CARINA LANDIN, Swedish Friend of the DEAD

OK, sorry for the confusion. I'm just getting up to speed with things, and OLD claims are problematic. I'm 2500 miles away from those files, and Randi couldn't find it. It sure does look like it was there though.

Randi is talking with Oren now.
 
This is good news. I particularly like that she appears to welcome the idea of a random drawing from a larger batch, which would allow varying different ratios of male/female diaries. If anything, that makes her job more difficult.

Could we be close to an actual test?
 
Proposed arrangement of a preliminary test of Carina Landin

Purpose
The test will investigate Carina Landin’s ability to determine if a diary written by a deceased person was written by a man or a women. Her claim is that she can do this correctly in at least 80% of the cases.

Persons
A = archivist
O = observer appointed by Carin Landin
JD = Jan Dalkvist
SOH = Sven Ove Hansson

Preparations 1
A few days before the test the archives and SOH select 15 diaries written by men and 15 written by women. As far as possible,diaries without handwriting on the outside are chosen. (If this cannot be avoided, the handwriting will be covered by SOH with some method approved by A.) Furthermore (in accordance with Landin’s wish) diaries older than the late 19th century are avoided as far ass possible. SOH ties up each diary with a string so that
it can be handled without being accidentally opened. A small piece of
cardboard is tied to each diary (a label will be attached to it later). SOH puts all diaries in a cardboard box which he seals, and they are then locked in by A.

Preparations 2
SOH arrives an hour before the test, receives the cardboard box from A and
selects the 20 diaries that will be used in the test by tossing a coin. He is alone when doing this. If the coin-tossing results in less than 5 diaries from one of the sexes he interrupts and repeats the process. (Landin has
expressed a wish that the distribution should not be more skewed than that.)
He then puts the selected 20 diaries in a pile.
When the selection is finished he calls for O. Jointly, they put labels with the numbers 1-20 on the diaries. When they do this, O takes the labels one by one without seeing their numbers and gives them to SOH who attaches them to the cardboard pieces that are tied to the diaries. After this SOH
arranges the diaries in numerical order and puts them in a box which he seals.

The test
The test takes place in a room provided by the archives. Only Landin and JD are present during the test. Landin and JD sit across each other at a table. A vertical board has been mounted on the table, with hole(s) at the bottom for
Landin’s hands. The board is so constructed that the two cannot see each
other and Landin cannot see the diaries. On Landin’s side of the table there is a board of wood to which JD applies furniture polish at the beginning of the test (in order to conceal possible differences in how the diaries smell). In the room there is also a video camera that will run throughout the test, including the post-test check-up of the results. JD arranges the room and starts the video camera. He then asks Landin if the conditions for the test are OK. Landin is given the opportunity to test that she can feel an object through the hole in the vertical board. If there are any problems with the arrangement of the room, the board etc., these are adjusted until she is
satisfied. If conditions that satisfy her cannot be arranged, the test is called off. JD calls for SOH (via mobile phone). SOH arrives with the box with diaries and puts it on JD’s side of the table. Courtesy phrases may be exchanged. SOH leaves the room before the box is opened. JD takes out the diaries from the box and puts them on the table. All diaries should be within sight of the video camera throughout the experiment. JD takes the diaries one by one in
numerical order, and puts it in front of Landin who then has the opportunity to feel it with her hands. For each diary she says ”man”, ”woman” or ”do not know”. JD writes down what she says to the test protocol. Landin may see the note if she so wishes. She also has access to pencil and paper and may make her own notes if she so wishes. Landin may use a pair of ear-muffs if she so wishes. SOH provides ear-muffs for the test. JD is silent when Landin focuses on the task, but talks to her when it is time to write down her verdict for the respective diary. Landin is allowed at most two and a half hours to complete the test. It is finished after this time unless she has
herself finished it before. She brings a clock and keeps track of the time herself. JD changes tapes in the video camera when this is needed.
After the test has been finished, JD interviews Landin about how she thinks the test went. After this he calls SOH, A, and O into the room. JD and A see to it that all who are present have a photocopy of the protocol. After this Landin and A jointly open the diaries (i.e. cut off the strings) and notes are made about the sex of the diarist. JD writes the official protocol, and the
others can check what he writes. When this has been done JD and A copy this protocol to all who are present.

Follow-up and reporting
If Landin gives correct answers in at least 80% of the cases (at least 16 of the 20 diaries) the test is regarded as successful. SOH and JD have expressed an interest in performing, in that case, further investigations in order to better understand the result. Among the hypotheses that should then be tested is that the diaries differ in some way that can be perceived
with the tactile sense. SOH writes a report for the James Randi Educational Foundation about the outcome of the test. A draft of the report is sent
within one week to Landin and JD, each of whom may add comments of their own within a week. After that the report is sent in. Each of those present is free to publish the results of the test. JD and SOH jointly determine if they want to publish a scientific report, in which case they write it jointly if possible.
 
That looks good. One caveat: is there a chance that the size of the diaries could give clues? Is it possible/necessary to have the dimensions of the books within certain parameters? I'm thinking of the diference that might obtain between a desk-diary, and a more intimate diary capable of being carried in a handbag. The former would be ambiguous in its ownership, while the latter would have a probability attached.


Also, more recent diaries might be written with ball-point pens, where the depth of impression of any writing might proide a clue. Would it be prudent to insist on dairies written using nibs only, or will the diaries have absolutely no writing accessible to the applicant's touch?
 
That looks good. One caveat: is there a chance that the size of the diaries could give clues? Is it possible/necessary to have the dimensions of the books within certain parameters? I'm thinking of the diference that might obtain between a desk-diary, and a more intimate diary capable of being carried in a handbag. The former would be ambiguous in its ownership, while the latter would have a probability attached.


Also, more recent diaries might be written with ball-point pens, where the depth of impression of any writing might proide a clue. Would it be prudent to insist on dairies written using nibs only, or will the diaries have absolutely no writing accessible to the applicant's touch?

It's my understanding that the diaries were going to be sealed, such that the contents would not be of use (I imagine several handwriting experts could perform this task quite well if allowed to view the text).
 
Given that enough diaries are available, would a Base Line Test http://www.randi.org/research/faq.html#5.6 similar to the one used with dowsers make sense?

Ms. Landin could calibrate her "spirit" and all conditions will get set up (as mentioned in the protocol proposal) to her complete agreement (earmuffs, size of the holes, table setup, etc.) so that she cannot blame the test conditions for the outcome.



Determining the gender of a deceased human being from the handwriting in a diary seems like an educated guessing game to me. No offense, Ms. Landin.

Coming up with specifica like location and date of birth, location and date of death, married, kids, names, etc. would convince me more of a paranormal event.
 
Read the protocol, people. Ms. Landin will not read the diaries. She will not see the handwriting. She will not even see the books themselves. She will be sitting behind a screen through which she will extend only her hands.

My concern is that simply feeling the covers of the diaries may give her adequate clues as to the sex of the owners. Are men's diaries more likely to be leather? Are women's diaries more likely to have some kind of embossed emblem on the front, like a flower or butterfly, or something? I continue to follow this test with interest.
 
My concern is that simply feeling the covers of the diaries may give her adequate clues as to the sex of the owners. Are men's diaries more likely to be leather? Are women's diaries more likely to have some kind of embossed emblem on the front, like a flower or butterfly, or something? I continue to follow this test with interest.

From Sven Ove Hansson:

Dear Kramer,

After many discussions about other more complex experimental arrangements she agreed to an arrangement in which she will identify which of a selection of diaries were written by males respectively females. I am just now waiting for answers from people at archives who will hopefully provide us with a sufficient number of diaries (or course with no visible cue on the outside, and "sealed" so that they cannot be opened to peek at the handwriting.

Sven Ove
 
...
Determining the gender of a deceased human being from the handwriting in a diary seems like an educated guessing game to me. No offense, Ms. Landin.
...

Unlucky wording on my part:
I understood fairly well before that Ms. Landin will only touch the surface of the diaries to determine the gender of the owner and will not see any handwriting with her eyes.

However, there has to be at least some handwriting inside the diary - e.g. the name of the owner. I speculated in my last post, Ms. Landin will pick up her "data" from the handwriting inside.



I agree with you Gr8wight, Ms. Landin may well tilt the odds in her favour by simply guessing the gender correctly after picking up clues from the outside.

Allowing her to touch the diaries seems risky to me. Does this seem too careful to anyone?
 
I think that the use of the word "gender" must be avoided and replaced with the word "sex" in all documents. "Gender" is associated with identity in many cases, and is ambiguous with repsect to biologolical sex.

I realise, by the way, that the diaries will be sealed and the the handwriting won't be visible. My concern was that *any* handwriting at all on the cover - along the lines of "This is the diary of..." could possible be read by fingertip to a practiced practitioner, and even the depth oof pen impress could provide clues.
 
I think that the use of the word "gender" must be avoided and replaced with the word "sex" in all documents. "Gender" is associated with identity in many cases, and is ambiguous with repsect to biologolical sex.

In the swedish original the word "kön" is used which is translated to sex. If they ment gender the the word "genus" would have been used instead.
 
I think that the use of the word "gender" must be avoided and replaced with the word "sex" in all documents. "Gender" is associated with identity in many cases, and is ambiguous with repsect to biologolical sex.
...

I seem confused:
Does this mean the same homo sapiens can be considered of male "sex" and also of female "gender" at the same time? (Homosexuals not being the issue here.)
 
Not female gender, female and male are sexes. Gender is man-woman, boy-girl. Transsexuals are often of one sex but a different gender.
 
In the swedish original the word "kön" is used which is translated to sex. If they ment gender the the word "genus" would have been used instead.
I expected that most documents to date are in Swedish. The application and the legal stuff will probably be written in the language of teh jursidiction that applies to JREF, though, won't it?

The gender thing can lead to ambiguities.

There's a discussion here as to the difference: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/gender

as well as here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender

It refers to identity rather than biological differentiation.

The point has already been mentioned that she could point to a diary and say "no. The person was a woman trapped in a male body", or some such stuff.

Having said that, she seems to ring true all the time, and the changes she has accepted stretch the odds quite a bit. I hope this goes all the way to a test!
 
I just received a message from Carina Landin asking to be her translater. I think I will start a new tread where you can ask her questions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom