Journalist attacked by violent mob

They could start by suspending the praxis of giving demonstration permits to extreme right wing groups who only come to Portland because they know there will be violence. What these groups are doing have nothing to do with freedom of speech or the right to peacfully demonstrate, and everything to do with wanting to win a street fight over "leftists".

I agree that these groups are venue shopping when they set their rallies in Portland. They want a fight and Portland happily grants them an arena.

So long as there can be street fights with no legal consequences, there will be thugs drawn to the city. It's not hard to identify the small number of potential brawlers. Just have police monitor and follow the people who look like they walked off the set of a Mad Max movie and the problem will be easily sorted.

Denying permits because of street fights is surrendering to the heckler's veto. Arresting these people works, the city just needs to do its job.

I will note that Boston, like many other big cities, also has these right-wing goons show up. The difference is that our police show up in force and make it very clear that violence will lead to arrest. The alt-right goons yell at the antifa goons, but there's no explosion of violence. It is not necessary to deny permits to prevent public places from becoming a giant Thunderdome.
 
Last edited:
Don't know why we are even bothering to debate the pros and cons of "Antifa", capitalised or not.

To my skeptical viewpoint and having watched the video, this looks like an agent provocateur. The "attacker" could have been anyone, dressed head to toe in black with their face covered and no ID. But they picked on a journalist, not any other marchers. Plenty of other people were there carrying cameras and participating. But the pro-redneck journalist alone still gets picked out... Why? To make a shock-horror-it's-all-Antifa's-fault moment. And now the rednecks will get even more riled up for blood because they certainly won't ask questions. Job done!

Ah, yes. The old go out and get yourself beat up so you can blame it on someone trick. Works every time.



Here's the thing. Even if, in this case, it happened to be true, the only reason it could work is because the conspirators are imitating real people. There really are a bunch of idiots in America today who think it's trendy to get dressed in black, leave all their ID at home, and disrupt activities by violence. And there are idiots that they can protest who do the same sort of stupid stuff, but have different clothes and have different chants.

If we could just rent them a big open field where they can beat each other up, I think most Americans would be ok with that. The problem is that, instead, they show up in the middle of cities, and then windows get broken, and innocent people get hit, and police have to be paid overtime. A pox on all their houses.
 
Ah, yes. The old go out and get yourself beat up so you can blame it on someone trick. Works every time.



Here's the thing. Even if, in this case, it happened to be true, the only reason it could work is because the conspirators are imitating real people. There really are a bunch of idiots in America today who think it's trendy to get dressed in black, leave all their ID at home, and disrupt activities by violence. And there are idiots that they can protest who do the same sort of stupid stuff, but have different clothes and have different chants.

If we could just rent them a big open field where they can beat each other up, I think most Americans would be ok with that. The problem is that, instead, they show up in the middle of cities, and then windows get broken, and innocent people get hit, and police have to be paid overtime. A pox on all their houses.

Prohibit one of the groups and you'll automatically get rid of the other. I'll leave you to figure out which is which.
 
Prohibit one of the groups and you'll automatically get rid of the other. I'll leave you to figure out which is which.

Sadly, it isn't true, because Antifa has been found at lots of occasions, including "they invited the wrong people to speak at the university".


Also, the whole "prohibit one of the groups" idea just doesn't seem to fit in with American values.
 
Sadly, it isn't true, because Antifa has been found at lots of occasions, including "they invited the wrong people to speak at the university".

Fascists, yes. So what I said is still true.

Also, the whole "prohibit one of the groups" idea just doesn't seem to fit in with American values.

American values is to allow Nazi street gangs to intimidate a city and engage in outright battles with anti-fascist opponents?

'Cause that's what you have.
 
Fascists, yes. So what I said is still true.



American values is to allow Nazi street gangs to intimidate a city and engage in outright battles with anti-fascist opponents?

'Cause that's what you have.

Generalize all you want, but this thread is about some guy with a camera getting mobbed in the streets by mask wearing antifa goons. Andy Ngo was not engaged in violence when he was attacked. His beating for participating in the public square is inexcusable, no matter how much one may detest his brand of propaganda.

Portland is not being overrun with right wing or left wing goons. These videos never show more than a dozen or so people on either side engaged in the skirmishes. It is well within the ability of the police to quash this violence. They choose not to.
 
Last edited:
Ah, yes. The old go out and get yourself beat up so you can blame it on someone trick. Works every time.



Here's the thing. Even if, in this case, it happened to be true, the only reason it could work is because the conspirators are imitating real people. There really are a bunch of idiots in America today who think it's trendy to get dressed in black, leave all their ID at home, and disrupt activities by violence. And there are idiots that they can protest who do the same sort of stupid stuff, but have different clothes and have different chants.

All this, of course, applies equally to the Jussie Smollett case.

Dave
 
All this, of course, applies equally to the Jussie Smollett case.

Dave
Indeed yes. And the only reason Jussie though he could get away with it is that he was imitating real people.

Unfortunately for Jussie, he got some of the details wrong and his fake wasn't very convincing.
 
Generalize all you want, but this thread is about some guy with a camera getting mobbed in the streets by mask wearing antifa goons. Andy Ngo was not engaged in violence when he was attacked. His beating for participating in the public square is inexcusable, no matter how much one may detest his brand of propaganda.

How do you know what Andy Ngo has done? He's being portrayed as some journalist who just happened to be targeted by Antifa - something that is far from a given. He's a right wing agitator who regularly join extreme right wingers when they come to Portland to fight. He's not a journalist.

Portland is not being overrun with right wing or left wing goons. These videos never show more than a dozen or so people on either side engaged in the skirmishes. It is well within the ability of the police to quash this violence. They choose not to.

I don't know. I know from personal experience that crowd control of this kind is difficult. I also know that the best way to get it to stop is to stop handing out permits. The police know why the Nazis are coming to Portland. They are coming to fight.
 
How do you know what Andy Ngo has done? He's being portrayed as some journalist who just happened to be targeted by Antifa - something that is far from a given. He's a right wing agitator who regularly join extreme right wingers when they come to Portland to fight. He's not a journalist.



I don't know. I know from personal experience that crowd control of this kind is difficult. I also know that the best way to get it to stop is to stop handing out permits. The police know why the Nazis are coming to Portland. They are coming to fight.

Sure, he's a propagandist, trying to shed antifa in the most unfavorable light possible. He laid out some very obvious bait and they gobbled it up.

One might question the character of people so easily baited into mob violence.

They are coming to fight and the police let them. I'm not saying that the police could totally eliminate violence, but they could do a lot more if they wanted. There were three arrests at this latest skirmish. They aren't even trying.
 
Last edited:
Sure, he's a propagandist, trying to shed antifa in the most unfavorable light possible. He laid out some very obvious bait and they gobbled it up.

One might question the character of people so easily baited into mob violence.

Doesn't take much to get it going in a situation like that. As you say, he baited them, and he got eggs and silly strings and milkshake. Unfortunately, the little fascist apparently got punched as well. Too bad, so sad. Still, Andy Ngo isn't a victim. He's an active player.
 
He's an active player.

Sure. Bad actors all around. I will gladly repudiate all of these street thugs, regardless of ideology. The problem is those that presume to give Antifa a free pass to commit violence in the name of "safety". It's absurd.
 
Sure. Bad actors all around. I will gladly repudiate all of these street thugs, regardless of ideology. The problem is those that presume to give Antifa a free pass to commit violence in the name of "safety". It's absurd.

I'll give them a free pass to fight fascists, because that means someone does it. Law enforcement won't give them a free pass, however, and they should face punishment for what they do.
 
I agree that these groups are venue shopping when they set their rallies in Portland. They want a fight and Portland happily grants them an arena.


It's more than just granting them an arena. Portland police and government, like that of Oregon in general, has always had very strong white supremacist leanings. The state was founded on principles of white nationalism, after all.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-new...far-right-group-prompts-investigation-n972161
https://www.wweek.com/news/courts/2...er-ringleader-joey-gibson-show-warm-exchange/

This is a city where white supremacist organization Patriot Prayer also came to one of the protests with rifles and other firearms, stationed themselves on a roof nearby, and were not treated as significant threat by police. Firearms were temporarily confiscated, then almost as quickly returned, and no arrests were made.

https://www.oregonlive.com/portland/2018/10/armed_protesters_were_on_portl.html

Had it been left-wing protesters or black people on that roof, I can guarantee that there would have been much more stringent action taken by police.
 
I'll give them a free pass to fight fascists, because that means someone does it. Law enforcement won't give them a free pass, however, and they should face punishment for what they do.

Law enforcement largely does give them a free pass. Portland is the repeat venue for these skirmishes because both sides are fairly confident they will not be arrested. This confidence is firmly rooted in prior evidence of police not intervening.

Portland is the poster child for how not to deal with fascist violence. "Let antifa deal with" is among the worst possible solutions, guaranteeing escalations and repeat incidents.

What exactly the motives are for the city not enforcing the law is unclear to me. Perhaps the city doesn't want to be seen as entering the political fray as they arrest violent actors on both sides of the skirmish. Perhaps they want a history of violence as a pretext for denying public assemblies. I can't figure out their motives, but the results are terrible.
 
Law enforcement largely does give them a free pass. Portland is the repeat venue for these skirmishes because both sides are fairly confident they will not be arrested. This confidence is firmly rooted in prior evidence of police not intervening.

Portland is the poster child for how not to deal with fascist violence. "Let antifa deal with" is among the worst possible solutions, guaranteeing escalations and repeat incidents.

What exactly the motives are for the city not enforcing the law is unclear to me. Perhaps the city doesn't want to be seen as entering the political fray as they arrest violent actors on both sides of the skirmish. Perhaps they want a history of violence as a pretext for denying public assemblies. I can't figure out their motives, but the results are terrible.

I can just say that this is not the view of the anti-fascists. In part because of what luchog says above, and in part because of their own experiences, they see Portland police as allied with the extreme right, protecting them and attacking the anti-fascists.

But it might be as you say. Maybe they need to crack down harder on the street violence. The first step - again - is to stop handing out permits for Nazis to come to fight.
 
Portland is the poster child for how not to deal with fascist violence. "Let antifa deal with" is among the worst possible solutions, guaranteeing escalations and repeat incidents.


"Let antifa deal with it," is an artifact of the police not actually wanting to do anything about the white supremacists in the first place. If they got involved, they'd have to either start arresting their white supremacist buddies, or find some way to convincingly explain why their policing is so one-sided.

What exactly the motives are for the city not enforcing the law is unclear to me.


See my previous post for citations.
 
Terrorists don't break store windows and loot and assault people, they blow up buildings and hijack planes and kill people. Not all political violence is terrorism, you don't have to misapply the term "terrorism" in order to condemn bad behavior.

Terrorism is defined in U.S. law as "premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against noncombatant targets by subnational groups or clandestine agents," and does not require the sort of dramatic acts of which you speak. It is enough that the violence be politically motivated, organized, and directed against noncombatants.

If a bunch of thugs show up prepared to do violence, having announced their targets based on politics, the semantic analysis seems straightforward enough.
 
I love how "Letting Nazis keep marching in the streets" isn't "escalation" but marching against the Nazis is.

It's the same way someone punching you in the face over and over isn't "escalating" the fight but you hitting them back is.
 
It's more than just granting them an arena. Portland police and government, like that of Oregon in general, has always had very strong white supremacist leanings. The state was founded on principles of white nationalism, after all.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-new...far-right-group-prompts-investigation-n972161
https://www.wweek.com/news/courts/2...er-ringleader-joey-gibson-show-warm-exchange/

This is a city where white supremacist organization Patriot Prayer also came to one of the protests with rifles and other firearms, stationed themselves on a roof nearby, and were not treated as significant threat by police. Firearms were temporarily confiscated, then almost as quickly returned, and no arrests were made.

https://www.oregonlive.com/portland/2018/10/armed_protesters_were_on_portl.html

Had it been left-wing protesters or black people on that roof, I can guarantee that there would have been much more stringent action taken by police.

No doubt there are many compromised police officers.

White nationalist cops looking the other way for their brethren is certainly a very big problem. I imagine a close examination of police departments across the country would reveal an abundance of authoritarians and other undesirables.

But there is a leadership problem in Portland right now. It is increasingly clear that the standing orders are not to interfere. Ultimately this problem stops at the Mayor. Either he is giving this order or he has lost all control of his department. If he has lost control of the department, he should be yelling it from the rooftops day and night. My money is that the Mayor is complicit in the hands-off approach.

I don't think this is a case of bad cops undermining sound policing. It's more a total vacuum of law and order, in which bad cops are taking advantage to push their own ends.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom