Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
So you want to stop studying viruses with pandemic potential in the hopes that will somehow make you safer? Do you realize how ridiculous that is?

What’s even more ridiculous is attacking the distinctions of different kinds of gain of function as if it were of no importance. The specific definition that paused certain types of gain of function was to allay fears that viruses studied in labs could escape and cause a pandemic. But if you remove all distinctions and say that no viral or bacterial gain of function experiments could be done then you presumably could not even make vaccines which clearly involve gain and/or loss of function to work.
 
Just an FYI: My comments were about the fruitless distraction arguing the semantics of what GoF was.

As for we needed that research, we don't have an irony meter big enough to address that comment.

And if the evidence was addressed without all the political interference, some of you might have noticed there were safety measures not followed in the research so far, and not just in Wuhan labs.

From memory those included things like providing a number of barriers between a potential lab leak and a dense population center. That was objected to as not feasible given the scientists at the labs would want to live in those urban population centers. And to that I say the internet could easily accommodate connections to said urban center. We have scientists now who spend months in Antartica and on the International Space Station. I'm sure we could recruit researchers willing to spend a few months away from home as they studied PPPs.

But we can't accomplish that without an honest evaluation of just how COVID 19 got out.
 
Last edited:
Just an FYI: My comments were about the fruitless distraction arguing the semantics of what GoF was.
...
And if the evidence was addressed without all the political interference, some of you might have noticed there were safety measures not followed in the research so far, and not just in Wuhan labs....
Skeptic Ginger's usual misinformation.
The discussion of what GoF is not semantics. The funding of GoF research at the WIV was based on a specific definition of GoF, apparently including the target of making the virus both more infectious and transmittable. WIV only researched making making the virus both more infectious.
We have no actual evidence that there were safety measures not followed at the Wuhan labs.
A fantasy that PPP's (potential pandemic pathogens) need to be studied in labs in Antarctica or the ISS.
A fantasy that there is no honest evaluation of just how COVID 19 got out. There are scientists honestly evaluating all of the evidence for the origin of COVID 19 such as whether the virus got out of a animal population or out of a lab. Currently the best evidence is still for a bat origin (such as the Laos bats with the closest match to the virus), an intermediate animal vector, and those animals ending up at the Wuhan market(s). This does not eliminate a lab leak.
 
Last edited:
What’s even more ridiculous is attacking the distinctions of different kinds of gain of function as if it were of no importance. The specific definition that paused certain types of gain of function was to allay fears that viruses studied in labs could escape and cause a pandemic. But if you remove all distinctions and say that no viral or bacterial gain of function experiments could be done then you presumably could not even make vaccines which clearly involve gain and/or loss of function to work.

Note that even for real GoF work, some of the most dangerous is considered essential in understanding what viruses present a pandemic risk to humans. The moratorium on it wasn't because the research isn't essential it was because some countries (but primarily the US) had no regulation or controls around it whatsoever.

GoF is really just a red herring that plays into the whole right wing "never trust science, scientists are evil" sentiment.
 
GoF is really just a red herring that plays into the whole right wing "never trust science, scientists are evil" sentiment.
It is not a red herring created by the whole right wing... I agree with you that GOF can be quite useful and Researchers have proven that; where the rub comes is transparency. When GOF was initially restricted we were in a different environment (no virus, China vs USA was not as polarized and we had a President that was pretty sharp)... today, Wuhan will not allow independent bodies to review procedures, we have a virus of unknown origin already spread around the world, and it is a completely politicized disease.

Doing GOF in this environment is suicidal more suicidal than re-electing Trump. We know how to conduct GOF, that will never go away; having said that...

Would you want a Republican Administration overseeing GOF?
 
It is not a red herring created by the whole right wing... I agree with you that GOF can be quite useful and Researchers have proven that; where the rub comes is transparency. When GOF was initially restricted we were in a different environment (no virus, China vs USA was not as polarized and we had a President that was pretty sharp)... today, Wuhan will not allow independent bodies to review procedures, we have a virus of unknown origin already spread around the world, and it is a completely politicized disease.

Doing GOF in this environment is suicidal more suicidal than re-electing Trump. We know how to conduct GOF, that will never go away; having said that...

Would you want a Republican Administration overseeing GOF?

The US doesn't allow the Chinese to inspect it's BSL4 labs, why would China allow the US to inspect it's labs?

The real threat from GoF was always mainly unregulated private labs primarily located in the US. This is where anyone could perform whatever GoF experiments they wanted with no oversight whatsoever. China on the other hand doesn't have a problem with lack of oversight, just the opposite in fact their government wants it's fingers in everything.
 
Have the Chinese released the Delta and Omicron variants, or has evolution done the job? If it’s the latter, isn’t it reasonable that evolution came up with the original variant?
 
Have the Chinese released the Delta and Omicron variants, or has evolution done the job? If it’s the latter, isn’t it reasonable that evolution came up with the original variant?

Funny you should say that because some lab leak theorists do indeed claim that Omicron came from a lab as well. I have seen Yuri Deigin float that idea (though not for Delta). Bret Weinstein and Jordan Peterson have been showing how completely bat **** they have become by suggesting that the variants are some kind of Big Pharma ruse (honestly, people used to think they were smart dudes but the pandemic has turned them into Alex Jones).

Interestingly, the Proximal Origins paper by Andersen, Lipkin, Garry, Rambault and Holmes argued that one of the strongest pieces of evidence for considering the virus to be a result of natural spillover was that it wasn’t as good a fit to the human ACE-2 receptor as a lab-produced virus would likely to be. I think the continued increase in fitness that we are seeing of the virus variations seem to vindicate them in this way.
 
It is not a red herring created by the whole right wing... I agree with you that GOF can be quite useful and Researchers have proven that; where the rub comes is transparency. When GOF was initially restricted we were in a different environment (no virus, China vs USA was not as polarized and we had a President that was pretty sharp)... today, Wuhan will not allow independent bodies to review procedures, we have a virus of unknown origin already spread around the world, and it is a completely politicized disease.

Doing GOF in this environment is suicidal more suicidal than re-electing Trump. We know how to conduct GOF, that will never go away; having said that...

Would you want a Republican Administration overseeing GOF?

Seems a red herring as political administrations don’t usually oversee the lab experiments themselves. Despite Trump’s claims about knowing loads about science because of his uncle being a professor for a record-breaking amount of time, he probably did not spend any time in a BSL-4 lab recreating the days when his uncle got him a chemistry set for Christmas.
 
Funny you should say that because some lab leak theorists do indeed claim that Omicron came from a lab as well. I have seen Yuri Deigin float that idea (though not for Delta). Bret Weinstein and Jordan Peterson have been showing how completely bat **** they have become by suggesting that the variants are some kind of Big Pharma ruse (honestly, people used to think they were smart dudes but the pandemic has turned them into Alex Jones).


I pointed out earlier this thread that you can find accusations of a lab leak surrounding virtually every major virus outbreak. The only difference is that this time some people are taking it seriously and even promoting it for reasons of politics and propaganda.


Interestingly, the Proximal Origins paper by Andersen, Lipkin, Garry, Rambault and Holmes argued that one of the strongest pieces of evidence for considering the virus to be a result of natural spillover was that it wasn’t as good a fit to the human ACE-2 receptor as a lab-produced virus would likely to be. I think the continued increase in fitness that we are seeing of the virus variations seem to vindicate them in this way.

Another thing they pointed out is that the RBD is out of frame, something that would never happen if it were designed by humans but does occur from time to time in evolution.
 
Have the Chinese released the Delta and Omicron variants, or has evolution done the job? If it’s the latter, isn’t it reasonable that evolution came up with the original variant?

Not sure what you mean but the lack of variability in the first batches of the COVID genomes was evidence it appeared on the spot there in Wuhan in late 2019. And the evidence supported the conclusion it was a one-time event of the virus' entering the human population.

Evidence of lineages A and B can be explained by an error in the way genomes are processed. But even if that isn't what happened, the two lineages are only a couple mutations apart, again not evidence the virus was circulating in any significant numbers prior to the one time release in Wuhan.

From there on mutations and the resulting variants demonstrate what one would have seen had the virus been circulating for very long before or within Wuhan.

Passing a virus through a host multiple times can lead to it becoming more contagious and/or deadly.

Researchers pass viruses repeatedly through cell cultures or animal hosts to create versions adapted to whatever they are studying.

Researchers in N. Carolina and at the WIV have been doing that with SARS CoV related viruses for years.

PNAS 2016: SARS-like WIV1-CoV poised for human emergence
This manuscript describes efforts to extend surveillance beyond sequence analysis, constructing chimeric and full-length zoonotic coronaviruses to evaluate emergence potential. Focusing on SARS-like virus sequences isolated from Chinese horseshoe bats, the results indicate a significant threat posed by WIV1-CoV. Both full-length and chimeric WIV1-CoV readily replicated efficiently in human airway cultures and in vivo, ...

... we developed a framework to examine circulating CoVs using reverse genetic systems to construct full-length and chimeric viruses. The results indicate that viruses using WIV1-CoV spike are poised to emerge in human populations due to efficient replication in primary human airway epithelial cell cultures. However, additional adaptation, potentially independent of the spike protein receptor-binding domain, is required for pathogenesis and epidemic disease.
Primary human airway epithelial cell cultures derived from human donors and grown at an air–liquid interface represent the closest model to the human lung. Therefore, the ability of both WIV1-CoV and WIV1-MA15 to grow equivalently to the epidemic SARS-CoV in these cultures is a major concern for emergence. However, pathogenesis studies in mice suggest that further adaptation may be required for epidemic disease..

Know what the SARS CoV viruses needed to make them spread more readily in humans?

LEAKED GRANT PROPOSAL DETAILS HIGH-RISK CORONAVIRUS RESEARCH
The proposal, rejected by U.S. military research agency DARPA, describes the insertion of human-specific cleavage sites into SARS-related bat coronaviruses.
... the proposal describes the process of looking for novel furin cleavage sites in bat coronaviruses the scientists had sampled and inserting them into the spikes of SARS-related viruses in the laboratory.

“We will introduce appropriate human-specific cleavage sites and evaluate growth potential in [a type of mammalian cell commonly used in microbiology] and HAE cultures,” referring to cells found in the lining of the human airway, the proposal states.

The grant was denied but said grant was not the WIV's only source of funding.

You know the saying, 'if you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras'?

You have a virus that appeared abruptly, in Wuhan where they were not just studying SARS CoVs, they were manipulating the viruses to make them more dangerous for humans. And there is no evidence of any spillover, no evidence of bats infected with the close progenitor of COVID, no evidence of any intermediate species of animal, no evidence where or when a naturally occurring precursor virus to COVID evolved.

Horses or zebras?
 
Last edited:
Funny you should say that because some lab leak theorists do indeed claim that Omicron came from a lab as well.....
Irrelevant red herring. There are many such red herring claims. China says omicron was introduced to Beijing on incoming mail from Canada. It couldn't live long enough mail packaging to do so.

You post this crap to try to mislead away from the science and toward CTs. If you had better arguments for a natural spillover you wouldn't need to do this.
 
Irrelevant red herring. There are many such red herring claims. China says omicron was introduced to Beijing on incoming mail from Canada. It couldn't live long enough mail packaging to do so.

You post this crap to try to mislead away from the science and toward CTs. If you had better arguments for a natural spillover you wouldn't need to do this.

I'm just posting facts. Lionking asked, and I answered. Literally some of the most prominent lab leak theorists ARE claiming Omicron came from a lab.
 
I'm just posting facts. Lionking asked, and I answered. Literally some of the most prominent lab leak theorists ARE claiming Omicron came from a lab.

"Prominent lab leak theorists"?

You mean the ones you read about on the CT sites? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Nothing about the cases resembled a "fungal infection". To claim otherwise is to imagine you know more than the doctors treating the patients.

Again you claim to know more than the doctors treating the patients. I assure you you do not.

But as for what the miners had that Shi seems to not fully address:

The genetic structure of SARS‐CoV‐2 does not rule out a laboratory originNote the invitation to take samples from the mine came because the miners contracted a severe pneumonia. They were not diagnosed with a fungal infection as both histoplasmosis and aspergillosis would not have been a mystery infection. And a cluster of 6 cases of undiagnosed pneumonia in miners working where SARS likely originated would raise a big red flag which resulted in contacting the WIV.
Add to that what was the presumptive diagnoses the physician taking care of these patients stated in the master's thesis and you have a likely SARS CoV-like viral pneumonia.

Of course this is that paper by Segreto and Deigin that has been hand-waved away because of some reason over their hypothesis on the furin cleavage sites.


You all can spin your wheels over this all you want, it doesn't change the evidence based facts.

"Prominent lab leak theorists"?

You mean the ones you read about on the CT sites? :rolleyes:

No, ones YOU have quoted…
 

Attachments

  • 8FF934D9-C616-4ED0-B310-FCE62BE65542.jpg
    8FF934D9-C616-4ED0-B310-FCE62BE65542.jpg
    72.8 KB · Views: 4
There's no link there to get a bit more context so I've gone looking for myself. I cannot find where you got that thumbnail from but regardless, this is what I did find:

NPR: The mystery of where omicron came from — and why it matters

Omicron has a slew of genetic changes and it is unclear how those accumulated. There are a number of hypotheses.

The discovery of the omicron variant of the coronavirus — which has a high number of concerning mutations — has kicked off a frenzy of research. Scientists are racing to figure out how transmissible this variant is and how resistant to vaccines it is.

They're also grappling with a mystery: How did omicron get created? ...

But Bedford says that when you look at the family tree for this omicron variant, there's something surprising: "With omicron, your closest sequences are back from mid-2020 — so over a year ago. That is very rare to see."

In other words, while scientists can tell that this variant evolved from a strain that was circulating in mid-2020, in the intervening months there has been no trace of all the intermediate versions that scientists would have expected to find as it morphed into its current form.

"It doesn't tie into anything that was circulating more recently," says Bedford." Yet its mutations put it a long way from that 2020 strain.
Three hypotheses are discussed.

Deigin's relevant Twitter thread
If you hear anyone claim “we know the virus didn’t come from a lab”, don’t buy it — it may well have. Labs around the globe have been creating synthetic viruses for years:

He merely posits it as a fourth hypothesis. This is completely different from your dismissal:
asoba said:
Funny you should say that because some lab leak theorists do indeed claim that Omicron came from a lab as well. I have seen Yuri Deigin float that idea (though not for Delta). Bret Weinstein and Jordan Peterson have been showing how completely bat **** they have become by suggesting that the variants are some kind of Big Pharma ruse (honestly, people used to think they were smart dudes but the pandemic has turned them into Alex Jones).
Serious researchers discussing the lab leak hypotheses are not bat **** crazy. And I don't see anything on Deigin's Twitter suggesting some Big Pharma CT.
Feel free to post the actual link in context and I'll take another look.

Evidence for a mouse origin of the SARS-CoV-2 Omicron variant
The rapid accumulation of mutations in the SARS-CoV-2 Omicron variant that enabled its outbreak raises questions as to whether its proximal origin occurred in humans or another mammalian host. Here, we identified 45 point mutations that Omicron acquired since divergence from the B.1.1 lineage. We found that the Omicron spike protein sequence was subjected to stronger positive selection than that of any reported SARS-CoV-2 variants known to evolve persistently in human hosts, suggesting a possibility of host-jumping. The molecular spectrum of mutations (i.e., the relative frequency of the 12 types of base substitutions) acquired by the progenitor of Omicron was significantly different from the spectrum for viruses that evolved in human patients but resembled the spectra associated with virus evolution in a mouse cellular environment. Furthermore, mutations in the Omicron spike protein significantly overlapped with SARS-CoV-2 mutations known to promote adaptation to mouse hosts, particularly through enhanced spike protein binding affinity for the mouse cell entry receptor. Collectively, our results suggest that the progenitor of Omicron jumped from humans to mice, rapidly accumulated mutations conducive to infecting that host, then jumped back into humans, indicating an inter-species evolutionary trajectory for the Omicron outbreak.


You make little effort to look at the bigger picture or have a serious discussion of the evidence, opting instead to cherry pick what suits your dismissive narrative.
 
Last edited:
Omicron has a slew of genetic changes and it is unclear how those accumulated. There are a number of hypotheses.

Three hypotheses are discussed.

Deigin's relevant Twitter thread


He merely posits it as a fourth hypothesis. This is completely different from your dismissal:

Funny you should say that because some lab leak theorists do indeed claim that Omicron came from a lab as well. I have seen Yuri Deigin float that idea (though not for Delta). Bret Weinstein and Jordan Peterson have been showing how completely bat **** they have become by suggesting that the variants are some kind of Big Pharma ruse (honestly, people used to think they were smart dudes but the pandemic has turned them into Alex Jones).
Serious researchers discussing the lab leak hypotheses are not bat **** crazy. And I don't see anything on Deigin's Twitter suggesting some Big Pharma CT.
Feel free to post the actual link in context and I'll take another look.

Evidence for a mouse origin of the SARS-CoV-2 Omicron variant



You make little effort to look at the bigger picture or have a serious discussion of the evidence, opting instead to cherry pick what suits your dismissive narrative.

Please try to read my posts properly.

First of all, I pointed out that Yuri Deigin "floated the idea". I am colour-coding my quote so you can see that I am distinguishing what he says from what Bret Weinstein and Jordan Peterson have said.

I have actually had some correspondence with Yuri Deigin and I have a bit more respect for him than I do for Weinstein and Peterson, and it is the latter who I dismiss as ******* crazy.
 
LOL!

Also, looks like Dr John Campbell is also floating the theory a little bit, although you have to love his "Hey, I just read the letters face!"

 

Attachments

  • John Campbell Omicron from a lab.jpg
    John Campbell Omicron from a lab.jpg
    24.7 KB · Views: 3
Actually a lack of reading comprehension from Skeptic Ginger :eye-poppi.

If you hear anyone claim “we know the virus didn’t come from a lab”, don’t buy it — it may well have. Labs around the globe have been creating synthetic viruses for years:
...
5:37 AM · Apr 26, 2020·Twitter for iPhone
This is a comment about the original variant of the virus and irrelevant to NPR: The mystery of where omicron came from — and why it matters published December 1, 2021.

It is the twitter posted by angrysoba that has Yuri Deigin's actual hypothesis of "a lab leak origin of Omicon".

That post was in reply to Skeptic Ginger lying again about the irrelevant cases of miners who became ill and some died from what could have been fungal infections. Everything about the cases resembled fungal infections. The symptoms also match an unknown viral infection probably from the bats in the caves they worked in. We do not know what they got. The cases are irrelevant to a discussion on the origin of COVID. Shi stating her opinion that it was fungal infection is irrelevant to this thread.

Before this post there is her repeated idiocy about a proposal for research funding by the EcoHealth Alliance (not the WIV) that was refused in 2018 :eek:! To connect this refused funding to COVID-19 we need some bits of conspiracy theory.
  1. The EcoHealth Alliance got secret (as in no one has found it) funding for the insertion of a novel furin cleavage site into bat coronaviruses.
    The proposal says they wanted §14.209,245 for the entire DEFUSE project. So a few millions of dollars have mysteriously appeared.
  2. The EcoHealth Alliance secretly got the WIV to do that research.
  3. The WIV secretly did that research and there was a lab leak.
  4. A conspiracy to cover that research up, e.g. no one working on it has come forward.
 
Please try to read my posts properly.

First of all, I pointed out that Yuri Deigin "floated the idea". I am colour-coding my quote so you can see that I am distinguishing what he says from what Bret Weinstein and Jordan Peterson have said.

I have actually had some correspondence with Yuri Deigin and I have a bit more respect for him than I do for Weinstein and Peterson, and it is the latter who I dismiss as ******* crazy.

And yet you brought up Deigin directly followed by your "bat **** crazy" accusation.

I know how to read. Maybe you need a grammar lesson in antecedents.

And you brought up my citing Deigin. Have you seen me bring the other two up because I don't recognize their names.

Bottom line, I would appreciate if you would address the issues and arguments and stop dismissing the facts based on your accusations against the sources of the information. But I have asked you multiple times and you keep doing it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom