Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

Well, my son's class is closed today because a lot of kids are off sick. Presumably this is because of Covid.

In Japan, and no doubt elsewhere, there is a system called gakkyuu heisa, or school closures due to spreading illnesses. In recent years it was mostly used for flu, but a load of kids from my son's school are off, so a few classes have shut down, and it may end up being the whole school.

Looking at the news, it seems this is also happening in Niigata, Kanagawa, Chiba, Kyushu and Okayama, so it is spreading far and wide.

This completely makes sense to me. However, the difference between flu and Covid is that with Covid it is less predictable seasonally.
 
Well, my son's class is closed today because a lot of kids are off sick. Presumably this is because of Covid.

In Japan, and no doubt elsewhere, there is a system called gakkyuu heisa, or school closures due to spreading illnesses. In recent years it was mostly used for flu, but a load of kids from my son's school are off, so a few classes have shut down, and it may end up being the whole school.

Looking at the news, it seems this is also happening in Niigata, Kanagawa, Chiba, Kyushu and Okayama, so it is spreading far and wide.

This completely makes sense to me. However, the difference between flu and Covid is that with Covid it is less predictable seasonally.
We don't really know the seasonable pattern with COVID yet, it might take years to settle into one.

School outbreaks of respiratory infections, OTOH, are quite predictable. The few kids passing something around in the summer go to school in Sept (in the northern hemisphere) and pass it around to whole classes full of kids. By Oct the kids have gone home and infected the parents. And by Nov the working parents have passed the infections on to their coworkers who don't have kids in school. By this time the illnesses are spreading through the whole community.

Influenza oddly enough has found itself the Winter niche. In Winter flu virus in droplets live longer on surfaces and people are indoors more, close enough together to be touching a lot of the same surfaces. A lot of people think they have influenza in the Fall when in reality they have a whole slew of rhinovirus, adenovirus, and other viruses.

Pertussis (a bacteria) outbreaks peak in Spring and there are some pathogens more common in Summer. I'm not sure we have answers for these patterns but maybe someone has. I digress.

Typically the Fall and Winter prevalence of these pathogens can be as low as a 10% or much higher. Most respiratory infections are actually droplet spread. That accounts for the low rate. Higher infectivity can make that higher when it takes a lower dose to infect a person.

And then there is COVID.

COVID is airborne, not droplet spread, and it seems to be as contagious as measles and chickenpox. There is a problem though that unlike measles and chickenpox, COVID immunity is shorter acting. People are getting it twice and they are getting it despite being vaccinated.

Schools closing and people staying home from work because they are ill is still a problem.

There will be milder cases, fewer people will end up in the hospital and fewer will die. One need not panic. But it would be nice if people didn't think basic things like vaccines and mask wearing were so difficult. Some more vulnerable people are needlessly going to get very sick.


You can bet that Seattle and other cities that cruise ships dock, plus where kids are going back to school are going to see some immediate fairly large spikes in cases. It's inevitable.
 
Last edited:
We don't really know the seasonable pattern with COVID yet, it might take years to settle into one.

School outbreaks of respiratory infections, OTOH, are quite predictable. The few kids passing something around in the summer go to school in Sept (in the northern hemisphere) and pass it around to whole classes full of kids. By Oct the kids have gone home and infected the parents. And by Nov the working parents have passed the infections on to their coworkers who don't have kids in school. By this time the illnesses are spreading through the whole community.

Influenza oddly enough has found itself the Winter niche. In Winter flu virus in droplets live longer on surfaces and people are indoors more, close enough together to be touching a lot of the same surfaces. A lot of people think they have influenza in the Fall when in reality they have a whole slew of rhinovirus, adenovirus, and other viruses.

Pertussis (a bacteria) outbreaks peak in Spring and there are some pathogens more common in Summer. I'm not sure we have answers for these patterns but maybe someone has. I digress.

Typically the Fall and Winter prevalence of these pathogens can be as low as a 10% or much higher. Most respiratory infections are actually droplet spread. That accounts for the low rate. Higher infectivity can make that higher when it takes a lower dose to infect a person.

And then there is COVID.

COVID is airborne, not droplet spread, and it seems to be as contagious as measles and chickenpox. There is a problem though that unlike measles and chickenpox, COVID immunity is shorter acting. People are getting it twice and they are getting it despite being vaccinated.

Schools closing and people staying home from work because they are ill is still a problem.

There will be milder cases, fewer people will end up in the hospital and fewer will die. One need not panic. But it would be nice if people didn't think basic things like vaccines and mask wearing were so difficult. Some more vulnerable people are needlessly going to get very sick.


You can bet that Seattle and other cities that cruise ships dock, plus where kids are going back to school are going to see some immediate fairly large spikes in cases. It's inevitable.

Thanks. Very informative.

That said, you will probably find as high a percentage of mask-wearing here than you will anywhere else in the world. The same probably goes for vaccination as well. On top of that, the class and school closures are done to prevent spread, so it is taken seriously without any attendant panic.
 
Thanks. Very informative.

That said, you will probably find as high a percentage of mask-wearing here than you will anywhere else in the world. The same probably goes for vaccination as well. On top of that, the class and school closures are done to prevent spread, so it is taken seriously without any attendant panic.

Well everyone calmly wearing masks and calmly closing school is exactly what is called panic elsewhere.
 
The editorial group of the John Snow Project propose a new a new paradigm for COVID-19 "in light of the accumulating evidence":

COVID-19 is a disease that has an acute and chronic phase. Both phases can be asymptomatic or symptomatic, and the severity and nature of symptoms in either phase depends on the host immune response, viral inoculum and location of infection. In the chronic phase, commonly known as Long COVID, many more people than those who exhibit symptoms of Long COVID, or perhaps everyone who has been infected by COVID-19, is on the same spectrum of T cell activation and may share as yet undiscovered characteristics of viral persistence or immune dysfunction, regardless of whether they experience Long COVID symptoms or not, and the experience of those symptoms, which may be associated with further immune perturbation on reinfection, may be related to the location and/or quantity of viral RNA/protein/replicating virus in persistent reservoirs.
COVID-19: A NEW DISEASE PARADIGM (John Snow Project, Sep 14, 2023)


I can recommend the John Snow Project's primers, videos and perspectives.

If you don't already know them, they are the people behind the John Snow Memorandum, which criticized the Great Barrington Declaration signed by the main proponents of the herd-immunity-by-infection strategy and sponsored by AIER, "a conservative and libertarian free-market think tank" and an enemy of the CDC and any and all attempts to prevent global warming.
 
Well everyone calmly wearing masks and calmly closing school is exactly what is called panic elsewhere.


Where would "elsewhere" be? And why would calmly wearing masks and calmly closing schools during an outbreak of infectious diseases be called a panic?! :confused:

It seems to be a very rational and well-considered measure:
Last week in Kentucky, Lee County School District and Magoffin County Schools both closed due to large numbers of COVID-19 cases. In Magoffin County, attendance fell to 83 percent during the third week since returning from summer break, leading to the decision to switch to remote schooling at the end of last week.
“We’re seeing a lot of illness being reported consistent with COVID and influenza,” Scott Lockard, a public health director in Kentucky, told ABC News. “Lee County had a surge of cases and attendance dropped below the threshold needed to stay open, so they closed.”
Runge Independent School District in Texas, which has 195 students, closed from August 22–29 and canceled all extracurricular activities due to a sharp rise in COVID-19 among staff, with 10 out of the district’s 43 staff members testing positive as of August 21.
School systems in the United States experience surge in COVID-19 and other illnesses as classes resume (WSWS, Aug 30, 2023)


I see no sign of panic at all. Angrysobe described how the Japanese school closure was "taken seriously without any attendant panic," so the panic appears to be entirely in people who object to the prevention of disease.
 
The disease exists and will continue to exist, although the trajectory its on almost certainly means it will become less of a problem, because we now know that repeated exposure creates stronger immunity. 5 more years and it's likely to be just another coronavirus.


What 'we' don't appear to know is that SARS-CoV-2 evolves. Today's new variants evade yesterday's immunity:
We first estimated the effective reproduction number (Re) of BA.2.86 based on genome surveillance data until Sept 4, 2023, in Denmark, where multiple XBB subvariants including EG.5.1 are currently co-circulating, and 12 BA.2.86 sequences were reported (appendix p 10). Although there was considerable uncertainty in this estimation due to a smaller number of available BA.2.86 sequences, the Re of BA.2.86 was 1·29-fold greater than that of XBB.1.5 (95% Bayesian confidence interval 1·17–1·47; appendix p 10). Importantly, the Re of BA.2.86 was comparable to or even greater than that of EG.5.1, one of the most rapidly expanding XBB subvariants (appendix p 10), and the estimated posterior probability that the Re of BA.2.86 exceeds that of EG.5.1 was 0·901 (appendix p 10). These findings suggest that BA.2.86 potentially has greater fitness than current circulating XBB variants including EG.5.1.
(...)
Altogether, these results suggest that BA.2.86 is one of the most highly immune evasive variants so far.
Transmissibility, infectivity, and immune evasion of the SARS-CoV-2 BA.2.86 variant (TheLancet, Sep 18, 2023)

‘Lessons have been forgotten’: is the UK ready for a new Covid variant? (TheGuardian, Sep 16, 2023)

And then there is the damage that SARS-CoV-2 appears to wreck on the immune system:
SARS-CoV-2 Infection Weakens Immune-Cell Response to Vaccination (NIH, Mar 20, 2023)
However, a new idea about how COVID can affect immunity has emerged: that even mild infections routinely cause consequential damage to our bodies’ defenses. This degradation was referred to as “immunity theft” by T. Ryan Gregory, an evolutionary biologist, as a counterargument to "immunity debt" being the reason why respiratory infections were more severe than usual this past fall.
So while the acute infection may be one reason to not want to keep getting infected with SARS-CoV-2 over and over again, the idea that it can increasingly cause damage to the immune system should be a significant reason. Throughout the pandemic, scientific evidence has mounted that even mild COVID infections may be doing something to our immune systems, as well as our collective immunity.
COVID Impacts: Immune Dysfunction (Memorial Sloane Kettering Library, Sep 7, 2023)


So much for the ignorant claim that "repeated exposure creates stronger immunity"! :mad:
 
Why Minimizers Panic

As Covid continues to spread worldwide, many people are finding it difficult to accept reality. They refuse to examine facts, even when they’re presented in forms that are easy to comprehend. Instead, they insist on reclaiming an obsolete version of “normal” that involves large indoor gatherings without any precautions. This could be you or someone you love. Do they need help?
The short answer is yes.
They do.
If You Suffer from Urgent Normal Syndrome, Ask for Help (OK Doomer, Aug 5, 2023)


This is what the Covid minimizers do. They intentionally conflate concern with Covid for "panic" and "alarm." They equivocate. They gently guide the public away from making any effort to prevent infection in the first place. It's starting to become clear that the minimizers might actually believe their own lies. They actually do believe they're too healthy to get Long Covid. They actually do think they can get infected and reinfected without consequence. They really do think a trip to the ER will save them, and that they'll get to go back to normal. They're willing to take us down with them.
For what?
At first, I thought it was about money. Then I thought maybe it was about fame and power. Now I know it's about a desperate attempt to be right, to save face after so many embarrassing mistakes. Now I get it.
They're never going to admit they were wrong.
They would rather die.
It's Time to "Cancel" Covid Minimizing Doctors (OK Doomer, Aug 30, 2023)
 
And then there is the damage that SARS-CoV-2 appears to wreck on the immune system:

"wreak" Your ESL status is showing.

And the piece is irrelevant. It notes that immune response is lower in people who were vaccinated prior to infection, so since most people were infected before vaccines were available, it bears no relation to what's happening now.

Maybe you've built a time machine and can go back and vaccinate people before the pandemic started.

Right now, anyone who hasn't been vaccinated is a moron and of zero interest to me.

The point stands - infection raises immunity levels - I'm quite happy to quote the hundreds of scientific reports that show vaccination + infection increases immunity.

Why Minimizers Panic

:dl:

You really do quote some insane sites to try to project your panic onto others. A blog by a chick with the most excellent name of Jessica Wildfire is hardly authoritative, but since she agrees with you I can see the attraction.

Samples from the site:

The World Has Already Ended.

Sleep has turned into a form of class privilege. It’s also a weapon in class warfare.

And she's totally not panicking...

If you keep getting infected with Covid, you will eventually develop a disabling condition.

It will eventually kill you

There is one article I saw that looks like it has your name all over it: Good People Are The Worst

Thanks for the morning laugh.
 
Saw my pulmonary doc the morning. Kaiser still doesn't have the new variant boosters or the RSV vaccine for adults. I did get my flu shot.

I tried to talk him into giving me Paxlovid to have at home and he soundly rejected the idea asking me if I wanted it for prophylaxis. So not up to date these guys. :rolleyes:

I told him no, you have it at home so you can start it the soonest your antigen test is positive. They had no issue giving me an epipen and narcan (which no way do I need). I have another appointment tomorrow with rheumatology, maybe she'll let me have some.

And apparently they are no longer dispensing home antigen tests. Fortunately I still have some left. BTW if you have any and they've been properly stored you can add two years to the expiration date.
 
In what way is it ironic ....
What's ironic is you telling Dann, "You have some insane idea that people should listen to you and act in accordance with your idiotic ideas. ..." while you expect everyone to listen to you.

I crossed off "idiotic" and "insane" because those are what I'm talking about, the way you are judging other people in this thread.

Recommendations on what we should be doing to prevent COVID are all over the map. I see no evidence anyone is panicking.

The argument the 2 of you are having over what is a pandemic and what does endemic mean is a waste of thread pages.
 
..." while you expect everyone to listen to you.

No, I don't expect or care whether anyone listens to me. Those who did made a heap of money and those who didn't, didn't. And from a covid perspective, the enormous majority of people are in sync with where I am. What percentage of people where you are are still wearing masks?

I'm just enjoying pouring water on someone who thinks the world should behave like the Davos attendees did, despite that being logistically impossible and totally unwanted.

I repeat - people concerned about covid should mask up and get vaccinated. Expecting anyone else to at this juncture isn't even idiotic, it's insane. Even NZ has removed all restrictions.

The argument the 2 of you are having over what is a pandemic and what does endemic mean is a waste of thread pages.

I don't believe there's even an argument to be had on that subject, so I'm happy to leave it out.
 
It appears to be necessary to repeat the message about this:
The disease exists and will continue to exist, although the trajectory its on almost certainly means it will become less of a problem, because we now know that repeated exposure creates stronger immunity. 5 more years and it's likely to be just another coronavirus.


1) Exposure to the the SARS-CoV-2 virus gives most survivors of the infection some immunity against the variant causing the infection. However, the immunity is temporary. It wanes. And since the immunity is against the variant one is infected with, it doesn't protect against future variants when the virus mutates. The acquired immunity is only against previous variants and to some extent against new variants with few new mutations. See post 67 about the new BA.2.86 'Pirola' variant.

2) Nothing indicates that SARS-CoV-2 is evolving to "become less of a problem" and nothing makes it "likely to be just another coronavirus" in five years. The Atheist has no basis on which to predict the evolution of SARS-CoV-2. So far, his predictions have been overly optimistic.
As for "just another coronavirus": It already is another coronavirus! The implied idea that it is bound to evolve into the common cold is comforting, but it isn't true, unfortunately: We are often told that viruses always evolve to become benign. In reality, virulence is a double-edged sword.
The idea that disease-causing organisms always become benign—a hypothesis known as the avirulence theory—was debunked.
(...)
Tuberculosis has been with us for hundreds of years and it is still deadly. Dengue fever’s own virulence has risen over the last decades. And the myxoma virus, slayer of rabbits? It too has grown deadlier fangs, according to limited data from the 1980s, with a larger percentage of circulating virus in Australia being highly virulent compared to the previous decade. The universality of avirulence theory simply has too many contradictions. Viruses don’t always evolve to become benign.

If it weren't for vaccines, rabies would still be as deadly, i.e. 100%, as it was 2,000 years ago. It still is without the vaccinations.
As for the coronaviruses specifically: Meet SARS-CoV-1 and MERS-CoV (Wikipedia).

Another thing:
Since this thread is in the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology subforum, some of you may have wondered about this peculiar argument in The Atheist's most recent post:
No, I don't expect or care whether anyone listens to me. Those who did made a heap of money and those who didn't, didn't.


It explains a lot.
 
2) Nothing indicates that SARS-CoV-2 is evolving to "become less of a problem"

Simply absurd.

As Dr Sid notes, covid was killing thousands of people a day, now, it's killing fewer than car crashes, homicides and TB.

As for the coronaviruses specifically: Meet SARS-CoV-1 and MERS-CoV (Wikipedia).

Wow, you know a dishonest argument is being made when you pick on the two coronaviruses that haven't spread through humans, and ignore the many others which do, and aren't lethal at all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronaviridae#/media/File:44149_2021_5_Fig3_HTML.webp

It explains a lot.

No, it doesn't explain anything, which is no doubt why it confused you.

I'm happy to stand by my predictions both in science, where my prediction of global pandemic was made on 23 January 2000 in the first iteration of this very thread, and this little financial gem.

On the other hand, your predictions of doom from the last several variants of covid - most notably using Japan/Okinawa - have turned out to be hot air.
 
TA said:
As Dr Sid notes, covid was killing thousands of people a day, now, it's killing fewer than car crashes, homicides and TB.
Tricky slight of the denominator hand. :rolleyes:

TB and malaria kill millions and millions. COVID has never surpassed those numbers.

Those two pathogens plus homicides and MVA's kill numbers of people that vary considerably from country to country but again, why should COVID killing fewer people be relevant to your argument?

COVID is still an issue. There's no need to argue about what is worse or how to label it as a pandemic or having reached the endemic phase.

It's not a benign pathogen yet. People in the US are poorly informed about the risks and about prevention like mask use. The vaccine booster for the newest variant is not yet widely available in the US. And there's no guarantee a more virulent variant won't appear in the future.

The idea people should ignore basic measures to prevent further spread because that is 'panicking' is absurd.
 
The vaccine booster for the newest variant is not yet widely available in the US.


Do you mean the current, newly formulated booster? I got mine on Saturday. It was available at every CVS and Walgreens pharmacy in town.
 
Do you mean the current, newly formulated booster? I got mine on Saturday. It was available at every CVS and Walgreens pharmacy in town.

Which town?

Kaiser didn't have them today and my dentist said she could not yet find any at the local pharmacies. I imagine we will see them very soon here.
 
Tricky slight of the denominator hand. :rolleyes:

TB and malaria kill millions and millions. COVID has never surpassed those numbers.

I didn't mention malaria and covid well and truly passed the 1.5M TB deaths in both 2020 and 2021. If you're going to try a factual approach, at least get your facts right.

The idea people should ignore basic measures to prevent further spread because that is 'panicking' is absurd.

I've said time and time again people are welcome to wear masks, and if they feel they should then nobody's stopping them.

Panicking would be attempting to use the measures at Davos as a worldwide benchmark, and only one person anywhere is suggesting that.
 
Reality Check

Come on Dann, are you claiming covid will kill million per wave again ? That it hasn't decreased virulence drastically ?

Simply absurd.

As Dr Sid notes, covid was killing thousands of people a day, now, it's killing fewer than car crashes, homicides and TB.


Dr. Sid and The Atheist have both got me confused with the The Atheist, which is a little odd in The Atheist's case since he is the one who has excelled in predictions, always very, very wrong predictions, for the last couple of years. That he continues to lie about the current death rates of COVID-19 and car crashes is not surprising. He has been lying about those, too, for years:
I don't understand why The Atheist never checks out New Zealand's numbers, before he makes these nonsensical claims! Covid minimizers gonna minimize, but I don't understand what he hopes to get out of this.

Covid-19 deaths in New Zealand 2023, so far: 211
Road deaths in New Zealand 2023, so far: 56

"(Less than a quarter of car crash deaths)"
Yeah, right!

I'm getting bored with having to fact check for The Atheist all the time.
Would somebody like to take over the job?!
New Zealand road deaths in 2022: 373 - a little more than the average of recent years and yet no comparison to the SARS-CoV-2 death toll:
New Zealand Covid-19 deaths in 2022: 2,280


I have already pointed out that many countries have stopped reporting COVID-19 deaths. It is not surprising that The Atheist continues to report the corresponding low numbers as if they were based on reporting and not on the lack of reporting:


The Atheist has also been telling the fairy tale about flu and C-19 for years. It wasn't true in 2022, and it isn't true in 2023.
Covid-19 vs the flu: Death rates compared (RNZ.co.nz, Dec 13, 2022)
Covid-19 vs the flu: Death rates compared NZHerald.co.nz, Dec 12, 2022)

Fortunately, New Zealand is one of the countries that still registers and reports the C-19 death toll: Since Jan 1, 2023, New Zealand has had 978 registered C-19 deaths, which is already considerably more than the number of people who die from the flu: Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths (Our World in Data).
Last year in March, The Atheist made this prediction: "'Flu deaths here are ~500 a year, and omicron's going to be much lower than that."
Much lower than ~500 a year wasn't true then, and it isn't true now.

Wow, you know a dishonest argument is being made when you pick on the two coronaviruses that haven't spread through humans, and ignore the many others which do, and aren't lethal at all.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronaviridae#/media/File:44149_2021_5_Fig3_HTML.webp


I was not the one who wrote: "5 more years and it's likely to be just another coronavirus." It was obvious that The Atheist wasn't interested in comparisons with SARS-CoV-1 and MERS-CoV, which is why I brought them up. His point was that, even though SARS-CoV-2 is nothing like the common cold, it will allegedly be so, which is why I pointed out that two recent coronaviruses don't show any inclinations to become the common cold in spite of considerably more than five years having passed. Fortunately, SARS-CoV-2 doesn't have the same IFR as SARS-CoV-1 and MERS-CoV, and fortunately those two aren't nearly as infectious as SARS-CoV-2.

No, it doesn't explain anything, which is no doubt why it confused you.

I'm happy to stand by my predictions both in science, where my prediction of global pandemic was made on 23 January 2000 in the first iteration of this very thread, and this little financial gem.

On the other hand, your predictions of doom from the last several variants of covid - most notably using Japan/Okinawa - have turned out to be hot air.


Panic must have set in again for the claim that I make "predictions of doom" to be made. Instead of emulating The Atheist and making predictions that are already obviously wrong at the point in time when they are made, I report facts, which is also what I did about Okinawa and Japan. The Atheist registers those facts as "predictions of doom," which is annoying, but it can't be helped, I guess. It's what panic does.
Hot air and false predictions all the way to the bank.

Since it keeps popping up: Could we have a link to my alleged "predictions of doom from the last several variants of covid"?
The claim that I make those predictions is really starting to annoy me. I have been far too busy correcting The Atheist's overly optimistic C-19 predictions to start making predictions of my own. I am interested in facts about the pandemic, not in castles in the air.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom