Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Skeptic Ginger persists with misunderstanding the Lancet open letter which rightfully condemned lab leak conspiracy theories, not the lab leak hypothesis.
Skeptic Ginger persists with irrelevant links. A timeline of the Wuhan lab-leak hypothesis saying nothing about the "manipulated the Lancet piece" nonsense.
A "The head of the WHO stated in no uncertain terms the lab hypothesis was prematurely dismissed." lie.
WHO Director-General's remarks at the Member State Briefing on the report of the international team studying the origins of SARS-CoV-2

This is the WHO Director-General agreeing with the report. A least likely hypothesis is a still possible hypothesis. There is a hint that the study recommended no further study but it did not. Page 120:


ETA: This is the study WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part. The "Introduction through a laboratory incident" section begins on page 118.
Arguments in favour are
  • "Although rare, laboratory accidents do happen" and
  • The Wuhan CDC lab moved closer to the Huanan market on 2 December 2019 - "Such moves can be disruptive for the operations of any laboratory.".
Arguments against are
  • "The closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2 from bats and pangolin are evolutionarily distant from SARS-CoV-2."
  • "There is no record of viruses closely related to SARS-CoV-2 in any laboratory before December 2019, ..."
  • The risk of accident culturing of SARS-CoV-2 is extremely low since there is no evidence of circulation among people globally before Decamber 2019.
  • "The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019...".
  • No reported "disruptions or incidents" during the Wuhan CDC lab move. "They also reported no storage nor laboratory activities on CoVs or other bat viruses preceding the outbreak"

I also think it is worth remembering that there was nothing surprising about the appearance of Covid-19. Professional bodies had been warning about the risk of a respiratory virus pandemic arising from a virus crossing the species boundary for many years. Coronaviruses had been raised as a specific risk, which is why the Gates Foundation war-gamed a coronavirus pandemic the year before it occurred.

This was an expected event; there is no need to look for an extraordinary explanation. Whilst I accept that this does not rule out a laboratory origin, Occam's razor would suggest it should not be our first choice of explanation.
 
Are we on page 51 yet? [yes we are]

SG - perhaps it would help things, if you could sort of start over and state your point clearly. What is your specific issue? Do you have an odds % that you an share on where you personally think this pandemic originated? Any way that we can reset and be more productive in the dialogue here?

I have learned a lot in this thread, even though my personal interest is in how misinformation / conspiracy theories propagate. I can't contribute much to the science talk, and I'd like to keep learning.
 
I also think it is worth remembering that there was nothing surprising about the appearance of Covid-19. Professional bodies had been warning about the risk of a respiratory virus pandemic arising from a virus crossing the species boundary for many years. Coronaviruses had been raised as a specific risk, which is why the Gates Foundation war-gamed a coronavirus pandemic the year before it occurred.

This was an expected event; there is no need to look for an extraordinary explanation. Whilst I accept that this does not rule out a laboratory origin, Occam's razor would suggest it should not be our first choice of explanation.

A lab accident is not an extraordinary explanation despite the attempt by Daszak and some people in this thread to make it one.

Occam's razor doesn't suggest one origin hypothesis over the other. People who claim a natural spillover is the favored explanation cherry pick and ignore the history of lab accidents.

And yes, not only was it an expected inevitable event, a lab accident resulting in such a pandemic has been warned about for years. They even have a name for the pathogen: PPP potentially pandemic pathogens.

Framework for Guiding Funding Decisions about Proposed Research Involving Enhanced Potential Pandemic Pathogens 2017
 
Last edited:
SG - perhaps it would help things, if you could sort of start over and state your point clearly. What is your specific issue? Do you have an odds % that you an share on where you personally think this pandemic originated? Any way that we can reset and be more productive in the dialogue here?

I have learned a lot in this thread, even though my personal interest is in how misinformation / conspiracy theories propagate. I can't contribute much to the science talk, and I'd like to keep learning.

I appreciate the suggestion and have been asking repeatedly to return to a discussion of the evidence.

But I have also stated my POV in this thread clearly a dozen times and then some. One way to return to a productive discussion is for people to stop trying to discredit me and start discussing the evidence.

In addition, a number of people here claim that when I post a significant amount of supporting evidence that it is a gish-gallop. That's another word for tl;dr and that is not because of a gish-gallop, it is because there is a lot of evidence supporting the lab accident.

Where do I stand in addition to the supporting evidence?

This forum is supposed to be full of critical thinkers. What I see are people who were duped from the beginning that a lab accident was a CT and when it became clear that it wasn't that far-fetched, these same people have been unable to let go of that first conclusion they bought into.

Notice that paragraph is about a lab accident not being a CT. It is not about conclusive evidence of one hypothesis over the other.

Do I lean one way or the other? Yes, the longer it goes without an immediate source being identified, the greater the chances it was a lab accident. We are 2 months shy of 2 years looking for said source species.

When attention is drawn to that problem, the knee-jerk reaction is to claim it took a dozen plus years to find the source of SARS 1. No it did not. It took that long to find the source that infected the proximal species from which SARS jumped to people. The proximal species was found within months of the first human cases.
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Ginger persists with misunderstanding the Lancet open letter
This is a stupid comment that has nothing to do with any discussion of the evidence.

which rightfully condemned lab leak conspiracy theories, not the lab leak hypothesis.
Skeptic Ginger persists with irrelevant links. A timeline of the Wuhan lab-leak hypothesis saying nothing about the "manipulated the Lancet piece" nonsense.
A "The head of the WHO stated in no uncertain terms the lab hypothesis was prematurely dismissed." lie.
WHO Director-General's remarks at the Member State Briefing on the report of the international team studying the origins of SARS-CoV-2
Can you not knock this crap off?


This is the WHO Director-General agreeing with the report. A least likely hypothesis is a still possible hypothesis. There is a hint that the study recommended no further study but it did not. Page 120:


ETA: This is the study WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part. The "Introduction through a laboratory incident" section begins on page 118.
Arguments in favour are
  • "Although rare, laboratory accidents do happen" and
  • The Wuhan CDC lab moved closer to the Huanan market on 2 December 2019 - "Such moves can be disruptive for the operations of any laboratory.".
Arguments against are
  • "The closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2 from bats and pangolin are evolutionarily distant from SARS-CoV-2."
  • "There is no record of viruses closely related to SARS-CoV-2 in any laboratory before December 2019, ..."
  • The risk of accident culturing of SARS-CoV-2 is extremely low since there is no evidence of circulation among people globally before Decamber 2019.
  • "The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019...".
  • No reported "disruptions or incidents" during the Wuhan CDC lab move. "They also reported no storage nor laboratory activities on CoVs or other bat viruses preceding the outbreak"
Addressing that last bit:


Let's look at this list from the WHO source. The list is from the WHO report and supposedly is evidence against a lab accident.
Arguments against are
"The closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2 from bats and pangolin are evolutionarily distant from SARS-CoV-2."
That's actually evidence of the opposite.


"There is no record of viruses closely related to SARS-CoV-2 in any laboratory before December 2019, ..."
We don't know that. We do know China as not been forthcoming about the work being done in these labs in Wuhan.


The risk of accident culturing of SARS-CoV-2 is extremely low since there is no evidence of circulation among people globally before Decamber 2019.
This is evidence against a natural spillover event.


"The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019...".
First, there is evidence they weren't well managed but it's moot. There is evidence coronaviruses were being studied in level 2 and level 3 labs, not level 4.


No reported "disruptions or incidents" during the Wuhan CDC lab move. "They also reported no storage nor laboratory activities on CoVs or other bat viruses preceding the outbreak"
And it has proven to be false that no live cultures or live bats were being studied at the WIV.


Nice attempt to make it seem as if there is a equal paucity of evidence against the lab accident as there is against a natural spillover but it is a fail.


Simply asserting the WHO investigation was somehow definitive doesn't make it so. The team spent half their time in quarantine and China withheld requested information.
 
Last edited:
A lab accident is not an extraordinary explanation despite the attempt by Daszak and some people in this thread to make it one.

Occam's razor doesn't suggest one origin hypothesis over the other. People who claim a natural spillover is the favored explanation cherry pick and ignore the history of lab accidents.

The history of lab accidents is that they have never introduced a novel virus that caused a human pandemic. In spite of this nearly every pandemic or epidemic, we see theories about lab leaks and cover-ups.

For every pandemic our initial expectation is:
a) That it will almost certainly be naturally occurring mutation of zoonosis
b) Some people will claim it started in a lab.
 
That document is not about lab accidents. Rethinking Biosafety in Research on Potential Pandemic Pathogens looks more relevant to lab safety.
Not that this means much for the Wuhan labs because no evidence has been found in the investigations that that lab safety was not up to standards. The latest was WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part. Hopefully, there will be the follow up study that the investigators imply should be done and the WHO head explicitly stated should be done.
 
Last edited:
More than one citation on the history of lab accidents has been posted in this thread already.

As for hasn't led to a pandemic yet, that has also been addressed.
 
People who claim a natural spillover is the favored explanation cherry pick and ignore the history of lab accidents.
This is the history of lab accidents of BSL-3 and BSL-4 labs as in the WIV that you are ignoring, Skeptic Ginger.
List of laboratory biosecurity incidents
Incidents in BSL-3 and BSL4 labs infected individuals and monkeys over the last ~50 years (BSL standards were set in the 1970's). 2 SARS and 1 Ebola incidents infected 3 people. There were no outbreaks of SARS or Ebola from these incidents. An obvious reason is that safety does not stop in the actual lab. People working with pathogens would be tested often (daily? each time they exit BS 3 or 4L?) for infection by that pathogen.
The history of BSL-3 and BSL-4 incidents shows that outbreaks from the rare incidents will be even more rare.

Biosafety level
Biosafety level 3
Biosafety level 3 is appropriate for work involving microbes which can cause serious and potentially lethal disease via the inhalation route.[11] This type of work can be done in clinical, diagnostic, teaching, research, or production facilities.[12] Here, the precautions undertaken in BSL-1 and BSL-2 labs are followed, as well as additional measures including:

* All laboratory personnel are provided medical surveillance and offered relevant immunizations (where available) to reduce the risk of an accidental or unnoticed infection.[11]
Biosafety level 4 builds on BSL-3. My impression is that the baT coronavirus research was only done in the Wuhan BSL-4 lab.
Virologist Danielle Anderson was the last foreign visitor and "was impressed with the institute’s maximum biocontainment lab" since her first visit in 2018. She worked in the Wuhan BSL-4 lab. What makes a lab leak more unlikely is "no one she knew at the Wuhan institute was ill toward the end of 2019" and "“There was no chatter,” Anderson said. “Scientists are gossipy and excited. There was nothing strange from my point of view going on at that point that would make you think something is going on here.”" at a conference in Singapore in late December.
 
Last edited:
This is the history of lab accidents of BSL-3 and BSL-4 labs as in the WIV that you are ignoring, Skeptic Ginger.
List of laboratory biosecurity incidents
Incidents in BSL-3 and BSL4 labs infected individuals and monkeys over the last ~50 years (BSL standards were set in the 1970's). 2 SARS and 1 Ebola incidents infected 3 people. There were no outbreaks of SARS or Ebola from these incidents. An obvious reason is that safety does not stop in the actual lab. People working with pathogens would be tested often (daily? each time they exit BS 3 or 4L?) for infection by that pathogen.
The history of BSL-3 and BSL-4 incidents shows that outbreaks from the rare incidents will be even more rare.

Biosafety level

Biosafety level 4 builds on BSL-3. My impression is that the baT coronavirus research was only done in the Wuhan BSL-4 lab.
Virologist Danielle Anderson was the last foreign visitor and "was impressed with the institute’s maximum biocontainment lab" since her first visit in 2018. She worked in the Wuhan BSL-4 lab. What makes a lab leak more unlikely is "no one she knew at the Wuhan institute was ill toward the end of 2019" and "“There was no chatter,” Anderson said. “Scientists are gossipy and excited. There was nothing strange from my point of view going on at that point that would make you think something is going on here.”" at a conference in Singapore in late December.

Most coronavirus research was done at BSL-3. There was some research done at BSL-2 and some scientists such as Ian Lipkin have expressed concern about that.
 
More ignorance from Skeptic Ginger

...Addressing that last bit:
Skeptic Ginger persists with misunderstanding the Lancet open letter which rightfully condemned lab leak conspiracy theories, not the lab leak hypothesis.
Skeptic Ginger persists with irrelevant links. A timeline of the Wuhan lab-leak hypothesis saying nothing about the "manipulated the Lancet piece" nonsense.

This post has the following about the "Introduction through a laboratory incident" section in WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part.
  • "That's actually evidence of the opposite." ignorance.
    Being "evolutionarily distant" makes it harder for a lab to accidently mutate a virus into another. On the other hand, every infected bat is a 'laboratory' that can accidently mutate the virus.
  • Denies the fact of "There is no record of viruses closely related to SARS-CoV-2 in any laboratory before December 2019, ..." with her opinion of the Chinese government.
  • "This is evidence against a natural spillover event." ignorance.
    Any leak must have happened before the first known cases in December 2019. WIV workers would have been the first people infected. WIV workers travelled "globally", e.g. to a conference in Singapore. But "there is no evidence of circulation among people globally before December 2019.".
  • An unsupported "there is evidence they weren't well managed but it's moot." assertion.
    Any evidence of "not well managed " laboratories is relevant since safety is a part of lab management.
  • An unsupported and ignorant "There is evidence coronaviruses were being studied in level 2 and level 3 labs, not level 4." assertion.
    Coronaviruses were definitely being studied in the BSL-4 lab. Virologist Danielle Anderson worked in the Wuhan BSL-4 lab studying bat coronaviruses.
    A BSL-3 lab should the least level required to study coronaviruses since the tend to be airborne (SARS and COVID-19, not MERS).
    Actually read the WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part. study, Skeptic Ginger, and note that the only lab studying the bat coronavirus they mention is the CDC (BSL-4) one
    These are expert who know what was being worked on at the WIV and in what labs.
  • "And it has proven to be false that no live cultures or live bats were being studied at the WIV." nonsense.
    What she is replying to is the Wuhan CDC lab relocation!
    No reported "disruptions or incidents" during the Wuhan CDC lab move. "They also reported no storage nor laboratory activities on CoVs or other bat viruses preceding the outbreak"
    The Wuhan CDC lab move was without reported "disruptions or incidents". No CoVs or other bat viruses were stored at the Wuhan CDC lab before the outbreak.
 
Last edited:
An unsupported and ignorant "There is evidence coronaviruses were being studied in level 2 and level 3 labs, not level 4." assertion.
Coronaviruses were definitely being studied in the BSL-4 lab. Virologist Danielle Anderson worked in the Wuhan BSL-4 lab studying bat coronaviruses.
A BSL-3 lab should the least level required to study coronaviruses since the tend to be airborne (SARS and COVID-19, not MERS).

This part is not ignorant or unsupported. Basically, coronavirus research is done at BSL-3. This is stated in many papers by Shi et.al and repeated by her and others. It has been confirmed here on the forum by Capsid and also Amy Rosenfeld says so on TWiV.

This is not really in dispute.

There was other research done at BSL-2. As far as I can understand, this research was NOT with dangerous pathogens but it did arouse some raised eyebrows (to say the least) from some virologists such as Ian Lipkin (as I mentioned earlier) and Stuart Neil who is a virologist professor at King’s College London. Stuart Neil has been arguing for the high likelihood of spillover, so he is not someone trying to make up reasons for a lab leak. Ian Lipkin is of course one of the authors of Proximal Origins of Covid-19, so again as far from a lab leak theorist as you can get.
 
This part is not ignorant or unsupported. Basically, coronavirus research is done at BSL-3. This is stated in many papers by Shi et.al and repeated by her and others. It has been confirmed here on the forum by Capsid and also Amy Rosenfeld says so on TWiV.

This is not really in dispute.

There was other research done at BSL-2. As far as I can understand, this research was NOT with dangerous pathogens but it did arouse some raised eyebrows (to say the least) from some virologists such as Ian Lipkin (as I mentioned earlier) and Stuart Neil who is a virologist professor at King’s College London. Stuart Neil has been arguing for the high likelihood of spillover, so he is not someone trying to make up reasons for a lab leak. Ian Lipkin is of course one of the authors of Proximal Origins of Covid-19, so again as far from a lab leak theorist as you can get.
Thanks for the clarification angrysoba. The ignorance though was the "not level 4" part of her assertion when Danielle Anderson (an expert in bat-borne viruses) worked there on presumably on bat coronaviruses. ETA: And the quote she replied to says BSL3 or 4.
This does a question, why did the WHO study only mention concentrate on the CDC (BSL-4) lab as a possible lab leak? Reading the section again suggests it was the relocation or the research at BSL-4 (gain-of-function?). The other labs may not be doing appropriate work to be an origin.
The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019, and no serological evidence of infection in workers through SARS-CoV-2-specific serology-screening
 
Last edited:
List of laboratory biosecurity incidents
Incidents in BSL-3 and BSL4 labs infected individuals and monkeys over the last ~50 years (BSL standards were set in the 1970's). 2 SARS and 1 Ebola incidents infected 3 people.
A correction - these are the BSL levels that the Wikipedia article lists. There are other incidents that do not have the level but would reasonably be BSL-3 or BSL-4. For example
  • "Two researchers at the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention contracted the virus in Beijing, China around April 2004, and then spread the infection to around six other people. The two researchers contracted the virus in two incidents, two weeks apart.[31]"
  • "A researcher at Russian biological weapons research facility VECTOR died after accidentally pricking herself with a needle contaminated with the Ebola virus.[33]"
Looking at pathogens rather than BSL the incidents in BSL 3 or 4 for people look like 5 Ebola , 1 H5N1 influenza virus , 2 or 3 Marburg virus, 3 SARS, maybe 3 1970's Smallpox incidents, 1 West Nile virus, 1 Yersinia pestis and 1 Zika virus. Call it roughly a score of incidents in BSL 3 or 4 labs over the last 50 years.
 
So this is probably going to cause some commotion...

one of the members of the WHO investigation, Paul Embarek, was giving some information about their trip to China and how China did not want any possibility of a lab leak to be in the report. This actually doesn't sound that weird, and the WHO themselves pointed out that they had to address the question even if only to say it was unlikely. Embarek spitballed that one possible way in which the lab could be implicated is if a worker at the WIV got infected in the field:

COVID could have started when a Wuhan laboratory researcher was infected by a bat, according to World Health Organization official Peter Embarek.

Embarek, who led the WHO's COVID origins mission to China earlier this year, has told Danish news broadcaster TV2 that the bat infection scenario is a probable theory.

According to TV2, Embarek said, in comments translated from Danish: "An employee who was infected in the field by taking samples falls under one of the probable hypotheses."

However, he added that WHO experts could find no direct evidence to support the theory that the pandemic stemmed from Wuhan bat research.


The so-called lab leak theory of the origins of the COVID pandemic has been a controversial subject for several months and has caused tensions on the international stage.

In the WHO's initial report on the outbreak, the scenario was labelled "extremely unlikely."

However, Embarek told TV2 that while investigators were given access to laboratories in Wuhan, "we did not get to look at any documentation at all."

Link

I'd be interested to see the whole interview although I can imagine that much of what Embarek says is likely to be quote-mined or repackaged as:

"WHO INVESTIGATOR NOW SAYS COVID PROBABLY FROM A LAB!"
 
So this is probably going to cause some commotion...

one of the members of the WHO investigation, Paul Embarek, was giving some information about their trip to China and how China did not want any possibility of a lab leak to be in the report. This actually doesn't sound that weird, and the WHO themselves pointed out that they had to address the question even if only to say it was unlikely. Embarek spitballed that one possible way in which the lab could be implicated is if a worker at the WIV got infected in the field:
Excuse my ignorance, but I was wondering whether one or more of the lab workers got it "naturally" as well. Hadn't considered that they might have got sick while collecting samples.
 
Most coronavirus research was done at BSL-3. There was some research done at BSL-2 and some scientists such as Ian Lipkin have expressed concern about that.

Most work with coronaviruses involves sequencing RNA samples. This can be done quite safely because there are no live viruses involved. The main risk is going to be other organisms that can live in the places the samples were collected. Eg corona viruses can't live in bat faeces where most of these samples are taken but there are other potentially dangerous organisms that can.
 
Thanks for the clarification angrysoba. The ignorance though was the "not level 4" part of her assertion when Danielle Anderson (an expert in bat-borne viruses) worked there on presumably on bat coronaviruses. ETA: And the quote she replied to says BSL3 or 4.
This does a question, why did the WHO study only mention concentrate on the CDC (BSL-4) lab as a possible lab leak? Reading the section again suggests it was the relocation or the research at BSL-4 (gain-of-function?). The other labs may not be doing appropriate work to be an origin.

Mainly because the presence of the BSL-4 lab is the same city the pandemic started was the thing viewed to be suspicious in the first place. There was no other reason to start investigating labs in the first place.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom