Don't jump to conclusions in this case!
Remember how the microwave-weapon theory promoted by the New York Times was debunked by Washington Post just a few days later? All it took was a little journalistic effort: WP had simply interviewed a couple of scientists about the feasibility of that kind of weapon.

And remember how the cricket-like sound that set the whole thing off turned out be be ... crickets (combined with a panicky work environment)? Until then, apart from the State Department, the FBI, the CIA and other trusted investigators, nobody (in particular: no journalists) had had access to the embassy employees themselves and based their reporting on their own naïve trust in the people in charge. Again, all it took was a little journalistic field work.

And now the media are willing to jump to conclusions about Russia because the NBC has talked with people who want us to think so. They are actually so willing to jump to conclusions that the FBI refuses to comment and the State Department warns against the NBC report:

The FBI said it did not have a comment on the NBC report. And a US government source familiar with official assessments said intelligence agencies would not confirm the report.
Heather Nauert, State Department spokeswoman, told Reuters on Tuesday: "We have made no determination on who or what is responsible for the health attacks."
Russia emerges as main suspect in mystery of US diplomats' illness in Cuba, according to officials (Telegraph, Sep. 12, 2018)


(This might be a good point to stop calling them "health attacks" then ...)

State Department spokesperson Heather Nauert cautioned reporters to be “very skeptical” about the NBC report during a press briefing on Tuesday. “Our position has not changed. We have not assigned any blame and we continue to look into this.”
Now Russia is suspected of attacks against diplomats in Cuba. Will U.S. strike back? (Miami Herald, Sep. 11, 2018)


By the way, the Miami Herald article has many examples of who would like to believe what in this case. For instance, it probably won't come as a surprise to anybody that Marco Rubio is convinced that the Cubans are to blame no matter what.

ETA: Even in the NBC article Heather Nauert was quoted:
“The investigation is ongoing. We have made no determination on who or what is responsible for the health attacks.”
 
Last edited:
Notice what the NBC article told us:

1) ”The officials declined to elaborate on the nature of the intelligence.”
That is what they do, isn't it? But is it wise to believe them, then?!

2) ”Since last year, the U.S. military has been working to reverse-engineer the weapon or weapons used to harm the diplomats (…) including by testing various devices on animals.”
Notice what this tells us about the case: It’s appears to be even more absurd than men staring at goats!!! People at the top have decided that these allegedly new infirmities among U.S. diplomats - let’s call them diplomella from now on – were caused by weapons, and now they have spent more than a year subjecting animals to what probably amounts to very unusual cruelty to come up with a weapon that might do the kind of harm that they think they have discovered in the diplomats. (I imagines something along the lines of the urban myth about the poodle in the microwave oven … except that ”one or more additional technologies were also used.”)

3) “the fact the incidents continued long after they became publicly known has cast doubt on the possibility that the damage was accidental.”
Remember that this was Checkmite’s latest idea, too. It doesn't contradict that this is a case of mass hysteria/mass psychogenic illness, and it sure as hell doesn't support the idea that it's any kind of attack. Notice also that nobody so far - as far as I can tell and I have probably read everything that's been published - has claimed that the alleged damage was accidental. There’s method to it, it just doesn’t seem to be weapons technology method …

4) ”in addition to State Department diplomats, the victims include multiple CIA officers, at least one member of the U.S. military, and representatives of other agencies.”
Just to remind you that these guys don’t appear to have been typists …

5) And another reminder: “The exact medical syndrome remains a mystery even to the University of Pennsylvania physicians treating the patients.” And even when ”Penn physicians presented their most recent technical findings” in August, ”the summit ended with no new medical revelations.”[/I] So let’s recapitulate the findings of the original JAMA article:
MRI neuroimaging was obtained in all 21 patients. Most patients had conventional imaging findings, which were within normal limits, at most showing a few small nonspecific T2-bright foci in the white matter (n = 9, 43%). There were 3 patients with multiple T2-bright white matter foci, which were more than expected for age, 2 mild in degree, and 1 with moderate changes. The pattern of conventional imaging findings in these cases was nonspecific with regard to the exposure/insult experienced, and the findings could perhaps be attributed to other preexisting disease processes or risk factors. Neurological Manifestations Among US Government Personnel Reporting Directional Audible and Sensory Phenomena in Havana, Cuba (JAMA, Mar. 20, 2018)
Microwave-weapon attacks!!! Who do they think they’re kidding? A major part of the U.S. American public, apparently!
 
The Ars Technica article I quoted from in post 499 has added an update:

Update: The Washington Post reports skepticism about microwaves being the source of the symptoms among doctors and scientists, including some doctors who were critical of the initial JAMA report. University of Cincinnati neurologist Alberto J. Espay told the Post, “Microwave weapons is the closest equivalent in science to fake news.”


However, Russian microwave weapons appear to be the latest craze ...
 
Hmm...I too inexplicably woke up at 7 in the morning today (I set my alarm for 10:00 am).

Heard some high pitched ring in my bathroom and (thought?) I felt a little nauseous or gassy. Burped a bit, maybe it was my heartburn?

Maybe this is hysteria.
 
By the way, they came up with this idea more than a year after the first alleged attacks in late 2016, a long time after the sonic one had become too ridiculous to maintain, so I'm not really impressed that they didn't try to stick to it and instead invented another one to make the idea of an attack seem plausible.

As I've already mentioned, to my knowledge the doctors quoted as tentatively supporting microwaves as "a possibility" never said anything in support of sonic attacks when that was the prevailing media rumor; so it's not a matter of "THEY" dropping the sonic attack "idea" and "inventing" another one instead.

Also, it seems like they were answering press questions about the possibility of microwaves, rather than actually promoting or announcing that possibility of their own volition.

On another tangent, I'm a little curious. What would it take - in theory - to provoke an "outbreak" of MPI?
 
... when that was the prevailing media rumor; ...


The sonic attack had already been debunked a long time ago when the doctors published their report.

What would it take - in theory - to provoke an "outbreak" of MPI?


Uninteresting. Look at what it takes in practice instead!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hysterical_contagion
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypochondriasis
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_disorder
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4884863/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3536509/
What causes mass psychogenic illness?
Many outbreaks of mass psychogenic illness start with an environmental “trigger.” The environmental trigger can be a bad smell or a suspicious-looking substance. Or it could be something else that makes people in a group believe they have been exposed to a germ or a poison. When this happens, many of them may begin to experience symptoms of sickness at the same time. In some cases, one person gets sick and then other people in the group also start feeling sick.
FamilyDoctor.org


In this case the environmental trigger wasn't a bad smell or a suspicious-looking substance. It was the sound of crickets heard by a group of suspicious spies, some of whom weren't familiar with the sound. Remember post 435?

"Everybody was in a frenzy about it," says a second U.S. diplomat who was stationed in Havana at the time with young children. "We had a big window in the front of the house. It was a horrible feeling. We just thought, ‘Oh my God, we're in harm's way,’" she says. "You start to feel paranoid."
(...)
A panel of Cuban scientists that evaluated U.S. evidence and gathered its own data concluded in December 2017 that U.S. recordings of a grating, supposedly unnatural sound match the chirping of the Jamaican field cricket, a notoriously noisy insect that's common in Cuba. People's state of mind determined whether they developed symptoms, the first diplomat asserts. "I don't know anybody who at one point thought we were under no risk and then subsequently decided that they were a victim."(...)
She acknowledges that over time, a divide widened between "the true believers" and those like her who are skeptical that there was an attack.
 
In this case the environmental trigger wasn't a bad smell or a suspicious-looking substance. It was the sound of crickets heard by a group of suspicious spies, some of whom weren't familiar with the sound. Remember post 435?

Well wait - I'm not sure we know enough to say that. We know some people heard sounds, and one person who recorded them managed to record crickets; that makes it reasonable to deduce that the ones who heard sounds probably heard crickets. But since some of the individuals never claimed to have heard sounds and yet "fell into" the MPI, I don't think it makes sense to call the crickets the trigger. It was just another thing that was noticed once people became hyperaware.
 
Yes, it does make sense!
All it takes is a couple of people who apparently fall ill. To the rest, they, the first victims of the MPI, become the trigger! In the case of the HPV-vaccine-scared girls in Denmark, there was no smell, no substance (other than the vaccine itself, which wasn't suspicious until the rumors made it so), no sound. As soon as a couple of girls fell ill after the vaccinations (correlation is not causation and all that), attributing their symptoms to the vaccine and going online with their stories, you have the trigger.

It's not very different from what happens when children fall ill after other kinds of vaccination and their parents don't tell themselves that children fall ill all the time with or without vaccines (more often without, of course) so the two things might not be connected - except that that would be 'mass psychogenic illness by proxy', of course! :)

By the way, I think that this is something I haven't mentioned before about the HPV-vaccine scare in Denmark: A disproportionate number of the girls affected were elite athletes. And, as it turned out, the girls also tended to have visited MDs more frequently than their peers even before they were vaccinated against HPV.
I don't know if this is a pattern that you also find in other cases of MPI.
 
Yes, it does make sense!
All it takes is a couple of people who apparently fall ill. To the rest, they, the first victims of the MPI, become the trigger!

You do not know whether the ones who heard the sounds were the first victims.
 
No, and you don't know that they weren't!
However, it does seem to be the more likely scenario, which is just one of the many things that are so infuriating about the way the U.S. autorities have handled and are still handling the case:

”The officials declined to elaborate on the nature of the intelligence.”
 
Last edited:
No, and you don't know that they weren't!

I'm not the one making a claim about what the inciting stimulus was.

However, it does seem to be the more likely scenario,

There is literally nothing in evidence to suggest it is the more likely scenario. You are personally lending it such weight solely because it would reinforce your claim.
 
How on earth do you manage to come up with the idea that "There is literally nothing in evidence to suggest it is the more likely scenario", i.e. that "the ones who heard the sounds were the first victims."???
I do know that the one (!) "who heard the sound" was (!) "the first" victim (!).

It has literally been (more than) suggested by one newspaper article after another since the beginning - "Later their symptoms came." - and still is: "First came the mysterious sound — then the diplomatic fury."

Those who became sick, including Canadian diplomats who suffered unexplained nosebleeds, mentioned hearing a distinctive sound or feeling a pressure or vibration in their heads.


The mystery began late in 2016. Personnel attached to the U.S. embassy in Havana developed symptoms such as headaches, dizziness, and insomnia after (!!!) hearing strange loud sounds or feeling a sensation of pressure.
(...)
The first to fall ill was a U.S. intelligence agent in Havana. The "index case," as Hoffer calls him, complained to the embassy doctor of ear pain, tinnitus, vertigo, and feeling "cognitively not perfect." The agent said he had heard "a really odd, loud noise that seemed to follow him in the room," says Hoffer, who examined him in February.
Sonic attack or mass paranoia? New evidence stokes debate over diplomats’ mysterious illness (June 20, 2018)


Your denial is absurd! What do you hope to gain from being in denial about this?! Could it be that you, Checkmite, "are personally lending it such weight solely because it would reinforce your claim"???
 
Last edited:
Cuba scientific investigators met with State Department officials and scientists in Washington Thursday in an effort to make some headway on what is causing the mysterious ailments that have struck 26 diplomats at the U.S. Embassy in Havana.
(…)
The nine-member Cuban scientific delegation also met with members of Congress and the National Academy of Sciences to press their point that there needs to be more scientific cooperation to unravel the mystery. Cuban investigators have complained that the United States is not sharing enough medical information on the victims to carry out an adequate investigation.
After the meeting at the National Academy of Sciences, José Ramón Cabañas, the Cuban ambassador to the United States, tweeted “when Cuba and U.S. scientists meet there is only one language: Science.”
Cuban scientists visit U.S., say, yes, U.S. diplomats were sick but there were no attacks (Miami Herald, Sep. 13, 2018)


Especialistas de Cuba rechazan la teoría de los «ataques de salud» y «daño cerebral» a diplomáticos de Estados Unidos (juventud rebelde, Sep. 13, 2018)

The New York Times and NBC News don't seem to have been present at the meetings ...
 
Now the NYT has reported that meetings took place yesterday, Thursday, Sep. 13:

“We believe there can be a few individuals who have some sort of illness,” said Dr. Mitchell Joseph Valdés Sosa, the director general of the Cuban Center for Neurosciences. But he said the possibility that psychological factors may have played a role could not be eliminated.
Cuban Experts Insist No Proof Exists of Attack on Diplomats (NYT, Sep. 13, 2018)


"The Cuban side is completely unable to support the hypothesis of health attacks and brain damage as reported by the State Department," said Dr. Mitchell Valdes Sosa, chief of the group of Cuban scientists and physicians. "Nothing was presented that could add up to sustain such a thing."
The Cuban delegation renewed calls for the State Department to release to it specific medical records and other data about the victims in order for it to be studied.
No progress as US, Cuba meet on mysterious ‘health attacks’ (The State, Sep. 13, 2018)
 
Last edited:
How on earth do you manage to come up with the idea that "There is literally nothing in evidence to suggest it is the more likely scenario", i.e. that "the ones who heard the sounds were the first victims."???
I do know that the one (!) "who heard the sound" was (!) "the first" victim (!).

It has literally been (more than) suggested by one newspaper article after another since the beginning - "Later their symptoms came." - and still is: "First came the mysterious sound — then the diplomatic fury."

Your denial is absurd! What do you hope to gain from being in denial about this?! Could it be that you, Checkmite, "are personally lending it such weight solely because it would reinforce your claim"???

Are you deliberately ignoring the parts which occur immediately after your highlighted segments that say "or feeling a pressure or vibration in their heads"? Because that's not the same as hearing a sound.

Additionally, tinnitus is NOT the cricket sound, and the crickets certainly didn't cause any vertigo.

I think a far "more likely scenario", to borrow your terminology, is that later victims heard that the earliest victims had "heard sounds" - that is, reported tinnitus symptoms - and these later victims just became hyperattentive to the point where they were primed to notice any "unusual sound", like the crickets. This is essentially a sort of campfire story effect; where you hear tree branches creak and groan and snap all day in the woods and don't pay it any attention whatsoever - if you even notice it at all - but after nightfall and a nice scary ghost story, suddenly those sounds become much more noticeable and take on a much more not-readily-identifiable, if not sinister, nature.
 
Last edited:
No, I don't ignore anything.
And, no, "a pressure or vibration" in the head is not the same as a sound.
Did I claim that it was?!
Have you noticed that what you're describing now is a perfect example of mass hysteria/mass psychogenic illness? What you describe as "essentially a sort of campfire story effect."

Additionally, tinnitus is NOT the cricket sound, and the crickets certainly didn't cause any vertigo.


No, tinnitus is not the cricket sound, nor is it any sound at all, actually, but to the victims of tinnitus it is as if they 'hear' something, and sometimes what they think they hear is very close to a cricket sound. That depends on the individual case of tinnitus. And crickets don't cause any vertigo:

Vertigo is a symptom where a person feels as if they or the objects around them are moving when they are not. Often it feels like a spinning or swaying movement. This may be associated with nausea, vomiting, sweating, or difficulties walking. It is typically worse when the head is moved. Vertigo is the most common type of dizziness.
Vertigo (Wikipedia)


Now look at this list: MPI: Common symptoms (Wikipedia)

The crickets themselves don't cause this, but they may trigger the "anxiety or nervousness" of the victims of MPI.
Just like a weird smell ... or scary campfire stories ...

Be sure to remember that you were the one who, albeit inadvertently, ended up comparing the CIA agents in Havana to a group of girl scouts telling each other scary ghost stories around the campfire! :)
 
Last edited:
No, I don't ignore anything.
And, no, "a pressure or vibration" in the head is not the same as a sound.
Did I claim that it was?!
Have you noticed that what you're describing now is a perfect example of mass hysteria/mass psychogenic illness? What you describe as "essentially a sort of campfire story effect."

Yes - and I'll warn you now that I will continue to make such comparisons in the future; because contrary to your near-Trumpian characterizations otherwise, I conceded that Cuba was a psychogenic case pages (chronologically: MONTHS) ago.

What you are missing is the specific point of the comparison. I suggest it was the people who came later, who had heard about "strange sounds" (a misunderstanding of the initial tinnitus symptoms reported by the first victims) and misinterpreted the crickets as one such "strange sound" as meaning they (the later victims) were also "under attack". The crickets were not the trigger for the MPI; their sound was simply incorporated as part of it later on. I propose that the "triggers" for this MPI event were one or two legitimate cases of tinnitus, connected or not with a couple of coincident legitimate sinus discomfort cases or headache/migraines, and things spiraled from there.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, it is difficult (or maybe even impossible) to figure out exactly what "the specific point of the comparison" ought to be as long as we are more or less left in dark about most of the details of the case. What you describe is not unlikely, but the only thing we seem to know about the order of the individual cases is the first one, the index case:

The "index case," as Hoffer calls him, complained to the embassy doctor of ear pain, tinnitus, vertigo, and feeling "cognitively not perfect." The agent said he had heard "a really odd, loud noise that seemed to follow him in the room," says Hoffer, who examined him in February.
(From post 513)


I find it a little strange that the (CIA? FBI? NSA? Just curious, it doesn’t matter much in the context) agent who was the index case complained of both tinnitus and "a really odd, loud noise that seemed to follow him in the room," since that is what you would expect tinnitus to do unlike an ordinary source of sound: Since it is inside you, you take it with you as if it were a sound coming from earphones. This also seems to correspond with the reports that some people heard sounds that others in the same room didn’t hear!
(However, that doesn’t mean that other cases where the sound allegedly was heard only in one, very limited part of a room and stopped when you moved away from it, that these cases might not have been tinnitus, too, since tinnitus tends to be worse when you are lying or sitting still, focusing on it. When you get up, listen to something else and no longer focus on it, it seems to go away. On the other hand, it might also just be a cricket that stops chirping when it sees you get close to it.)

But because of the secretive nature of the spy business, probably, we don’t know anything about the order of the next cases and how exactly they described their experiences and symptoms. You get it wrong when you write about “the initial tinnitus symptoms reported by the first victims (!)”. We just know about the tinnitus symptoms of the index case. We don’t know if the cases that followed immediately after also complained of or had tinnitus, heard crickets, or heard nothing at all. But (if the reports were correct) we do know that some of the cases didn’t hear a thing, some did, etc.

Mass hysteria doesn’t doesn’t seem to require that there is a trigger like a sound or a smell even though there often is one:
Symptoms often follow an environmental trigger or (!) illness in an index case and spread rapidly by audiovisual cues, often aggravated by a prominent emergency or media response.
Episodes of mass hysteria in African schools: A study of literature (U.S. National Library of Medicine/Malawi Medical Journal, Sep. 2011)


The conclusion of the African study, which mentions parents spreading it from school to school by calling a local radio station, is also interesting:

From the review of the literature above, Mass hysteria is something that has occurred in many schools in Africa. Mass hysteria has been defined as the occurrence in a group of people of a constellation of physical symptoms suggesting an organic illness but resulting from a psychological cause with each member of the group experiencing one or more of the symptoms. It is caused by the extreme stressful situations that the student encounters and enhanced by face-to-face or visual communication, indirect conversation or gossip, and the mass media. Mass hysteria has a negative impact on the physical, psychological and social wellbeing of students and need to be quickly managed. Time should not be wasted in a fruitless search for environmental precipitants, which by reinforcing behavior may serve to prolong the episode. In other words, Mass hysteria should not be a diagnosis of exclusion, after all the physical, chemical and biological factors have been ruled out. Group anxiety should be reduced, and Statements denying the role of the presumed agent (such as witchcraft or the supernatural as is the case in most African countries) should be made by those in authority. Unless the initial fear is given credibility by the media or authorities, cases of mass anxiety hysteria seldom last more than a few days.


Compare this to the credibility (= aggravation!) that is now given by the media and authorities to the Russian microwave weapon!!! And consider that after examining at least dozens of cases, the doctors found only “3 patients with multiple T2-bright white matter foci, which were more than expected for age, 2 mild in degree, and 1 with moderate changes.” Especially when ”the findings could perhaps be attributed to other preexisting disease processes or risk factors.”


ETA: I would really, really, REALLY like to read the report that tries to explain this case to Trump! :)
 
Last edited:
It just occurred to me: I can't imagine a ******** weapon than this (imaginary) one!
In the course of more than a year, the damage it (allegedly) caused was: “3 patients with multiple T2-bright white matter foci, which were more than expected for age, 2 mild in degree, and 1 with moderate changes.” And even these ”findings could perhaps be attributed to other preexisting disease processes or risk factors.”

I can't imagine that the damage to the credibility of the CIA, the FBI and the State Department doesn't outweigh anything that this weapon could have done if it actually existed!
No wonder the Russian RT is having a field day on Youtube - the presenter is even wearing a tinfoil hat! :)

 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom