Don't jump to conclusions in this case!
Remember how the microwave-weapon theory promoted by the New York Times was debunked by Washington Post just a few days later? All it took was a little journalistic effort: WP had simply interviewed a couple of scientists about the feasibility of that kind of weapon.
And remember how the cricket-like sound that set the whole thing off turned out be be ... crickets (combined with a panicky work environment)? Until then, apart from the State Department, the FBI, the CIA and other trusted investigators, nobody (in particular: no journalists) had had access to the embassy employees themselves and based their reporting on their own naïve trust in the people in charge. Again, all it took was a little journalistic field work.
And now the media are willing to jump to conclusions about Russia because the NBC has talked with people who want us to think so. They are actually so willing to jump to conclusions that the FBI refuses to comment and the State Department warns against the NBC report:
(This might be a good point to stop calling them "health attacks" then ...)
By the way, the Miami Herald article has many examples of who would like to believe what in this case. For instance, it probably won't come as a surprise to anybody that Marco Rubio is convinced that the Cubans are to blame no matter what.
ETA: Even in the NBC article Heather Nauert was quoted:
“The investigation is ongoing. We have made no determination on who or what is responsible for the health attacks.”
Remember how the microwave-weapon theory promoted by the New York Times was debunked by Washington Post just a few days later? All it took was a little journalistic effort: WP had simply interviewed a couple of scientists about the feasibility of that kind of weapon.
And remember how the cricket-like sound that set the whole thing off turned out be be ... crickets (combined with a panicky work environment)? Until then, apart from the State Department, the FBI, the CIA and other trusted investigators, nobody (in particular: no journalists) had had access to the embassy employees themselves and based their reporting on their own naïve trust in the people in charge. Again, all it took was a little journalistic field work.
And now the media are willing to jump to conclusions about Russia because the NBC has talked with people who want us to think so. They are actually so willing to jump to conclusions that the FBI refuses to comment and the State Department warns against the NBC report:
The FBI said it did not have a comment on the NBC report. And a US government source familiar with official assessments said intelligence agencies would not confirm the report.
Heather Nauert, State Department spokeswoman, told Reuters on Tuesday: "We have made no determination on who or what is responsible for the health attacks."
Russia emerges as main suspect in mystery of US diplomats' illness in Cuba, according to officials (Telegraph, Sep. 12, 2018)
(This might be a good point to stop calling them "health attacks" then ...)
State Department spokesperson Heather Nauert cautioned reporters to be “very skeptical” about the NBC report during a press briefing on Tuesday. “Our position has not changed. We have not assigned any blame and we continue to look into this.”
Now Russia is suspected of attacks against diplomats in Cuba. Will U.S. strike back? (Miami Herald, Sep. 11, 2018)
By the way, the Miami Herald article has many examples of who would like to believe what in this case. For instance, it probably won't come as a surprise to anybody that Marco Rubio is convinced that the Cubans are to blame no matter what.
ETA: Even in the NBC article Heather Nauert was quoted:
“The investigation is ongoing. We have made no determination on who or what is responsible for the health attacks.”
Last edited: