Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Will you help me Obi Wan ferd burfle?
Go, you must, to university.

There, for five years, toil and study, you must. Humble must you be, and numbers sincerely learn. All above, post to this thread until you have graduated must you not.
 
Last edited:
So Tom was wrong or right in relation to electrostatics and comets then?
Sol88, as the only person posting to this thread who understands the ELECTRIC COMET model, only you can say if what Tom did is consistent with that model.

But please, enough of the endless diversions, let's see your calculations! :mad:
 
Great something with a bit of substance rc! :D
Sorry, Sol88, what you posted has no substance. :(

Please tell us more with reference to J.Deca’s paper, I’m all ears, we’ll eyes really.
Please tell us more, with reference to data on the motion of probes around/near comets, and how estimates of the bulk densities of those comets can be obtained, using the ELECTRIC COMET model. Please be certain to post something quantitative.
 
Plasmas have separated charges. I think I see the problem here!

Can the solar wind plasma around a comet be separated into Ions and Electrons violating quasi neutrality?
This thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), Sol88.

What is the problem with the ELECTRIC COMET model that you think you see?

In the ELECTRIC COMET model, can the solar wind plasma around a comet be separated into Ions and Electrons violating quasi neutrality? If so, please explain how, quantitatively.
 
and Tom was told!

he didn't like the answer either!
You, Sol88, have been asked many questions. And told - many times - that your answers make little sense. Yet you continue to repeat your mistakes, over and over again.

It is clear that you seem to intensely dislike being asked about the ELECTRIC COMET model; why is that?
 
Said there was nothing wrong with the math!

Just his assumptions.

Coulomb force is cancelling some of the attraction from the nucleus’s mass.
Yes, Sol88, we know that this is a key part of the ELECTRIC COMET model. After all, you've said so a dozen or more times.

But why oh why have you not taken the next step? Why have you never posted anything at all on applying "Coulomb force" to show what the estimated bulk densities of (some) comets is (per the ELECTRIC COMET model)?

Cojones, you lack?
 
24 July 2018: Lies about J. Deca et. al paper which has no "solar plasma is back to quasi neutral".

PDF for the Jan Deca, et. al paper

This is solar wind protons grabbing cometary electrons to become neutral and cometary ions grabbing solar wind electrons to become neutral.


There is no "return" to quasineutrality. This basic property of plasma is always there.
Figure 3 has ion distributions that are non-zero: "FIG. 3. Solar wind, cometary, and total (solar wind + cometary) ion energy distributions along the Sun-comet direction [(a)–(c), respectively]. The cut is indicated in Fig. 1(a). The white band represents the comet location."

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
RC, with respect, I think you are approaching this in a sub-optimal manner.

Not that what you post is necessarily incorrect, but it’s not directly pertinent.

As I am like a broken record in saying, this thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model. And Sol88 is the only one posting here who really knows what that is.

So far, he has been extraordinarily reluctant to discuss anything scientific, with respect to the ELECTRIC COMET model, preferring all manner of diversions, obfuscation, and nonsense.

Showing, in detail, just how poor (let's say) his understanding of the papers he claims to have read is, is like shooting fish in a barrel. Everyone who reads this thread knows that, in spades.

It’s almost as if he lacks the cojones to directly address his beloved ELECTRIC COMET model, perhaps for fear that he will discover for himself that it’s nothing more than malarkey.

So why not constantly ask him to do some real science? Download data, crunch numbers, build quantitative models, etc? And stop taking the bait he so often dangles.
 
Which is precisely the calculation that Tom and Harvey have done! Or did you not recognise Coulomb's equation in those calculations? So, numerically, how much attraction is being cancelled, and what sort of charge on the nucleus do you need to achieve that? For the umpteenth time.
(my bold)

I agree.

Sol88, numerically, how much attraction is being cancelled, and what sort of charge on the nucleus do you need to achieve that?

Do you have the cojones to answer?
 
As I am like a broken record in saying, this thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model. And Sol88 is the only one posting here who really knows what that is.
The problem is that Sol88 does not show that he really knows about the electric comet model. Otherwise he world give sources. Thus he is lying or ignorant about the electric comet or just trolling. A little bit of time recording his ignorance, delusions and lies so that they do not fool lurkers does not worry me.

The official source for the electric comet are the Thunderbolt authors (Talbott, Thornhill and Scott) and their books, web site, videos and a few (electric sun) papers by Scott. Most of Sol88's electric comet garbage does not appear there. They are (as far as I can tell) not ignorant enough to claim that mainstream ices and dust papers using words like "bedrock" are describing rock, etc.

As for Sol88 doing physics, I do not recall a single physics calculation from him in the last 9 years. He is even incapable of using an impact calculator when given a link to one.
25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Usual irrelevant and lying post to detail from his electric comet insanity

Great something with a bit of substance rc! :D

Please tell us more with reference to J.Deca’s paper, I’m all ears, we’ll eyes really.
25 July 2018: Usual irrelevant and lying post to detail from his electric comet insanity.

My posts about the J .Deca, et. al. paper are just above his post!

24 July 2018: Usual stupidity of citing an ices and dust come paper (J Deca, et al) to support his electric comet insanity.

24 July 2018: Lies about J. Deca et. al paper which has no "solar plasma is back to quasi neutral".

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Usual lie and stupid question to derail form his electric comet insanity

Plasmas have separated charges. I think I see the problem here!

Can the solar wind plasma around a comet be separated into Ions and Electrons violating quasi neutrality?
25 July 2018: Usual lie and stupid question to derail form his electric comet insanity.

There is no problem with plasmas having separated charges - being ionized is what a plasma is :jaw-dropp!
He is supposed to be the electric comet guru, he needs to answer his own questions about the electric comet.

Plasmas have separated charges.
Plasmas do not ""violate" quasi-neutrality.
Deluded fantasies about basic plasma properties do not support the insanity of the electric comet.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Last edited:
Can the solar wind plasma around a comet be separated ... violating quasi neutrality

Can the solar wind plasma around a comet be separated into Ions and Electrons violating quasi neutrality?
This a electric comet question in an electric comet thread so:
25 July 2018 Sol88: Can the solar wind plasma around a comet be separated into Ions and Electrons violating quasi neutrality?

13 July 2018 Sol88: Where are the ʻOumuamua jets, coma and tails predicted by your electric comet?[/QUOTE]

25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
electric comet explanation about why RSI measured too low a mass for rock

Sol88:
The Rosetta RSI data showed that the trajectory of Rosetta was being altered by a mass of 10 trillion kilograms (the 2014 result) +/- 10% (a density of ~4 g/cc). The current mean density of 67P with recent data + volume calculations is 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cc

25 July 2018 Sol88: Please give the official electric comet explanation about why RSI measured too low a mass for rock

If this is the electrostatic repulsion "claimed by some Electric Comet supporters" then:
25 July 2018 Sol88: Please calculate the electrostatic charges needed on Rosetta and the nucleus of 67P to increase the measured mass ~6 times.
 
What electric fields at a comet do not need charge separation in the electric comet

Question.

What electric fields at a comet do not need charge separation?

We can add it to the list.
Yes we can.
25 July 2018 Sol88: What electric fields at a comet do not need charge separation in the electric comet model?
 
Last edited:
*** By the way, there is no electric comet! I am unaware of any physical mechanisms that can support its operation! Simply put. the electric comet is physically impossible!
Why?

Which bit specifically is impossible?

Are you Tom Bridgeman ????

Have yo been keeping up at all Indagator???

Will you have a go at answering Tom's persistent questions?

Sol88! The real question screaming for an answer is, are YOU capable of keeping up? Before we get started, I wonder if I might get your thoughts on the following quote ...

"Mathematics is the KEY and DOOR to the sciences." --- Galileo Galilei

Are you ready to play?

Which bit specifically is impossible?

You, Sol88, are some kind of funny! Let's rephrase your question in such a way that we may query the resident "ec" expert ...

Which bits specifically ARE possible? Have you got any science to share?

Remember! This is your electric comet thread! You and I are only going to talk about your electric comet model and the specific "eu/ec" physics, chemistry, geology, and mechanics that drive same! You see, we need to concentrate on "new and innovative eu/ec" science in this thread as mainstream science appears to be woefully inadequate at describing an electric comet. If mainstream science had any legs with respect to your electric comet, we would have seen hundreds of peer reviewed papers by now! Right? If there was a way to physically model an electric comet using mainstream science and mathematics, we would not be here having this inconsequential conversation! Right?

I really think you and your electric comet model have a few "impossible" problems to overcome!

To give your brain a rest (a brief distraction), I would like to ask your opinion on a slightly off-topic issue. Is the electric universe a genuine science? Or nothing more than a religion? Evidence indicates religion! If you think the "eu" is science ... PROVE IT! If you think mainstream science can help ... PROVE IT! I suggest you start by using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, to prove that eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet! If you need to introduce "new and innovative eu/ec" science to advance your model ... SPELL IT OUT! CHAPTER AND VERSE! And please be quick! I would hate to see another nine years fly by with nothing to show for it!

Now, would you like me to restate any of the above in a slower, simpler form?

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you claim that comets are made of rock! PROVE IT! Remember, dust collected does not equal "electric" rock! Stating the obvious, dust collected is nothing more than "dust" collected! Please, describe in detail what "electric comet rock" looks like when viewed from an altitude of 10 kms? 100 kms? 400 kms? Hows about one meter? Are you absolutely certain that you know what rock looks like? As relates to your "electric rock" what scientific information can be gleaned from CIVA? OSIRIS? VIRTIS-M? MIRO? RSI?

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you claim that there are problems with the determination of density for comets! PROVE IT! I suggest (as have others) that you use the actual RSI data! Don't you worry though, Sol88, I will be there to help you out in a subsequent post or two! Please be patient!

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you claim that electric discharges are responsible for blasting comets and asteroids from planets and moons! PROVE IT! Hee! Hee! This fictional "ec" genesis story should be fun to watch! But alas, I expect no effort will be made by our valiant "ec" expert, or anyone else from the "eu/ec" brain trust! CRITICAL FAILURE!

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you claim that asteroids and comets are similar (i.e., their compositions vary, but their interiors and surfaces will have the same composition! PROVE IT! What "ec" data is available to scientifically support this statement? Please define "composition" as relates to the thermal characteristics of electrically machined dust! In other words, what happens to a mineral exposed to the extreme heat of an electric discharge? Any change in the chemical composition? How do you know? Experimental data? How does composition impact the "compactness" or "fluffiness" of a machined dust particle? As a further test of your claim that the interiors and surfaces of comets have the same composition, I would recommend you use the current shape model for 67P and your "best" estimate of density to compute the angular moment of inertia! What might this exercise tell you?

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you claim comets are simply asteroids on eccentric orbits! PROVE IT! Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet! Again, please refer to the table posted previously! If you wish, you may also show how eccentricity impacts charge separation! You will no doubt recall, that 12/13 objects with similar eccentricities do not exhibit behaviour consistent with that of your electric rocks. WHY?

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you claim there is a weak electric field, centered on the Sun. This "weak" e-field is capable of causing electrical stresses which yield electrical discharges! PROVE IT! Define the term "weak" numerically! Describe in detail what "electrical stresses" are, both physically and mathematically! Define the three-dimensional structure and strength of this "weak electric field" using physics and mathematics! Does this heliospheric e-field drop off linearly, exponentially, or does it follow some other relationship (e.g., a negative power law or a step function)? How do non-magnetic, airless bodies behave in this weak electric field? Please be specific! Based on your model of the weak electrical field, predict what the field strength will be at 1 AU! How can we measure that? As a test of your model, note that at 4.3 AU inbound, 67P was observed to be active! What was the field strength at that distance from the Sun! Please be specific, or run screaming!

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you claim that the observed jets are "electric arc discharges TO the nucleus!" These discharges produce the comet geomorphology we see in OSIRIS and NAVCAM images! PROVE IT! Please define the term "arc" mathematically! In scientific terms, please explain what you mean by "discharges TO the nucleus" when you claim elsewhere that the surface of the nucleus carries regions that are both positively and negatively charged! What voltages do we expect in a "weak" electric field that would cause an "electric arc discharge" to an object that is following an eccentric orbit around the sun. Please be specific! Hint: You will need to derive from first principles, a dynamic (i.e., time dependent) equation, or set of equations, that addresses orbital mechanics (including variables like inclination and velocity), your variable weak electrical field, a dynamic and variable plasma environment, and the discharge "turbulence" caused by the objects rotation! In its initial form, this equation must be robust enough to predict the behaviour of several unique objects following different orbits! How does the system's voltage change following an "electric arc discharge" that lasts for minutes versus one that lasts for hours? How much charge is lost in any given discharge event? How much charge is your electric comet capable of holding? What physical "ec" mechanism is responsible for throttling the discharge? How does an electric comet "recharge" on the inbound leg of its eccentric orbit following a discharge event? How does an electric comet "recharge" on the outbound leg of its eccentric orbit following a discharge event?

And Sol88! Do you remember making this claim in 2009?

It is the electric force that holds the spherical cometary coma in place as the comet races around the Sun. The diameter of the visible coma will often reach millions of miles. And the visible coma is surrounded by an even larger and more "improbable" spherical envelope of fluorescing hydrogen visible in ultraviolet light.

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you made that claim on 2009/07/26! You know the routine by now! PROVE IT! Using electrostatics and electrodynamics show how your "weak" radial electric field, centered on the Sun produces a stable, spherical, expanding coma that often reaches millions of kilometers! Define the term "improbable" mathematically! Using "eu" science (as mainstream cannot help you), please explain what electrical interactions are taking place within your weak electrical field that would hold the coma in place? Is the heliospheric electric field stronger than the electric field centered on the nucleus? Define the term "often" as relates to eccentricity! Does "often" apply equally to inbound and outbound legs of the eccentric orbit?

And what about this little nugget?

The primary distinction between comet and asteroid surfaces is that electrical arcing and "electrostatic cleaning" of the comet nucleus will leave little or no dust or debris on the surface during the active phase, even if a shallow layer of dust may be attracted back to the nucleus electrostatically as the comet becomes dormant in its retreat to more remote regions.

As resident expert in the electric comet model, you made that claim on 2009/07/26! Would you like to PROVE IT! PROVE IT? This one should be easy for you to work with as it requires no mathematics or physics! Just time! Please provide us with a sequence of images from the OSIRIS-NAC data archive that illustrates how "electrostatic cleaning" occurred in the Hapi region. I suggest the Hapi region as it was found to be the most active during the initial mapping phase following rendezvous in 2014. If you FAIL to find corroborating evidence of "electrostatic cleaning" in the Hapi region, you may look elsewhere on the comet! EXPECTING FURTHER FAILURE!

Which bit specifically is impossible?
Good luck sorting out your ... science fiction story!

Are you Tom Bridgeman ????
No!

Have yo been keeping up at all Indagator???
What do you think? Your nightmare is just beginning, my friend! Of course, those afflicted with "eu religion" are absolutely certain that they are always right, while everyone around them is WRONG! You will never change, Sol88! You will never grow! I predict you will be repeating the same slimy "eu/es/ec" dogma years into the future! In the mean time, I will do everything I can to discourage others from following you into intellectual darkness! Have I been keeping up? I am so far ahead of you ....

Will you have a go at answering Tom's persistent questions?

Why bother?

NO! Tom's questions are for you and your crew! They are applicable to your FAILED electric comet model! They require "eu/ec" science to answer! Case in point? There is no battery needed in the mainstream model!

How much charge is your electric comet "insulator" capable of holding? What physical "ec" mechanism is responsible for throttling the discharge? Perhaps you could describe your electric comet with an RLC circuit! How does an electric comet "recharge" on the inbound leg of its eccentric orbit following a discharge event? How does an electric comet "recharge" on the outbound leg of its eccentric orbit following a discharge event? How is charge redistributed across the nucleus surface as the comet rotates?

PostScript - We'll get to the Deca paper in short order! If you'd like, I'll also do a separate post on the Behar paper as well.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom