I find it a little strange that the (CIA? FBI? NSA? Just curious, it doesn’t matter much in the context) agent who was the index case complained of both tinnitus and "a really odd, loud noise that seemed to follow him in the room," since that is what you would expect tinnitus to do unlike an ordinary source of sound: Since it is inside you, you take it with you as if it were a sound coming from earphones. This also seems to correspond with the reports that some people heard sounds that others in the same room didn’t hear!


I'm not sure he did complain of both. The quote starts out saying that he complained of tinnitus and from there seems to just describe the tinnitus symptoms in more detail. I don't think the "sound that followed him" is meant to be interpreted as (or necessarily was, at any rate) something separate from the tinnitus. However, if his coworkers also misinterpreted it that way, it could cause them to be wary of "strange (external) sounds".

This seems pretty smashing, to me. You found the index case, and that person did indeed have tinnitus and some "general malaise", the latter being the kinds of symptoms that it's easy for a person to work themselves up into "experiencing". I think the "trigger" so to speak has been identified.
 
Last edited:
You are right, I think. When Hoffer says that "the "index case" (...) "complained to the embassy doctor of ear pain, tinnitus, vertigo, and feeling "cognitively not perfect," tinnitus might just be Hoffer's (or the doctor's) interpretation of the index case describing a "really odd, loud noise that seemed to follow him in the room."
It could be a layman's way of describing what an MD would diagnose as tinnitus.

I first noticed my own tinnitus when I was still a kid (about 9 or 10, I think), and I don't remember ever thinking that it was a real sound, something existing outside of my own head, but I can imagine that it may be different for somebody who 'hears' it for the first time as an adult.
 
Last edited:
PS

I don't remember ever thinking that it was a real sound, something existing outside of my own head


But I do remember why I didn't think that it was real: When I turned my head I noticed that the one-sided 'sound' followed. I could turn 180 degrees, and I still heard the sound in the same ear. Source discovered! :) (or maybe :( )
 
I linked to an RT Youtube video in post 520.

There's also an article quoting professor Foster, a microwave expert at the University of Pennsylvania:

Foster, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania who studied microwave phenomena while working at the Naval Medical Research Center in Bethesda, told RT that the evidence that these purported injuries were caused by some kind of microwave weapon – which the NBC article alleges – is “science fiction.”
“The kind of effect that has been talked about with the embassy is purely a fairy tale,” Foster said. He noted that while non-lethal microwave weapons exist, they require high-power transmissions and are only able to cause “thermal pain” in people. “I can’t conceive of a microwave weapon as it’s being thought about in this case. And it’s not clear that the symptoms are real.”
‘It’s science fiction’: Professor doubts claims of ‘microwave attacks’ on US diplomats in Cuba (RT, Sep. 15, 2018)
 
The allegations wouldn't make it to a court of law, because the US to my knowledge hasn't accused anyone specific. There are individuals speculating, but we can't keep treating these speculative rumors as if they are official statements or specific claims; they're not.
 
But to this day, the State Department still claims that actual attacks took place - and it can't be more official than that:

The ARB found the lack of a single designated senior-level Department official with responsibility for responding to the attacks resulted in insufficient communications with employees and impeded coordination within the Department and with other agencies.
Cuba Accountability Review Board (U.S. Department of State – Diplomacy in Action, Aug. 30, 2018)


The withdrawal of U.S. agents and diplomats from Havana was based on these accusations as was the expulsion of Cuban diplomats in Washington:

US orders 15 Cuban diplomats to leave Washington embassy over sonic 'attacks' (Guardian, Oct. 3, 2017)

I would love to see the sentence changed to "... responding to the alleged attacks ..."
 
Last edited:
Cuba is waiting impatiently for the evidence to appear:

Cuba’s ambassador to the United States says the ball is now in the U.S. court to present evidence that deliberate attacks caused the mysterious health symptoms reported by American diplomats in Havana.
“In this case you have the conclusion without introducing the evidence,” José Ramón Cabañas, the Cuban ambassador in Washington, said in an interview with the Miami Herald. “They are the ones who have to demonstrate what happened. We are the ones asking.”
(...)
“The logistics of an attack don’t work. How do you get that amount of energy into the house, then direct it at the brain without damaging the skin or affecting anything else in the house?”
Cuba: Show us evidence of weapons behind alleged health attacks on American diplomats (Miami Herald, Sep. 15, 2018)
 
Miscellaneous

The last case from Havana was confirmed in June. The U.S. said two embassy staffers were affected in a single occurrence in late May in a diplomatic residence at which both officers were present. Those were the first confirmed cases in Havana since August 2017.
One U.S. official said Thursday's meeting was organized after Cuba complained that Washington has withheld important details about the affected Americans' medical conditions. The official was not authorized to discuss the matter publicly and spoke on condition of anonymity.
US, Cuba to Meet on Mysterious ‘Health Attacks’ in Havana (VOA News/AP, Sep. 13, 2018)


After meeting with U.S. officials at the State Department, members of a team Cuba assembled to look into the incidents said their requests for patient records and other information had again been rebuffed and rejected anew after Washington’s assertions that the injuries were caused by targeted attacks.
(…)
“Nothing was presented that could add up to sustain such a thing.”
U.S., Cuba fail to clear up mysterious illnesses afflicting diplomats (Global News (Ca)/AP, Sep. 14, 2018)


Cuba denies any involvement and government officials have said they believe there were never any attacks, which they described as a pretext to justify conflict.
Diaz-Canel was expected to travel to the United States for the United Nations General Assembly next week but said in an interview broadcast on Sunday he could not talk with Trump as long as his administration kept its “abnormal” attitude toward the island.
Cuba’s President Meets US Senator amid Tense Relations (Tasnim News Agency, Sep. 21, 2018)


Were the agents trying to gather information about the Cuban exiles who support a dialogue with the communist country?
Were they looking for intelligence on possible Cuban “spies” who might have contacted them?
Or were their inquiries related to an FBI investigation into the mysterious attacks against U.S. officials in Havana, which have sickened 26 people?
(…)
Some of the Cuban-American activists contacted by the FBI were invited to attend the meeting with the Cuban delegation to the UN, scheduled for Sept. 28 in New York.
The FBI visits to several Cuban exiles’ homes were first reported by the New York Times. But activists cited by the newspaper suggested that the federal agency was singling them out because they support the normalization of relations with Cuba and oppose the harsher rhetoric of Trump.
Yes, the FBI is knocking on doors of some Cuban exiles in Miami. Here’s why (Miami Herald, Sep. 19, 2018)


The working theory now is that two forms of microwave signals might be at play: infra, which are considered silent, or ultra, which are more (?) audible, Wilson said.
(…)
“And indeed we’re dealing with a totalitarian state in Cuba, so there is nothing that occurs there that is not without the knowledge of the government and the military,” he said.
SC congressman Joe Wilson: Who’s pointing sick rays at US embassies? Cuba knows, he says. (Post and Courier, Sep. 22, 2018) (Sep. 22, 2018)


I know too little to say if infra and ultra microwave signals are an actual thing. A google search suggests that they aren’t. (But I do know what double negatives are! :) )
 
Last edited:
The department has played down or denied reports that investigators have focused on a microwave device as the source of the attacks and that Russia is the leading suspect.
(…)
In congressional testimony last week, State Department medical personnel suggested they had shared more information with China about the incident in Guangzhou than they had with the Cubans about what had happened in Havana.
(…)
In two private classified briefings with congressional aides and lawmakers, the officials repeated that they had not come to any conclusions about what caused the injuries or who might be responsible for them.
U.S. officials frustrated by lack of answers on mysterious ‘health attacks’ in Cuba (The Independent, Sep. 13, 2018)


September 13, 2018. Press conference hosted by the Cuban delegation that participated in a meeting at the State Department on the alleged health incidents reported by US diplomats in Havana.


But in May 2018, two new cases were reported at a diplomatic residence in Havana and confirmed in June. A U.S. government worker in China also was confirmed to be suffering from similar symptoms this past summer.
Tablada said FBI investigators were in Cuba at the time the May incident occurred. When investigators went to the home, the mysterious sound turned out to come from water pump at a neighboring home, she said. Such water pumps often make a shrill, grinding sound when they start up.Let’s not be so quick to blame a ‘James Bond-type weapon’ for diplomat symptoms, Cuban doc says (Miami Herald, Sep. 17, 2018)
 
Last edited:
The Pont-Saint-Esprit incident is another more specific case IIRC; very localized in time, as far as onset of symptoms goes - although IIRC some of those people remained "crazy" for the rest of their lives.


I just received my copy of The Day of St. Anthony's Fire by John G. Fuller, which I ordered several weeks ago. It looks interesting, but I have only just started reading it. However, let me quote from the flap of the dust jacket:

Many of the most highly regarded citizens leaped from windows or jumped into the Rhône, screaming that their heads were made of copper, their bodies wrapped in snakes, their limbs swollen to gigantic size or shrunken to tiny appendages. Others ran through the streets, claiming to be chased by "bandits with donkey ears," by tigers, lions and other terrifying apparitions.

Lions, and tigers and ... other terrifying apparitions ... oh my!
And speaking of the animal kingdom, it gets even worse:

Animals went berserk. Dogs ripped bark from trees until their teeth fell out. Cats dragged themselves along the floor in grotesque contortions. Ducks strutted like penguins. Villagers and animals died right and left.


I think we can rule out mass hysteria/mass psychogenic illness in the case of Pont-St.-Esprit! :)


ETA: I would have loved to watch the ducks strutting like penguins, but I haven't been able to find anything on Youtube!
 
Last edited:
Why apocrypha? It appears to be the only book written about the case, at least in English.
Do you think that he lied about the animals going berserk? Or that the animals were victims of mass hysteria?
I still haven't read it but look forward to doing so. I probably won't have the time until mid October.
 
Why apocrypha? It appears to be the only book written about the case, at least in English.

Well...that's part of why.

"Apocrypha" doesn't imply a willful lie, necessarily. I will say, if it's objectively true that animals actually were behaving in such ways then yes that would tend to rule out mass hysteria. It would not prove ergot poisoning, or that bread was the source of the issue, but it would rule out mass hysteria.
 
Well, I'll see which references he has for his animal stories. That only pet animals and ducks are mentioned makes bread a pretty good contender ...
 
This is a very good (and very short) article that sums up the shortcomings of the U.S. American allegations in just 325 words:

Cuba again categorically rejected the use of the term “attack,” without any evidence to support it, during a recent meeting between U.S. and Cuban scientific experts
(...)
The information provided does not support the hypothesis of attacks that resulted in the range of symptoms and brain injuries to diplomats reported by the State Department.
The information exchanged does not demonstrate the existence of a new neurological disorder.
It cannot be claimed that brain injuries usually caused by blows to the head could have occurred without any cranial trauma.
The medical evidence presented has serious shortcomings.
No scientific evidence to prove alleged attacks on U.S. diplomats (Granma, Oct. 4, 2018)


It's a disgrace that this sham is still going on.
 
Last edited:
Maureen Whitefield, Cuba correspondent for the Miami Herald, has written another thorough article. She is one of the journalists (and they appear to be very few!) who actually talk to the people involved in the investigation of the alleged attacks, to U.S. American scientists as well as to Cubans. She has even made a short video interview with one of the people leading the investigation on the Cuban side:

"Dr. Mitchell Joseph Valdés Sosa, head of the Neuroscience Center of Cuba details why Cuba doesn't think U.S. diplomats who suffered health ailments were attacked last year in Havana."

The interview can be found above the article where Robert Bartholomew says that he's "willing to stake his career that the answer is psychogenic illness":

If researchers truly wanted to get to the bottom of the Havana illnesses, he said, they should have conducted a social network analysis that looked at how the patients might be acquainted and whether they had knowledge of others becoming ill. “If patients were unaware that others were falling ill, it rules out mass psychogenic illness,” he said.
Asked about the University of Miami/University of Pittsburgh assertion that testing of the Havana patients showed differences in eye movement patterns in the affected diplomats and family members, Bartholomew said: “These results are not definitive and open to interpretation.”
He said he’s willing to stake his career that the answer is mass psychogenic illness. “Think of it as a collective stress response. It happens to normal, healthy people. We are all susceptible,” Bartholomew said in response to Miami Herald questions.
Why no one can agree on what really happened to the U.S. diplomats in Havana (Miami Herald, Oct. 1, 2018)


This part of it, "they should have conducted a social network analysis that looked at how the patients might be acquainted and whether they had knowledge of others becoming ill," is what the Danish researchers also failed to do in the case of the HPV-vaccine scare.
 
In the meantime, and not at all surprisingly, the poor handling of the situation is stoking the paranoia of the ‘targeted individual community’. A family member of mine is one of these supposed ‘TIs’, and is more convinced than ever that electronic/microwave harassment of random people is real since some doctors, scientists, and the major news media have finally said so. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/danvergano/microwave-conspiracy-theory
 
No wonder! It’s right down their alley.
Did you already see PartSkeptic’s ISF thread? Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation? (June 9, 2018)

So now the FBI and the Trump Administration have managed to not only cast suspicions on a totally innocent neighboring country. They’ve also contributed to aggravating the mental illness of thousands of Americans.
I guess that they must think it's worth doing so:

“We, too, are in search of an investigation as to who and where are those controlling the covert weapons that are adversely affecting the health and well-being of many thousands of Americans daily,” Robinson said, whose group belongs to FFTI. In a mass email sent to reporters in September, Robinson blamed “covert operatives” for the electronic attacks.
(…)
Some psychologists are concerned that many people with these implausible beliefs may have mental health issues. In a 2016 study, David James and a colleague found that of 1,040 people who reported being stalked in a survey, the 128 who said they were stalked by a group or gang were all likely delusional. The diagnosis of delusion was made by two independent psychologists whose assessments were based on American Psychiatric Association guidance for false beliefs that persist despite “incontrovertible or obvious proofs to the contrary.”
The injuries reported by the US diplomats are perfect fodder for people prone to paranoia, a fixed, false belief that you are being harmed or persecuted. As much as 1.5% of the population may report such beliefs to some extent, based on past surveys.
(…)
Some psychologists who have studied people with delusions of electronic persecutiondeclined to comment to BuzzFeed News on this latest claim of diplomats getting zapped, citing repeated threats they received after being quoted in earlier news reports about mental illness leading to beliefs in a microwave conspiracy.
SCIENCE: Conspiracy Theorists Are Embracing A Microwave Theory About US Diplomats Injured In Cuba. “Paranoia has to find an outlet,” said one psychologist. (BuzzFeed News, Oct. 3, 2018)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom