Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, so I don't understand any of the science here, but it seems that one of the questions to do with the origins is at what stage lineage A and lineage B of SARS-CoV2 diverged.

Well, a group of scientists including Michael Worobey, suggest that maybe they did not and that they therefore represent different points of emergence.

Link

This might bolster the multiple spillover theory.

Michael Worobey, on this Twitter thread, discusses a dispute he is having with one of the DRASTIC members about whether he is doing the science right. As Worobey says, it is pretty technical, and I have no idea how to say who is right and who is wrong in this.

The bottom line seems to be that there has been more than one introduction of SARS-CoV2 into humans, which would support the idea of multiple spillovers rather than, say, a single lab accident.

Two possible counter-arguments are that:
1.) The two lineages diverge from each other, and we have evidence of that which Worobey is throwing out (I think that is Daoyu's position)

and

2.) The two lineages diverge from each other even if we currently don't have evidence of it, and the divergence is simply lost somewhere.

As I say, I have no idea.

Maybe Capsid or SG want to chime in here... :blush:
I had to take those ******* quote marks out of your link to make it work. It would be nice if you would test links before hitting reply.

https://news.arizona.edu/story/nove...-undetected-months-first-covid-19-cases-wuhan

I posted about that already. I referred to it as sputtering. It's an hypothesis but I didn't see any evidence that supported it. I'll look again.

I do think the two lineages has to put the origin back before Oct explaining the removal of access to the WIV work on Sept 19, 2019.
 
Last edited:
So I have a couple of issues here re the Twitter entries.

One)
If a human-transmissible SARS-CoV-2 progenitor was circulating among such animals, the SARS1 story teaches us that it would be likely to jump multiple times into humans.
And yet, not only is there no direct evidence of a jump from any species to humans one time, there clearly isn't evidence of 2 separate jumps, both tied to Wuhan in some way or even not tied to Wuhan directly.

And the second issue is the WA State case was not the first case in the US after all. Six earlier cases in 5 different states have been found.

In addition, while contact tracing of the first WA case to the Seattle case detected in a flu study to the outbreak at the Life Care Center in Kirkland WA wasn't feasible by the time they were all detected, there was no reason to think they were not connected cases. Our lovely underfunded public health department here in King County (where all the cases were) failed to take the most basic steps of contact tracing before the index patient was diagnosed. They followed up on all the people the index case exposed after he was diagnosed. But the guy had come through SeaTac airport directly from Wuhan before he ended up in Everett a short time later where he was diagnosed.

Everyone on the plane and in the airport were exposed during flu season here where such a respiratory illness wouldn't seem that unusual to the exposed persons.


I'll keep reading.
 
Last edited:
I guess I should have linked to the original Twitter thread that Worobey posted that accompanied the research he and his group are doing.

Link

The links work fine for me. The quotation marks are added by the software on this platform whenever you embed a link. If you can't go to the link the problem must be at your end.
 
Skeptic Ginger relies on probably fake news again?

Including an actual case where an accident infected a researcher with COVID-19.
If a researcher got COVID-19 in 2020 when working with SARS-CoV-2 after the outbreak, that says nothing about a lab incident releasing SARS-CoV-2 before December 2019.

I highlighted "If" because Skeptic Ginger does not give any sources. This may be the probable fake news Skeptic Ginger has cited before.
18 August 2021: If credible news sources have ignored a news article for almost 2 weeks (since 5 August), it is probably fake news.
24 August 2021: Skeptic Ginger cites probably fake news again.

Senior Chinese scientist acquired SARS-CoV-2 in lab infection accident, virologist says
The US Right To Know web site got Professor Shan-Lu Liu’s emails. One email has "Feng Gao s my 师兄 in 北京的病毒所 we we e from the same lab where my former director has now been infec ed by SARS CoV 2! Ve y sad but he s doing OK!" Followed by "Your former colleague was infected with sars2 in the lab?" question from Lishan Su and a "Yes, he was infected in the lab!" email from Shan-Lu Liu.

The report originally from US RTK is an lie according to an equally "valid" source.
Source refutes Aussie journalist’s rumor that researcher at Beijing lab infected with coronavirus at work
Regarding the accusations in the report, the Global Times learned from a source close to the NIVDC on Monday that the report was a complete lie. A person familiar with the situation told the Global Times that one researcher at the institute did become infected early last year but that person belonged to the institute's viral hepatitis division, which has nothing to do with the coronavirus research work. His office and his activities were located on the second floor of the institute and he had no access to the samples or to the P3 laboratory on the sixth floor of the building.
According to the source, the researcher was infected out of the workplace early last year when the COVID-19 epidemic was much severe in China. Relevant departments in Beijing have visited the NIVDC to investigate the case and confirmed that the infection process was not connected to the laboratory. This case was also included in Beijing's COVID-19 infection data and there was no "cover-up" as alleged in some reports.
...
However, another source close to the NIVDC told the Global Times on Monday that Liu had left the institute for "at least more than a decade" and that it was impossible for him to know what was going on at the institute as researchers were not close to him.
What makes this fake news is that it popped up on August 5, 2021 and a month later no one else has reported that this researcher caught COVID-19 in the lab.
 
Dr Shi lying about the 6 miners having had fungal infections, not a virus
How China’s ‘Bat Woman’ Hunted Down Viruses from SARS to the New Coronavirus
Three years earlier Shi’s team had been called in to investigate the virus profile of a mine shaft in Yunnan’s mountainous Mojiang County—famous for its fermented Pu’er tea—where six miners suffered from pneumonialike diseases and two died. After sampling the cave for a year, the researchers discovered a diverse group of coronaviruses in six bat species. In many cases, multiple viral strains had infected a single animal, turning it into a flying factory for new viruses.

“The mine shaft stunk like hell,” says Shi, who, like her colleagues, went in wearing a protective mask and clothing. “Bat guano, covered in fungus, littered the cave.” Although the fungus turned out to be the pathogen that had sickened the miners, she says it would have been only a matter of time before they caught the coronaviruses if the mine had not been promptly shut.
Dr Shi did not lie. The miners could not have been infected with SARS-CoV-2 related viruses because there were no such viruses in the cave :eye-poppi! That leaves the probable cause as fungal infection. Dr Shi stated what she believed.
WHO study Annex, p131.
With regard to the matter of morbidity and mortality in miners in a mine in Mojiang, Yunnan Province, where bats were present, Professor Shi said that the events had been clarified in an addendum to her Nature article. Doctors sent her the samples for testing after something like three months of illness. Miners had been to the cave 2-3 times and it was 1 meter thick with bat feces. Professor Shi’s team went there in 2012-15 about seven times to look for novel viruses. They found no viruses close to SARS-CoV but there was a rat henipa-like virus (Mojiang paramyxovirus), as reported by another group in China. Samples taken during subsequent visits to the cave were found to contain no viral sequence related to SARS-CoV-2 (like RaTG13). However, none of them has higher similarity to SARS-CoV-2 than the RaTG13 has. Therefore, none of them are the progenitor virus of SARS-CoV-2 (this would usually entail >99% in genome). None could be isolated. The reported illnesses associated with the miners, according to the WIV experts, were more likely explained by fungal infections acquired when removing a thick layer of guano.
A minute with Google gives Fungal pneumonia
Fungal pneumonia is an infection of the lungs by fungi. It can be caused by either endemic or opportunistic fungi or a combination of both. Case mortality in fungal pneumonias can be as high as 90% in immunocompromised patients,[1][2] though immunocompetent patients generally respond well to anti-fungal therapy.
My guess is that probable SARS-1 origin at the time (2012) as bats lead to inappropriate treatment of the miners and thus the deaths.
 
Last edited:
If a researcher got COVID-19 in 2020 when working with SARS-CoV-2 after the outbreak, that says nothing about a lab incident releasing SARS-CoV-2 before December 2019.

I highlighted "If" because Skeptic Ginger does not give any sources. This may be the probable fake news Skeptic Ginger has cited before.
18 August 2021: If credible news sources have ignored a news article for almost 2 weeks (since 5 August), it is probably fake news.
24 August 2021: Skeptic Ginger cites probably fake news again.

Senior Chinese scientist acquired SARS-CoV-2 in lab infection accident, virologist says
The US Right To Know web site got Professor Shan-Lu Liu’s emails. One email has "Feng Gao s my 师兄 in 北京的病毒所 we we e from the same lab where my former director has now been infec ed by SARS CoV 2! Ve y sad but he s doing OK!" Followed by "Your former colleague was infected with sars2 in the lab?" question from Lishan Su and a "Yes, he was infected in the lab!" email from Shan-Lu Liu.

The report originally from US RTK is an lie according to an equally "valid" source.
Source refutes Aussie journalist’s rumor that researcher at Beijing lab infected with coronavirus at work

What makes this fake news is that it popped up on August 5, 2021 and a month later no one else has reported that this researcher caught COVID-19 in the lab.

I wouldn't rely on Global Times which is pretty clearly a propaganda outlet for the Chinese government.

[The links work fine for me. The quotation marks are added by the software on this platform whenever you embed a link. If you can't go to the link the problem must be at your end.]

Either way, none of this really gets us closer to the origins.
 
I wouldn't rely on Global Times which is pretty clearly a propaganda outlet for the Chinese government.
Thus my quotes around "valid". Both sources have biases and are unreliable. That may be a reason that they were ignored by credible news agencies. More likely, journalists did the simple step of asking Shan-Lu Liu for his source and found that it was gossip. They may have contacted the lab and found no director was infected from an lab incident.
 
Sorry, my mistake. Apparently it won't open with my outdated Chrome on the other laptop. :o

No problem. Glad it got sorted out.

Yeah right, like no one in this thread has ever posted anything unpleasant to me. :rolleyes:

No doubt people do, so how about we call a truce and try to go through things objectively. The first one to be unpleasant to the other one's a loser. How about it? ;)
 
Just saying you left off an important caveat.

Well then you aren't paying attention.

Evidence of past lab accidents
Evidence of past lab accidents in Chinese labs where people contracted the infections being studied
Including an actual case where an accident infected a researcher with COVID-19
Evidence the WIV was researching SARS-like CoVs
Evidence of exposures to bats when WIV students and staff were collecting specimens in Yunnan complete with pictures of the injuries and lack of proper PPE
Dr Shi lying about the 6 miners having had fungal infections, not a virus

There's more but dismissing these as "questions, guesses and insinuation" really misrepresents what said evidence actually is.

There is nothing in this list that provides evidence that the current COVID 19 pandemic originated in a release from a lab. The list suggests that CLOVID 19 could have originated in a release from a lab, but that suggestion can equally be made without reference to any of the listed items. And I would, and do, equally accept that release from a lab could be the origin without being presented with that list. The list itself adds nothing.

Further, you are insinuating that the combination of the items on this list rises to the level of actual evidence that the current COVID 19 pandemic originated in a release from a lab. It really does not. What it actually provides evidence for is that in some cases security it some labs has been a problem. It does absolutely nothing to address an actual release of COVID 19.
 
Okay, so I don't understand any of the science here, but it seems that one of the questions to do with the origins is at what stage lineage A and lineage B of SARS-CoV2 diverged.

Well, a group of scientists including Michael Worobey, suggest that maybe they did not and that they therefore represent different points of emergence.

Link

This might bolster the multiple spillover theory.

Michael Worobey, on this Twitter thread, discusses a dispute he is having with one of the DRASTIC members about whether he is doing the science right. As Worobey says, it is pretty technical, and I have no idea how to say who is right and who is wrong in this.

The bottom line seems to be that there has been more than one introduction of SARS-CoV2 into humans, which would support the idea of multiple spillovers rather than, say, a single lab accident.

Two possible counter-arguments are that:
1.) The two lineages diverge from each other, and we have evidence of that which Worobey is throwing out (I think that is Daoyu's position)

and

2.) The two lineages diverge from each other even if we currently don't have evidence of it, and the divergence is simply lost somewhere.

As I say, I have no idea.

Maybe Capsid or SG want to chime in here... :blush:
I'd concur with that. Seems the sequences of the 2 lineages can not have occurred by transition and rather could be a sequencing error.
 
I'd concur with that. Seems the sequences of the 2 lineages can not have occurred by transition and rather could be a sequencing error.

Thanks for that, Capsid. Would that, therefore, increase the likelihood of multiple introductions into humans and thus increase the likelihood of multiple zoonotic/spillover events?
 
Thanks for that, Capsid. Would that, therefore, increase the likelihood of multiple introductions into humans and thus increase the likelihood of multiple zoonotic/spillover events?
Worobey seems to think so, "If a human-transmissible SARS-CoV-2 progenitor was circulating among such animals, the SARS1 story teaches us that it would be likely to jump multiple times into humans."
 
There is nothing in this list that provides evidence that the current COVID 19 pandemic originated in a release from a lab. The list suggests that CLOVID 19 could have originated in a release from a lab, but that suggestion can equally be made without reference to any of the listed items. And I would, and do, equally accept that release from a lab could be the origin without being presented with that list. The list itself adds nothing.

Further, you are insinuating that the combination of the items on this list rises to the level of actual evidence that the current COVID 19 pandemic originated in a release from a lab. It really does not. What it actually provides evidence for is that in some cases security it some labs has been a problem. It does absolutely nothing to address an actual release of COVID 19.
I can't say it enough apparently, BOTH options are on the table, neither has been supported with conclusive evidence.

The evidence does not support a natural event. Feel free to list the evidence you think does and/or to post why any particular piece of evidence for a lab leak is questioned.

That does not mean simply saying the evidence isn't direct proof. I've never said it did.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom