Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Right, nothing to do with you repeating the rosy picture for which pretty much everyone else knows it is a lie.
 
No. I am suggesting that as lab workers working in the wild with bats known to carry coronavirus, their health would be monitored and they would report any incidents such a bite from a bat or protective gear failure. The monitoring would pick up symptomatic infection. The monitoring might include regular samples that would be tested after the outbreak was known.
As you say, the monitoring would pick up on symptomatic infection, not on asymptomatic infection - the most common sort. And the regular samples that were taken would be subject to the problem that probably nobody who care about their own, or their lab’s future would publish any positive findings.
 
That is correct. The lab close to the market is the Wuhan CDC lab which also collected bat samples. Its relocation was an argument for a laboratory incident in the March 2021 WHO study (the other was just that lab accidents happen). The argument against this is that the CDC lab reported no issue with the move and "reported no storage nor laboratory activities on CoVs or other bat viruses preceding the outbreak".



First it was the BSL-4 lab so we needed to investigate the WiV because they study Corona viruses there.

The BSL-4 lab was too far away from the epicenter so it was the WiV work in BSL-2 and BSL-3 labs (which exist in nearly every large city, so much for it being "to much of a coincidence")

But the WiV is still in the wrong place but there is another lab that is closer.

Expect this lab isn't used by the WiV it's used by the CCDC, so now after a year of accusations and calls to investigate the WiV and the BSL-4 they are off the table and now we need to investigate the CCDC and a completely different lab

It's just a continuous cycle of searching for some new thing that hasn't been debunked yet, and you can bet that it will go full circle and it'll be back to calls for more investigation of the BSL-4 lab within a few days.
 
Last edited:
Right, nothing to do with you repeating the rosy picture for which pretty much everyone else knows it is a lie.
Nothing to do with my posts on the source of SARS-CoV-2. What I have written is that the evidence is
  • The most probable source of the virus is animals with bats as the leading candidate.
  • The least likely source is a lab leak (I disagree with the WHO study's use of "extremely unlikely").
This is the scientific consensus on the SARS-CoV-2 origin.
 
Last edited:
Please give the pages of the section on China's refusal to supply actual evidence

Skeptic Ginger, give the pages of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence" in the WHO study.
WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part

Note that your "this was so" is that the WIV had a staff health monitoring programme. Evidence would include staff stating they were in a health monitoring programme. What China did in July 2021 is refuse to allow a follow-up WHO study: China rejects WHO plan for study of COVID-19 origin

ETA: An answer could be that you made a mistake and the study does not have this section.
 
Last edited:
Nothing to do with my posts on the source of SARS-CoV-2. What I have written is that the evidence is
  • The most probable source of the virus is animals with bats as the leading candidate.
  • The least likely source is a lab leak (I disagree with the WHO study's use of "extremely unlikely").
This is the scientific consensus on the SARS-CoV-2 origin.

Bats are by far the most common species for this type of viruses, but there are viruses that infect other animals (Pangolins) that are quite closely related.

While bat to human can't be ruled out the RBD doesn't appear to bind well to the bats that carry most of the related viruses. Something like a Mink or a Pangolin that has more "human like" ACE2 may be a better candidate. On the other hand very similar genetic sequences do show up in corona viruses than infect bats, but these may not be binding to ACE2.

There is at least 1 cross species jump involved here, possibly more and one or more recombination event as well. For example it could be possible that there was an ancestral viruses that infected something with human like ACE2 that either underwent recombination and\or jumped back to bats and the cases where we see similar RBD RNA are actually in the process of loosing sequences they don't need anymore. It's also possible that the viruses has been evolving towards this particular RBD in an intermediate species. It may even be possible both are happening at once.

IOW we see signs of evolution, but we don't have enough samples to know map out how that evolution is playing out.
 
Skeptic Ginger, give the pages of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence" in the WHO study.
WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part

Note that your "this was so" is that the WIV had a staff health monitoring programme. Evidence would include staff stating they were in a health monitoring programme. What China did in July 2021 is refuse to allow a follow-up WHO study: China rejects WHO plan for study of COVID-19 origin
You expect them to have spelled that out in the report? Are you seriously that naive?

It's pretty clear you aren't keeping up in the thread. It's also clear you aren't reading much at all about what's going on. No it was not just a refusal to allow an additional investigation by the WHO team.

BBC: Covid-19 pandemic: China 'refused to give data' to WHO team
 
You expect them to have spelled that out in the report? Are you seriously that naive?

So you didn't mean "section of the REPORT" when you typed this?

....
Did you miss the whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence?

If not, section of what?
 
So you didn't mean "section of the REPORT" when you typed this?

If not, section of what?
No I didn't as a matter of fact. I meant section in this thread. And BTW, I don't see "section of the report" in my sentence at all. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Or Please give the posts for the section on China's refusal to supply actual evidence

You expect them to have spelled that out in the report? Are you seriously that naive?...
That is what you wrote in response to my post about the WHO study. The quotes are from your post. Actually answer the question instead of linking to an irrelevant news report.
Skeptic Ginger, give the pages of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence" in the WHO study.

ETA: Alternatively. Skeptic Ginger, give the posts of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence" in the WHO study.
Note that your "this was so" is that the WIV had a staff health monitoring programme.

The 14 February BBC news report is microbiologist Dominic Dwyer complaining about actual evidence (patient data) being a summary, not raw data. "The investigators had asked for raw data on the 174 identified cases of Covid-19 from Wuhan in December 2019, Professor Dwyer told Reuters.". There would be an issue of patient confidentiality. On the other hand, this is a pandemic.
 
Last edited:
First it was the BSL-4 lab so we needed to investigate the WiV because they study Corona viruses there.

The BSL-4 lab was too far away from the epicenter so it was the WiV work in BSL-2 and BSL-3 labs (which exist in nearly every large city, so much for it being "to much of a coincidence")

But the WiV is still in the wrong place but there is another lab that is closer.

Expect this lab isn't used by the WiV it's used by the CCDC, so now after a year of accusations and calls to investigate the WiV and the BSL-4 they are off the table and now we need to investigate the CCDC and a completely different lab

It's just a continuous cycle of searching for some new thing that hasn't been debunked yet, and you can bet that it will go full circle and it'll be back to calls for more investigation of the BSL-4 lab within a few days.

Well, if that’s not enough, Yuri Deigin on Twitter has been making a lot of fuss about some of the early Italian cases by looking at labs there that study coronaviruses and noticing that some Chinese names are on papers for-authored by scientists who do work in those labs.

This is “gotta have a lab leak” thinking.
 
I can't help it if you misread my post and then refused to acknowledge the clarification I made when asked.

I don't see "section of the report" in my sentence at all.

But this is what a number of you have been doing in most of this thread, finding little ways to worm out of looking at the actual facts.

And as a clear example, you ignore the fact China's refusal to provide access to their raw data has been the topic of report after report in the news and in the scientific literature for more than a year.
 
Last edited:
As for early cases in Italy, there is not clear evidence any of those early cases predate the Wuhan cases. Nor is there evidence the earliest US cases or cases in any other country predate the Wuhan cases.

What they do do, however, is provide more evidence the cases in Wuhan may very well have started in Sept 2019 or earlier.

As a reminder re early cases in the A lineage because I noticed those A lineage strains were claimed to have been evidence of early cases originating in Guangdong:

From Bloom's paper

I noted another salient fact: four GISAID sequences collected in Guangdong that fall in a putative progenitor node are from two different clusters of patients who traveled to Wuhan in late December of 2019 and developed symptoms before or on the day that they returned to Guangdong, where their viruses were ultimately sequenced (Chan et al. 2020; Kang et al. 2020b). Since these patients were clearly infected in Wuhan even though they were sequenced in Guangdong, I annotated them separately from both the other Wuhan and other China sequences.
 
Jesse D. Bloom's preprint is not "evidence of early cases originating in Guangdong"

Jesse D. Bloom's preprint is not "evidence of early cases originating in Guangdong".
Recovery of deleted deep sequencing data sheds more light on the early Wuhan SARS-CoV-2 epidemic
I noted another salient fact: four GISAID sequences collected in Guangdong that fall in a putative progenitor node are from two different clusters of patients who traveled to Wuhan in late December of 2019 and developed symptoms before or on the day that they returned to Guangdong, where their viruses were ultimately sequenced (Chan et al. 2020; Kang et al. 2020b). Since these patients were clearly infected in Wuhan even though they were sequenced in Guangdong, I annotated them separately from both the other Wuhan and other China sequences.
You highlighted that patients were clearly infected in Wuhan.
What happened in Guangdong was collection of samples from patients who traveled to Wuhan in late December of 2019. That would be weeks after the first known cases in Wuhan. These samples were sequenced in Guangdong. The author states that Guangdong patients were infected in Wuhan several times ("Wuhan-infected patients hospitalized in Guangdong", etc.).

ETA: There are references in that quote.
A familial cluster of pneumonia associated with the 2019 novel coronavirus indicating person-to-person transmission: a study of a family cluster
From Jan 10, 2020, we enrolled a family of six patients who travelled to Wuhan from Shenzhen between Dec 29, 2019 and Jan 4, 2020.
Evidence and characteristics of human-to-human transmission of sars-cov-2 is a February 17, 2020 preprint. Family cluster A looks like the same family cluster (5 cases, "stayed in Wuhan during December 29, 2019 to January 4, 2020"). Figure 1 ("Spatio-temporal distribution of cases in Guangdong Province, China, by February 10, 2020" ) starts on 1 January 2020. Figure 2 has the first Guangdong Province cluster on 16 January 2020 (a family cluster).
 
Last edited:
Let's see, not a right wing source, not the GOP report, is a respected scientist with a strong reputation for competent genome analysis, well written paper ...

Clearly you don't give a **** what the evidence is. Not my problem.

BTW, what was that evidence for a natural spillover event again? Oh that's right, there isn't any.



I was going back over the Dec 2018 paper by Shi on the origin of SARS and I thought this bit was worth mentioning again.

Origin and evolution of pathogenic coronaviruses

I wanted to point this part out as it contrasts with the emergence of SARS CoV2:
At the beginning of the SARS epidemic, almost all early index patients had animal exposure before developing disease. After the causative agent of SARS was identified, SARS-CoV and/or anti-SARS-CoV antibodies were found in masked palm civets (Paguma larvata) and animal handlers in a market place12,16,39–42. However, later, wide-reaching investigations of farmed and wild-caught civets revealed that the SARS-CoV strains found in market civets were transmitted to them by other animals16,39. In 2005, two teams independently reported the discovery of novel coronaviruses related to human SARS-CoV, which were named SARS-CoV-related viruses or SARS-like coronaviruses, in horseshoe bats (genus Rhinolophus)15,43. ...

A 5-year longitudinal study revealed the coexistence of highly diverse SARSr-CoVs in bat populations in one cave of Yunnan province, China18,20,55.
The cave the WIV was heavily involved in studying bats from.

it is highly likely that SARS-CoV newly emerged through recombination of bat SARSr-CoVs in this or other yet-to-be-identified bat caves. This hypothesis is consistent with previous data showing that a direct progenitor of SARS-CoV emerged before 2002 (refs42,57,58). Recombination analysis also strongly supported the hypothesis that the civet SARS-CoV strain SZ3 arose through recombination of two existing bat strains, WIV16 and Rf4092 (ref.20). Furthermore, WIV16, the closest relative to SARS-CoV found in bats, likely arose through recombination of two other prevalent bat SARSr-CoV strains20. ...

Because there were no SARS cases in Yunnan province during the SARS outbreak, we hypothesize that the direct progenitor of SARS-CoV was produced by recombination within bats and then transmitted to farmed civets or another mammal, which then transmitted the virus to civets by faecal–oral transmission. When the virus-infected civets were transported to Guangdong market, the virus spread in market civets and acquired further mutations before spillover to humans.

And the critical bit of evidence is the reconstructed sequence of events it took for the "spillover event" to be successful:
On the basis of SARS spread, the SARS 2002–2003 outbreak could be divided into three phases, with the early phase characterized by a limited number of localized cases, followed by a middle phase during which a superspreader event occurred in a hospital and finally the late phase of international spread62. The viral genomes from early-phase patients contain two genotypes of orf8, one with a complete orf8 (369 nucleotides) and the other containing an 82-nucleotide deletion. By contrast, viral genomes from late-phase patients and most of the genomes from middle-phase patients contain a split orf8 (orf8a and orf8b) owing to a 29-nucleotide deletion; two exceptions were found in middle-phase genomes, one containing an 82-nucleotide deletion in orf8 and the other with the whole orf8 deleted. The human isolates from 2004 and all civet SARS-CoV genomes have a complete orf8 except one civet strain with an 82-nucleotide deletion62. These data indicate that orf8 genes underwent adaptations during transmission from animals to humans during the SARS epidemic.

Where is the evidence of this sequence of adaptation events in SARS CoV2? Could it be there isn't any because this adaptation took place in a lab? Why yes, yes it could be that.


And once again, in reference to potential lab accidents, I believe I posted this recently: Senior Chinese scientist acquired SARS-CoV-2 in lab infection accident, virologist says

That would be virologists in an email exchange acquired through a FOIA request.
 
A "Oh that's right, there isn't any." lie

Let's see, ..
A post ignoring her latest error in many errors over the last week.
18:August 2021: Jesse D. Bloom's preprint is not "evidence of early cases originating in Guangdong" because these are not that early (mid-January 2020) patients who were originally infected in Wuhan
That SARS-CoV-2 spread from Wuhan to the rest of China and the entire world is not news.
She even misses that Recovery of deleted deep sequencing data sheds more light on the early Wuhan SARS-CoV-2 epidemic is not a paper. It is a not peer reviewed preprint in bioRxiv
bioRxiv posts many COVID19-related papers. A reminder: they have not been formally peer-reviewed and should not guide health-related behavior or be reported in the press as conclusive.
Jesse D. Bloom has an impressive publishing history so the preprint should be correct and be published.

13 August 2021: Cites a news report hyping well known epidemiology that the number of people with antibodies to a virus is always larger than the number of people who report infections.
13 August 2021: A so far "speculations about cases in September 2019" source in this thread fantasy
13 August 2021: Skeptic Ginger quote mines the earliest value from Table 8 of WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part
12 August 2021: Ignorance about the "Introduction through a laboratory incident" section in WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part.
11 August 2021: An outstanding "Cite where Metzl "addressed Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis", Skeptic Ginger."? question.
11 August 2021: Cites an obviously dubious paper to people who read it.
11 August 2021: Skeptic Ginger persists with misunderstanding the Lancet open letter which rightfully condemned lab leak conspiracy theories, not the lab leak hypothesis.
11 August 2021: Skeptic Ginger repeats the error pf citing Jamie Metzl's biased blog (a non-biologist lying about no evidence for an animal origin)
11 August 2021: Previous "evidence" from Skeptic Ginger.

18 August 2021: A "What was that evidence for a natural spillover event again? Oh that's right, there isn't any." lie.
WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part lists the evidence for both the probable natural spillover event and the less likely lab incident scenarios.
 
Last edited:
And once again, in reference to potential lab accidents, I believe I posted this recently: Senior Chinese scientist acquired SARS-CoV-2 in lab infection accident, virologist says
And what does a just as credible news sources say?
Source refutes Aussie journalist’s rumor that researcher at Beijing lab infected with coronavirus at work
Neither source is reliable. Apply some common sense. If credible news sources have ignored a news article for almost 2 weeks (since 5 August), it is probably fake news. It looks like only the Australian and The Defender repeated the rumor. One things that real journalists so is check their information. A real news story would have comments from Shan-Lu Liu, Lishan Su and that former director. No one even bothers to find the name of that director and what happened to them :eek:!
The former director infected email is in a USRTK pdf.
F om u Shan- u
To h h
Subje t Re Eme g ng M c bes & Infect ons - TEMI-20 0-0121 - changes qui ed o ou subm s ion
Date iday eb ua y 4 2020 6 13 2 M
I just finished reading Feng’s paper – indeed ery good.
Small e ror noted in he f rst paragraph “Know ng he origin of such a pa hogen is critical to de elop ng means to blocking further transm ssion and to de elop accines”. I saw this kind of error frequent for asian people but no big deal.
Feng Gao s my 师兄 in 北京的病毒所 we we e from the same lab where my former director has now been infec ed by SARS CoV 2! Ve y sad but he s doing OK!
Shan-Lu
Followed by "Your former colleague was infected with sars2 in the lab?" question from Lishan Su and a "Yes, he was infected in the lab!" email from Shan-Lu Liu. That is an unsupported assertion that no credible news agency would print by itself.
"Feng Gao s my 师兄 in 北京的病毒所" means "Feng Gao s my brother in Beijing Virus Institute".
The NIVDC is the National Institute for Viral Disease Control and Prevention and does not do research. The Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention (China CDC) monitors diseases. George F. Gao is its Director-General and may be this Feng Gao.
 
Last edited:
"She even misses" good gawd are you going to keep obsessing over my posts instead of the evidence?

My citations support what I've posted. Full stop.
 
"She even misses" ...
Your many errors about science are relevant in a Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology section. Preprints are not peer-reviewed science as everyone knows. I did look at the preprint.
18:August 2021: Jesse D. Bloom's preprint is not "evidence of early cases originating in Guangdong" because these are not that early (mid-January 2020) patients who were originally infected in Wuhan
These cases did not originate in Guangdong. These cases were detected in Guangdong.
 
Last edited:
Origin and evolution of pathogenic coronaviruses
Where is the evidence of this sequence of adaptation events in SARS CoV2? Could it be there isn't any because this adaptation took place in a lab? Why yes, yes it could be that.
That is not how labs working with bat coronaviruses would do research. They do not house bats and hope for recombination events such as those that created SARS-1 :p!
It took 15 years for the Wuhan Institute of Virology to find the evidence that gave the route of SARS-1 from bats to humans. Not having definitive evidence for SAR-2's route from animals after less than 3 years is no surprise, especially during a pandemic with its lockdowns.
Severe acute respiratory syndrome
Severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) is a viral respiratory disease of zoonotic origin caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus (SARS-CoV or SARS-CoV-1), the first identified strain of the SARS coronavirus species severe acute respiratory syndrome–related coronavirus (SARSr-CoV). The syndrome caused the 2002–2004 SARS outbreak. Around late 2017, Chinese scientists traced the virus through the intermediary of Asian palm civets to cave-dwelling horseshoe bats in Xiyang Yi Ethnic Township, Yunnan.[3]
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom