Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, Nicholas Wade has another article out.

It seems to be about Andersen, Fauci, Farrar and Daszak, etc....

I haven't read it yet, but will try to do so in the next few days.

Link
 
No I didn't as a matter of fact. I meant section in this thread. And BTW, I don't see "section of the report" in my sentence at all. :rolleyes:

You replied to a quote from a report with a link to the report, and asked someone quoting from that report it if they missed "the section where..."

The reader is not at fault when your writing is unclear. I'm sorry if you feel attacked, but you do this quite a bit. The eyerolls, accusing others of "failing to understand" etc. Not helpful.
 
Last edited:
You replied to a quote from a report with a link to the report, and asked someone quoting from that report it if they missed "the section where..."

The reader is not at fault when your writing is unclear. I'm sorry if you feel attacked, but you do this quite a bit. The eyerolls, accusing others of "failing to understand" etc. Not helpful.

You can put words in my mouth until the cows come home. Obviously I wasn't talking about the WHO report when my specific comment was about the lack of cooperation by the Chinese not being addressed in the WHO report. :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Absolutely several of you failed to notice that in your haste to pretend SG isn't posting much of evidentiary value.

But the evidence is what it is, and it's piling up on the side of a lab accident origin. Whereas the evidence it was a natural spillover is looking weaker and weaker.


For example, the finding of 2 lineages early on hasn't panned out to be evidence of the pandemic starting elsewhere.

Frozen food, wildlife farms, trying to connect the earliest cases to "other unnamed wildlife markets", the pangolin as an intermediator species... none of that has panned out... none!

What else you (general you not carlitos you) got? So much time has been spent here trying to discredit sources and attack me personally it seems no one is paying attention to looking for actual evidence for a natural spillover. I imagine that is because no such evidence is being discovered.
 
You wrote
Did you miss the whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence?
After my post:
It is standard operating procedure to monitor the health of lab workers in labs and the field. That is part of the BSL standard for operating labs. That is basic commonsense for fieldwork. This might include taking spit and blood samples, possibly at the end of a field trip. Part of what made the transfer by WIV workers "extremely unlikely" was the lack of any SARS-CoV-2 antibodies found when they were tested after the pandemic started.
WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part
The context says that you were writing about the DOC study and its statement that the labs have a "staff health monitoring programme". Emphasized by this is a forum thread with no sections!
Thus my question:
Skeptic Ginger, give the pages of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence" in the WHO study.
You then asserted that this "section" is in this thread. So I asked:
Alternatively. Skeptic Ginger, give the posts of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence".
Everyone knows that China is currently not allowing access. It is the "refused" (past tense) and the "them" (the WHO study team) that are dubious.
 
Last edited:
Give it up. You're just proving my point that you are obsessed with trying to make me look bad.

I repeat, I'm not sure how you misunderstood my post when this was obvious:
Obviously I wasn't talking about the WHO report when my specific comment was about the lack of cooperation by the Chinese not being addressed in the WHO report.

You misunderstood, I explained what I meant. In most rational discussions that would have been the end of it.

Now either you want something like me saying oh gee, I can see why you misunderstood (I can't but if that makes you happy go for it); or you think I really was referring to something in the report itself noting the WHO acknowledged in their very politically correct report that the Chinese weren't cooperating (in which case see my quote above from an earlier post because that is just stupid).

Moving on, as I said several times now, the fact the Chinese did not cooperate, still are not cooperating, and it has been mentioned in article after article since the first WHO report should be the end of this nonsensical sidetrack.
 
So I saw today that Vincent Racaniello went on Lex Fridman's podcast and may end up going on Joe Rogan's podcast later. I think it would be interesting to see them hash out the arguments of the pro-lab leakers vs the spilloverers.

Of course, such arguments don't further the science but it is possible that some clarifications might come from these discussions.

Possibly...
 
Still avoiding answering a simple question

Still avoiding answering a simple question: Alternatively. Skeptic Ginger, give the posts of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence".
Who stated that China refuse to less the WHO team access to any "actual" evidence for health monitoring at the Wuhan labs?
Link to the posts(s) with the requests from the WHO team for this evidence.
For that matter: Why would the WHO team need or ask for this evidence from "China"? They would talk to the lab workers. They would talks to pervious visitors to the labs. Team members had visited or worked at the labs and probably had their health monitored. The team would know that health monitoring is standard at BSL-4 and BSL-3 labs: WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part
The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019, and no serological evidence of infection in workers through SARS-CoV-2-specific serology-screening
However there is a 2016 paper (Bat Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome-Like Coronavirus WIV1 Encodes an Extra Accessory Protein, ORFX, Involved in Modulation of the Host Immune Response) with "All experiments using live virus was conducted under biosafety level 2 (BSL2) conditions.". This does not mean that 3 years later BSL-2 labs were working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development.
 
Last edited:
This is a follow up to the Danish interview with Embarek.

And BTW, let me save some people the trouble: To dismiss the facts which are easily corroborated elsewhere like in the Danish documentary, :rolleyes: just say AIDS Healthcare Foundation and BusinessWireIndia are not reliable sources. Then people needn't so much as ruffle a feather about it.

China Tried to Bury the COVID-19 Lab Leak Hypothesis – The World Deserves to Know Why, Says AHF
A recent interview with the chief of an international mission which investigated the origins of COVID-19 in Wuhan earlier this year has revealed the team was under intense pressure from Chinese authorities to downplay the possibility of the virus escaping from a local lab. In light of these developments, AIDS Healthcare Foundation (AHF), the world’s largest HIV/AIDS care provider globally, calls on the international community to continue demanding transparency from China, including full access to raw clinical data and independent interviews with whistleblowers and early COVID-19 patients, with guarantees that they will not face retaliation for speaking up.
As in the WHO team did not have access to the raw clinical data, only the Chinese summary of the findings.

According to The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post, the World Health Organization (WHO) expert leading the mission, Dr. Peter Ben Embarek told Danish documentary film makers that initially Chinese counterparts refused to include any mention of the lab leak hypothesis in the investigative report. Eventually they relented, but only on the condition that the hypothesis be described as very unlikely. The latest revelation marks a dramatic departure from WHO’s prior reluctance to openly criticize China or acknowledge that the investigation was not sufficiently independent to yield credible results.

“Embarek has said before that politics was always in the room during discussions about the investigative report. In fact, by some accounts, the international scientists on the team were outnumbered by up to 60 Chinese scientists and public health figures – it certainly appears China had a stake in molding the report to its purposes by de-emphasizing the possibility of a lab accident,” said Dr. Jorge Saavedra, Executive Director of the AHF Global Public Health Institute at the University of Miami. “What those purposes are is unknown, but the more China resists calls for transparency on the origins of COVID-19, the more people everywhere will wonder if something went wrong, perhaps there was an accident, or a human error of some kind. Whatever may have caused or contributed to the emergence of COVID-19 ...
 
Still avoiding answering a simple question

Still avoiding answering a simple question: 18 August 2021: Alternatively. Skeptic Ginger, give the posts of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence".
Who stated that China refuse to less the WHO team access to any "actual" evidence for health monitoring at the Wuhan labs?
Link to the posts(s) with the requests from the WHO team for this evidence.
For that matter: Why would the WHO team need or ask for this evidence from "China"? They would talk to the lab workers. They would talks to pervious visitors to the labs. Team members had visited or worked at the labs and probably had their health monitored. The team would know that health monitoring is standard at BSL-4 and BSL-3 labs.
 
Still ignoring the gazillion posts and citations with the answer I see. And you continue to be obsessed with my posts for some reason.

Perhaps you should investigate getting help for that.
 
China Tried to Bury the COVID-19 Lab Leak Hypothesis – The World Deserves to Know Why, Says AHFAs in the WHO team did not have access to the raw clinical data, only the Chinese summary of the findings.
As in the WHO team who were not given access to raw patient data probably due to privacy concerns. Patient confidentiality is standard medical ethics for doctors. So they were given summaries. To be more exact:
BEIJING—Chinese authorities refused to provide World Health Organization investigators with raw, personalized data on early Covid-19 cases that could help them determine how and when the coronavirus first began to spread in China, according to WHO investigators who described heated exchanges over the lack of detail.

The Chinese authorities turned down requests to provide such data on 174 cases of Covid-19 that they have identified from the early phase of the outbreak in the Chinese city of Wuhan in December 2019. The investigators are part of a WHO team that this week completed a monthlong mission in China aimed at determining the origins of the pandemic.

Chinese officials and scientists provided their own extensive summaries and analysis of data on the cases, said the WHO team members. They also supplied aggregated data and analysis on retrospective searches through medical records in the months before the Wuhan outbreak was identified, saying that they had found no evidence of the virus.
(my highlight).
That the WHO team was not supplied raw, anonymized data as typically suppled to investigators is the issue.

What Dr. Peter Ben Embarek said was
According to The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post, the World Health Organization (WHO) expert leading the mission, Dr. Peter Ben Embarek told Danish documentary film makers that initially Chinese counterparts refused to include any mention of the lab leak hypothesis in the investigative report. Eventually they relented, but only on the condition that the hypothesis be described as very unlikely.
That is a reasonable response and reply from people who know about the level of safety in the Wuhan labs.
 
Last edited:
....
That is a reasonable response and reply from people who know about the level of safety in the Wuhan labs.
It's not reasonable when it is a demonstrated lie.

There are numerous citations in this thread reflecting on the safety problems in the Chinese labs.

Capsid dismissed one such record claiming all it meant was some boxes were lying around. But that was not the only report of unsafe practices at the WIV. And we don't have much information at all on the safety of the CCDC lab in Wuhan. In addition, I don't recall much information on the safety at the level 2 & 3 labs in the WIV or the precautions taken when the CCDC changed locations.

Politico: In 2018, Diplomats Warned of Risky Coronavirus Experiments in a Wuhan Lab. No One Listened.
Its research on bat viruses had already drawn the attention of U.S. diplomats and officials at the Beijing Embassy in late 2017, prompting them to alert Washington that the lab’s own scientists had reported “a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory.”...

... The researchers boasted that they may have found the cave where the original SARS coronavirus originated. But all the U.S. diplomats cared about was that these scientists had discovered three new viruses that had a unique characteristic: they contained a "spike protein” that was particularly good at grabbing on to a specific receptor in human lung cells known as an ACE2 receptor. That means the viruses were potentially very dangerous for humans—and that these viruses were now in a lab with which they, the U.S. diplomats, were largely unfamiliar. ...

... But many of the scientists who spoke out to defend the lab were Shi’s research partners and funders, like the head of the global public health nonprofit EcoHealth Alliance, Peter Daszak; their research was tied to hers, and if the Wuhan lab were implicated in the pandemic, they would have to answer a lot of tough questions. ...


And there's this: A Beijing laboratory director was infected with Covid-19 in a lab accident in early 2020, explosive emails have revealed, showing an inadvertent leak of the highly contagious coronavirus is far ... Sorry, behind a paywall but the following is about the same incident:

I posted this upthread: Senior Chinese scientist acquired SARS-CoV-2 in lab infection accident, virologist says


And there's this from 2004: SARS escaped Beijing lab twice


So you can believe all you want these labs are perfectly safe, but clearly they are not.
 
It's not reasonable when it is a demonstrated lie.

There are numerous citations in this thread reflecting on the safety problems in the Chinese labs.

Capsid dismissed one such record claiming all it meant was some boxes were lying around. But that was not the only report of unsafe practices at the WIV. And we don't have much information at all on the safety of the CCDC lab in Wuhan. In addition, I don't recall much information on the safety at the level 2 & 3 labs in the WIV or the precautions taken when the CCDC changed locations.

Politico: In 2018, Diplomats Warned of Risky Coronavirus Experiments in a Wuhan Lab. No One Listened.


And there's this: A Beijing laboratory director was infected with Covid-19 in a lab accident in early 2020, explosive emails have revealed, showing an inadvertent leak of the highly contagious coronavirus is far ... Sorry, behind a paywall but the following is about the same incident:

I posted this upthread: Senior Chinese scientist acquired SARS-CoV-2 in lab infection accident, virologist says


And there's this from 2004: SARS escaped Beijing lab twice


So you can believe all you want these labs are perfectly safe, but clearly they are not.

The hyperbolic statement you hilited is not something that has been claimed in this thread.
 
Cites probably fake news again

It's not reasonable when it is a demonstrated lie....
The truth was Chinese counterparts to the WHO team initially did not want a lab incident listed in the study and changed their minds to list it as very unlikely. The WHO team wrote
The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019, and no serological evidence of infection in workers through SARS-CoV-2-specific serology-screening.
Their Chinese counterparts would know the same. It is a reasonable reaction to initially not want a lab incident origin in the study.

Opinions of "a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory.” in late 2017 as stated in a politics article extracted from a book does not make the labs unsafe in 2017 and especially not in 2019. Other scientists disagreed when this political reporter wrote a news report.
Large parts of the scientific community also decried my report, pointing to the fact that natural spillovers have been the cause of other viral outbreaks, and that they were the culprit more often than accidents. But many of the scientists who spoke out to defend the lab were Shi’s research partners and funders, like the head of the global public health nonprofit EcoHealth Alliance, Peter Daszak; their research was tied to hers, and if the Wuhan lab were implicated in the pandemic, they would have to answer a lot of tough questions.
That of course included Shi’s research partners because Shi and her fellow researchers used the labs.

You still do not understand that credible news comes from credible sources.
18 August 2021: If credible news sources have ignored a news article for almost 2 weeks (since 5 August), it is probably fake news.
You linked to one of the couple of other newspapers who parroted what the USRTK wrote apparently without doing any checking. There are questions that a skeptic would ask.
  • Has anyone checked with the email author?
  • Has any Beijing laboratory director been reported independently as involved in a lab incident and infected with SARS-2?
  • Why are major news agencies ignoring this big story?
  • Why is Beijing not spelt "Wuhan" :p?
No one here has written that labs are perfectly safe. Everyone knows about the lab incidents. I gave you a list (List of laboratory biosecurity incidents) that incudes that SARS incident in 2004. 2 researchers were infected at the Chinese Institute of Virology in Beijing, presumably in separate incidents given the time between they were hospitalized.

This is implied evidence against lax safety at the Wuhan labs. When incidents happen, generally steps are taken to to prevent them happening again. A probable step was creating the first Chinese BSL-4 lab in Wuhan.
 
Last edited:
Are you actually claiming the Chinese have been transparent in the investigation and virology labs in China have meticulous safety records?

Good gawd what planet do you live on?
 
Are you actually claiming the Chinese have been transparent in the investigation and virology labs in China have meticulous safety records?

Good gawd what planet do you live on?


The problem is that we will never know if the Chinese are being honest or not. They have a system that punishes openness, and that throws doubt at anything they say.

They might not have anything to hide, but we’ll never know.
 
The problem is that we will never know if the Chinese are being honest or not. They have a system that punishes openness, and that throws doubt at anything they say.

They might not have anything to hide, but we’ll never know.

I'm pretty sure they are not being honest. One need only look at some history we do know about. For example the ophthalmologist (he worked in a hospital, BTW, I hadn't known that at first) who saw an inexplicable rash of pneumonia cases and tried to talk about it was silenced. Later when he died of COVID, IIRC, the government might have apologized. Bottom line, we know the government tried to silence him.

That's only one example of many. I saw an interesting assortment of government responses to SARS. The central government advised other administrators to record and discuss cases. But some local governments like the head administrator of Beijing tried to hide the cases. It's been a while but again IIRC they moved people around so people with SARS weren't in a particular hospital. Now in that case the central government chastised the Beijing government for trying to hide the cases. Beijing was trying to save face by not admitting there was a problem. In that situation however, it was known that SARS was a natural spillover event so the circumstances were quite different.

Think about it, if this was a lab accident the central Chinese government would have every reason to hide that from the world. Talk about saving face!

Put that together with how the Chinese limited the WHO's assessment of the situation and it's pretty clear suppressing information was no accident. If they had nothing to hide and the evidence would have gone further to establish the event was spillover, they aren't stupid. They would want to be completely transparent.

There's a very slight chance they didn't trust the WHO team to represent the WIV and other labs honestly. But that also makes no sense given they had Shi and Daszak to assure the evidence was treated fairly or at least steered the evidence away from a lab accident.

I do think at some point we will know. Keep in mind there has still not been found any animal source for this spillover event. With SARS it was clear within a couple of months that the outbreak was due to a natural exposure at more than one wet market. And it wasn't a nebulous claim, "well we don't have the evidence but we are going to say it was more than one market." Nope, they identified (I think) 5 different spillover events in Guangdong. Those were clearly documented within a matter of months.
 
Last edited:
No comments about the documentary on the lab leak hypothesis broadcast on Channel 4 on Sunday?

https://www.channel4.com/programmes/did-covid-leak-from-a-lab-in-china

ETA: I don't think it can be watched outside the UK.
It's not the Danish documentary, is it?

Can't see it without logging in but here is a news report on the documentary:

Wuhan ‘lab leak’: Explosive Channel 4 documentary provides compelling evidence supporting Covid origin theory

The missing natural source and the "ready to go" problem for spillover believers:
Early in the pandemic, scientists argued there must have been an intermediate species to provide a bridge from bats to humans, but that species has not been identified more than 18 months on....

Using computer modelling to try to identify an intermediate species, Professor Petrovsky discovered that the species Sars-Cov2 bound to the most was humans.

Because the virus could not have originated in humans, the modelling pointed to the humanised mice, or lab-grown human cells.

Professor Petrovsky says: “Just the tiniest single viral particle in the air is enough to infect the first human and then rapidly transmit, because now it doesn’t need to adapt.

You have the perfect human virus already at the time you have the very first case. That would explain this rapid transmission, the lack of need of the virus to adapt… And that is that is simply not normal of any pandemic virus that we’ve seen before.”
They do say the lab source has also not been found leading to equal weight to both or origin hypotheses. But that's only if you don't look at the other cumulative evidence.

All this has been brought up and source-cited in this thread.:thumbsup: I hope the documentary is available on other media sometime soon. The news article doesn't cover a lot of what I would guess is in the video.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom