ol mate is an effect of such KINETIC PLASMA EFFECTS!![]()
But but but....but but but....![]()
Reconnection happens (though slightly different in the EU) but it will be found to be a standard KINETIC PLASMA EFFECT !
Electron beams are real, electric fields are real, double layers and KINETIC PLASMA EFFECTS are real!
and that me 'ol mate is an effect of such KINETIC PLASMA EFFECTS!![]()
...
The problem that people on here have with this SAFIRE thing, is that there is no working model for an electric sun, so what the heck are they basing their experiments on?
There was a long running thread devoted to the electric sun idea, here:
...
Let's just say that there are serious problems with it/ them!
Safire is an experiment. I think they mentioned temperatures in the video. I do not know how they compare to the Sun though.Welcome to ISF, SDG!
I’m not sure whether you intend to defend SAFIRE as science or not; however if you are, could you please let us know how the density, temperature, and pressure radial gradients of SAFIRE compare with those of the Sun?
IIwas kind of hoping that the poster SDG might have been Siggy G, from Dunderdolts. If not, I apologise. However, I was still hoping he might be an EUist with some scientific and mathematical knowledge. Hope he/ she sticks around. Maybe we can make some sense of this disaster that is the 'Electric Comet' woo.
23 July 2018: Repeats a lie that this paper is an electric comet answer to any of W.T. "Tom" Bridgman's list of questions for electric comet proponents.The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
23 July 2018: A deluded lie that he has given us papers about the electric comets insanity to "work off"...Some thing to work off of.
!23 July 2018: Stupid questions to derail form his electric comet insanityI have no idea who is Siggy G.
What is Dunderdolts?
23 July 2018: Emphasizes that the WWW will "never" forget a spate of ignorance, delusions and lies from a electric comet insanity supporter[3rd person]Sol88 looks at his signature line and remembers those immortal words “The WWW never forgets”.[/3rd person]
I know you’re new to this thread, so some relevant background:Safire is an experiment. I think they mentioned temperatures in the video. I do not know how they compare to the Sun though.
I am open minded, nevertheless I check, cross check, double check, triple check information to no end if I can.![]()
I have no idea who is Siggy G.
What is Dunderdolts?
Safire is an experiment. I think they mentioned temperatures in the video. I do not know how they compare to the Sun though.
I am open minded, nevertheless I check, cross check, double check, triple check information to no end if I can.![]()
Wow, that's a long thread. Thank you for the reference.
I thought the model is straight forward.
Do I miss anything?
Whoops not Sol88 - apologies SDG.For others:
Siggy G is a supporter of the electric universe stupidity.
Dunderdolts is the ignorant, deluded and lying Thunderbolts cult. Full of
Siggy G is a supporter of the electric universe stupidity.
Dunderdolts is the ignorant, deluded and lying Thunderbolts cult. Full of
Whoops not Sol88 - apologies SDG.
The data does not compare to the Sun at all because the Sun is not a metal sphere powered externally to produce plasma! That is the easily understood part of the electric sun delusion that this experiment is supposed to be modeling.Safire is an experiment. I think they mentioned temperatures in the video. I do not know how they compare to the Sun though.
Science is evidence driven and never "proven". See above for evidence that supports (literally!) a thermonuclear model of the Sun.The current hypothesis for the origin and functioning of the sun is the gravity-driven ‘Thermonuclear’ model. It is taught in every school on Earth. It has never been proven.
The electric sun has a history of a couple of decades of work from ignorant cranks, not 250 years by scientists. If you go to their electric sun pioneers page you will see a list of lies. Benjamin Franklin, Michael Faraday, James Clerk Maxwell, Sir William Crookes, Kristian Birkeland, Nikola Tesla, Irving Langmuir, and Hannes Alfvén did not work on any "electric sun model". They worked on electromagnetism, the Earth's interaction with the solar wind (Birkeland who speculated that the Sun was powered by radioactive decay as in radium) and magnetohydrodynamics (Alfvén).There is another quite different hypothesis, the 'Electric Sun' model, which has been 250 years in the making. It also has never been proven.
In those 6 years they have produced one mainstream, non-solar paper about plasma physics.