It has likely been pointed out already, but I found this detail from the article insightful:


Cricket behavior could also help explain another mysterious detail of the Cuban incidents: Several diplomats claimed that the sound abruptly stopped when they entered a room or moved around. That’s “consistent with an insect stopping a call when threatened,” Stubbs and Montealegre-Z write.
 
That is my personal experience, too. I had one in a classroom recently (an ordinary Danish cricket, not the Caribbean kind), and it was pretty easy to determine the corner that the sound came from, but it stopped as soon as anybody approached that corner so we didn't get to see until one day when it was moving around on the floor.

If dealing with one of these guys, however, I would probably try to make myself as inconspicuous as I possibly could. :)


 
Last edited:
The story about Anurogryllus celerinictus has now appeared in the Cuban newspaper Granma:

Un estudio, recientemente presentado en la reunión anual de la Sociedad de Biología Integrativa y Comparativa (SICB) muestra que los misteriosos ruidos coinciden con los chirridos de un tipo específico de insecto.
Las grabaciones de sonidos analizadas por un equipo de zoólogos y biólogos, entre los que se encuentran Alexander Stubbs, de la Universidad de Berkeley, en California, y Fernando Montealegre-Zapata, de la Universidad de Lincoln en el Reino Unido, terminan de echar por tierra las absurdas teorías conspirativas que, además, en un giro peligroso de los acontecimientos, culpan a los rusos de ser los autores de la agresión sónica a los diplomáticos estadounidenses.
El Dr. Stubbs, en una entrevista con The New York Times, declaró: «Lo único que puedo decir de manera bastante definitiva es que la grabación publicada por AP es de un grillo, y creemos que sabemos de qué especie es».
Del canto del sinsonte al del grillo (Granma, Jan. 10, 2019)


The Google translation isn't bad except for one small part of it:

"A study, recently presented at the annual meeting of the Society of Integrative and Comparative Biology (SICB) shows that the mysterious noises coincide with the squeaks of a specific type of insect.
Sound recordings analyzed by a team of zoologists and biologists, including Alexander Stubbs of the University of Berkeley, in California, and Fernando Montealegre-Zapata, of the University of Lincoln in the United Kingdom, end up dismissing land the absurd conspiracy theories that, in addition, in a dangerous turn of events, blame the Russians for being the authors of the sonic aggression against the American diplomats.
Dr. Stubbs, in an interview with The New York Times, said: "The only thing I can say quite definitively is that the recording published by AP is of a cricket, and we believe that we know what species it is.""


I think that "echar por tierra" means throw to the ground, i.e. debunking.
 
Fox News has also reported the latest development of the story:
Mysterious sounds recorded at Cuba Embassy were ... crickets (Fox News, Jan. 10, 2019)

And so has the Nordic Business Insider:
'Sonic attacks' on U.S. diplomats in Cuba may have been ... crickets (Nordic Business Insider, Jan. 7, 2019)

The Fair Observer:
US Diplomats Attacked in Cuba … by Crickets (Fair Observer, Jan. 9, 2019)


However, I would particularly recommend this article from Vanity Fair for people who haven't been following the story. This is how it describes the development of the mass psychogenic illness in Havana:

If you retrace the key events and anomalies of the outbreak at the embassy in Havana, every step of the way corresponds to those in classic cases of conversion disorder. The first few staffers hit by the symptoms were C.I.A. agents working on hostile soil—one of the most stressful positions imaginable. The initial conversation between Patient Zero and Patient One referenced only the odd sound; neither experienced any symptoms. Then, a few months later, a third embassy official reported that he was losing his hearing due to a “powerful beam of high-pitched sound.” As word spread quickly throughout the small, tight-knit complex of diplomats and other staff, Patient Zero helped sound the alarm. “He was lobbying, if not coercing, people to report symptoms and to connect the dots,” says Fulton Armstrong, a former C.I.A. officer who worked undercover in Cuba.
According to ProPublica, Patient Zero informed Ambassador Jeffrey DeLaurentis, in a telling phrase, that “the rumor mill is going mad.” So a meeting was called, which spread the word even further.
THE REAL STORY BEHIND THE HAVANA EMBASSY MYSTERY - U.S. officials say dozens of diplomats in Cuba were felled by a sonic “attack.” But the likeliest culprit is far less futuristic—and much more terrifying. (Vanity Fair, Jan. 6, 2019)


And for those of you who have kept up with the news, this may be of particular interest. The otolaryngology report from December 2019 talking about inner-ear afflictions has been dismissed by other experts:

In December, a new study found that 25 embassy staffers tested positive for real, physical symptoms—in this case, impairments to balance and cognitive functions. “What we noticed is universal damage to the gravity organs in the ear,” the study’s lead author told the Times. But a closer look at the study itself, experts say, reveals that it found no such thing. “This paper only reports statement of deficits without giving any evidence, or scores, or methods, or statistics, or procedures,” explains Della Sala, the editor of Cortex. “It is far below par, and would not pass the scrutiny of any respected neuropsychology outlet.” In other words, he says, the symptoms cited in the study may be testable. But that alone “does not necessarily support an organic cause.”
 
One of the two researchers behind the new paper, integrative biology Ph.D. student Alexander Stubbs (the other one being Prof. Fernando Montealegre-Zapata of the University of Lincoln in the U.K.), is ”a grad student in professor Jimmy McGuire’s lab in the Museum of Vertebrate Zoology at Berkeley,” and Berkeley News has used the opportunity to interview him.

Asked how they can be so sure that the species identified in their report is really correct, Stubbs says, “No other known continuously calling cricket has a wing stroke rate of 180 per second. We can definitively say this recording is of a cricket, and we are pretty sure we know what species it is.”
Recorded sounds that plagued U.S. diplomats in Cuba just crickets hard at work (Berkeley News, Jan. 10, 2019)


The article also mentions another incident when the USA blamed one of its enemies for what later turned out to be an entirely natural occurrence:

The 1981 “yellow rain” incident came about when the United States accused the Soviet Union of providing communist fighters in Southeast Asia with chemical weapons that were later found to be the feces of giant bees.


I hadn’t heard the story about Yellow rain (Wikipedia) before, but it’s very interesting – and in many ways very similar to the way that the USA has treated the sonic cricket attacks:

After a lengthy investigation, U.S. analysts concluded in 1981 that the substance, dubbed “yellow rain,” was a chemical weapon made of fungus toxins and created by the Soviet Union. The U.S. secretary of state at the time, Alexander Haig Jr., announced that the Soviet Union had given the weapon to the Viet Cong and Pathet Lao, who dropped it on the Hmong (and other ethnic groups) in their villages and while they fled to refugee camps.
(…)
After reviewing the original study done by U.S. investigators, Meselson’s team found inconsistencies and contradictions in the testimony of people who witnessed yellow rain. The liquid sometimes rained down when there wasn’t a plane in sight. Most of the health problems could be explained by dysentery and nutritional deficiencies in refugee camps. It also became clear that the original interviewers had asked leading questions and unconsciously manipulated testimonies.
The Mystery of Yellow Rain (Science History, April 13, 2018)


So you not only shouldn't confuse yellow rain with chemical weapons, you should also be aware that yellow rain has absolutely nothing to do with golden showers! :)
 
Unfortunately, the rest of NewScientist’s new article is behind a pay wall, but this is how it begins:

CUBA has long been a hotbed of improbable US spy games. Fidel Castro was famously targeted by hundreds of creative assassination attempts, including exploding cigars and suicide bomber clams, poison-tipped fountain pens and toxic wetsuits.
In 2017 the boot appeared to be on the other foot, as US officials concluded that hearing loss reported by diplomats in their embassy in Cuba was due to a covert sonic weapon wielded by nefarious agents.
What strategic goal is served by deafening diplomats is a mystery, unless Cuba is suddenly feeling protective about the relaxing sounds of the Buena [Vista Social Club (my guess, dann] …

Feedback: Havana spies bugged by shrieking Cuban crickets (NewScientist, Jan. 16, 2019)


I can recommend this 16 min. youtube video:
The biggest purveyors of conspiracy nonsense out there are the main stream media establishment cronies, who are nothing other than repeaters of whatever lie is coming from whatever government agency is feeding them a line today, and they will just run with it, and they will report it, and they are the professionals who are getting the inside scoop about ’signals intelligence and blah blah blah secret technology no one knows what it is but it must be the Russians we have no proof but it doesn’t matter.’ These are the conspiracy peddlers that are clearly trying to lead the public in a certain direction. And the big headline stories will get all the coverage, ‘oh my God, secret microwave radiation attacks,’ but the niggly little details about that … that … the actual report … And please do go and read through the actual paper that they linked here in its … it’s not just an abstract, it’s an actual scientific paper where they show in great detail the pulse rates and the oscillations and everything: It is a cricket sound that’s been recorded. But more so than that even: They do get into the issue of the University of Pennsylvania paper that was criticized as using an arbitrarily low threshold for neurological impairment. The idea is this was at best a psychological phenomenon. People were hearing about, ‘oh there’s this thing that’s going on is affecting people, and they started to come down with the symptoms that were not quite nailed-down-able and can’t real quick pinpoint what this is, but it must be some new disorder.’ No, it was at best …, it was the public being trauma…, the diplomatic workers being traumatized by hearing these other stories and believing … duping themselves into believing that they had it, at best.
And on a societal scale, that’s what propaganda like this is meant to do when we hear nothing but these stories of this extraordinary weapons technology that’s being used on you by these Russkies that are hiding under every bed, it puts people into a fear state where they will begin to enact this in the real world – whether that’s some sort of neurological disorder or whatever else it is. That fear state is what they want you to dwell in, and that’s why the headline, the sensational headlines about secret brain frying maker microwave radiation will get all the coverage. The retractions will get none, except in the alternative media …
Secret Brain-frying Microwave Technology UNMASKED!!! - #PropagandaWatch, (The Corbett Report, Jan. 16, 2019)
 
That is my personal experience, too. I had one in a classroom recently (an ordinary Danish cricket, not the Caribbean kind), and it was pretty easy to determine the corner that the sound came from, but it stopped as soon as anybody approached that corner so we didn't get to see until one day when it was moving around on the floor.

If dealing with one of these guys, however, I would probably try to make myself as inconspicuous as I possibly could. :)



Meh, wetas are totally harmless. Well except for the ones on Skull Island, but other than those.....
 
It has likely been pointed out already, but I found this detail from the article insightful:

Cricket behavior could also help explain another mysterious detail of the Cuban incidents: Several diplomats claimed that the sound abruptly stopped when they entered a room or moved around. That’s “consistent with an insect stopping a call when threatened,” Stubbs and Montealegre-Z write.


That was pretty clear from the very beginning: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11998004#post11998004
 
Meh, wetas are totally harmless. Well except for the ones on Skull Island, but other than those.....


Well, the tree-climbing wetas appear to be very aggressive, but their bite doesn't appear to be really harmful, no more so than the bite of my lovebirds (i.e. non-toxic) when they felt that I was trespassing on their territory.
However, I just don't like large insects, so I'm glad that we don't have any that size around these parts.
 
Canada confirms 14th case of illness; halves Havana embassy staff

(CNN)Canada has confirmed a 14th case of unusual health symptoms experienced by diplomatic staff in Havana, Cuba.

In a statement, the Canadian government acknowledged the case, and announced that diplomatic staff in Cuba would be halved. The number of diplomats at the Canadian embassy in Cuba will now be reduced from 16 to eight, according to a Canadian government official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak publicly.

"The health, safety and security of our diplomatic staff and their families remain our priority," the statement said. "The Canadian government continues to investigate the potential causes of the unusual health symptoms experienced by some Canadian diplomatic staff and their family members posted in Havana, Cuba. To date, no cause has been identified."

Cuban ambassador to Canada Josefina Vidal criticized the decision to cut staff as an "incomprehensible" move that "fuels speculation." "This behavior favors those who in the United States use this issue to attack and denigrate Cuba," she said. She emphasized Cuba's cooperation in investigating the symptoms and affirmed the country's commitment to good relations.

The Canadian statement said that after the last confirmed case of unusual health symptoms in November 2018, a number of Canadian diplomatic staff in Cuba underwent additional medical testing.

"These tests confirm that an additional employee has symptoms consistent with those of previously affected employees. This brings the total number of affected Canadian employees, spouses and dependents to 14."

In April, Canada pulled all nonessential staff and diplomats' family members, after testing concluded that their diplomats also suffered from mystery symptoms that included dizziness, ringing in the ears and memory loss.

The Canadian government said Wednesday there is no evidence that Canadian travelers to Cuba are at risk.

I don't see what's so "incomprehensible" about Canada's decision. Whether the Canadian diplomats are actually falling ill or simply succumbing to hysteria, it makes no sense for Canada to keep feeding a full contingent of replacements to Havana knowing they will keep getting sick and having to come back.
 
I do see why the Cubans say that they find Canada's decision incomprehensible:

Canada will reduce its diplomatic presence in Cuba by half after another Canadian diplomat came down with symptoms of a mysterious illness that has bedevilled U.S. and Canadian diplomats posted in Havana, Canadian officials announced Wednesday.
(...)
The fact that a recently arrived diplomat reported symptoms means the undiagnosed ailment is still a threat, officials said speaking on the condition of anonymity.
‘Havana Syndrome’ forces Canada to halve its diplomatic presence in Cuba (Radio Canada International, Jan. 30, 2019)


A Canadian official said government officials are working closely with US officials. The US has not said what caused the incidents, although initial speculation centered on some type of sonic attack. The Canadian official said they have no information to indicate a cause or what might or who might be behind it.
Canada cuts staff in Cuba embassy after mystery illness strikes again (The Guardian, Jan. 31, 2019)


Cuba understands the obligations of the government of Canada to protect its diplomatic personnel posted anywhere in the world and to try to find answers to the health symptoms reported in Cuba, however, it considers that Canada´s decision made public today is incomprehensible.
(...)
During the exchanges that had been held, it has become clear that there is no evidence that might reveal any brain damage, or that may explain the varied symptoms reported, or that may indicate that these symptoms had occurred due to the stay of the affected diplomats in Cuba. The symptoms reported are varied, with a common denominator which is that they are difficult to measure or verify through technical means.Statement by the Cuban Ambassador to Canada, Josefina Vidal January 30, 2019 (Representaciones Diplomaticos de Cuba en el Exterior, Jan. 30, 2019)


But on the other hand, diplomatic language aside, Cuba does seem to comprehend what is the actual reason for Canada's decision. From the same statement:

This behavior favours those who in the United States use this issue to attack and denigrate Cuba.
 
Do you feel that the statement "an undiagnosed ailment is still a threat" is in error, logically or as a practical matter of fact?

Do you feel that mass hysteria, itself, is not a threat that requires some kind of intervention?

If your answer to either is "no", then you cannot support a statement that Canada's decision is incomprehensible.

The Cuban representative's statement on the matter can be disregarded. It basically amounts to "Canada's decision is bad because they don't know exactly is causing the symptoms, and because the US could use it for propaganda". The first half is a non sequitur, and the second is wholly irrelevant; it's not Canada's job to worry about what the US thinks of the situation, and certainly not their responsibility to keep their staff in harm's way to avoid giving someone in some third country a propaganda point.

The statement also leaves out one very important common denominator between the symptoms: they were all reported after being stationed in Havana, which is reason Canada is drawing down staff there. It is prudent and logical.
 
Do you feel that the statement "an undiagnosed ailment is still a threat" is in error, logically or as a practical matter of fact?


It's not a question of how I feel. And an undiagnosed ailment is an undiagnosed ailment. It's not a threat as long as nothing (so far) has indicated that it's contagious, so it's in error logically and as a practical matter of fact. Especially in this case where it isn't even really undiagnosed.

Do you feel that mass hysteria, itself, is not a threat that requires some kind of intervention?


It's still not a question of how I feel. But, yes, mass hysteria, hysterical contagion, mass psychogenic illness, behavioural contagion or conversion disorder (Wikipedia) requires "some kind of intervention":

In the days following the incident, questions will remain as to what caused of the illness, what safeguards are there to prevent a reoccurrence, and what assurances are there that the facility is now safe. Answers to these questions when no physical cause is identified, as is the case in a mass psychogenic illness, must focus on building confidence that adequate care has been taken. Inquiries can be expected from students, parents, and the media. The ease with which individuals with questions can receive a reply from an appropriate university spokesperson can affect the level of trust perceived in the answers given. It is appropriate that at the end of the professional investigation of the incident, a report be issued to all interested parties. Because indeed the symptoms experienced by the victims were real, it is important to acknowledge that. Especially in cases of mass psychogenic illness, a coordinated staff response is essential for minimizing the disruption to the student community.
A case of Mass hysteria or toxic fumes ?: Considerations for University Administrators (Indiana University)


Epidemic Hysteria in Virginia: The Case of the Phantom Gasser of 1933-1934 (Bartholomew/Wessely, King's College, London)
conversion disorder: Treatment (Wikipedia)
Mass Psychogenic Illness: Risk Factors and Treatment (Clinical Neurology News, Feb. 2018)

If your answer to either is "no", then you cannot support a statement that Canada's decision is incomprehensible.


The Canadian decision is wrong, but it isn't really incomprehensible.

The Cuban representative's statement on the matter can be disregarded. It basically amounts to "Canada's decision is bad because they don't know exactly is causing the symptoms, and because the US could use it for propaganda". The first half is a non sequitur, and the second is wholly irrelevant; it's not Canada's job to worry about what the US thinks of the situation, and certainly not their responsibility to keep their staff in harm's way to avoid giving someone in some third country a propaganda point.


No, it's not Canada's job to worry about what the US thinks, but Canada sure tends to worry. It's also not Canada's job to "keep their staff in harm's way," but in a rational world it would be their job to recognize that there is no harm at all to remove their staff from. And if there were, why leave half of their staff "in harm's way" if they actually think that there is harm? Wouldn't that be an incomprehensible and irresponsible way of treating their staff?!!! It's very telling that they don't seem to think so, isn't it?

The statement also leaves out one very important common denominator between the symptoms: they were all reported after being stationed in Havana, which is reason Canada is drawing down staff there. It is prudent and logical.


No, you're wrong again: They weren't all reported after being stationed in Havana. At least one was reported in Guangzhou, and that's not counting the other the more apocryphal cases ...

I think I'll sit down and watch The Falling (The Guardian) while we wait for the next chapter of this increasingly absurd story. I feel that it'll be fun to see the Arya Stark actress in a very different role.

In the meantime, did you read the Vanity Fair article?!
 
No, it's not Canada's job to worry about what the US thinks, but Canada sure tends to worry.

Not about this. They were not concerned enough to evacuate their mission in Havana when the US did for similar reasons; only now is Canada acting.

Canada does not share the US's antagonistic and troubled history and political relationship with Cuba. It has cordial relations with Cuba and was always openly critical of the US embargo. Canada has no reason to want an excuse to disrupt diplomatic relations with Cuba and despite your proclamation above there is no actual historical precedent for them to care about or defer to the US's opinion of Cuba, or the US's opinion of Canada-Cuba relations.

It's also not Canada's job to "keep their staff in harm's way," but in a rational world it would be their job to recognize that there is no harm at all to remove their staff from.

If Canadian diplomats are becoming hysterical with some regularity upon posting to Havana, there is harm in continuing to send new people there. The alternative is literally to insist nothing is wrong while sending more staff and inevitably continuing to create new hysteria cases, which seems highly unethical to say the least. I say inevitable, because I cannot find anything in the researchable internet literature about mass psychogenic illness that suggests a simple authoritative announcement that nothing is wrong and all the symptoms are entirely in the sufferers' own heads, and forcing sufferers to remain within the triggering environment or conditions, is known to put an end to a mass hysteria outbreak.

And if there were, why leave half of their staff "in harm's way" if they actually think that there is harm? Wouldn't that be an incomprehensible and irresponsible way of treating their staff?!!! It's very telling that they don't seem to think so, isn't it?

The people who are staying presumably have not succumbed to the hysteria, which means there is no danger for them specifically to remain. Determining whether new personnel are susceptible to hysteria requires them to be sent there, which is problematic because "failing the test" means they develop the troublesome symptoms which are certainly disturbing and grievous for them to deal with, psychosomatic though they may be.

ETA: There also may be logistic issues at work here. During the original outbreak, once Canadian diplomats began reporting symptoms, the Canadian government made a public announcement that it was allowing any diplomat who wanted to leave Cuba, regardless of symptoms, to return and be reassigned. With new cases of symptoms continuing to emerge, things may have come to a point where too many staffers have asked to leave Cuba and not enough staffers have volunteered to be sent to Havana to replace them.

No, you're wrong again: They weren't all reported after being stationed in Havana. At least one was reported in Guangzhou, and that's not counting the other the more apocryphal cases ...

There are no reports I can find of Canadian diplomats reporting these symptoms anywhere other than Cuba. Perhaps you are conflating them with the US diplomatic reports.
 
Last edited:
Not about this. They were not concerned enough to evacuate their mission in Havana when the US did for similar reasons; only now is Canada acting.

Canada does not share the US's antagonistic and troubled history and political relationship with Cuba. It has cordial relations with Cuba and was always openly critical of the US embargo. Canada has no reason to want an excuse to disrupt diplomatic relations with Cuba and despite your proclamation above there is no actual historical precedent for them to care about or defer to the US's opinion of Cuba, or the US's opinion of Canada-Cuba relations.


And yet the Havana syndrome (Wikipedia) spread from CIA agents to Canadian diplomats.

If Canadian diplomats are becoming hysterical with some regularity upon posting to Havana, there is harm in continuing to send new people there. The alternative is literally to insist nothing is wrong while sending more staff and inevitably continuing to create new hysteria cases, which seems highly unethical to say the least. I say inevitable, because I cannot find anything in the researchable internet literature about mass psychogenic illness that suggests a simple authoritative announcement that nothing is wrong and all the symptoms are entirely in the sufferers' own heads, and forcing sufferers to remain within the triggering environment or conditions, is known to put an end to a mass hysteria outbreak.


Why do you think, literally, that the alternative is "to insist nothing is wrong while sending more staff and inevitably continuing to create new hysteria cases"? Is that what a single one of the many recommended treatments or interventions suggests? Why did you try to "find anything in the researchable internet literature about mass psychogenic illness that suggests a simple authoritative announcement that nothing is wrong and all the symptoms are entirely in the sufferers' own heads," instead of reading what they actually recommend? Why this fairy tale about a(nother) wrong way of tackling a problem as the only alternative to the wrong way that is actually being used?!

The people who are staying presumably have not succumbed to the hysteria, which means there is no danger for them specifically to remain. Determining whether new personnel are susceptible to hysteria requires them to be sent there, which is problematic because "failing the test" means they develop the troublesome symptoms which are certainly disturbing and grievous for them to deal with, psychosomatic though they may be.


I don't presume anything about why they are staying. Since they aren't tourists but employees of Canada, my guess is that they are staying because Canada wants them to stay. I haven't heard of a test to decide whether or not somebody is "susceptible to hysteria". Have you?! I assume that only an insignificant number of the embassy employees to be withdrawn from Havana will be teenage girls ...
(You can read about how the girls at the Le Roy High School were treated.)

ETA: There also may be logistic issues at work here. During the original outbreak, once Canadian diplomats began reporting symptoms, the Canadian government made a public announcement that it was allowing any diplomat who wanted to leave Cuba, regardless of symptoms, to return and be reassigned. With new cases of symptoms continuing to emerge, things may have come to a point where too many staffers have asked to leave Cuba and not enough staffers have volunteered to be sent to Havana to replace them.


I don't think that your hypothesis is backed up by the words used to describe the situation.

There are no reports I can find of Canadian diplomats reporting these symptoms anywhere other than Cuba. Perhaps you are conflating them with the US diplomatic reports.


No, I'm not. But why do you want to watch the Canadian cases isolated from the U.S. American ones that started it all?!
 
Last edited:
By the way, I wonder why we haven't heard the Brits complain about health-harmed diplomats. Their embassy in Havana is right next to Canada's. Why would the crickets only bother New-World English speakers? :confused:
:CANADA: :UK: :USA: :CUBA:
 
This is like a lot of the nonsense people believe. If there is something physical that affects one's tissues, then it can be detected. Unless you think it's magic pixie dust, that's not detectable.

Are these people presenting with the same symptoms consistently between individuals and are the symptoms accompanied by physical findings?

This case has all the hallmarks of hysteria.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom