I don't have access to the full text of all the letters mentioned in the post above this one, but the letter from Jon Stone, PhD, Stoyan Popkirov, MD, and Alan J. Carson, MD, says:




And in another letter Robert E. Bartholomew writes:

I did not intend to refer to the length of time in which sufferers suffer. Syndrome longevity aside, my understanding was that most of the sufferers' symptoms ended when or soon after they left Cuba, although I will concede it's been long enough since I read any of the original articles that I may be mistaken about that impression.

I was talking more about the persistence of the focus; the idea that completely new victims are apparently continuing to fall prey to the hysteria many months later. Your typical "laughing mania" for instance gripped several students within a short amount of time; and in those students the symptoms lasted however long they lasted, but new never-before-affected students did not start catching the mania again the next school year....or even later in the same school year. The Pont-Saint-Esprit incident is another more specific case IIRC; very localized in time, as far as onset of symptoms goes - although IIRC some of those people remained "crazy" for the rest of their lives.
 
Last edited:
The Pont-Saint-Esprit incident is another more specific case IIRC; very localized in time, as far as onset of symptoms goes - although IIRC some of those people remained "crazy" for the rest of their lives.


You mean this one?
Pont-Saint-Esprit poisoning: Did the CIA spread LSD? (BBC, Aug. 23, 2010)
Did the CIA early dose a French village with LSD? (The Atlantic, 2010)
1951 Pont-Saint-Esprit mass poisoning (Wikipedia)
Affaire du pain maudit (French Wikipedia)

You are right that the case seems to be very different from the Embassy attack accusations in Cuba (Wikipedia), but nobody seems to think that it was a case of mass hysteria or mass psychogenic illness. (And the CIA hypothesis seems to be a conspiracy theory.) See the five hypotheses in the article in French Wikipedia above and the provisional conclusion:
Cependant, pour des chercheurs au laboratoire de toxicologie de l'INRA, Isabelle Oswald et Olivier Puel, qui étudient les mycotoxines, les « symptômes des habitants de Pont-Saint-Esprit, hallucinations et signes de vasoconstriction, font penser à une crise d'ergotisme ».
French Wikipedia
 
I was talking more about the persistence of the focus; the idea that completely new victims are apparently continuing to fall prey to the hysteria many months later. Your typical "laughing mania" for instance gripped several students within a short amount of time; and in those students the symptoms lasted however long they lasted, but new never-before-affected students did not start catching the mania again the next school year....or even later in the same school year.


You are right. Some cases of mass psychogenic illness are characterized by a sudden outbreak and don't last very long. Others, however, do go on and on, and new victims fall prey to them day after day, sometimes for decades. I've already mentioned the recent HPV-vaccine scare in Denmark, but another illustrative example is Wi-Fi syndrome or electromagnetic hypersensitivity:
The Nocebo Effect: How We Worry Ourselves Sick (The New Yorker, Mar. 29, 2013)
Electromagnetic hypersensitivity (Wikipedia)
A very recent case: Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation? (ISF, June 9, 2018)

By the way, the HPV-vaccine scare in Denmark and the sonic-attack scare in Havana have one thing in common: Both the media and some politicians encourage(d) the alleged victims to believe that they are/were the victims of something real, not just a scare.
 
And speaking of electromagnetic hypersensitivity: Now we're back with the "microwave weapons" ... just as unsubstantiated as the first time.
Microwaves suspected in 'sonic attacks' on US diplomats in Cuba and China, scientists say (CNN, Sep. 2, 2018)
Microwaves suspected in attacks on US diplomats in Cuba and China (CNN - Youtube, Sep. 2, 2018)
”Some sort of mysterious beam of energy (...) It seems to fit the scenario …”
Yeah, right!

ETA:
Microwave Weapons Are Prime Suspect in Ills of U.S. Embassy Workers (NYT, Sep. 1, 2018)
Microwave weapons suspected in US embassy ailments – report (The Guardian, Sep. 2, 2018)
Microwave weapon now strongly suspected in mystery attacks on US diplomats in China, Cuba (News com.au, Sep. 3, 2018)
 
Last edited:
And Robert Bartholomew has already commented on the micowave theory:

The State Department’s mishandling this case is a recipe for what I call ‘The Sonic Attack Scare’ (or if you like, ‘The Microwave Panic’) spreading even further. The U.S. has nearly 300 physical embassies, consulates and diplomatic missions around the world with thousands of employees, everywhere from Afghanistan to Zimbabwe, all with staff who are now on the lookout for strange sounds and vague feelings of illness. This is a classic mass hysteria setup. The groundwork has been laid for future "attacks" via mass suggestion. As a result, this saga seems destined to continue with no end in sight.
Weak Evidence for Microwave Radiation in U.S. Embassy (Psychology Today, Sep. 2, 2018)


Great article, as always.
 
How long will it take before they arrest those embassy workers that do not get ill? surely they must be the moles who have planted the devices that trigger the symptoms?
 
In his latest article in Psychology Today, Bartholomew writes:

Not long ago, the prestigious science journal Nature published an article by Sharon Weinberger reviewing the progress in the development of microwave weapons. Titled, “Microwave Weapons: Wasted Energy,” it concluded that “Despite 50 years of research on high-powered microwaves, the U.S. military has yet to produce a usable weapon.” Ouch! A piece of advice: Stick with mainstream science and the known, before speculating about exotic, far-fetched explanations, and the unknown.


From Sharon Weinberger’s article in Nature (Sep. 12, 2012) about a demonstration of the US American microwave weapon in Quantico, Virginia:

However, the day of the test was cold and rainy. The water droplets in the air did what moisture always does: they absorbed the microwaves. And when some of the reporters volunteered to expose themselves to the attenuated beam, they found that on such a raw day, the warmth was very pleasant.
A demonstration of the system on a sunny day this March proved more successful. But that hasn't changed a fundamental reality for the Pentagon's only acknowledged, fully developed high-power microwave (HPM) weapon: no one seems to want it. Although the Active Denial System works (mostly) as advertised, its massive size, energy consumption and technical complexity make it effectively unusable on the battlefield.
 
How long will it take before they arrest those embassy workers that do not get ill? surely they must be the moles who have planted the devices that trigger the symptoms?


I think that's probably the reason why the Science article (June 20, 2018) mentioned and quoted in post 435 keeps some of its sources anonymous, referring to them in this way: ”says a second U.S. diplomat (…) The second diplomat echoes that experience”.

To use one of Trump's favourite words: It’s a ******* disgrace.
 
Woo-woo or Voodoo?

It's interesting to read what Wikipedia can tell us about the so-called Microwave auditory effect (Frey effect):

Experts, such as Kenneth Foster, a University of Pennsylvania bioengineering professor who published research on the microwave auditory effect in 1974, have discounted the effectiveness of the proposed device. Foster said that because of human biophysics, the device "would kill you well before you were bothered by the noise". According to former professor at the University of Washington Bill Guy, ”There’s a misunderstanding by the public and even some scientists about this auditory effect," and "there couldn’t possibly be a hazard from the sound, because the heat would get you first".
Microwave auditory effect: Electronic warfare (Wikipedia)


And with this, we've returned to my old thread title: Alien Attack? Mass Hysteria? Conspiracy?

Numerous individuals suffering from auditory hallucinations, delusional disorders or other mental illness have claimed that government agents use forms of mind control technologies based on microwave signals to transmit sounds and thoughts into their heads as a form of electronic harassment, referring to the technology as "voice to skull" or "V2K".There are extensive online support networks and numerous websites maintained by people fearing mind control. California psychiatrist Alan Drucker has identified evidence of delusional disorders on many of these websites and other psychologists are divided over whether such sites reinforce mental troubles or act as a form of group social support.
Microwave auditory effect: Conspiracy theories (Wikipedia)


Since the perpetrators of the alleged attacks appear to have tried to turn the US American diplomats into some kind of mindless zombies, I think that we should consider a new conspiracy theory:
It was neither the Cubans, the Russians nor the Chinese!
It must have been the Haitians!



ETA: ‘Mind control’ experiences on the internet: Implications for the psychiatric diagnosis of delusions
 
Last edited:
You mean this one?
Pont-Saint-Esprit poisoning: Did the CIA spread LSD? (BBC, Aug. 23, 2010)
Did the CIA early dose a French village with LSD? (The Atlantic, 2010)
1951 Pont-Saint-Esprit mass poisoning (Wikipedia)
Affaire du pain maudit (French Wikipedia)

You are right that the case seems to be very different from the Embassy attack accusations in Cuba (Wikipedia), but nobody seems to think that it was a case of mass hysteria or mass psychogenic illness. (And the CIA hypothesis seems to be a conspiracy theory.) See the five hypotheses in the article in French Wikipedia above and the provisional conclusion:

I had originally planned to apologize and thank for the correction, as I had been under the impression somehow that it was a case of mass hysteria. However, reading the article you linked me to, it doesn't seem like mass hysteria can actually be ruled out. Because these "five hypotheses" are in fact hypotheses, not findings. They are:

1. Ergot mold in the rye used to make bread that the afflicted people ate
2. Methyl-mercury dicyandiamide, a fungicide used to protect the flour before baking, surviving into baked bread
3. Mycotoxin produced by fungi in grain storage towers, transferred through to final bread products
4. Some kind of chemical (a lubricant?) transferred to flour from machines used during the whitening process
5. LSD planted by the CIA because....no, just no

It sounds to me like all of these are problematic, for various highly crucial reasons - namely that none of those chemicals was ever actually found in the bread, flour, or grain. (in fairness, 3 is a newer hypothesis developed long after the incident, and 2 has been disproven by more recent unrelated chemical research). You will note, this is the same as the primary argument against the Cuba case, which is that no electronic signals or chemical toxins have actually been found that would support some kind of external attack on the sufferers.

So what we essentially have here is various proposals for what might have happened. But what did happen is not known, and it could easily have been a case of mass psychogenic illness.
 
You are right. Some cases of mass psychogenic illness are characterized by a sudden outbreak and don't last very long. Others, however, do go on and on, and new victims fall prey to them day after day, sometimes for decades. I've already mentioned the recent HPV-vaccine scare in Denmark, but another illustrative example is Wi-Fi syndrome or electromagnetic hypersensitivity:
The Nocebo Effect: How We Worry Ourselves Sick (The New Yorker, Mar. 29, 2013)
Electromagnetic hypersensitivity (Wikipedia)

To my knowledge, "Wi-Fi syndrome" and claims of electromagnetic hypersensitivity, much like claims of "wind turbine syndrome", cannot qualify as "mass psychogenic illness" because they are noticeably missing the "mass" part. Only isolated "cases" of these "syndromes" ever appear in any one place. I'm not willing to concede that, say, 25 cases of the same illness can be called mass hysteria if each one of those 25 people lives in a different city scattered across the globe or even just a country the size of the US. At best, these are cases of hypochondria that share the same references. As opposed to mass psychogenic illness were it seems the most important trigger is seeing other people around oneself becoming afflicted, leading to one's own infliction.
 
Last edited:
It doesn't really matter what you concede to call it. Mass hysteria used to be very localized, say a school, a monastery, a factory or a village. Nowadays you have internet communities. The HPV-vaccine scare in Denmark was spread in discussion groups on the internet, not at school. For the same reason that you now use to deny the existence of mass hysteria "if each one of those 25 people lives in a different city scattered across the globe," a Danish MD, Jesper Mehlsen, refused to believe that the girls could have heard rumors about the (alleged, imaginary) dangers of the vaccine since they came from all over the country. However, the social media is how rumors are spread these days. To insist that the only way to spread rumors is the old-fashioned way by word of mouth is just plain ignorant. "seeing other people around oneself becoming afflicted" is how this used to happen from the Middle Ages until the late 1990s, probably, but it's no longer how it's done today.
Consequently, the way to contain the scares is also different from what it used to be. You might as well insist that ordinary infectious diseases are still spread the way they were when Columbus was alive as if planes hadn't been invented and now contribute to the spreading of disease.
 
I had originally planned to apologize and thank for the correction, as I had been under the impression somehow that it was a case of mass hysteria. However, reading the article you linked me to, it doesn't seem like mass hysteria can actually be ruled out. Because these "five hypotheses" are in fact hypotheses, not findings. They are:


Yes, of course they are hypotheses, which is why I called them hypotheses. The tools of scientific research have developed quite a bit since 1951 so maybe it would would be possible to detect mold, methyl-mercury dicyandiamide, mycotoxins, LSD or other chemicals nowadays that they couldn't back then. I don't know if there are any bodies that they could exhume and take samples from.
I notice that your argument is that since we are talking about hypotheses it is perfectly alright to assume that the cause was mass psychogenic illness even though nothing really suggests that it was the case. I also notice that even though the four hypotheses are merely hypotheses, you still feel absolutely sure that it couldn't possibly be the fifth hypothesis ...

1. Ergot mold in the rye used to make bread that the afflicted people ate
2. Methyl-mercury dicyandiamide, a fungicide used to protect the flour before baking, surviving into baked bread
3. Mycotoxin produced by fungi in grain storage towers, transferred through to final bread products
4. Some kind of chemical (a lubricant?) transferred to flour from machines used during the whitening process
5. LSD planted by the CIA because....no, just no


I notice that, despite the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, despite the CIA's Project MKUltra, despite the CIA's fake vaccination campaign, and despite the Edgewood Arsenal human experiments, you are perfectly willing to blame the Cubans for attacks even though nothing whatsoever seems to indicate that any attacks took place, but "LSD planted by the CIA because....no, just no".

It sounds to me like all of these are problematic, for various highly crucial reasons - namely that none of those chemicals was ever actually found in the bread, flour, or grain. (in fairness, 3 is a newer hypothesis developed long after the incident, and 2 has been disproven by more recent unrelated chemical research). You will note, this is the same as the primary argument against the Cuba case, which is that no electronic signals or chemical toxins have actually been found that would support some kind of external attack on the sufferers.


Yes, I do note that you say that "this is the same as the primary argument against the Cuba case," but I also note that you reject one hypothesis (the CIA in France), but seem to be convinced about the other (an actual attack agains U.S. diplomats in Havana and Guangzhou).

And if you take a closer look at the third hypothesis, it has this going for it:
In 2002, according to the work of Régis Delaigue, the affair of the cursed bread of Pont-Saint-Esprit is still unclear.
However, for researchers at INRA's toxicology laboratory, Isabelle Oswald and Olivier Puel, who study mycotoxins, the "symptoms of the inhabitants of Pont-Saint-Esprit, hallucinations and signs of vasoconstriction, are reminiscent of a seizure of ergotism." (Google translated from French Wikipedia)

Vasoconstriction doesn't seem to be one of the typical sign of mass psychogenic illness! Neither do hallucinations to the extent of people actually killing themselves.

So what we essentially have here is various proposals for what might have happened. But what did happen is not known, and it could easily have been a case of mass psychogenic illness.


No, it couldn't "easily" have been any such thing ... unlike the embassy attack accusations in Cuba where actually nothing whatsoever (apart from the title) suggests that it was anything other than mass hysteria/mass psychogenic illness.
Why do you think that mass hysteria/mass psychogenic illness isn't one of the hypotheses mentioned in the Wikipedia article about the 1951 Pont-Saint-Espirt mass poisoning?!
 
I notice that your argument is that since we are talking about hypotheses it is perfectly alright to assume that the cause was mass psychogenic illness even though nothing really suggests that it was the case.

That the presenting symptoms were psychogenic in nature, and that it happened to a mass of people, are two facts which are highly suggestive of mass psychogenic illness.

I also notice that even though the four hypotheses are merely hypotheses, you still feel absolutely sure that it couldn't possibly be the fifth hypothesis ...

There is literally nothing that exists to connect the CIA with this incident.

I notice that, despite the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, despite the CIA's Project MKUltra, despite the CIA's fake vaccination campaign, and despite the Edgewood Arsenal human experiments, you are perfectly willing to blame the Cubans for attacks even though nothing whatsoever seems to indicate that any attacks took place, but "LSD planted by the CIA because....no, just no".

Important points:

1. Even when I was convinced of the plausibility of an electronic or chemical/biological attack against the diplomats in Cuba, I never blamed Cubans for those attacks.

2. Two of your examples weren't conducted by the CIA and the third involved general deception, not any kind of medical experimentation. The remainder, which was begun years after the incident in France, required sequestration and continual monitoring of vic...err, test subjects. There is nothing to suggest the CIA ever even considered an experiment involving poisoning a foreign country's food supply and keeping tabs on the results via second-hand sources.

Yes, I do note that you say that "this is the same as the primary argument against the Cuba case," but I also note that you reject one hypothesis (the CIA in France), but seem to be convinced about the other (an actual attack agains U.S. diplomats in Havana and Guangzhou).

I don't believe I've said anything about Guangzhou. Of Cuba, on the other hand, I've been convinced that the sound some reportedly heard and recorded was crickets, not a sonic weapon.

And if you take a closer look at the third hypothesis, it has this going for it:


Vasoconstriction doesn't seem to be one of the typical sign of mass psychogenic illness! Neither do hallucinations to the extent of people actually killing themselves.


That seems to be something the first hypothesis has going for it; but nevertheless, the quote does not give any information about the prevalence of vasoconstriction in sufferers of MPI. Since notably adrenalin, along with countless other substances that can be produced by the body itself or introduced by outside sources (caffeine, for instance), is a vasoconstrictor, one would expect to see signs of vasoconstriction in any person who has been excited or has been engaging in physical exertion.

Mass suicide does not seem to feature as an outcome of ergot poisoning either, outside this lone supposed instance!


Why do you think that mass hysteria/mass psychogenic illness isn't one of the hypotheses mentioned in the Wikipedia article about the 1951 Pont-Saint-Espirt mass poisoning?!

For the same reason the US government refuses to consider mass hysteria as a hypothesis for what has happened in Cuba perhaps?
 
You annoy the hell out of me, Checkmite, and mainly because you don't even make an effort!
You come up with the example of the Pont-Saint-Esprit bread poisoning tragedy without even remembering what it was all about, and when I provide you with links, you don't even spend a little time considering what you could learn from the case if you studied it just a little. Instead, you stick to your false memory (or is it a case of the Mandela effect, maybe?) and insist that it might still have been a case of mass psychogenic illness even though it never was. And the worst thing is that you don't even consider why the hell nobody else seems to have come to the same conclusion, ever! You may imagine yourself a genius for coming up with your false memory, but shouldn't it make you at least a little suspicious of your favourite explanation that no expert has ever had the same 'idea'?!

I've had to waste more of my valuable time debunking yet another awkward attempt of yours to render the U.S. American accusations against Cuba probable.


Let me begin with a couple of the quotations that you didn't waste your time finding and reading when you came up with the harebrained explanation for the Pont-Saint-Esprit case as mass psychogenic illness:

What became a national disaster began on Aug. 16, 1951, when the inhabitants of the small town of Pont-Saint-Esprit in the Gard region of southern France were suddenly stricken by frightful hallucinations of being consumed by fire or giant plants or horrid beasts.
A worker tried to drown himself because his belly was being eaten by snakes. A 60-year-old grandmother threw herself against the wall and broke three ribs. A man saw his heart escaping through his feet and beseeched a doctor to put it back in place. Many were taken to the local asylum in strait jackets. There was no treatment, no cure and only one possible explanation: something in the bread baked the night of Aug. 15-16 had caused the calamity.(…)
more than 300 people afflicted, 7 to 10 dead, 46 detained in asylums, and many unable ever to hold jobs or lead normal lives.
(…)
The local baker most, if not solely, responsible was declared to be Roch Briand, who had unwittingly used contaminated flour.
France’s unsolved mystery of the poisoned bread (NYT, July 23, 2008)


This more recent commentary suggests that in fact the poisoning was most likely caused by Aspergillus fumigatusand its toxins (originally suggested by Moreau in 1982) - particularly because the mill that produced the infected flour was reported to have been flooded earlier in the same year - providing excellent conditions for fungal growth withing the flour or stored grain.
Pont-Saint-Esprit Mass Poisoning, August 1951 (Aspergillus, Fri, 09/07/2012)


Why do you think that every hypothesis except yours (and maybe the CIA one) has bread (cursed, poisoned, molded or otherwise contaminated) in it?

How do you think that they ruled out pollution of air or water, for instance?

I'll let you think about that for a while and give you a chance to come up with the correct answer before I return.
 
Last edited:
One of these is in Norwegian, sorry, but run it through google translate and you will probably get the gist of it:

But what had caused the modern-day plague that engulfed this single obscure French village? It soon became clear that all the victims had eaten bread made by a specific baker, M. Roche Briand.Just When You Thought It Was Safe to Go Back to the Boulangerie (Emergency Medicine News, May 2006, Vol. 28, issue 5 – p. 9)


Det store spørsmålet både innbyggerne og hele nasjonen stilte seg sommeren 1951 var hva galskapen i den franske landsbyen skyldtes. Hva var årsaken til det skrekkelige massehysteriet som skapte overskrifter verden over? Svaret lå hos en lokal baker ved navn Roch Briand.Natten før den 16. august, da galskapen begynte, hadde Briand ubevisst bakt brød som inneholdt giftig mel.[/HILITE] Melet i det nybakte brødet førte til en ekstrem form for matforgiftning som var som snytt ut av nesen på middelalderens fantasirike skildringer av sinnsforvirrelser og byers galskap.
Landsby gikk amok (abc nyheter (Norwegian), Feb. 22, 2009)


Unfortunately, the Norwegian article uses the word "massehysteriet" (= mass hysteria, obviously), but it obviously does so incorrectly. However, that a lay person uses the word about a situation where a major number of people are hallucinating and running amok is forgivable.

Back in 1951, they seem to have done the old-fashioned but nevertheless scientific approach to tracing the origins of a disease: What did the victims seem to have in common?! It's what you still do today, meticulously, when you want to find the source of food poisoning, in particular when people start to die. A fairly recent case: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Germany_E._coli_O104:H4_outbreak (Wikipedia)
That is the reason why all hypotheses focus on the bread, that is the reason why it's referred to as the case of "cursed bread", and that is the reason why mass hysteria wasn't suspected. (Apart from the fact that the hallucinations went far beyond anything you've seen in modern cases of mass hysteria. And the hallucinations were wildly different unlike the mere delusions that the victims of mass hysteria tend to have.)

Meticulous analysis was what they did in Pont-Saint-Esprit, France, but what was never done in Havana, Cuba. Instead, they immediately jumped to the conclusion that some kind of supersonic weapon must have caused the 'disease' even though the 'victims' had absolutely nothing in common. They didn't even all hear the crickets, but that didn't matter. And it still doesn't matter now that they've come up with the idea that another science-fiction weapon, the microwave gun (whatever!) must have harmed the 'diplomats'!
And your newspapers report this inane nonsense even though they ought to be a little careful now that they had the opportunity to learn from the pathetic and unsuccessful first version, the sonic one.

I don't know if you have a personal stake in this - I don't usually find your posts as gullible as the ones in this thread - but I look forward to your next version ...
 
By the way, I've ordered a copy of the book The Day of St. Anthony's Fire. May I suggest that you do, too?
I would have preferred a Kindle version, but it doesn't exist, apparently. (It's from 1968.)
The writer may have been the one who came of with the LSD hypothesis (probably not so far out in 1968!), but a lot of his research appears to have been rational:

... the clients of M. Briand, a prosperous and responsible baker, fell ill after eating the second baking on a hot July day. They suffered, according to the author, from all the symptoms of historical ergotism, not seen since 1816 and most commonly associated with the Middle Ages. Victims experienced the euphorie beate, characterized by unsuitable high spirits and sleeplessness, followed by l'eclosion brutale, the ""savage breaking out""--hallucinations and a mad desire to leap from the nearest window. Five died. Briand and others had complained of the greyish, oily flour allotted to them by the powerful Union Meuriere. It was traced to the mill of M. Maillet ...
Review: THE DAY OF ST. ANTHONY'S FIRE (Kirkus Review, Aug. 1, 1968)
 
That the presenting symptoms were psychogenic in nature, and that it happened to a mass of people, are two facts which are highly suggestive of mass psychogenic illness.


They weren't psychogenic in nature. You confuse psychogenic with hallucinogenic.
And you confuse mass poisoning with mass psychogenic illness, which is no surprise since you also confulse mass psychogenic illness with attack with a concealed weapon ...

There is literally nothing that exists to connect the CIA with this incident.


No, there probably isn't. But there's also literally nothing that exists to connect the allegedly damaged health of the U.S. diplomats in Havana and Guangzhou with attacks of any kind - except the people who insist that it's caused by attacks - you being one of them.

Important points:

1. Even when I was convinced of the plausibility of an electronic or chemical/biological attack against the diplomats in Cuba, I never blamed Cubans for those attacks.


And now that you're convinced of the plausibility of a microwave attack instead, nothing much has changed: The USA still blame the Cubans - either of being the perpetrators of the non-existent attack or of failing to protect the 'victims' from it.
You may have given up on the idea of crickets = sonic attacks, which makes it ludicrous to insist that any kind of attack took place.
At least the crickets had one thing going for them: They make an awful racket, and some (not all) of the diplomats appear to have heard them. But at least they were actually there.

2. Two of your examples weren't conducted by the CIA and the third involved general deception, not any kind of medical experimentation. The remainder, which was begun years after the incident in France, required sequestration and continual monitoring of vic...err, test subjects. There is nothing to suggest the CIA ever even considered an experiment involving poisoning a foreign country's food supply and keeping tabs on the results via second-hand sources.


There may be nothing to suggest that the CIA considered poisoning French bread, but we all know that it's a very clandestine agency, so I really don't see why you dismiss this conspiracy theory when you are so fond of the other one.

I don't believe I've said anything about Guangzhou. Of Cuba, on the other hand, I've been convinced that the sound some reportedly heard and recorded was crickets, not a sonic weapon.


Then it's about time that you do, 'cause the U.S. government seems to think that they'e the same thing.

That seems to be something the first hypothesis has going for it; but nevertheless, the quote does not give any information about the prevalence of vasoconstriction in sufferers of MPI. Since notably adrenalin, along with countless other substances that can be produced by the body itself or introduced by outside sources (caffeine, for instance), is a vasoconstrictor, one would expect to see signs of vasoconstriction in any person who has been excited or has been engaging in physical exertion.


In the case of the contaminated bread in France, vasoconstriction appears to have been at an extremely unhealthy level - beyond the usual level off coffee-drinking Frenchmen or athletes. Otherwise, it would hardly have been reported in the context. Ergotism: Gangrenous.

Mass suicide does not seem to feature as an outcome of ergot poisoning either, outside this lone supposed instance!


No, and there's also a big difference between mass suicide and mass psychogenic illness. However, that a couple of people kill themselves in an outbreak of severe hallucinations caused by food poisoning is to be expected. (Apparently five people died; it doesn't say that they all died from committing sucide.

For the same reason the US government refuses to consider mass hysteria as a hypothesis for what has happened in Cuba perhaps?


I already answered that one:
No, I refuse to believe that stubborn revanchism and chauvinism is the reason in your case.
 
Last edited:
You annoy the hell out of me, Checkmite, and mainly because you don't even make an effort!
You come up with the example of the Pont-Saint-Esprit bread poisoning tragedy without even remembering what it was all about, and when I provide you with links, you don't even spend a little time considering what you could learn from the case if you studied it just a little. Instead, you stick to your false memory (or is it a case of the Mandela effect, maybe?) and insist that it might still have been a case of mass psychogenic illness even though it never was. And the worst thing is that you don't even consider why the hell nobody else seems to have come to the same conclusion, ever!

I did, you simply missed it (the first time; you appear to have found it later).


Let me begin with a couple of the quotations that you didn't waste your time finding and reading when you came up with the harebrained explanation for the Pont-Saint-Esprit case as mass psychogenic illness:


Your highlighted quote is the chosen words of the newspaper article's author, who is in turn quoting no one when he states that there is "no other explanation". Alas, he was a year too early to hear about and opine on the credibility of the secret-CIA-experiment theory.

However, further down you give two different sources giving a total of five deaths, whilst this newspaper article seems to double the death count by a factor of 2. This is another problem with this incident, where much like an instance of woo, subsequent tellings have exaggerated the facts. I've seen articles on websites describing "the entire town" as having gone insane and trying to kill themselves, which clearly isn't the case.


Why do you think that every hypothesis except yours (and maybe the CIA one) has bread (cursed, poisoned, molded or otherwise contaminated) in it?

Because bread was the only (or the first) link between the victims that the investigators were willing to consider?

How do you think that they ruled out pollution of air or water, for instance?

I'll let you think about that for a while and give you a chance to come up with the correct answer before I return.

I'm not so sure they did formally rule those things out; at least, I haven't seen an article describing any research being done in that area. In fact, while you're making a great big deal out of the fact that the possibility mass hysteria in specific was never apparently invoked by the investigators, I'm coming up empty when it comes to finding any solid information that they ever actually investigated literally ANYthing else besides the "contaminated bread" angle. They may have dismissed those other things, but I don't see any actually enumerated reasons why, which is the reason we have to sit here and speculate under the assumption they actually did their due diligence when it came to these other possibilities, an assumption which I'm not sure is supported.

Nevertheless, fine, let's speculate. They didn't consider air or water pollution because there were people in the area who were not affected, that must've been breathing the same air and drinking the same water. But this reason unfortunately also makes the ergot poisoning conclusion problematic - I can't find a nailed-down statement that everybody who ate that baker's bread that night actually got sick. Further, it's established that the baker got his "contaminated" batch of flour from a government distribution silo, which many bakers in the area also got flour from, and yet nobody else, anywhere else, ever got sick from contaminated bread in this manner around that time, an eventuality that is excruciatingly unlikely even from a purely statistical standpoint. The mechanical process of producing flour would seem to make it quite impossible for ergot mold in quantities toxic enough to drive people suicidally insane could go through the flour-making process and yet every single trace make it into a single bag of flour.

None of the sources I've found describing this incident even bother to try and explain that glaring problem; they blip right over it.

No, I refuse to believe that stubborn revanchism and chauvinism is the reason in your case.

Well admittedly, those weren't the reasons I was thinking of. Foremost on my mind is the fact that nobody likes to "admit" being the victim of mass hysteria, particularly when the results are so dramatic. And I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss chauvinism in that case either, because authorities and investigators might be just as prejudiced against even considering such an explanation for something that afflicted their countrymen.

They weren't psychogenic in nature. You confuse psychogenic with hallucinogenic.

Perhaps you're right; but in the context of this discussion, it occurs to me that asserting the symptoms were hallucinogenic rather than psychogenic, or vice-versa, is question-begging. Hallucinations must be self-reported, just like all psychosomatic symptoms must be. Claims of amnesia suffer the same problems for the same reason.

And you confuse mass poisoning with mass psychogenic illness,

This on the other hand is quite explicit question-begging.



No, there probably isn't. But there's also literally nothing that exists to connect the allegedly damaged health of the U.S. diplomats in Havana and Guangzhou with attacks of any kind - except the people who insist that it's caused by attacks - you being one of them.

I'm entertaining the notion; and pointing out things I find interesting which might at face value support that notion. Yes, clearly this is irritating to you; for that I apologize. However, I've been far from insistent, even from the very beginning, and my position has changed more than once in this thread. In your frustration you're starting to treat me increasingly unfairly with statements like this.


And now that you're convinced of the plausibility of a microwave attack instead

Don't be absurd. I've never said anything remotely like this; the only person who's invoked "microwave attacks" in this thread is you just a few posts ago, with justified ridicule.


There may be nothing to suggest that the CIA considered poisoning French bread, but we all know that it's a very clandestine agency, so I really don't see why you dismiss this conspiracy theory when you are so fond of the other one.

And we all know that certain countries (or, well, one certain country) have attacked the health and well-being, and in some cases the actual lives, of individuals it sees as problematic or hostile (including American diplomatic staff) in the past using varied methods and there is ample evidence that they continue to do so, as recently this year in the UK. It is not the notion of "an attack against diplomats" itself which makes the Cuba allegations less-than-credible.

In the case of the contaminated bread in France, vasoconstriction appears to have been at an extremely unhealthy level - beyond the usual level off coffee-drinking Frenchmen or athletes. Otherwise, it would hardly have been reported in the context.

That's an assumption you're willing to make that I am not, necessarily. I'd like to hear more about what specifically was observed in the afflicted patients that is being characterized as signs of "an extremely unhealthy level of vasoconstriction". For instance, I would certainly hope they're not creatively re-interpreting things being shouted by patients in a psychotic hallucinatory state as if they were symptoms being reported by a calm and lucid person.

However, that a couple of people kill themselves in an outbreak of severe hallucinations caused by food poisoning is to be expected.

Obviously not, since this is the only reported case of it ever happening, so far as I'm aware. I've been reading that page a couple of times now presuming there was another given instance of suicide in connection with ergotism in it but I must be missing it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom