Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
I cited Metzl as supporting evidence of Daszak's attempt to steer the WHO investigative team away from the lab accident origin. Metzl has the opinion like many others do that the origin is not yet determined either way.Just out of curiosity, what are Jamie Metzl's qualifications in virology? I looked, but he seems to be mostly involved in politics, public relations, and human rights, along with being a sci-fi author.
As a recognized advisor to the WHO Metzl has been taken very seriously.
[caps are from the source] PBS treanscipt: OUR NEXT GUEST IS AN ADVISOR TO THE W.H.O.'S COMMITTEE ON HUMAN GENOME EDITING.
It doesn't take a PhD in virology to note something so obvious as a non-scientific evidence supported conclusion.Metzl: SO THE REASON WHY I'VE BEEN SUCH A CRITIC OF THOSE TWO LETTERS. [Lancet letters]
FIRST WAS IN THE LANCET IN FEBRUARY IS THAT THESE SCIENTISTS WERE CLAIMING A CERTAINTY THAT WASN'T SUPPORTED BY THE AVAILABLE EVIDENCE.
SO BY SAYING IN THE LANCET LETTER THAT IT WAS EXTREMELY LIKELY THAT THIS HAD A NATURAL ORIGIN AND THAT ANYONE, PEOPLE LIKE ME WHO WERE WITH THE BEST OF INTENTIONS IN TRYING TO HAVE THE MOST OPEN MIND POSSIBLE, ANYONE WHO IS SUGGESTING THE POSSIBILITY OF A LAB INCIDENT EVEN A SCENARIO WHERE IT WAS VERY BENIGN, CHINESE RESEARCHERS WORKING TO DEVELOP VACCINES WHO HAD AN ACCIDENTAL INCIDENT, ANYONE WAS A CONSPIRACY THEORIST.
THAT'S WHY I'VE BEEN SUCH A CRITIC OF THAT LETTER.
I'VE CALLED IT SIGNIFICANT PROPAGANDA, NOT SCIENCE. ...
I THINK THAT THAT LETTER AND THAT PAPER CROSSED THE LINE FROM DATA DRIVEN SCIENCE INTO POLITICS BASED ON A DESIRED OUTCOME.
Read Metzl's description of the WHO team's trip to China in that interview. One need not be a virologist to see it's pretty clear there was no significant investigation.
In addition to his position as advisor to the WHO, here is his educational credentials:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie_Metzl
He is a magna cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa graduate of Brown University.[8] He holds a Ph.D. in Southeast Asian history from Oxford University (1994),[14] and a J.D. from Harvard Law School.[15]
Yes, people in this thread have tired to dismiss Metzl before as if his statement about Daszak had no corroborating evidence. The idea only a small subset of expertise is valid in this discussion makes it easy to dismiss any POV you don't like.
Redfield is a virologist, he thinks a lab accident is the most likely. Oh wait, let's dismiss his opinion because he's too political.
Chinese virologist says Fauci’s emails ‘verify’ her Wuhan lab leak claims
Salon interview
To better understand this issue, Salon spoke with Dr. Stanley Perlman, a professor of microbiology and immunology, as well as of pediatrics, at the University of Iowa. He has studied coronaviruses for 39 years. As usual, the following transcript has been lightly edited for clarity and context. ...
Why do you feel the lab accident idea has gained more credibility?
Partly because we've had a lot of trouble finding these intermediate animals [harboring coronaviruses]. We know that people found them: a [similar] virus was found in a cave, and some of the people infected with it became ill. We know that that virus is similar to SARS-CoV-2 — it's 96% similar — but viruses mutate at a certain rate per year and this virus was a thousand nucleotides different from the SARS-CoV-2. So it is not the direct precursor by any means to SARS-CoV-2. If it was taken into a lab and somehow made into a clone and then manipulated, you still wouldn't end up with SARS-CoV-2. It's not possible to do that.
So that's why I think the thinking has changed — because it's been very, very difficult to find these intermediate animals or that virus that is close to SARS-CoV-2
