The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reality checks fantasy shattered by just one paper.



Decoupling=separating :D

Debye length explanation please. :)

Check out the scale.



Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet


Double layer by rc’s admission!


:D


The dust is strongly negatively charged as well!!!!!

This is behaving as an electron beam/fluid.

Complete gibberish, and nothing to do with the total failure of the EC woo.
 
How the actual **** is this still going? Seriously, can the mods put this nonsense out of its misery? The only EC proponent is going round and round in circles without a hint of ever learning a thing. Good grief. Four threads, heading to a fifth, and we're still getting ridiculous posts like "mostly rock then?" as though it hasn't been thoroughly addressed thousands of times already.
 
How the actual **** is this still going? Seriously, can the mods put this nonsense out of its misery? The only EC proponent is going round and round in circles without a hint of ever learning a thing. Good grief. Four threads, heading to a fifth, and we're still getting ridiculous posts like "mostly rock then?" as though it hasn't been thoroughly addressed thousands of times already.

Agreed!
 
Rock, it is.

Tick one off the predictions of the ELECTRIC COMET.

Rock with a density half that of water. Composed purely of dust. With very low tensile and compressive strengths. So weak that a puny little impactor leaves a dirty great hole in it, and excavates ice. With a thermal inertia nothing like rock. And, unlike Earth rock, totally unmagnetised. What kind of rock is that?

Fail8
 
How the actual **** is this still going? Seriously, can the mods put this nonsense out of its misery? The only EC proponent is going round and round in circles without a hint of ever learning a thing. Good grief. Four threads, heading to a fifth, and we're still getting ridiculous posts like "mostly rock then?" as though it hasn't been thoroughly addressed thousands of times already.

Great some fresh air.

As I’ve not seen you post before welcome.

What’s your take on
(c) Whatarecometsmadeof? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].


Very basic question.

Are comets mostly ice or mostly rock?

A’Hearn says our understanding has been evolving toward mostly rock.

But jd116 and reality check seem to contradict A’Hearn and say the rock is actually just dust.


They will not admit comets are mostly vacuum (85% porosity) with “dust” @2600 kg/m³ with very little to no ice.

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications


So, I assume you can read and understand a peer reviewed paper?


Are comets, at the very basic level mostly ice as per Whipple’s model or has OUR understanding been evolving toward mostly rock.

Just spinning the wheels until part two.
 
Last edited:
How’s your understanding of plasma physics and MHD, Jond?

BecUse the other thing the electric comet needs is charge separation of the solar wind plasma.

This is seen and mentioned in this paper.

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

The scale is 1500km computational domain.

You may see the electrons and ions seperate setting up an electric field, an ambipolar electric field or more correctly a double layer.
 
Last edited:
A’Hearn says our understanding has been evolving toward mostly rock.

But jd116 and reality check seem to contradict A’Hearn and say the rock is actually just dust.


They will not admit comets are mostly vacuum (85% porosity) with “dust” @2600 kg/m³ with very little to no ice.

Another bunch of lies. Not sure how you keep getting away with it.

No rock ever detected at comets;

Rock with a density half that of water. Composed purely of dust. With very low tensile and compressive strengths. So weak that a puny little impactor leaves a dirty great hole in it, and excavates ice. With a thermal inertia nothing like rock. And, unlike Earth rock, totally unmagnetised. What kind of rock is that?

Fail8

Thousands of tonnes of ice excavated from the top few dozen meters at Tempel 1. And floating around Hartley 2.

Quit the lying, and start backing up your assertions with some actual science.
 
How’s your understanding of plasma physics and MHD, Jond?

It has to be better than yours. You haven't got a scooby!


BecUse the other thing the electric comet needs is charge separation of the solar wind plasma.

This is seen and mentioned in this paper.

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

The scale is 1500km computational domain.

You may see the electrons and ions seperate setting up an electric field, an ambipolar electric field or more correctly a double layer.

Lying about his own woo, now! This is pathetic. You need rock. There isn't any. You need EDM (lol). There isn't any. You need electric discharges. There aren't any. Ergo, complete failure. And there is no double layer. Stop lying.
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

The RSI data was bang on, there’s is minimal “ice” and the DUST is pulverised ROCK!
The RSI data shows that the electric comet theory is insane by confirming has the last 70 years of data of comets not having the density of rocks.

Usual ices in quotes lie when ices have been detected as he has been told many times and has acknowledged many times by citing ices and dust comet papers..
A "minimal ice" lie about the electric comet theory whose insanity includes comet having no ices. Sometimes we see weaseling out of this with "little" ices. Comets have at least 16% ices (67P) which is not "little".
A dust = pulverized rock delusion when the returned dust we have is not pulverized rock.
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

EDM on the molecular scale, ionising rock and releasing dust, along with water vapour from clays and carbon dioxide/monoxide from carbonates
As he has been told many times, the insanity of the electric comet theory includes physical impossible EDM on massive scales.

The authors of the electric comet theory have the delusion that EDM is possible on comets. The authors of the electric comet theory use that delusion modify the surfaces of comets. Comets are tens of kilometers in sizes :jaw-dropp!

Ignorant releasing dust etc. by a physical impossible EDM delusion.
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

We see these ROCKS on asteroids.
As he has been told many times, asteroids are not comets :jaw-dropp!

As he has been told many times, images do not tell us the composition of asteroids or comets so we so not see clays or carbonates on asteroids.
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

Now the real homework for you reality check, is where are all these organics coming from?
As he has been told hundreds of times, mainstream ices and dust comets are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

A lying question because the article he cites states how the building blocks of life found on 67P were formed.
Building Blocks of Life Found in Comet's Atmosphere (2016)
For the first time, scientists have directly detected a crucial amino acid and a rich selection of organic molecules in the dusty atmosphere of a comet, further bolstering the hypothesis that these icy objects delivered some of life's ingredients to Earth.
...
The glycine probably didn't form on the comet itself, Altwegg said, but rather in the broad stretches of dust and debris that made up the solar system before planetary bodies formed.
 
Last edited:
The cometary double layers delusion pops up yet again

COMETARY DOUBLE LAYERS!! :D
This is a delusion in upper case.
  • There is no evidence that the insanity in the electric comet theory includes double layers.
    Comets being rock insanity.
    Being blasted from rocky planets including the Earth insanity.
    Electric discharges between planets dong that blasting insanity.
    EDM insanity.
    Comet jets being electrical discharges insanity.
    Insanity of 14 year old lies about Deep Impact as if the authors cannot read and understand science or English.
    No cometary double layers insanity from the authors that I can recall.
  • As he has been told many times: It is physically impossible for there to be cometary double layers.
    A delusion that data from 1 comet showed double layers but that was changes in voltage over scales of many kilometers when the Debye length would be ~10 meters (DL's of maybe ~100 meters in scale).
    A plasma physicist studying comets (tusenfem) stated that comet coma were too turbulent for double layers to form.
    Take 5 minutes to search the scientific literature and there are no cometary double layers papers.
If the authors are so deluded as to have cometary double layers, Sol88 can give us a citation.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom