Cont: Sweden's liberal pandemic strategy questioned as Stockholm death toll mounts (Part 2)

Anders Tengel was the one who wanted the comparison in the first place, and the majority of Swedes followed suit - always coming up with excuses for Sweden's excessive COVID-19 death toll.
Johanna Frändén was just one of many.
One of Anders Tegnell's excuses very early on was that Norway and Finland had lower population densities than Sweden. He stopped using that one when people pointed out that Denmark's population density is 5-6 times higher than Sweden's. I already presented the numbers for Belgium: Sweden: 25 per km2; Belgium: 383 per km2, i.e 15-16 times higher than Sweden.

There were honorably exceptions to this exceptionalist attitude, the people in VetCov19, for instance. And there were the researchers at the Royal Swedish Academy of Science, whose report was more or less ignored or outright dismissed: Slutrapport efterlyser oberoende expertenhet vid pandemier (Nov 30, 2021).

For the most part, Swedish skeptics joined in the celebration of Anders Tegnell, a real personality cult (and still active), but a few Swedes, in particular actual Swedish scientists, dared oppose them, for instance in what corresponded to Swedish ISF: https://forum.vof.se. I use the past tense because it was shut down in the fall of 2022. The reason for taking this step was never made clear, but I assume that it was because the most active thread, the one about Sweden's pandemic response, had become too embarrassing to let live. The irony is that the thread started as a celebration of Sweden's pandemic strategy and its heroes, Sweden's pandemic response allegedly being the only one in the world that was based on science.

So in a way, it is fitting that Anders Tegnell now embraces right-wing media and invites them into his home, but it's a damn shame that is doesn't seem to make Swedish skeptics consider their allegiance to him.
I wonder what our Swedish skeptics think of The Daily Sceptic's tribute to Anders Tegnell:
When Anders Tegnell Stood Alone (The Daily Sceptic, March 23, 2023)

Daily Sceptic Bias (MediaBias/FactCheck)
The Daily Sceptic (Wikipedia)


Another one of those guys is Martin Kuldorff at the Brownstone Institute. Swedish pandemic pseudo-science has had a considerable impact on the world in the past three years.
 
I believe in european statistical authorities.
(I can't post URL:s yet, because I am a new member at this forum.)
Sources:
Statistiska Centralbyrån(SCB) Sverige
Statistikcentralen Finland
Danmarks statistik
Statistisk sentralbyrå Norge
CBS Statistics Netherlands
Statbel, the Belgian statistical office

You can easily find relevant facts at the SCB site.

If you want to believe in a russian like Dimitry Kobak and Twitter activists, it's up to you.


I don't "want to believe" anybody, but if there is one thing I have learned to distrust during the pandemic, it's Swedish epidemiologists.
As for Swedish excess mortality in the pandemic years so far:
Excess mortality: Raw number of deaths from all causes compared to projection based on previous years, Sweden, Jan 2020 to Feb 19, 2023 (Our World in Data)
Unfortunately, it doesn't allow for direct comparisons between countries.

And as for Dimitry Koba, he seems to be a very shrews guy, mainly interested in the truth. That he happens to be born in Russia isn't something I hold against him, but I can see why a Random person would. Much the same way that I don't hold it against Anders Tegnell, Johan Giesecke and Martin Kuldorff where they happen to be born, I also don't hold t against anybody born in Russia. Only nationalists do, and I am not one of those.

I think that this is interesting:
Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the Covid-19 death toll than the official daily updated number, argues Dmitry Kobak
Excess mortality reveals Covid's true toll in Russia (Royal Statistical Society, Feb 3, 2021)

Is a Random person's problem with Dmitry Kobak that the pandemic has taught them not to trust anybody whose thinking isn't ruled by Chauvinism?

For people who are actually interested in the question of excess mortality in the pandemic, i.e. not driven by jingoism, I can recommend this Twitter thread:
A lot of debate right now about this @SvD chart showing #Sweden with the lowest excess mortality in Europe for 2020-22.
Obviously this is causing something of a stir.
So is it a plausible claim?
TLDR - yes, maybe....but it's not quite so simple....
Paul C of :ENGLAND: i :SWEDEN: (Mar 6 to Mar 8, 2023)


Tweet 19 is interesting, isn't it?! It is no coincidence that all the Nordic countries have the lowest excess mortalities, even Sweden, but it has very little to do with pandemic strategies and everything to do with pre-existing conditions in those countries: low population densities (Denmark is the outlier in this respect with a population density of 137 per km2; Sweden #2 with 25 per km2), number of people per household, and probably even the attitude to social distancing, which tends to come 'naturally' to the Nordics.

This is also the reason why Sweden's pandemic response should be compared to the other Nordics instead of to Italy or Belgium. When Swedes prefer Belgium as the country to compare outcomes of pandemic strategies with, it has nothing to do with science and everything to do with nationalism.

If the whole thread is tl;dr for you, you can jump straight to the two charts in tweet 22.
 
You write: I also don't hold t against anybody born in Russia. Only nationalists do, and I am not one of those.

Are you Cuban?
 
Here in Finland they are no longer recommending covid jabs (or was it boosters) for children. Flu has started early. What will that be a recipe for?


It's the same in Denmark. And Covid-19 vaccinations stopped on March 1. Nobody will be able to get boosters for the next six months or so, unless prescribed by doctors, because the health authorities expect SARS-CoV-2 to behave like a seasonal flu. And all the Covid-19 numbers recently started to increase again, probably due to XBB.1.5. and maybe also waning immunity since the booster shots in October-November. 250 hospitalizations of patients with Covid-19 in week 10 --> 410 in week 11: Coronavariant medfører ny mindre smittebølge i Danmark (TV2.dk, Mar 23, 2023)

As for vaccinating children ... or not ... a new article in Science-Based Medicine:
Any doctor who pushes for the repeated mass infection of unvaccinated babies and toddlers with a novel, mutating virus, when an effective vaccine is available, is a medical radical.
Medical “Conservatives” Are Medical Radicals (Science-Based Medicine, Mar 24, 2023)
 
Friday, March 24, 2023:
Sweden had the lowest excess mortality in Europe.
Did it?


Monday, March 27, 2023:
No, Sweden didn't have the lowest excess mortality in Europe. The front page of the Swedish newspaper Dagens Nyheter today:
Överdödligheten under pandemin inte lägst i Sverige (DN, Mar 27, 2023)
Sweden didn't have the lowest excess mortality during the pandemic

Saturday, March 25, 2023:
You live in the past. Now it's 2023 and not 2020-2021.


Monday, March 27, 2023:
No, a Random person lives in a past that never existed outside of Sweden's consensual hallucination. (Which a few Swedes manage to stay exempt from, even a few Swedish skeptics.)
 
Friday, March 24, 2023:
No, a Random person lives in a past that never existed outside of Sweden's consensual hallucination.
And, it seems, Norway's leading epidemiologist.

One of Norway’s leading epidemiologists has claimed that criticism of Sweden’s Covid strategy was excessive. Preben Aavitsland, who served as Director for Surveillance at the Norwegian Institute of Public Health, argued that other countries “hid their own insecurities by scolding Sweden” because the country “undermined their mantra that we had no choice”.

In comments made to Swedish paper SvD, Aavitsland explained that while Norway’s “harder line” may have prolonged the lives of old people, he added that the model of “long, hard lockdowns” that was inspired by Italy and China made Sweden “the contrast they did not want”. Sweden “forced them to explain to their citizens why they acted as they did,” the epidemiologist explained. “For these people, it would have been better if everyone had done the same”.

Unlike the rest of Europe, Sweden largely avoided implementing mandatory lockdowns, instead relying on voluntary curbs on social gatherings, and keeping most schools, restaurants, bars and businesses open. This made Sweden an outlier, turning the country’s then-chief state epidemiologist Anders Tegnell into a hate figure, as he received death threats and urges to resign throughout the pandemic. This month, he told his successor to “have ice in your stomach”.

Despite avoiding strict lockdowns, SvD claims that Sweden’s excess mortality was the lowest out of all EU nations, including Nordic countries. While this claim is disputed, numerous studies have shown Sweden’s excess death rate to be among the lowest in Europe. Figures by the World Health Organisation, for example, show that in 2020 and 2021, the country had an average excess death rate of 56 per 100,000 — compared to 109 in the UK, 111 in Spain, 116 in Germany and 133 in Italy.

But Aavitsland stressed that a pandemic response could not be judged on excess deaths alone. “We also have to look at how people’s physical and mental health has been affected, school results and drop-outs, unemployment and social economy and other things,” he said. He went on to compliment the Swedish Public Health Agency’s communication over Norway’s, saying that it created less fear. “They gave more advice than threatened punishment,” the epidemiologist noted.

Fear may have been one reason as to why there were so few protests from the Norwegian population, which surprised Aavitsland. He said that it was “almost a little scary” what the population “accepts without protesting”. “We forbade families to visit their grandmother in the nursing home, we denied men attendance at their children’s births, we limited the number who were allowed to attend church at funerals,” he said. “Maybe people are willing to accept very strong restrictions if the fear is great enough”.

Norway's top epidemiologist: Sweden handled covid well
 
Yes, indeed!
It is no coincidence that Sweden's most recent celebration of its libertarian herd-immunity-by-infection strategy was based on a claim from Norwegian epidemiologist Preben Aavitsland. It was the same guy who declared that the pandemic was over ... on June 6, 2021. Back then, 22 months ago, he was clearly living in a future that still doesn't exist - except in the fantasies of Covid-19 minimizers.
He appears to be a big fan of Anders Tegnell, which shouldn't come as a surprise to anybody.

So let us take a look at the pandemic in the Nordics since June 6, 2021, shall we?!
On June 7, 2021, Norway's number of cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people was 144.27. Today it's 969.03. That 'top epidemiologist' really has a way with numbers, doesn't he?!

The pandemic in the Nordics had hardly begun on June 6, 2021.
 
And, it seems, Norway's leading epidemiologist.

Norway's top epidemiologist: Sweden handled covid well


Let us take a closer look at FatherLukeduke's article. Bolding is his, not mine.

It goes wrong from the beginning. The guy who is supposed to be Norway's top epidemiologist in the headline turns out to be just one of them in the article. He is not the Norwegian epidemiologist who was often described as the 'Norway's Tegnell' during the pandemic. I never heard about him until now.

One of Norway’s leading epidemiologists has claimed that criticism of Sweden’s Covid strategy was excessive. Preben Aavitsland, who served as Director for Surveillance at the Norwegian Institute of Public Health, argued that other countries “hid their own insecurities by scolding Sweden” because the country “undermined their mantra that we had no choice”.


To a fan of Anders Tegnell, I guess any criticism appears to be excessive. If he had an actual argument for this, it isn't presented in the summary of the article. I doubt that Norway's pandemic response had 'the mantra that they had no choice'. I never heard of such a mantra in the Nordics. I didn't follow Norway as closely as I did Sweden and Denmark, but the impression I got was that Norwegians were presented with the facts of the pandemic, much like the Danes but unlike the Swedes.

But the weirdest thing about this is that the other Nordic countries never really scolded Sweden or the Swedish pandemic strategy. A couple of times when Tegnell made comparisons with neighboring countries that were obvious lies, Norwegian and Danish newspapers mentioned it and asked him about it, but he never replied. And it was hardly ever mentioned by Swedish media when it happened.

In comments made to Swedish paper SvD, Aavitsland explained that while Norway’s “harder line” may have prolonged the lives of old people, he added that the model of “long, hard lockdowns” that was inspired by Italy and China made Sweden “the contrast they did not want”. Sweden “forced them to explain to their citizens why they acted as they did,” the epidemiologist explained. “For these people, it would have been better if everyone had done the same”.


That is a mantra that was repeated by Covid minimizers throughout the first years of the pandemic: Lockdowns were always hard (or draconian), even when they weren't. But in the Nordic countries lockdowns were never anywhere near what happened in Italy and China. People were never forced to stay at home. They could go outside as much as they pleased. Supermarkets weren't closed but it was recommended that whole families didn't go shopping together when it didn't take more than one person from each household to buy groceries. A very sensible recommendation to prevent the spread of an airborne virus like SARS-CoV-2 - and it also helped prevent the spread of the flu, which may have been the reason why 'excess mortality' in the Nordics (apart from Sweden) dropped below zero in 2020.
The alleged hard lockdown consisted mainly in schools resorting to online education, and public venues like movies theaters, and restaurants, cafes and nightclubs locking down along with hairdressers and similar professions.
It was enough, it worked, and the owners and workers of that kind of establishments were compensated. That these soft (?), mild (?), lockdowns wouldn't have worked in much more densely populated countries goes without saying. Conditions in the Nordic countries were favorable.

Unlike the rest of Europe, Sweden largely avoided implementing mandatory lockdowns, instead relying on voluntary curbs on social gatherings, and keeping most schools, restaurants, bars and businesses open. This made Sweden an outlier, turning the country’s then-chief state epidemiologist Anders Tegnell into a hate figure, as he received death threats and urges to resign throughout the pandemic. This month, he told his successor to “have ice in your stomach”.


Yes, it's true! Keeping those things open did indeed make Sweden an outlier: Daily new confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people in the Nordics, March 1 to Sep 1, 2020. Is it so hard to understand why people urged the state epidemiologist to resign with those results? He was the guy who not only urged schools to be kept open to help achieve herd immunity by infection, but he also asked the ECDC not to declare that the virus spread as airborne aerosols because that would make it obvious that his own claim about face masks being dangerous was absurd. Tegnell probably lied about face masks for the same reason that he lied about schools and the spreading virus: He wanted people to spread it in order to achieve herd immunity by infection. He was worried (!) that it wouldn't spread fast enough.

Despite avoiding strict lockdowns, SvD claims that Sweden’s excess mortality was the lowest out of all EU nations, including Nordic countries. While this claim is disputed, numerous studies have shown Sweden’s excess death rate to be among the lowest in Europe. Figures by the World Health Organisation, for example, show that in 2020 and 2021, the country had an average excess death rate of 56 per 100,000 — compared to 109 in the UK, 111 in Spain, 116 in Germany and 133 in Italy.


As it turns out, Sweden's excess mortality wasn't the lowest in EU countries. That it was lower than in many other EU countries was due to the things that the Nordics have in common: "pre-existing conditions in those countries: low population densities (Denmark is the outlier in this respect with a population density of 137 per km2; Sweden #2 with 25 per km2), number of people per household, and probably even the attitude to social distancing, which tends to come 'naturally' to the Nordics." See post 1,222.
UK: 277 per km2Spain: 94 per km2Germany: 240 per km2Italy: 206 per km2
But Aavitsland stressed that a pandemic response could not be judged on excess deaths alone. “We also have to look at how people’s physical and mental health has been affected, school results and drop-outs, unemployment and social economy and other things,” he said. He went on to compliment the Swedish Public Health Agency’s communication over Norway’s, saying that it created less fear. “They gave more advice than threatened punishment,” the epidemiologist noted.


So why don't we hear about "people's physical and mental health" etc? Aavitsland merely implies that Sweden must have fared so much better than everybody else, but where are the numbers showing that this was actually the case?
As for "creating less fear" and giving "more advice" instead of threatening "punishment": The daily press briefings in Sweden were farcical with Tegnell alway trying to make his strategy look good by coming up with euphemism for what was happening instead of presenting the facts and what they meant. I no longer remember all his hilarious terms, but I think that 'a slightly rising plateau' was one of them. And he always started with a presentation of how bad it was everywhere else, which made it easier for him to make it seem as if everything was fine in Sweden even when it wasn't.

I didn't follow the Norwegian press briefings, but the ones in Denmark were always fact-based: a presentation of the numbers, the impact that restrictions and behavior seemed to have, if more were needed or if they could be relaxed, and pretty realistic predictions. Unlike Tegnell's! During most of the first year of the pandemic, he always predicted herd immunity next week or next month, and in the late summer/early fall of 2020, he claimed that Sweden had actually achieved the goal: herd immunity!
So in a way it's true: Anders Tegnell "created less fear" - by consistently lying about the pandemic! By the way, I don't remember punishment being mentioned.

Fear may have been one reason as to why there were so few protests from the Norwegian population, which surprised Aavitsland. He said that it was “almost a little scary” what the population “accepts without protesting”. “We forbade families to visit their grandmother in the nursing home, we denied men attendance at their children’s births, we limited the number who were allowed to attend church at funerals,” he said. “Maybe people are willing to accept very strong restrictions if the fear is great enough”.


One reason as to why there were so few protests from the Norwegian population may have been that Norwegians received actual information about what was going on, actual facts. They were informed about the pandemic and the measures against it, understood what was going on, so why protest? They didn't want to kill their grandparents and didn't want to spread the virus in hospitals or in churches. That Aavitsland finds this "almost a little scary" is pathetic. One shouldn't live in fear, and he has no reason to be scared.
And speaking of protesting: This is one of the pandemic measures that Sweden took very seriously! Protests of more than 50 (if I remember correctly) people weren't allowed! So there is no reason to wonder why there were no mass protests against Sweden's state epidemiologist, not even outdoor demonstrations. Swedish police came down hard on a BLM demonstration in the summer of 2020. I don't know about Finland, Norway and Iceland in this respect, but we had a big BLM protest in Copenhagen at the time. Not a problem at all! And we had a few (much smaller!) protests by Covid deniers. It was allowed. In Sweden, it wasn't.

And I know, this won't persuade any minimizer that Sweden isn't a people of freedom fighters and everybody else scraredy cats cowering in fear of the common cold. Except ... why are minimizers so afraid of the truth that they always resort to hyperbole and disinformation? Why does it threaten their view of the world when they see people making an effort to stop spreading the virus, for instance by wearing a mask and only seeing grandma outdoors when there is a pandemic? Why do they portray infecting grandma and everybody else as the only sensible thing to do?
 
... why are minimizers so afraid of the truth that they always resort to hyperbole and disinformation? Why does it threaten their view of the world when they see people making an effort to stop spreading the virus, for instance by wearing a mask and only seeing grandma outdoors when there is a pandemic? Why do they portray infecting grandma and everybody else as the only sensible thing to do?


I have not noticed the word minimizer before, when it comes to describing attitudes towards the Covid-19 virus.

Are you possibly a maximizer?

The last quoted sentence is a typical example of your disinformation = lie.
 
I have not noticed the word minimizer before, when it comes to describing attitudes towards the Covid-19 virus.


Not everybody will have noticed, but the :sdl: in my previous post linked to a one-year-old article: From 'herd immunity' to today, Covid minimizers are still sabotaging our pandemic progress (The Guardian, Mar 29, 2022)
A much earlier example (not of the word but) of an actual Covid minimizer would be this Swedish article:

In the last two days, the number of people infected with the corona virus has increased sharply in Sweden. Now Anders Tegnell, who previously said that the climax would come on Saturday, backs down.
- I was a little too optimistic, he says to Aftonbladet.

When Aftonbladet interviewed Anders Tegnell, state epidemiologist at the Public Health Agency, on Thursday, he expected that the climax for all Swedes who were infected during the sports holiday celebrations in Italy would come "within one to two days". Tegnell said:
- If you count backwards and know that you have an incubation period of approximately five days, the number of travelers infected down there should decrease in the next few days. Most of those who are infected have now contracted the disease.
- I was a little too optimistic. I hadn't thought about or understood that it can take a few days in the system before the cases show up here in Sweden as well. It is not only the incubation period that applies, but you have to add a few more days before they are registred and diagnosed here in Sweden. Therefore, the peak seems to drag on for a few more days or more than I thought.
So the peak ends on Monday or Tuesday instead?
- Yes. Or the decline begins then.
The downturn starts on Tuesday?
- We'll see. These are difficult forecasts, there is always a large degree of uncertainty in them, says Tegnell.
Tegnell backs down: "Corona peaks on Monday or Tuesday" (Aftonbladet, Mar 8, 2020)


Other terms for this kind of person are COVID trivializer (used as early as April 2020) and COVID optimist (This one from Nov 27, 2021, but earlier examples exist).
 
Why Swedes can't bear criticism of Sweden's pandemic response

A short Swiss article in German about Sweden's pandemic response - with thirteen links to earlier articles about the same theme from 2020 and 2021:
Schweden in der Pandemie: Die vernichtende Bilanz (Die Mittelländische Zeitung, April 5, 2023)
Google's translation into English is quite good.
The article ends with a recommendation to Sweden about what it should do with its political culture.

On that note, I can also recommend another recent article, this one from CNN:
A Swedish glass paradise
As a travel writer and photographer, I regularly extol Sweden’s cultural and panoramic beauty I love so much through words and photography for various publications. I’ve also delved deep into understanding the Swedish psyche in my book LAGOM, which is translated into 18 foreign language editions, ironically except into Swedish, but I’m not surprised.
This unflinching need to always remain perfect and flawless is what continues to add to the tensions between various factions within society and an increasingly confusing global image.
Similar to every single character in my book, we’re all multi-dimensional, richly diverse, complex and messy human beings. We offer each other constructive feedback because we want each other to grow into better versions of ourselves.
Unfortunately here, any slight whiff of perceived criticism is considered an affront to the glass paradise that Sweden has built around its image. So, many people choose to silence their own voices and keep their lived stories untold, or risk exclusion from society.
Two things can always be true: You can be a world leader when it comes to certain issues and still have a lot of work to do in your own backyard.
For you to work on issues, you actually have to publicly acknowledge them. The UN issued an official report last year, urging Sweden to work on its systemic racism. That report was essentially glossed over here.
Sweden is very progressive in many ways. This cannot be argued and I love my adopted home for this.
The Swedish version of Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s We Should All Be Feminists is distributed freely to high school students across the country. The publishing industry is quick to bring in foreign authors and translate books that discuss trauma and heavy subjects set in other countries, except Sweden. Because bad things only happen somewhere else, not here.
Opinion: Why is Sweden afraid of publishing this book on race? (CNN, Mar 31, 2023)
 
An article in Science-Based Medicine today mentions some of the things that readers of this thread are familiar with:
A report by the government-appointed, independent Swedish Corona Commission later reported the unsurprising news that uncontrolled spread of the virus in the community was the “single most important factor behind the major outbreaks and the high number of deaths in residential care.” According to one damning investigation, “The Swedish people were kept in ignorance of basic facts such as the airborne SARS-CoV-2 transmission, that asymptomatic individuals can be contagious and that face masks protect both the carrier and others. ” Horrifyingly, it also found that:

"Many elderly people were administered morphine instead of oxygen despite available supplies, effectively ending their lives."
Yes, Schools Were Closed in Sweden (Science-Based Medicine, April 7, 2023)


But the main focus of the article is in on children and schools:
Children weren’t necessarily spared. Dr. Jonas Ludvigsson, a Swedish pediatrician and epidemiologist who was an original signer of the Great Barrington Declaration, claimed that there were “no major school outbreaks in Sweden,” even though such outbreaks had been reported in Swedish media. He also published a letter in The New England Journal of Medicine that claimed there had been no excess mortality in Swedish children in 2020 compared to 2019. However, in emails to Swedish chief epidemiologist Anders Tegnell from July 2020, Dr. Ludvigsson wrote “unfortunately we see a clear indication of excess mortality among children ages 7-16 old, the ages where ‘kids went to school.’”


Some of you are familiar with Mr. Steadson, who has told the author of the article what the pandemic has been like in Sweden.
Maybe some day Swedes will be able to look back and realize that they need to do a bit of pandemic Vergangenheitsbewältigung, but it doesn't come easy to them:
Redan långt före pandemin var landet bland de andra europeiska nationerna känt för att vara modernistiskt bäst på att förtränga det förflutna till förmån för framtiden. Länge har Sverige varit känt bland historiker att utmärka sig genom det lättstyrda folket som gör det lätt för politiken.
Om döendets konst (Dagens Arena, Oct 31, 2020)
Even a long time before the pandemic, the country was known by other European nations for being modernistically best at suppressing the past in favor of the future. For a long time, historians have known that people in Sweden are easy to rule, which makes things easy for the political establishment.
About the art of dying

This is why we need to remind them what actually happened. If we don't, it will be too easy for them to live in denial.
 
A new book by Sweden's C-19 vaccine coordinator criticizes Anders Tegnell and Sweden's Public Health Agency. Sweden's mainstream media isn't interested:

One of Sweden's top people during the pandemic, the vaccine coordinator Richard Bergström published a book this week, criticizing the PHA. None in the big print media thinks it's worth mentioning this, or review the book. Here's a Google News search for the title, last 7 days:
jorgenponder (on Twitter, April 22, 2023)
 
From a couple of posts back, I still find incomprehensible the idea it could ever be imagined to be not air borne, so how could this knowledge be kept from the people?
You need to know nothing about medicine to figure this was airborne like all winter illnesses. :confused:
 
How it started in Sweden is a bit convoluted:

The state epidemiologist Anders Tegnell was convinced that the best approach to the pandemic was to try to achieve herd immunity by infection. The faster, the better. He has denied this, but much like in the recent Fox case, we know about it because some of his emails were made public. There was a similar incongruity between what he was actually trying to accomplish and what he told the public. For instance, he wanted to keep schools open to avoid slowing down the spread of the virus (another thing we know from his emails), but he told people that school children didn't 'drive' the spread and that children were unaffected by the virus. It is no coincidence that Swedish school teachers were hit very hard.

On the same note, he not only claimed that face masks didn't prevent or slow down the transmission of the virus. According to Anders Tegnell, face masks were actually dangerous and helped spread the virus (which, of course, was what he was trying to accomplish). When he got wind of the ECDC's plans to declare that the virus was airborne, he protested because it would ruin Sweden's no-mask pandemic strategy.

There is reason (but no evidence) to assume that his accomplice Johan Giesecke, an adviser to WHO, may have contributed to the delay of that organization's declaration that the virus is airborne.

From the beginning, Tegnell's statements about SARS-CoV-2 were absurd: herd immunity would be accomplished next week, then next month, and next month and next month. When tests in the early fall of 2020 showed that relatively few people had been infected, it was hypothesized that herd immunity by infection had already been achieved, but for some reason it just didn't show up in the analyzed blood samples. Even one of Tegnell's critics believed so in October 2020.

So Sweden leaned back, mask-free, with very few restrictions and without a care in the world, expecting to be able to enjoy watching the other Nordic countries be inundated by the virus in the winter of 2020-21. And then the second wave in 2020-22 hit Sweden harder than the first one.

Watching Sweden's pandemic response has been like watching a comedy like The Death of Stalin or a tragedy like Chernobyl. Swedish nationalism helped make any critic of the country's pandemic response look like a traitor. One of those tragicomical moments was when the Italian ambassador to Sweden protested after Tegnell had declared that there was no reason to fear Italian conditions because Sweden's old people were much healthier and Sweden was much better prepared to deal with a pandemic. (Those primitive Mediterraneans!) Another one was when Tegnell declared that New Zealand couldn't possibly have ZeroCovid: "Impossible!" And the Swedish media hardly ever confronted him. Another tragicomical moment was when Ann Linde, minister of foreign affairs, met with a well-prepared journalist from Deutsche Welle (June 18, 2020)! A wonderful example of an arrogant ******* who had been used to talking only to subservient Swedish journalists. As for her claim that "we managed to flatten the curve":
Daily new confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people.

Swedes were also (and still are) convinced that Swedish science is superior to science in the rest of the world, so early meticulous studies of the transmissions of the virus (for instance the South Korean restaurant study) were ignored. Scandinavians are generally good at English, but unless they are professionals, they have a hard time reading studies like this one, so in general they depended on the information they got from local health authorities.

The other Nordics fared much better than Sweden until the winter of 2021-22 mainly because they relied on what their own statistics told them about the spread of the virus and the efficacy of restrictions (which were anything but 'draconian'). The (at first, daily) press briefings were to the point. We were presented with the unadulterated facts. In Sweden, press briefings with Anders Tegnell were absurd, always beginning with a story about how awful conditions were in the rest of the world before he began talking about the situation in Sweden, using plenty of euphemisms like 'a slightly rising plateau', which was always used when a new wave was really starting to take off or 'stable' when the level of transmission was high but no longer rising.

But after the majority of the populations had been vaccinated and the elderly boosted in the fall of 2021, the other Nordics adopted a vaccine-modified version of the Swedish strategy of letting it rip. After the vaccinations, we were expected to develop 'super immunity' or 'hybrid immunity' by getting infected. The death toll makes it obvious that the idea was absurd. Notice what happened in the other four Nordics when they let it rip after the vaccinations. It wasn't enough to catch up with Sweden's pre-vaccination herd-immunity-by-infection strategy even though Finland comes close.
I haven't heard anybody mention 'super immunity' since the summer of 2022. Nowadays, the other Nordic countries are as much in denial of the pandemic as Sweden was from the very beginning.

And at this point, the whole world seems to be in denial of the pandemic strategies of countries like Cuba and Singapore, which don't think that it's a good idea for their populations to 'learn to live with the virus'. The way to achieve ZeroCovid nowadays is to stop testing and pretend that it's gone.
 
New book by Johanthan Howard: We Want Them Infected (Redhawk Publications)
"How the failed quest for herd immunity led doctors to embrace the anti-vaccine movement ..."
But unlike Richard Bergström's recent book release Vaccinjägaren, it's not about Sweden this time: ... and blinded Americans to the threat of COVID.
 
The challenge for antivaxxers in a country like NZ is to show that the enacted policy resulted in more deaths than would have been the case without lockdowns and mandates. This of course can't be done.
I think the antivaxxers figure the deaths were never to involve them.

Of course many were financially ruined. That unfortunately is the other side of the coin. I see regularly two men in their 70s who would be dead by a let it rip policy, they are very grateful to Ardern, but of course financially independent.

Tegnell is an interesting experimenter, similar experiments are going on with gender for example, where money rules.
Tegnell must have saved the state a poultice by deliberately killing the aged. I say deliberately in recalling his top down command to not send them to hospital.
 
I don't think Tegnell even mentioned not sending the aged to hospital, i.e. palliative care for the elderly instead of oxygen. His very .... theoretical ... stance was that Sweden should:
1) protect the elderly from getting infected while letting the virus rip through the younger generations, who would then get herd immunity by infection;
2) slow down the transmission of the virus only if it threatened to inundate hospitals with Covid-19 patients.

As for
1), he never mentioned how the elderly were to be protected, and he never tried to find out if protecting them was even possible. He didn't consider it to be his responsibility to do so;
2), Sweden managed to get through the pandemic with vacant ICUs by letting old people die in their homes, i.e. palliative care instead of oxygen. Patients of a certain age weren't even visitited by a doctor; long-distance triage.

Yngve Gustafson, a professor of geriatrics at the University of Umeå, has alleged that some elderly COVID-19 patients in Swedish hospitals and nursing homes who could have survived with more active treatment were instead prematurely referred to palliative or hospice care, and that this has resulted in unnecessary deaths.[225] Politicians and health care workers in Sweden have also debated whether elder care homes have been too reluctant to transfer older patients to higher levels of care for fear of overwhelming the hospital system, and whether restrictions on scope of practice should have been relaxed to allow more patients in care homes to receive oxygen therapy without being transferred to hospital.[226]Swedish government response to the COVID-19 pandemic: Debate and criticism (Wikipedia)


In mid-March 2020, a kind of pox party for SARS-CoV-2 seemed like a good idea based on how little we knew at the time. I thought so myself: COVID-19 Party - A Modest Proposal (ISF » Members Only » Forum Community, March 12, 2020)
But it soon became clear that young people could get seriously ill and even die and old people couldn't be isolated and would get infected by visitors or care workers. It became obvious that it was necessary to do whatever we could to prevent transmission of the virus in people of all ages. The best way to protect the elderly was to reduce the general level of contagion. Sweden was a brilliant example of what happened if we didn't.
That Sweden's herd-immunity-by-infection strategy didn't work had become clear as early as April. Comparisons between Sweden and the other Nordic countries made it obvious that lockdowns worked even when they weren't very strict.
We also had Rolfe and her knowledge about viruses to guide us. She was spot on from the very beginning.


ETA: In the post I link to above, Rolfe said (on April 10, 2020):
The countries that win Covid-19 will be the ones which kept the largest proportion of their population alive by the time the vaccine appears. It's not going to be us, or America, or Sweden, or the Netherlands. New Zealand is a good one to bet on. So is Iceland. Maybe even South Korea.
Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people in USA, UK, Sweden, Netherlands, Iceland, South Korea, New Zealand (and I've added Cuba and Singapore).
I think the Netherlands stopped reporting in January 2023.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom