I understand that the Penn study cannot say for certain that the abnormalities were definitively the result of something that happened in Cuba. I understand the limitations of a retrospective study. But the mere fact that there were abnormalities found in the study group that were not found in a demographically similar control group is certainly suggestive.
No it isn't. If you take a group of people referred to the study because they had some kind of neuro symptom then you find a brain change in that group, you need to know how large was the group the symptomatic persons were selected out of.

All I’m really trying to get across is that there really isn’t enough information to draw conclusions. One cannot say, with anything approaching certainty, that “it was probably MPI,” just as one cannot say, “it was probably an attack.”
If you recognize there isn't enough information to draw conclusions then I'm in agreement there. But how do you go from 'not enough information' to 'they had measurable brain abnormalities'?

Dann would like us to accept that it’s most probably MPI because that fits his “America evil; Cuba good,” narrative. I say that we can’t just accept that because it isn’t clear at all. And I say that not because I’m trying to defend America (we’ve done our share of evil) but because there isn’t enough information.
The fact the first reports were out of Cuba is a red herring Dump promoted.
 
xjx388 doesn't know what he is talkinga about:

Patients from the US Embassy were first sent to ear, nose and throat doctors at the University of Miami and then to brain specialists in Philadelphia. Physicians examined the embassy patients using a range of tests to measure hearing, balance and cognition. They also took MRIs of the patients’ brains. In the 21 patients examined, 15 to 18 experienced sleep disturbances and headaches as well as cognitive, auditory, balance and visual dysfunction. Despite these symptoms, brain MRIs and hearing tests were normal.
(...)
the December 2020 National Academy of Science report concluded that mass psychogenic illness was a reasonable explanation for the patients’ symptoms, particularly the chronic symptoms, but that it lacked “patient-level data” to make such a diagnosis.
Havana syndrome fits the pattern of psychosomatic illness – but that doesn’t mean the symptoms aren’t real (Deccan Herald, Oct 1, 2021)
David Relman's idea, contrary even to everyday life experience, that it is unusual and a sign of a microwave attack if sound dissipates when you leave a room, seems to have made him forget about this.


And people say to me, they say, 'You don't know what you are talking about: concussion-like symptoms, white matter tract changes, brain damage! That can't possibly be mass psychogenic illness!'

But that's not what happened. The white matter tract changes never happened !
In December of 2017, information was leaked to the media that doctors examining a number of Havana Syndrome patients had discovered the significant white matter tract changes to their brains. This was big news, and for the next year, there was headlines about doctors finding brain anomalies in many of the diplomats. And then nearly a year later, in early 2018, the study came out, and in 21 patients only three had white matter tract changes . Two were mild, one was moderate.

If you walk down the streets of Melbourne or Sidney today and randomly pick 21 people, that's exactly what you would expect to find because white matter tract changes are common in everything from migraines to depression, to normal aging. So the claims of white matter tract changes are a myth as were the claims of brain damage. There was reports leaked that they had brain damage . When the studies came out, they were inconclusive.

And lastly, you have the study of hearing loss: In 2018, the results of a forthcoming study of 25 U.S. diplomats were leaked to the media. It was plain that about a third of the patients had hearing loss. This was reported for months and months and months in 2018. Once again the headlines: 'Diplomats suffering from hearing loss.' But when the study was published that December of 2018, they found that only two of the subjects had hearing loss. And both of them had hearing loss before they went to Cuba. And what had happened was: When they were interviewed, the subjects had expressed disbelief that they had hearing loss, but when they were given a standard hearing test, the others returned normal results.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13616228#post13616228
 
Dann would like us to accept that it’s most probably MPI because that fits his “America evil; Cuba good,” narrative. I say that we can’t just accept that because it isn’t clear at all. And I say that not because I’m trying to defend America (we’ve done our share of evil) but because there isn’t enough information.


There is more than enough information to say that this is a case of mass psychogenic illness.
A former CIA officer who was in Cuba at the time later noted that the first patient “was lobbying, if not coercing, people to report symptoms and to connect the dots.”
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13616292#post13616292
That was how it got started by Patient Zero - before it was then spread to a couple of million people by means of mass suggestion.
 
This beginning of this new article is rather typical of what has been written about the 'Havana Syndrome' (HS)after 60 Minutes. Notice the pitfalls:

1.
Earlier this month, a Biden administration expert panel rejected the idea that “psychosocial factors alone” explained symptoms.
Column: Are electromagnetic weapons involved? Taking victims of ‘Havana syndrome’ seriously (L.A.Times, Feb 24, 2022)
Not even those of us who say that the 'syndrome' is a case of mass psychogenic illness claim that “psychosocial factors alone" explain the symptoms. The cicadas, for example, aren't psychosocial, but they are integrated into the whole narrative that constitutes 'HS'. The very real microwave weapons are also integrated into this narrative, much the same way that UFO sightings are integrated into the story about alien abductions.
'But UFOs are real! People have seen them!' is as good an argument for alien abductions as actually existing microwave weapons are for 'HS': Yes, microwave weapons do exist, but they don't do what the imaginary microwave weapons in Havana are supposed to have done!

2.
In January, a CIA report dismissed all but a couple dozen reports as having mundane explanations such as stress. But in a CBS “60 Minutes” report, “Targeting Americans,” which aired Sunday, CIA Director William Burns, whose colleague reported symptoms in India last fall, said he was taking reports seriously.
Yes, that's what he said on 60 Minutes: He is taking the reports about symptoms seriously. He didn't say that he considered them to be symptoms of any kind of attack, which is what most comments seem to imply.

3. But this is the point where the L.A.Times article takes a step further than most other articles based on the 60 Minutes show because if these "high-ranking officials with no history of mental illness" are being taken seriously when they believe they are the victims of microwave attaks, then how about all those other people who believe that they, too, are the victims of sinister agencies shooting rays at innocent people? Like the author's father:
A Mexican immigrant who worked in shipbuilding in San Diego before he was laid off, he believes the CIA experimented on him with electromagnetic weapons that caused him to collapse in pain and develop insomnia, among other things.
In his telling, which he’s never been able to prove, the CIA was testing the weapons’ ability to dramatically alter behavior — by targeting drug addicts with electronic intervention. (My father was using crack cocaine, and quit because of this perceived intervention.)
And yes, I know! He was an addict and not a "high-ranking official" or one of Bob001's "responsible senior officials," but his story is very similar to the ones we have heard from 'HS' sufferers, isn't it?!


ETA: I assume that 3. is a step too far even for xjx388. This is where his faith in stories about sinister microwave attacks on innocent Americans stops because it doesn't fit his "Cuba evil; America good,” narrative.
 
Last edited:
One area where AI has proven to be beneficial is the health sector. Contrary to popular perception, AI applications have been used in diagnosing and treating diseases for nearly 50 years. One such example is the Natural Language Processing (NLP) application that is used to understand and classify clinical documentation.
Recently, scientists have found that AI can be used to study impacts of diseases on the human body and how these diseases can ‘alter the human body.’ The integrated system developed will help doctors to ascertain the difference in images down to single cell and study its effects after a disease or an injury. This tool has been named ‘TDAExplore’ and uses topology and AI to recognise alterations in the human body. In light of this, it can be assumed that AI will not only be helpful in solving existing problems in disease identification, but could also be beneficial in future studies.

One such potential use could be studying the cause and impact of the so-called ‘Havana Syndrome’. In the United States, four more cases of this syndrome were reported in Europe this year. According to US Secretary of State Antony Blinken, the government is investigating the matter. The ‘Havana Syndrome’ was first reported in Cuba in 2016, in which 16 US officials fell sick to a possible acoustic attack having symptoms ranging from hearing loss to mild brain injuries. Since, the cause and impacts of this mysterious illness remains unconfirmed, and microwave weapons are suspected to be a prime cause, this AI tool ‘TDAExplore’ could be used to study it. However, since this is a new tool and its effectiveness is as yet unproven, it may take time to reach any definitive conclusion.
Ensuring Equality Through and Within Emerging Technology (Modern Diplomacy, Feb 24, 2022)


This sounds very interesting! As a diagnostic tool it would have to be able to distinguish between the alleged genuine 'Havana Syndrome' sufferers, people who have actually been targeted and impacted by the hypothetical microwave weapon wielded by a hostile enemy, and all those other people who complain of similar symptoms but are just imagining them. It would have to be able to distinguish between, on the one hand, somebody who claims to be suffering from, for instance, EHS, but only imagineS it, and on the other hand, those who have the real 'syndrome' because they suffered a pulsed microwave attack.

The criterion invented by Dr. Relman and his colleagues, i.e. that real 'syndrome' sufferers would have to have been employed by the State Department or the CIA and have heard the sound of crickets in Havana, would become irrelevant, and the only recognized criterion would be the alleged physiological signs of this brand-new, never-heard-of-before syndrome!

I bet an AI couldn't possibly be as ignorant of acoustics as David Relman and it would render his obvious bias irrelevant.
So watch out, Dr. Relman! The AIs are breathing down your neck!
:)
 
Last edited:
This sounds very interesting! As a diagnostic tool it would have to be able to distinguish between the alleged genuine 'Havana Syndrome' sufferers, people who have actually been targeted and impacted by the hypothetical microwave weapon wielded by a hostile enemy, and all those other people who complain of similar symptoms but are just imagining them. It would have to be able to distinguish between, on the one hand, somebody who claims to be suffering from, for instance, EHS, but only imagineS it, and on the other hand, those who have the real 'syndrome' because they suffered a pulsed microwave attack.

The criterion invented by Dr. Relman and his colleagues, i.e. that real 'syndrome' sufferers would have to have been employed by the State Department or the CIA and have heard the sound of crickets in Havana, would become irrelevant, and the only recognized criterion would be the alleged physiological signs of this brand-new, never-heard-of-before syndrome!

I bet an AI couldn't possibly be as ignorant of acoustics as David Relman and it would render his obvious bias irrelevant.
So watch out, Dr. Relman! The AIs are breathing down your neck!
:)
I can spot the problem without any AI help. They all have a slew of symptoms that are inconsistent between sufferers. And of the consistent symptoms, they are all self reported and subjective. In addition, other people in the same proximity, including in the same room(s), have no complaints. So unless you think there is some kind of individual targeting, that alone puts the perceived etiology in doubt.
 
Last edited:
The same way that UFOs don't prove alien abductions.

And not only do microwave weapons exist, so do the gadgets to detect them:
Now, the Defense Department wants US soldiers outfitted with microwave weapon detectors. That was laid out in a Dec. 9 contract solicitation for "a low cost, low weight, small size wearable radio frequency (RF) weapon exposure detector," specifying high-frequency microwaves, that came from the Defense Department's Defense Health Program.


And there is also:
An Air Force Research Laboratory is rolling out a "counter-swarm electromagnetic weapon," called THOR, to fry drones in mid-air.


And yet the cell phones of the diplomats and spies seemed to be working fine when they were recording the cicadas while their brains were (allegedly) being fried! But maybe they have the James Bond impervious-to-microwaves smart phone.
 
Last edited:
I can spot the problem without any AI help. They all have a slew of symptoms that are inconsistent between sufferers. And of the consistent symptoms, they are all self reported and subjective. In addition, other people in the same proximity, including in the same room(s), have no complaints. So unless you think there is some kind of individual targeting, that alone puts the perceived etiology in doubt.


That seems to be what they are claiming: Two children and two adults individually targeted in the same hotel suite! (And yes, not bloody likely!)
 
Sure. The point is is simply that microwave weapons do exist, and the Pentagon wants to be able to detect their use. That doesn't prove anybody's using them against U.S. officials.
Which is not the same as secret targeted microwave beams.
 
Which is not the same as secret targeted microwave beams.


You are right. The existing microwave weapons that heat up people's skin are very different from the imaginary brain fryers. And the size of those things! (Yes, size matters!)

While high-temperature-inducing microwaves, like the ones found in ovens, can cook food and cause burns, the question of whether neurological health effects can result from less powerful ones has long lacked evidence and has been subject to the kinds of conspiracy theories seen today about 5G cell phones.
The Government Wants to Protect Troops from Microwave Weapons, Which Trump Officials Considered Using on Immigrants (BuzzFeed News, Feb 2, 2021)


They should add the burning sensation to the list of symptoms to be reported. That would make anybody with hot flashes feel targeted:
A hot flash is the sudden feeling of warmth in the upper body, which is usually most intense over the face, neck and chest. Your skin might redden, as if you're blushing. A hot flash can also cause sweating. If you lose too much body heat, you might feel chilled afterward. Night sweats are hot flashes that happen at night, and they may disrupt your sleep.
Hot flashes (Mayo Clinic)


And anybody whose cellphone stops working should also report a suspected enemy attack.
 
I have mentioned Sung Tieu a couple of times in this thread. Her short film has now been released:

Moving Target Shadow Detection (2022) is a new moving-image work by Sung Tieu, the recipient of the Frieze Artist Award 2021, co-produced and co-commissioned by Forma and Frieze.
Modelled and rendered in 3D, the film reconstructs the entire interior of the Hotel Nacional de Cuba in Havana, the site of the first-known instance of a supposed sonic attack, which collectively became known as the ‘Havana Syndrome’. First reported by CIA staff in the Cuban capital in 2016, the syndrome includes a range of unexplained disorders ranging from nausea, fatigue and memory loss to brain injuries resembling concussions.
In Tieu’s film, CCTV camera footage and images taken by a nano drone lead from the hotel’s lobby to an occupied hotel room, where the viewer is confronted with classified documents and news reportages of the recent Havana Syndrome attacks around the world.
Watch Now: Sung Tieu, 'Moving Target Shadow Detection' (2022) (Frieze, Feb 1, 2022)


The short film ends with the drone leaving the hotel room from the balcony and flying over the terrace towards El Malecón and the Atlantic Ocean. They should have let it continue east-northeast from Hotel Nacional de Cuba towards the Embajada de los Estados Unidos, which you can actually see from the hotel terrace if I remember correctly: Google Maps. I have spent many an afternoon on that terrace listening to one of their son bands.

It is a wonderful place to relax if you are stressed out. Patient Zero should have made use of the facilities offered by the hotel.*

I guess a drone approaching the US Embassy might spark a minor diplomatic incident, and it probably wouldn't make it better that the perpetrator is Vietnamese, but I would have loved to see one of those microwave drone fryers in action!

If they ever decide to turn The Shining franchise into a trilogy, I hope that they will put Sung Tieu in charge of the sequel to The Shining and Doctor Sleep.


* ETA: Sorry, I guess I owe Patient Zero an apology for this suggestion: There are crickets in the Hotel Nacional's garden!
 
Last edited:
Another case for mass psychogenic illness:

After 5 years, hundreds of cases on multiple continents, and continuous, inconclusive investigation, there may never be a definitive answer to whether Havana Syndrome is physical or psychogenic. But history may bring more clarity than Cold-War-era spycraft. Havana syndrome has some major differences from MPI epidemics of the past, but in many ways it's more similar than not -- and paranoia in the American intelligence community would hardly be unprecedented.
Is Havana Syndrome Real? Here's What History Can Tell Us (WebMD, Jan 12, 2022)
 
American Foreign Service Association chief Eric Rubin says syndrome, which remains a mystery, has affected recruitment
Havana syndrome has 'dramatically hurt' morale, US diplomats say (The Guardian, Feb 10, 2022)


But that is what they would say, isn't it? It seems as if 'Havana Syndrome' may just be a very bad excuse use to cover up the real reason why morale is bad and it is "getting harder to find young people to work abroad": Captured, Killed or Compromised: C.I.A. Admits to Losing Dozens of Informants (NYT, Oct 5, 2021)

That can't be a morale booster, can it?!

Leading counterintelligence officials issued a memo to all of the CIA's global stations saying that a concerning number of U.S. informants were being captured and executed.
The CIA’s counterintelligence mission center investigated dozens of incidents in the last few years that involved killings, arrests or compromises of foreign informants. In an unusual move, the message sent via a top secret cable included the specific number of agents killed by other intelligence agencies, according to The New York Times.
(....)
The cable, which also cited the issue of putting "mission over security," comes amid recent efforts by countries like Russia, China, Iran and Pakistan to find CIA informants and turn them into double agents, the Times reported.
(...)
"No one at the end of the day is being held responsible when things go south with an agent,” Douglas London, a former CIA operative who was unaware of the cable, said to the Times. "Sometimes there are things beyond our control but there are also occasions of sloppiness and neglect and people in senior positions are never held responsible."
CIA admits to losing dozens of informants around the world: NYT (The Hill, Oct 5, 2021)


I can see why Mr. Burns prefers to blame the whole thing on a 'mysterious' syndrome in Havana.
 
The Fringe of the Fringe

Havana Syndrome and Big Wireless (Kevin Kunze on YouTube, Aug 24, 2021 - 5:06 min.)
One comment reads: "my grand kid came home from school yesterday said three kids at her school had nosebleeds . i thought it very strange."
Kevin Kunze answers: "Maybe their classroom is right below a cell tower"
I'm a little disappointed that no Cuban was involved.

Using The Story Cards by Cathy Nichols
Is There a Link bw Havana Syndrome and Odd Events Elsewhere - Mexico?
Is There A Connection Bw The Havana Syndrome & Birds Falling Out Of Mexico's sky? (Blackcat Tarot on YouTube, Feb 26, 2022 - 4:12 min.)

Well, if the cards say so, then I'm convinced! :pigsfly

But I much prefer the version from the Havana Syndrome Guys (Calvin & Habs on YouTube, Feb 23, 2022)

 
The TikTok 'Tourettes'

Categorizing the new tic-disorder outbreak as a mass psychogenic illness would explain many of its notable features, such as the age and gender profile of patients. Bartholomew says that out of the 3,500 likely cases of MPIs that he has identified through history, “I would say 98 percent of them are majority female.” (Two possible exceptions are Gulf War and Havana syndromes.)The Twitching Girls - The Twitches That Spread on Social Media (The Atlantic, Feb 27, 2022)


I have mentioned another exception a couple of times: San Diego, 1988.

Kirsten Müller-Vahl told me that the reactions varied among her patients in Hannover when her team told them that they did not have Tourette’s—that something else was causing their tics and twitches. Some patients, she said, “were more or less cured after I offered the correct diagnosis.” Others could not accept that judgment. “They still think they suffer from Tourette’s,” she says; some patients keep running YouTube channels offering advice about the condition. When patients who have built an identity on being a Tourette’s influencer discover they do not have Tourette’s, Müller-Vahl said, she faces a poignant question: “I am asked: ‘How do I tell my followers?’”


I wonder what Mark Polymeropoulos and Mark Lenzi will tell the media. What will Mark Zaid tell his clients? What will David Relman tell the people who trusted his alleged expertise when he realizes that crickets are nothing but crickets?
 
I got chills, they're multiplyin'. And I'm losin' control.

Patients with mysterious disease in Canada criticize the lack of transparency of the investigation (eprimefeed, Feb 15, 2022)

For more than two years, dozens of people in the Canadian province of New Brunswick have suffered from a distressing array of neurological symptoms, prompting speculation that they had fallen victim to an unknown degenerative illness.
Provincial authorities are soon expected to release a report examining whether the cases are linked, or simply the result of misdiagnosis and clinical error. But as the public awaits the findings, those enduring the extreme symptoms say they've been left to suffer alone.
Victims and their families have described a frightening deterioration of bodies and minds, compounded by an agonizing wait for more information.
Gabrielle Cormier, 20, dreamed of attending medical school. But in 2019, she began experiencing muscle pain, difficulty concentrating and vision problems. Her family initially suspected it was fatigue from sports. Soon, however, she could no longer keep her balance.
'What's going on with me?' Canadian victims of mystery illness suffer alone (The Guardian, Jan 31, 2022)


It sounds familiar, doesn't it?!

After warning medical professionals to be on the lookout for a baffling neurological conditions that produced memory loss, muscle wasting and severe cognitive decline, authorities in the Canadian province of New Brunswick have concluded that no such illness exists, a finding that has prompted skepticism and disbelief as families search for answers.
New Brunswick officials last year flagged a possible cluster of residents suffering from an unknown neurological syndrome, similar to those of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease. Symptoms were varied and dramatic: some patients started drooling, and others felt as though bugs were crawling on their skin.
On Thursday, the province released the findings of its oversight committee, concluding that none of the 48 cases met the definition of an unknown brain syndrome and that the victims were instead probably suffering from known diseases.
"The oversight committee has unanimously agreed that these 48 people should never have been identified as having a neurological syndrome of unknown cause, and that based on the evidence reviewed, no such syndrome exists," Jennifer Russell, chief medical officer of health for New Brunswick, told reporters Thursday.
Victims dismayed are Canadian inquiry finds mystery syndrome does not exist (The Guardian, Feb 24, 2022)


New Brunswick neurological syndrome of unknown cause (Wikipedia)

Mysterious Brain Syndrome Stumps Canadian Doctors (NYT, June 4, 2021)
 
Last edited:
More about the 'new disease' in New Brunswick

The sufferers and their relatives react much like the U.S. spies and diplomats to the findings of the experts:

Almost one year after the New Brunswick government sounded the alarm about "a distinct atypical neurological syndrome" causing symptoms ranging from muscle spasms to visual hallucinations, the province now says there is no mystery neurological syndrome.
(...)
The oversight committee "could not conclude that the main referring neurologist had sought second opinions" for the patients before determining they may be suffering from an unknown illness.
The report doesn't mention him by name, but Dr. Alier Marrero identified 46 of 48 patients in the cluster. Marrero declined an interview through Vitalite Health Network on Thursday, but in the fall, he told Radio-Canada he stood by his theory.
(...)
Some patients and their families aren't happy with the committee's findings and plan to continue to push for a scientific investigation that would see the province conduct environmental testing.
(...)
Steve Ellis was also told his father, Roger, was a member of the cluster. He said he continues to decline physically and cognitively, which has driven his son to push for answers from the government, organizing other patients and their family members through a Facebook group.
"It was very clear that they've officially abandoned us," Ellis said.
"It's not just the 48, we know it's more than 48. That's not going to stop us from still asking them to do a proper investigation. That is their due diligence of care as a public health agency, provincially and federally."
New Brunswick has no mystery neurological illness, committee findsNew Brunswick has no mystery neurological illness, committee finds (CBC.ca, Feb 24-25, 2022)


It may have helped solve the 'mystery' that the symptoms of many of the patients in New Brunswick were much more debilitating and fatal than the ones of the 'Havana Syndrome:

On that same day, Shephard said eight patients who had died, including six who were part of the original cluster of 48, had autopsy results indicating they died from known diseases, such as cancer, Lewy body dementia and Alzheimer's disease.


So it sounds as if it is a conflation of people with different actual, well-known physical illnesses into a cluster with a brand-new diagnosis - probably with a few cases of MPI in the mix. I have only heard of one autopsy in the case of the 'Havana Syndrome': of a dog.
How a dog's brain may help solve the mystery of Canadian diplomats' Cuban nightmare (Ottawa Citizen, Feb 28, 2019)

Health officials in New Brunswick released a long-awaited report Thursday into a mysterious and debilitating neurological disorder that has struck dozens of people with bizarre symptoms — including a belief that family members have been replaced by impostors — stumped doctors and stoked fears across the province.
The conclusion? There is no new disorder.
(...)
The report’s authors say the 48 cases in what was thought to be a cluster were randomly allocated to pairs of neurologists who reviewed them and presented their findings to an oversight committee of six New Brunswick neurologists and other officials. The committee said none of the cases met the full criteria of the case definition.
Official investigation into New Brunswick’s mysterious brain disorder finds no new condition (Washington Post, Feb 24, 2022)


One comment to the WP article:
My (conspiracy?) theory is that a new type of non-lethal agent or weapon was being tested on the families of American and Canadian diplomats in Havana, and is now being deployed in multiple locations against specific targets.

But deploying it on apparently random people in a province of Canada doesn't sound very specific.
 
Last edited:
Jean Guerrero's L.A.Times article mentioned in post 1344 has been making the rounds since Feb 24, and now appears in the Korea Herald: Are electromagnetic weapons involved? Taking victims of ‘Havana syndrome’ seriously (Feb 28, 2022). However, the KH version of the article does not include the paragraphs about the author's crack-addicted father allegedly having been experimented on by the CIA using behavior-altering "electromagnetic weapons", but it still includes a call to expand the ongoing investigation of the 'syndrome' to every American citizen who feels targeted:

The Biden administration should create a centralized location for reporting cases, including by private citizens. The US can’t appropriately compensate victims without understanding the syndrome’s causes. That’s why investigators should scrutinize the United States’ own potential abuse of such technology, and collect testimony outside of US government personnel. Private citizens who’ve been reporting similar attacks since at least the early 2000s deserve to be heard.


I doubt that Biden, Blinken and Burns will accommodate her proposal ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom