Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
You seem to have missed a lot of the genetic timeframe research walking the mutations back in time and looking for the common ancestors. We just discussed this when the possible scenarios for A and B lineages were discussed. :boggled:


Do you think the A & B lineages (either or both) began/diverged in Oct? That makes no sense.

Sorry, could you state what you mean.

"You seem to have missed... Do you think...?" doesn't make your point clear.
 
Sorry, could you state what you mean.

"You seem to have missed... Do you think...?" doesn't make your point clear.

Not that hard. Which is it, the first cases were in Oct because we don't have a record of earlier cases, or, the genetic evidence indicates the first cases had to be earlier than Oct if 2 lineages diverged earlier than the first cases on record?
 
Not that hard. Which is it, the first cases were in Oct because we don't have a record of earlier cases, or, the genetic evidence indicates the first cases had to be earlier than Oct if 2 lineages diverged earlier than the first cases on record?

I don't know what you mean. We don't have evidence of cases in October.
 
Looks like Yuri Deigin is particularly impressed by the Sharri Markson documentary. From the clip he posts here, it sounds to me more like Trump apologists making up stories to cover their mishandling of the pandemic ("If only we had known earlier..." - Really? And yet you would still have ****** it up!)
Yuri Deigin shows how bad the DRASTIC group are. He repeats the unsupported speculation about 3 WIV staffers becoming ill during flu season in November 2019 having COVID-19. People getting flu bad enough to visit a hospital is not unexpected at that time. It is well known that the intelligence reports state this happened in November 2019.
3 Wuhan Lab Workers’ 2019 Illness Raises Concerns
Three researchers from the Wuhan Institute of Virology in China became sick with a flu-like illness and sought hospital care in November 2019, according to a U.S. intelligence report obtained by The Wall Street Journal.
Sharri Markson? and the first interviewee say October 2019 which Yuri may be blindly repeating. David Asher implies November 2019.
Yuri Deigin makes up a fantasy of loss of smell for the staffers. He seems the only one in the world to have seen their X rays ("They also recorded ground glass opacities in their lung X rays.") :eye-poppi.
 
Last edited:
I don't think anybody knows the answer to that, but most estimates seem to assume October is the earliest. We don't have any known cases from then, though.

First, I did not say 'consensus' or 'supported by the most data'. You essentially dismissed any possibility the index case(s) were in Sept.

The point here was that in some papers using evidence based on tracing the molecular clock backwards to the index case, it was estimated the beginning could have been in Sept.

You seem to think that by dismissing those conclusions you can dismiss the relevance of the Sept 9 date for removing the online data. And yet you admit here, "I don't think anybody knows. ..."

So which is it, the first case(s) could have been Sept or they absolutely could not have been Sept?

There are still pieces of the puzzle that may need to be tossed out. For example the satellite data showing a crowded hospital parking lot and the online search of a Chinese website for terms like diarrhea may not fit any corroborated timeline.

Actually that data showed a crowded parking lot in Oct which could be consistent with a Oct surge in cases.

Then there is the unresolved data suggesting The new coronavirus was circulating in Italy in September 2019, a study by the National Cancer Institute (INT) of the Italian city of Milan shows, signaling that it might have spread beyond China earlier than thought.
It showed that four cases dating back to the first week of October were positive for antibodies, meaning they had got infected in September, Giovanni Apolone, a co-author of the study, told Reuters.

“This is the main finding: people with no symptoms not only were positive after the serological tests but also had antibodies able to kill the virus,” Apolone said.

And don't forget one needs to add the incubation period to the index case which could explain the Sept 9th data purge.

Range of incubation periods.
2 - 14 days
Possible outliers: 0 - 27 days ...

However, a case with an incubation period of 27 days has been reported by Hubei Province local government on Feb. 22 [12]
In addition, a case with an incubation period of 19 days was observed in a JAMA study of 5 cases published on Feb. 21. [13]...


The point here is Sept has been noted as possible in some studies.
 
Last edited:
Not sure what to make of this, but very topical.

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/co...s-before-outbreak/FNOF4GO4NULPSWUYW3DLMKFYVM/

Wuhan scientists were planning to release enhanced airborne coronaviruses into Chinese bat populations to inoculate them against diseases that could jump to humans, leaked grant proposals dating from 2018 show.

New documents show that just 18 months before the first Covid-19 cases appeared, researchers had submitted plans to release skin-penetrating nanoparticles containing "novel chimeric spike proteins" of bat coronaviruses into cave bats in Yunnan, China.
 
Not sure what to make of this, but very topical.

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/co...s-before-outbreak/FNOF4GO4NULPSWUYW3DLMKFYVM/

Wuhan scientists were planning to release enhanced airborne coronaviruses into Chinese bat populations to inoculate them against diseases that could jump to humans, leaked grant proposals dating from 2018 show.

New documents show that just 18 months before the first Covid-19 cases appeared, researchers had submitted plans to release skin-penetrating nanoparticles containing "novel chimeric spike proteins" of bat coronaviruses into cave bats in Yunnan, China.

See post 2414 and following?
 
Not sure what to make of this, but very topical.

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/co...s-before-outbreak/FNOF4GO4NULPSWUYW3DLMKFYVM/

Wuhan scientists were planning to release enhanced airborne coronaviruses into Chinese bat populations to inoculate them against diseases that could jump to humans, leaked grant proposals dating from 2018 show.

New documents show that just 18 months before the first Covid-19 cases appeared, researchers had submitted plans to release skin-penetrating nanoparticles containing "novel chimeric spike proteins" of bat coronaviruses into cave bats in Yunnan, China.

See post 2414 and following?

According to Francois Balloux on Twitter:

This is incorrect. The grant proposed to vaccinate bats against Sarbecoviruses, not to release 'airborne coronaviruses'. The idea was largely similar to vaccinating wildlife (foxes, coyotes, raccoons, ...) against rabies, which is effective in reducing human spillover cases.

What he says squares with what I have heard, for example, Vincent Racaniello saying about rabies and other viruses. Vaccinations against certain viruses are often given to animals in meat. He also said in an interview with Lex Fridman that some virologists have wanted to spray bat caves with vaccinations. In that case, I think he was referring to rabies, but presumably this is would work for coronaviruses too.
 
In contrast to Daszak's paper claiming the potential for 400,000 spillover events, he along with Shi were authors on this paper in Sept 2019, published in Nov 2019. It was cited here before but in light of the claim of 400,000 spillover events I think it should be looked again in that context:

Human-animal interactions and bat coronavirus spillover potential among rural residents in Southern China
... we conducted biological-behavioral surveillance among rural residents in Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guangdong districts of Southern China, where we have identified a number of SARS-related coronaviruses in bats ...

A total of 1,596 residents were enrolled in the study from 2015 to 2017. Nine participants (0.6%) tested positive for bat coronaviruses. ...

This study provides serological evidence of bat coronavirus spillover in rural communities in Southern China. The low seroprevalence observed in this study suggests that bat coronavirus spillover is a rare event.



Going back to the This Week in Virology podcast/video interview with Daszak at the Nipah conference, there is more on the tape besides the reference to coronaviruses being easy to manipulate in the lab.

WHO inspector caught on camera revealing coronavirus manipulation in Wuhan before pandemic
At the 28:10 mark of the podcast interview, Daszak states that researchers found that SARS likely originated from bats and then set out to find more SARS-related coronaviruses, eventually finding over 100. He observed that some coronaviruses can "get into human cells in the lab," and others can cause SARS disease in "humanized mouse models."...

... Daszak at the 29:54 mark appears to reveal that the goal of the GoF experiments was to develop a pan-coronavirus vaccine for many different types of coronaviruses.

Based on his response, it is evident that just before the start of the pandemic, the WIV was modifying coronaviruses in the lab. "You can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily." What he then mentioned has become the telltale trait of SARS-CoV-2, its spike protein: "Spike protein drives a lot of what happens with the coronavirus, zoonotic risk." ...

Based on Daszak's statements, it appears that just before the start of the pandemic, the WIV was using GoF experiments with chimeras in an attempt to create a vaccine. These experiments appeared to have included infecting mice genetically modified to express the human ACE2 protein with these chimeras.

I'm going to go back to the 2015 paper tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
In contrast to Daszak's paper claiming the potential for 400,000 spillover events, he along with Shi were authors on this paper in Sept 2019, published in Nov 2019. It was cited here before but in light of the claim of 400,000 spillover events I think it should be looked again in that context:

Human-animal interactions and bat coronavirus spillover potential among rural residents in Southern China




Going back to the This Week in Virology podcast/video interview with Daszak at the Nipah conference, there is more on the tape besides the reference to coronaviruses being easy to manipulate in the lab.

WHO inspector caught on camera revealing coronavirus manipulation in Wuhan before pandemic


I'm going to go back to the 2015 paper tomorrow.


Chimaeras are not GoF!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The molecular clock papers are consistent with the first cases in December 2019

The point here was that in some papers using evidence based on tracing the molecular clock backwards to the index case, it was estimated the beginning could have been in Sept.
Those papers tracing backwards to the index case to September 2019 do not exist :eye-poppi!
There are papers "using evidence based on tracing the molecular clock backwards" to the the time to most recent common ancestor of SARS-CoV-2 genomes between 13 November 2019 and 23 December 2019 (95% confidence). They looked at the genomic sequences of 66 early cases. There is one paper that has a tMRCA of late September. This is not a date of infection of the first cases.
WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part page 81 (after Table 8 listing the different tMRCA studies).
In summary, the tMRCA analysis based on molecular sequence data suggested that the pandemic onset occurred before the end of December 2019. The tMRCA analyses can be considered a statistical inference but do not provide definitive proof of time of origins. The point estimates for the time to most 82recent ancestor ranged from late September to early December, but most estimates were between mid November and early December.

13 August 2021 The molecular clock papers are consistent with the first cases in December 2019.
The average date is 11 December 2019 which coincidentally is around the date of the first recorded case.
 
Last edited:
In contrast to Daszak's paper claiming the potential for 400,000 spillover events, he along with Shi were authors on this paper in Sept 2019, published in Nov 2019. It was cited here before but in light of the claim of 400,000 spillover events I think it should be looked again in that context:

Human-animal interactions and bat coronavirus spillover potential among rural residents in Southern China
There is no contrast for anyone who reads the preprint, commentary on it and the paper.
SARS-like viruses may jump from animals to people hundreds of thousands of times a year
Only two new coronaviruses have spread globally the past 2 decades: SARS-CoV, which caused an outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in 2003, and SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. But that may just be the tip of the iceberg of undetected infections with related viruses emerging from bats, a new paper claims. In a preprint published yesterday researchers estimate that an average of 400,000 people are likely infected with SARS-related coronaviruses every year, in spillovers that never grow into detectable outbreaks.

Although that number comes with big caveats, “It should be eye-opening to the entire scientific community that we don’t know very much about the frequency of zoonotic spillover,” says virologist Angela Rasmussen of the University of Saskatchewan, who was not involved in the work. That needs to change, she says, “because otherwise we grossly underestimate it.”
...
The confidence interval stretches from one to more than 35 million hidden infections per year, however...

A strategy to assess spillover risk of bat SARS-related coronaviruses in Southeast Asia by Sánchez et. al.
The preprint uses the habitats of 23 bat species known to harbor SARS-related coronaviruses in Southeast Asia. Then:
But the researchers went one step further. Small surveys done before COVID-19 erupted have suggested some people in Southeast Asia harbor antibodies against SARS-related coronaviruses. Combining those data with data on how often people encounter bats and how long antibodies remain in the blood, the researchers calculated that some 400,000 undetected human infections with these viruses occur each year across the region.
They used existing data on people infected by SARS-related coronaviruses. But the data included only a few thousand people and there may have been false positives. That would contribute to "The confidence interval stretches from one to more than 35 million hidden infections per year".

Human-animal interactions and bat coronavirus spillover potential among rural residents in Southern China is a sample of 1,596 rural residents in Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guangdong districts of Southern China from 2015 to 2017.
A total of 1,596 residents were enrolled in the study from 2015 to 2017. Nine participants (0.6%) tested positive for bat coronaviruses. 265 (17%) participants reported severe acute respiratory infections (SARI) and/or influenza-like illness (ILI) symptoms in the past year, which were associated with poultry, carnivore, rodent/shrew, or bat contact, with variability by family income and district of residence.
The highlighted statement "bat coronavirus spillover is a rare event" applied to a population of 500 million leads to 150,000 infections (0.6% presumably over 2 years).
 
Last edited:
Chimaeras are not GoF!
I never said they were.

And chimeras like the one Baric worked on would have been detectable whereas no one thinks SARS CoV2 was 'constructed'.

OTOH, arguing what is and what isn't GoF research is a distraction that isn't very useful.

Chimera- no, not a precursor to COVID-19.

Daszak collecting more than 100 SARS CoV specimens from the caves/mine in Yunnan does need a bit more scrutiny.
 
I never said they were.

And chimeras like the one Baric worked on would have been detectable whereas no one thinks SARS CoV2 was 'constructed'.
OTOH, arguing what is and what isn't GoF research is a distraction that isn't very useful.

Chimera- no, not a precursor to COVID-19.

Daszak collecting more than 100 SARS CoV specimens from the caves/mine in Yunnan does need a bit more scrutiny.

I get the impression from most of the DRASTIC people that they DO believe the virus was constructed. Hence talk of the FCS etc…. They talk about components d of the virus having been inserted and they tend to allege that these insertions happened at BSL-2 etc…. They don’t always say the words directly but imply that.
 
I get the impression from most of the DRASTIC people that they DO believe the virus was constructed. Hence talk of the FCS etc…. They talk about components d of the virus having been inserted and they tend to allege that these insertions happened at BSL-2 etc…. They don’t always say the words directly but imply that.

Got a quote from them saying as much? For that matter is anyone from The Team their designated spokesperson?

Yes, they thought the lab leak origin was being ignored/covered up and for the first year or so that was true. It is well documented.


What they say about Their works.
This website collects works and research done by D.R.A.S.T.I.C. members. Clear and proper attribution to D.R.A.S.T.I.C. are required for use of any of this work. For more information please contact our members directly or email us at [email protected].


The origin of SARS-CoV-2 is a riddle: meet the Twitter detectives who aim to solve it
They have been working tirelessly this year: reading academic papers, exploring barely known databases, sifting through Chinese media outlets. Their work place is Twitter. Some of them are professional scientists, others have different backgrounds, many use pseudonyms. They have a tendency to ask uncomfortable questions, and probably for this reason they are often blocked by other scientists and accused of promoting conspiracy theories.

There is an excellent chronology of the work of DRASTIC on that page, how they got to where they are now, that is well worth reading.
 
Here's a tweet from today from Yuri Deigin talking about inserting a furin cleavage site. That sounds to me like construction.
Rossana Segreto and Yuri Deigin believed in construction but that was in November 2020.
The genetic structure of SARS-CoV-2 does not rule out a laboratory origin was speculation that SARS-CoV-2 is a chimeric mix between bat and pangolin coronaviruses with an added furin cleavage site. That tweet suggests that Yuri Deigin still believes SARS-CoV-2 was purposely created.
 
Last edited:
Rossana Segreto and Yuri Deigin believed in construction but that was in November 2020.
The genetic structure of SARS-CoV-2 does not rule out a laboratory origin was speculation that SARS-CoV-2 is a chimeric mix between bat and pangolin coronaviruses with an added furin cleavage site. That tweet suggests that Yuri Deigin still believes SARS-CoV-2 was purposely created.

Yep. I think both of them are still pretty much in that camp. And most other DRASTIC members seem to be. That said, it is of course true that the group has many different members and many different theories. Yuri Deigin is merely one of the most sane members. The others go into truly bat **** territory. It really is like a Truther movement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom