Cont: Sweden's liberal pandemic strategy questioned as Stockholm death toll mounts (Part 2)

In the spring of 2020, Swedes were adamant that the many coronavirus deaths were worth it because schools weren't locked down during the pandemic (see, for instance, post 611, May 19, 2020). And nowadays we are told that Swedish schools stayed open because we followed science (Telegraph, Mar 10, 2023).

However, keeping schools open without masks or quarantines doubled Swedish teachers' COVID-19 risk (Science, Feb 15, 2021), and yesterday we heard that Keeping schools open during the pandemic may be at the cost of knowledge (Kvartal.se, April 25, 2023).

Quotations from the article in a Twitter thread (translation from Swedish):
But in retrospect it seems more uncertain that Sweden actually succeeded in this respect, in absolute terms or in comparison with other countries. Because even if the students were technically supposed to be taught in the schools, it often wasn't the case.
(...)
Much higher spread of infection than in many other countries, and by far the highest in the Nordic countries, in combination with the Public Health Agency's recommendations to stay at home at the slightest cold symptoms, led to a sharp increase in sick leave among both students and staff in elementary school. This also worsened the quality of classroom teaching among participating students due to canceled lessons, substitute teaching and a slower pace of teaching.
(...)
It is a fact that keeping Swedish primary schools "open" during the pandemic may, ironically, have resulted in more absenteeism, more instability and more sudden changes for the students in comparison to having locked down during continuous periods of high spread of the virus like in many other countries. In this context, it is relevant to consider that attendance during teacher-led sessions in the (locked down) Swedish upper secondary school actually seems to have increased during the pandemic among both students and teachers – in stark contrast to the situation in primary schools. So is the fact that mental illness actually decreased among students in high school compared to students in middle school.
https://twitter.com/killedbyproxy/status/1650974072845615104


The Twitter thread has an interesting graph of Number of instruction days (excluding school holidays, public holidays and weekends) where schools were fully closed in 2020 - Primary and upper-secondary general education.
 
Last edited:
Sweden was the go to example for NZ media like talk back queen Kerre McIvor, how to live with covid.
I remember like yesterday. I think Stephen Franks also.
My brother was anti lockdowns because the economic cost would be too great but his golfing partner was a doctor who saw the long term effects of the Spanish flu.
Very keen on the lockdowns accordingly.

Death is for other people of course.
 
The current state of the discourse in Sweden. A doctor, in one of the nation's major healthcare periodicals, actively encouraging people to go out sick and infect others. Normal stuff... 🤷*♂️https://twitter.com/dagensmedicin/status/1654467140232069120
Nicholas Loubere (Twitter, May 5, 2023)

Translation from the article:
"Relax and embrace your cold! It shows that you are alive! Take two Alvedon, nasal spray, and go to work. Cough on a colleague, sneezed on a friend, sneeze on a child," writes Henrik Widegren in this week's guest column.


Some criticism of the Swedish pandemic strategy does seep through in Swedish media, although it is relegated to the letters to the Editor section.
Today in the biggest morning paper by Stefan Hanson, ID doctor & PhD.
"FHM" is the Public Health Agency: https://www.dn.se/insandare/hog-tid-att-regeringen-svarar-pa-kritiken-mot-pandemihanteringen/
jorgenponder (Twitter, May 7, 2023)

See translation of excerpts in the tweet.
 
Swedish Aftonbladet, May 5, 2023:
Right Now: WHO: The pandemic is over

WHO:
COVID-19 over as a global health emergency.
However, that does not mean COVID-19 is over as a global health threat.
Last week, COVID-19 claimed a life every three minutes – and that’s just the deaths we know about.
As we speak, thousands of people around the world are fighting for their lives in intensive care units.
And millions more continue to live with the debilitating effects of post-COVID-19 condition.
This virus is here to stay. It is still killing, and it’s still changing. The risk remains of new variants emerging that cause new surges in cases and deaths.
The worst thing any country could do now is to use this news as a reason to let down its guard, to dismantle the systems it has built, or to send the message to its people that COVID-19 is nothing to worry about.
WHO Director-General's opening remarks at the media briefing (WHO, May 5, 2023)
 
Covid pandemic handling: Swedish media headlines today are actually roundly criticizing the Public Health Agency, based on a new report from the National Audit Office.
jorgenponder (Twitter, May 25, 2023)
See translated headlines in the tweet.

I doubt that it will have much of an impact on Sweden's attitude to its pandemic response. Earlier critical reports, for instance the Final report by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences’ Expert Group on COVID-19, were more or less ignored.

As mentioned in post 1,235, a recent book, Vaccinjägaren, (The Vaccine Hunter), by Richard Bergström, Sweden's vaccine coordinator at the start of the pandemic, got almost no coverage in the Swedish media. It was very critical of Anders Tegnell and the Swedish People's Health Authority.
 
Sweden's liberal pandemic strategy praised - by DeSantis

Berömde Sveriges hantering av coronapandemin
På väg från mötet fick han också svara på om han hade något budskap till Sverige.
– Sverige hanterade covid fantastiskt. De gjorde ett bra jobb, svarade han.
DeSantis om Sverige: Ni gjorde ett bra jobb med covid (SVT.se, June 3, 2023)
Praised Sweden's handling of the pandemic
On his way from the meeting, he also got the opportunity to say if he had any message for Sweden.
- Sweden's handling of Covid was fantastic. They did a good job, he answered.
Desantins about Sweden: You did a good job of COVID-19
 
Högt tryck på akutmottagningen vid Norrlands universitetssjukhus (MyNewsDesk, June 27, 2023)
High pressure on the emergency department at Norrland University Hospital

Norrlands universitetssjukhus i Umeå gick under torsdagen upp i förstärkningsläge för att hantera bristen på vårdplatser.
Norrlands universitetssjukhus upp i förstärkningsläge (DagensMedicin.se, June 29, 2023)
Norrland University Hospital in Umeå went into reinforcement mode on Thursday to deal with the lack of care places.
Norrland University Hospital in reinforcement mode

För en vecka sedan, den 29 juni, gick Norrlands universitetssjukhus i Umeå upp i förstärkningsläge efter en natt med en vårdplatsbrist som tog sig extrema uttryck. Sjukhuset var knökfullt och personalen var tvungen att köra ner patientsängar på akuten för att vårda patienter där.
Fortsatt förstärkningsläge på Nus – men på sjukhuset anas en ljusning (Läkartidningen.se, July 6, 2023)
A week ago, on June 29, Norrland University Hospital (NUH) in Umeå went into reinforcement mode after a night with a shortage of care places that took extreme forms. The hospital was chockfull and the staff had to take patient beds down to the emergency room to care for patients there.
Continued reinforcement mode at NUH - but a light at the end of the tunnel is perceived at the hospital


I find it weird that they don't say what caused the onrush of patients. If they had been injured by social distancing measures, I'm sure they would have told us.
 
In other Swedish news:

En fortsatt ökad risk för blodpropp i lungan fanns långt efter covid19, visar en stor svensk registerstudie.
För de som var sjuka i hemmet var risken fyra gånger så hög upp till två månader efter sjukdomen. För de som var inlagda på sjukhus höll den risken i sig i ett och ett halvt år.
"För att motverka proppar är det bra att gå upp röra sig" säger medicinprofessor Annika Rosengren.
Covid-19 ökade risk för proppar (SverigesRadio.se, July 7, 2023)
A large Swedish registry study shows an increased risk of blood clots in the lungs remains for a long after COVID-19 infection.
For people who were sick at home, the risk was four times higher for as much as two months after the illness. For people who were hospitalized, the risk persisted for a year and a half.
"To counteract clots, it's good to get up and move," says medical professor Annika Rosengren.
Covid-19 increased the risk of blood clots


Yes, exercise is almost always good, but it is probably even healthier to avoid getting COVID-19.
 
Last edited:
New Swedish study:
The most common post COVID-19 symptoms were altered smell and taste (68.8%), dyspnea (33.7%) and fatigue (30.4%). Overall, no major risk factors for post COVID-19 were identified except for being bedbound during COVID-19. However, asthma and rhinitis were associated with the post COVID-19 symptom dyspnea, migraine with altered smell and taste, and lower self-rated health with fatigue. In conclusion, post COVID-19 symptoms are common, also among young adults in the general population. Although not life-threatening, it could have a considerable impact on public health due to the high prevalence and long-term symptoms.
Post COVID-19 symptoms are common, also among young adults in the general population (Nature, July 12, 2023)
 
Sweden's children were not isolated like other children in the world, FHM has said, and now the same authority announces that Swedish children suffer from nasty infections due to isolation in the pandemic.
Sveriges barn isolerades inte som andra barn i världen har FHM berättat och nu meddelar samma myndighet att svenska barn drabbas av otäcka infektioner p.g.a. att de isolerats.
#flockdown
#källtillit
Translate Tweet:
Sweden's children were not isolated like other children in the world, FHM has told, and now the same authority announces that Swedish children suffer from nasty infections because they were isolated.
Rikard Hellqvist (Twitter, July 27, 2023)

N A Nielsen (Twitter, July 28, 2023)

In a perverse way, the attitude has been consistent.
 
At last, herd immunity (again)

I haven't counted the many times it was claimed that Sweden had achieved herd immunity, but I think that the most recent one was in March:
Message to the world:
Please take note of the fact that Sweden’s Chief Epidemiologist claims that Sweden has reached herd immunity in 2023 through repeated infections.
Nwiss (Twitter, Aug 14, 2023)

GöteborgSverige har nu en flockimmunitet mot covid-19, menar professor Magnus Gisslén. Tre år in i pandemin tänker han att man delvis kan lämna tankarna på viruset bakom sig.
– Så småningom handlar det om att ha infektionen upprepade gånger, säger han i Nyhetsshowen.
Professor Magnus Gisslén om coronaläget: "Vi har flockimmunitet nu" (GP.se, Mar 3, 2023)
Sweden now has herd immunity against COVID-19, says Professor Magnus Gisslén. Three years into the pandemic, he thinks that we can more or less stop thinking about the virus.
"It has become a question of getting infected repeatedly," he says in the News Show.
Professor Magnus Gisslén on the corona situation: "We have herd immunity now"

Gisslén has been rewarded with Anders Tegnell's old job as Swedish state epidemiologist:
Magnus Gisslén er ny statsepidemiolog i Sverige (Altinget.dk, May 30, 2023)

I am not sure that Sweden's new state epidemiologist knows how immunity works. So not really a big contrast to the old one.
 
No news isn't always good news:
Sedan i mitten på juli har antalet covid 19-fall ökat gradvis och är tillbaka på liknande nivåer som före sommaren.
(...)
Ökningen förväntas att fortsätta under hösten och vintern. Covid-19 är ett luftvägsvirus och de brukar spridas mer under höst och vinter.
Covid-19 ökar i Stockholms län (SVT.se, Sep 15, 2023)
Since mid-July, the number of covid-19 cases has gradually increased and is back at similar levels as before this summer.
(...)
The increase is expected to continue during autumn and winter. Covid-19 is a respiratory virus and they tend to spread more during autumn and winter.
Covid-19 is increasing in Stockholm County


I assume that Sweden's Public Health Agency will recommend that people start washing their hands again ...
 
'Immunity debt'

The pediatrician Ludvigsson promoted Sweden's herd-immunity-by-infection strategy. He was proud that Sweden didn't have school lockdowns. Now, he claims that lockdowns are the reason why so many Swedish kids get seriously ill from other infections: Their immune systems allegedly got lazy because they weren't exposed to infections.

For two or three years, the children's immune systems were not strained. It's like not doing running exercises and then running a long distance. You are less fit and your body tires fast. It is the same logic when it comes to children who have not experienced infections for a long time. They are worse at protecting themselves.
Niels A Nielsen (Twitter/X, Sep 17, 2023)

From Swedish Aftonbladet: Barnläkaren: Därför blir fler barn svårt sjuka (Aftonbladet.se, Aug 26, 2023)

That COVID-19 may weaken the immunes system is not a possibility worth considering for this Swedish doctor:
Severe COVID-19 Can Alter Long-term Immune System Response (Weill Cornell Medicine, Aug 18, 2023)

Outside of Sweden, it makes people wonder:
In Sweden, where he was working until moving to Imperial in October 2021, the incidence of RSV was markedly unusual last year too.
(...)
Besides, he adds, how then to explain that RSV is also running riot now in Sweden, which famously eschewed lockdowns and kept schools open? Those who have noisily championed the Swedish approach to the pandemic can hardly argue that it would have made any difference to our alleged immunity debt now. In short, Brodin says, it is much too simplistic to say: “What we’re seeing in children’s hospitals is simply the result of lockdown.” Besides, Levin adds: “Lockdown was an essential public health measure. It was the right strategy for a new disease with a totally susceptible population and probably saved thousands of lives.”
Immunity debt: does it really exist? (TheGuardian, Jan 14, 2023)
Ludvigsson can argue anything, obviously!


ETA:
In Sweden, immunity debt is religion. An example subtitled in English from Swedish local radio, an interview with a school physician.
jorgenponder (Twitter/X, Sep 16, 2023
 
Last edited:
A Little More 'Immunity Debt'

What do MARS500, HI-SEAS, SIRIUS and ISS have in common?
They're all experiments where people have been put in "lockdown" for months (520 days in one case) and intensively studied for subsequent health issues.
None reported "immunity debt" from lack of exposure to pathogens.
David Steadson #NAFO (Twitter/X, Sep 19, 2023)
Yup, in the twin study (Astronauts Scott and Mark Kelly), immune function was back to normal within 6 months.
David Steadson #NAFO (Twitter/X, Sep 20, 2023)
The NASA Twins Study: A multidimensional analysis of a year-long human spaceflight (PubMed, April 12, 2019)

The sole purpose of the 'immunity debt' idea was obviously misdirection: to make it seem as if ailments caused by COVID-19 are due to lockdowns and isolation.

Hvorfor nogle promoverer at det er godt at 'træne' immunforsvaret med gentagne corona infektioner ved jeg ikke
Det udstiller deres egen manglende forståelse af immunologi og virologi.
Det er bestemt ikke godt at blive smittet med corona igen & igen. Det viser utallige studier
Astrid Iversen, Professor of Virology and Immunology, University of Oxford; views my own. (Twitter/X, Sep 17, 2023)
 
Anders Tegnell, the former Swedish state epidemiologist, has now embraced herd immunity by vaccination and pretends that he never thought otherwise. He now calls his herd-immunity-by-infection strategy "completely foreign and unethical"!
You have got to be ******* kidding me. :mad:

Anders Tegnell:
"For those of us that work with infectiions, it was a strange debate and a strange way of looking at it. Herd immunity means that vaccines prevent many people from getting sick and thus limit the spread of infection"
David Steadson (Twitter/X, Oct 14, 2023)

"It is a completely foreign and unethical idea that one would let people get sick and die to save the most, it doesn't work like that"
I've got the ******* receipts.
David Steadson (Twitter/X, Oct 14, 2023)

Text in Swedish:
"Flockimmunitet blev ett begrep på alla läppar, en tanke om att immunitet skulle uppnås om många människor blev sjuka.
- För oss som arbetat med smittor blev det en märklig debatt och et konstigt sätt att se på det. Flockimmunitet innebär att man genom vaccin gör att många människor inte kan bli sjuka och på så vis begränsa smittspridning, exempelvis när vi vaccinerar mot mässlingen. Det är en helt främmande och oetisk idé att man skulle låta människor bli sjuka och dö för att rädda de flesta, det fungerar inte så.


Tegnell 2023: ”Covid är luftburet, det sprids när vi andas”
Tegnell 2020 till ECDC: ”[munskyddsrekommendation] skulle indikera att covid är luftburet vilket skulle allvarligt skada fortsatt kommunikation och förtroendet hos folket och vårdpersonal”
Fokus: Skydda förtroendet.
Mårten (Twitter/X, Oct 15, 2023)
Translation:
Tegnell 2023: "Covid is airborne, it spread when we are breathing"
Tegnell 2020 to ECDC: "[recommending face masks] would indicate that Covid is airborne, which would seriously damage further communication and the people's and the health-care workers' confidence"
Focus: Protect the confidence
 
Like in most Western countries right now, the infection is on the rise:
Sweden -
50% increase in Covid cases in a week (note: testing is only in aged care and hospitals) and a big increase in the number of hospitalised.
Anders Tegnell's replacement Magnus Gisslén - "but they're not that sick"
They're in hospital FFS.
David Steadson (Twitter/X, Nov 2, 2023)


It doesn't help that Sweden has postponed vaccinations till Nov 7.
 
Like in most Western countries right now, the infection is on the rise:

50% increase in Covid cases in a week (note: testing is only in aged care and hospitals) and a big increase in the number of hospitalised.

It doesn't help that Sweden has postponed vaccinations till Nov 7.
In New Zealand reported cases are staying low, but wastewater detections are spiking and hospitalizations are back up to where they were in April. My conclusion - more people aren't reporting their Covid infections. Many probably aren't testing for it and may not even know they have it!

The other interesting statistic is that (reported) reinfections are on the rise, now hitting 56%. However with so much under-reporting that may not be significant.
 
The levels are rising in wastewater samples in Denmark, too, along with the number of hospitalizations. Same thing in Finland. I don't know about Norway.
Only 65+ and the immunocompromised are eligible for C-19 vaccinations in Denmark. The health authorities still seem to think that herd immunity by infection is fine for the rest of the population.
And unlike NZ, winter is coming.
 
In New Zealand reported cases are staying low, but wastewater detections are spiking and hospitalizations are back up to where they were in April. My conclusion - more people aren't reporting their Covid infections. Many probably aren't testing for it and may not even know they have it!

The other interesting statistic is that (reported) reinfections are on the rise, now hitting 56%. However with so much under-reporting that may not be significant.


You appear to have a vaccine problem in NZ:
A pity that kiwis can't get the latest vaccines here until 6-8 months after the rest of the world. That will not help the uptake.
NZ now has a vaccine strategy only, but without the vaccines.
WicMar (Twitter/X, Nov 11, 2023)


The vaccines may not have reached their sell-by-date, but they have been rendered more or less useless by the mutations that now let the Pirola variant evade previously acquired immunity.
I already mentioned that Sweden postponed Covid boosters till Nov 9. Some people suspect that it may have been an attempt to expose people to the virus unprotected in order to have them acquire herd immunity by infection. I think it may simply have been an attempt to save money by vaccination them later, so the immunity wouldn't have vaned by late winter/early spring.
If true, I don't think it's a rational calculation. All in all, I think it might be cheaper to buy new updated vaccines in February instead of exposing people to the virus before they were boosted.

Is it a somewhat similar calculation in NZ?
'Let's not let the ineffective vaccines go to waste. They may be outdated and not offer much protection, but since we already have them, let's use them anyway. Having to buy the ones that actually work against the current variants is costly.'

Danes could get vaccinated since Oct 1, but only 65+ and other risk groups, which doesn't help young (and even middle-aged) people, who have been told that they are spending too much time on sick leave!!!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom