Let us take a closer look at FatherLukeduke's article.
Bolding is his, not mine.
It goes wrong from the beginning. The guy who is supposed to be Norway's top epidemiologist in the headline turns out to be just one of them in the article. He is not the Norwegian epidemiologist who was often described as the 'Norway's Tegnell' during the pandemic. I never heard about him until now.
One of Norway’s leading epidemiologists has claimed that criticism of Sweden’s Covid strategy was excessive. Preben Aavitsland, who served as Director for Surveillance at the Norwegian Institute of Public Health, argued that other countries “hid their own insecurities by scolding Sweden” because the country “undermined their mantra that we had no choice”.
To a fan of Anders Tegnell, I guess any criticism appears to be excessive. If he had an actual argument for this, it isn't presented in the summary of the article. I doubt that Norway's pandemic response had 'the mantra that they had no choice'. I never heard of such a mantra in the Nordics. I didn't follow Norway as closely as I did Sweden and Denmark, but the impression I got was that Norwegians were presented with the facts of the pandemic, much like the Danes but unlike the Swedes.
But the weirdest thing about this is that the other Nordic countries never really scolded Sweden or the Swedish pandemic strategy. A couple of times when Tegnell made comparisons with neighboring countries that were obvious lies, Norwegian and Danish newspapers mentioned it and asked him about it, but he never replied. And it was hardly ever mentioned by Swedish media when it happened.
In comments made to Swedish paper SvD, Aavitsland explained that while Norway’s “harder line” may have prolonged the lives of old people, he added that the model of “long, hard lockdowns” that was inspired by Italy and China made Sweden “the contrast they did not want”. Sweden “forced them to explain to their citizens why they acted as they did,” the epidemiologist explained. “For these people, it would have been better if everyone had done the same”.
That is a mantra that was repeated by Covid minimizers throughout the first years of the pandemic: Lockdowns were
always hard (or
draconian), even when they weren't. But in the Nordic countries lockdowns were never anywhere near what happened in Italy and China. People were never forced to stay at home. They could go outside as much as they pleased. Supermarkets weren't closed but it was recommended that whole families didn't go shopping together when it didn't take more than one person from each household to buy groceries. A very sensible recommendation to prevent the spread of an airborne virus like SARS-CoV-2 - and it also helped prevent the spread of the flu, which may have been the reason why 'excess mortality' in the Nordics (apart from Sweden) dropped below zero in 2020.
The alleged hard lockdown consisted mainly in schools resorting to online education, and public venues like movies theaters, and restaurants, cafes and nightclubs locking down along with hairdressers and similar professions.
It was enough, it worked, and the owners and workers of that kind of establishments were compensated. That these soft (?), mild (?), lockdowns wouldn't have worked in much more densely populated countries goes without saying. Conditions in the Nordic countries were favorable.
Unlike the rest of Europe, Sweden largely avoided implementing mandatory lockdowns, instead relying on voluntary curbs on social gatherings, and keeping most schools, restaurants, bars and businesses open. This made Sweden an outlier, turning the country’s then-chief state epidemiologist Anders Tegnell into a hate figure, as he received death threats and urges to resign throughout the pandemic. This month, he told his successor to “have ice in your stomach”.
Yes, it's true! Keeping those things open did indeed make Sweden an outlier:
Daily new confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people in the Nordics, March 1 to Sep 1, 2020. Is it so hard to understand why people urged the state epidemiologist to resign with those results? He was the guy who not only urged schools to be kept open to help achieve herd immunity by infection, but he also asked the ECDC not to declare that the virus spread as airborne aerosols because that would make it obvious that his own claim about face masks being
dangerous was absurd. Tegnell probably lied about face masks for the same reason that he lied about schools and the spreading virus: He
wanted people to spread it in order to achieve herd immunity by infection. He was worried (!) that it wouldn't spread fast enough.
Despite avoiding strict lockdowns, SvD claims that Sweden’s excess mortality was the lowest out of all EU nations, including Nordic countries. While this claim is disputed, numerous studies have shown Sweden’s excess death rate to be among the lowest in Europe. Figures by the World Health Organisation, for example, show that in 2020 and 2021, the country had an average excess death rate of 56 per 100,000 — compared to 109 in the UK, 111 in Spain, 116 in Germany and 133 in Italy.
As it turns out, Sweden's excess mortality wasn't the lowest in EU countries. That it was lower than in many other EU countries was due to the things that the Nordics have in common:
"pre-existing conditions in those countries: low population densities (Denmark is the outlier in this respect with a population density of 137 per km2; Sweden #2 with 25 per km2), number of people per household, and probably even the attitude to social distancing, which tends to come 'naturally' to the Nordics." See
post 1,222.
UK: 277 per km2Spain: 94 per km2Germany: 240 per km2Italy: 206 per km2
But Aavitsland stressed that a pandemic response could not be judged on excess deaths alone. “We also have to look at how people’s physical and mental health has been affected, school results and drop-outs, unemployment and social economy and other things,” he said. He went on to compliment the Swedish Public Health Agency’s communication over Norway’s, saying that it created less fear. “They gave more advice than threatened punishment,” the epidemiologist noted.
So why don't we hear about
"people's physical and mental health" etc? Aavitsland merely
implies that Sweden must have fared so much better than everybody else, but where are the numbers showing that this was actually the case?
As for
"creating less fear" and giving
"more advice" instead of threatening
"punishment": The daily press briefings in Sweden were farcical with Tegnell alway trying to make his strategy look good by coming up with euphemism for what was happening instead of presenting the facts and what they meant. I no longer remember all his hilarious terms, but I think that
'a slightly rising plateau' was one of them. And he always started with a presentation of how bad it was everywhere else, which made it easier for him to make it seem as if everything was fine in Sweden even when it wasn't.
I didn't follow the Norwegian press briefings, but the ones in Denmark were always fact-based: a presentation of the numbers, the impact that restrictions and behavior seemed to have, if more were needed or if they could be relaxed, and pretty
realistic predictions. Unlike Tegnell's! During most of the first year of the pandemic, he always predicted herd immunity next week or next month, and in the late summer/early fall of 2020, he claimed that Sweden had actually achieved the goal: herd immunity!
So in a way it's true: Anders Tegnell
"created less fear" - by consistently
lying about the pandemic! By the way, I don't remember
punishment being mentioned.
Fear may have been one reason as to why there were so few protests from the Norwegian population, which surprised Aavitsland. He said that it was “almost a little scary” what the population “accepts without protesting”. “We forbade families to visit their grandmother in the nursing home, we denied men attendance at their children’s births, we limited the number who were allowed to attend church at funerals,” he said. “Maybe people are willing to accept very strong restrictions if the fear is great enough”.
One reason as to why there were so few protests from the Norwegian population may have been that Norwegians received actual information about what was going on, actual facts. They were informed about the pandemic and the measures against it, understood what was going on, so why protest? They didn't want to kill their grandparents and didn't want to spread the virus in hospitals or in churches. That Aavitsland finds this
"almost a little scary" is pathetic. One shouldn't live in fear, and he has no reason to be scared.
And speaking of
protesting: This is one of the pandemic measures that Sweden took
very seriously! Protests of more than 50 (if I remember correctly) people weren't allowed! So there is no reason to wonder why there were no mass protests against Sweden's state epidemiologist, not even outdoor demonstrations. Swedish police came down hard on a BLM demonstration in the summer of 2020. I don't know about Finland, Norway and Iceland in this respect, but we had a big BLM protest in Copenhagen at the time. Not a problem at all! And we had a few (much smaller!)
protests by Covid deniers. It was allowed. In Sweden, it wasn't.
And I know, this won't persuade any minimizer that Sweden isn't a people of freedom fighters and everybody else scraredy cats cowering in fear of the common cold. Except ... why are minimizers so
afraid of the truth that they always resort to hyperbole and disinformation? Why does it threaten their view of the world when they see people making an effort to stop spreading the virus, for instance by wearing a mask and only seeing grandma outdoors when there is a pandemic? Why do they portray infecting grandma and everybody else as the only sensible thing to do?