In the spring of 2020, Swedes were adamant that the many coronavirus deaths were worth it because schools weren't locked down during the pandemic (see, for instance, post 611, May 19, 2020). And nowadays we are told that Swedish schools stayed open because we followed science (Telegraph, Mar 10, 2023).
However, keeping schools open without masks or quarantines doubled Swedish teachers' COVID-19 risk (Science, Feb 15, 2021), and yesterday we heard that Keeping schools open during the pandemic may be at the cost of knowledge (Kvartal.se, April 25, 2023).
Quotations from the article in a Twitter thread (translation from Swedish):
The Twitter thread has an interesting graph of Number of instruction days (excluding school holidays, public holidays and weekends) where schools were fully closed in 2020 - Primary and upper-secondary general education.
However, keeping schools open without masks or quarantines doubled Swedish teachers' COVID-19 risk (Science, Feb 15, 2021), and yesterday we heard that Keeping schools open during the pandemic may be at the cost of knowledge (Kvartal.se, April 25, 2023).
Quotations from the article in a Twitter thread (translation from Swedish):
But in retrospect it seems more uncertain that Sweden actually succeeded in this respect, in absolute terms or in comparison with other countries. Because even if the students were technically supposed to be taught in the schools, it often wasn't the case.
(...)
Much higher spread of infection than in many other countries, and by far the highest in the Nordic countries, in combination with the Public Health Agency's recommendations to stay at home at the slightest cold symptoms, led to a sharp increase in sick leave among both students and staff in elementary school. This also worsened the quality of classroom teaching among participating students due to canceled lessons, substitute teaching and a slower pace of teaching.
(...)
It is a fact that keeping Swedish primary schools "open" during the pandemic may, ironically, have resulted in more absenteeism, more instability and more sudden changes for the students in comparison to having locked down during continuous periods of high spread of the virus like in many other countries. In this context, it is relevant to consider that attendance during teacher-led sessions in the (locked down) Swedish upper secondary school actually seems to have increased during the pandemic among both students and teachers – in stark contrast to the situation in primary schools. So is the fact that mental illness actually decreased among students in high school compared to students in middle school.
https://twitter.com/killedbyproxy/status/1650974072845615104
The Twitter thread has an interesting graph of Number of instruction days (excluding school holidays, public holidays and weekends) where schools were fully closed in 2020 - Primary and upper-secondary general education.
Last edited: