The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Come on, I'm waiting. Quick. Get to it. EXPLAIN.

But they do! :D

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system

4. Conclusion In summary, the population of small bodies in our solar system today, including both minor planets and classical comets, is far less well-delineated into distinct groups of objects than the classical paradigm might have led one to believe in the past. These objects instead appear to occupy a continuum spanning the full range of observational, physical and dynamical properties classically attributed solely either to asteroids or comets. We now know of currently actively sublimating main-belt objects that could have originated either in the asteroid belt or in the outer solar system, and objects displaying comet-like activity that may have no volatile ice content whatsoever. We have found objects composed of inner-asteroid-belt-like material on long-period comet-like orbits, and active objects on comet-like orbits that may in fact originate from the asteroid belt. We also now recognize that dormant comets may be found in both comet-like and un-comet-like orbits. The population of continuum objects is extraordinarily diverse, with each type of object holding the potential for revealing exciting new insights about our solar system due to their unique sets of overlapping comet- and asteroid-like properties. Given this complexity and the growing interest in addressing the many questions that it has raised thus far, it is likely that many more interesting findings await us in this rapidly developing field in the coming years.


So there continuum objects now champ!
 
Last edited:
So what are the planets made of that the idiot Thornhill says the comets were blasted off of? Huh? Ice and frigging dust? Where did the idiotic loon explain this?

Come on, I'm waiting. EXPLAIN.
 
You champ crusader of the dead thoery of dirtysnowball, explain that!

Learn to spell theory, and I might take it seriously. Answer indagator's questions. NOW.
 
Last edited:
Now, where were these discharges? Hmmmm? Mag data, please. Where was the rock? Instrumental data please. Silence, yes?
 
So there continuum objects now champ!

Do you mean 'they're'? Learn to spell, then learn science, yes?

Answer indagator's questions. Now. Why are asteroids not turning into comets? Same conditions, and only a handful exhibit cometary behaviour. Why?
 
Last edited:
Where are metre sized chunks of ice coming from at Hartley 2? How are you getting them at Tempel 1? Science, or STFU.

Come on. We do not have all day. Show us the science. Where is it?
 
Time to get back to basics, after all of Sol's gish-galloping and avoidance. Let us remind ourselves of the core claims of the neo-Velikovskian, scientifically impossible woo that is the 'electric comet'.



Pure Velikovskian woo. Easily dismissed, as cometary surfaces are not at all like those of any rocky planet. Not to mention the impossibility of these 'electrical interactions'.



So, why don't asteroids on elliptical orbits show cametary behaviour? And why are their measured densities much greater than comets?



What weak electric field is this? Where has it been measured? Why would it be there?



What 'electrical stresses'? And the only glowing going on is mostly due to sunlight reflected from dust.



Oh dear, EDM (lol). Scientifically impossible nonsense. No discharges detected by the magnetometer. Pure woo.



See above.



Which is an outright lie. This was written in 2006, at which time dozens of comets had had H2O definitively detected at them. This goes back to the Kuiper Airborne Observatory observations of Halley in 1985, and Vega's subsequent detections in-situ in 1986.



Which is rendered moot by the previous. However, no negative O ions are observed, and there are nowhere near enough H+ ions to create even 1 litre of water. And the solar wind is travelling too quickly to combine with the non-existent O-. And the solar wind is getting nowhere near the comet when it is most active. Pretty dumb stuff.

http://thunderbolts.info/pdf/ElectricComet.pdf

So, it would appear that this electric comet woo is not only dead, but was never actually alive, due to its scientific impossibility. It can only have been dreamed up by people who are completely clueless about physics in general, and comets in particular. Possibly two thirteen year olds after a glue sniffing session? Certainly not by intelligent adults.

Still waiting...........................
 
Classic jd116!

You are an adult?

Completely ignores Henry H. Hsieh paper grabs his bat and ball and goes home to Mumsie.
 
Last edited:
Completely ignores Henry H. Hsieh paper grabs his bat and ball and goes home to Mumsie
.

What has that paper got to do with anything? Thornhill specifically tells us that comets are asteroids on elliptical orbits. What are the orbits of the very few asteroids with comet like behaviour? What about indagator's questions? What about all the asteroids with comet like orbits that are not comets? Why the refusal to answer? What planet was 67P blasted off of? Where is the water coming from? And the carbon dioxide? Where are the discharges? Where is the rock? Come on, answer the questions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom