CaveDave, what do you do when somebody questions your ethics and work in a forum?
So far, I don't believe it has ever happened.
As a hypothetical question? I would want to reexamine and review my actions, behavior, and writings critically, searching for any reason for such questions to arise, and in the absence of any, I would request from the questioner their evidence.
If I found reasons, I would attempt to correct any misunderstanding that may have led to the questioning or apologise and correct myself if there were indeed factual evidence of transgression on my part.
If the challenger proved to be unwilling to discuss the matter, and the accusations were spurious, I believe that I could trust that the other participants would reach their own conclusions about the affair. I never delude myself into the belief that I can control the thoughts of other men. If persuation via reasoned debate fails, I can choose to withdraw my participation.
How would you answer the same question?
Is ignoring the author the best choice?
No, but in the event that no other option remains, then go ahead.
=======================
Earlier, you wrote:
To criticize the salt solution takes somebody who just wants to pick a fight
I disagree. This is a forum mainly dedicated to challenging Authority when they proclaim "X" without properly supporting their assertions for "X" to be acceptably proven. In this case, you were asked to give the reasons for *each* of the particular recommendations in the recipe, and if it was indeed a useful product. I still doubt the need for boiling, assuming reasonable quality water, but learned a great deal from both sides in the debate between s'girl and the respiatory therapy expert (forgot the screen name, sorry.).
At another point you wrote:
You are not a crazy cat lady, but you are as mean, untruthful and vindictive as anybody I can imagine.
I disagree. I saw a self-confident, educated, dedicated professional who could be opinionated (most competent professionals are), occasionally abrupt (only a small fault, probably due to a busy schedule), and disinclined to suffer fools gladly (good for her).
I saw no evidence of any of your charges, but would welcome you to present your evidence for those assertions.
Please be precise and specific. Post your quotes supporting each charge with references to the original post number.
Let's have a lively debate, how about it?
Cheers,
Dave