Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

I wasn't sure what this type refers to. Speed? Angle of impact? Motivation of the pilots? Location? Angle of approach? Plane type?
Given that the words preceding "of this type" are "Airline crashes" and given that it was the crash of United 93 which was the topic under discussion, I would have thought it clear what type R.Mackey was referring to.
 
B
You see black in Val's photo, I see gray. I see black in your two photos on the right, I see gray in the photo on the left.
You see no differences, I do.



Your contention over the colour of the smoke is ridiculous. There will always be a wide range of variations dependent on camera exposure settings and white balance. If you read the thread in which we discussed this matter with Killtown, you will see that there are numerous examples of aircraft crash photos with a range of various shades of gray, from very pale to as dark as to constitute black.

-Gumboot
 
I'm not associating myself with killtown. Killtown doesn't think a plane crashed at Shanksville. I do. I do however think the photo is fraudulent. My opinion on the photo has nothing to do with a plane crash or a non-plane crash.

Why would it need to be faked if a plane did crash there? The FBI investigated it and confirmed it is genuine.

I would also request an authority as stated below to verify not the photo but the original digital file to put the matter to rest. As this, to my knowledge, has not happened, the premise that the photo is a fraud still remains valid.
Why don't you ask for a forensic analysis of the negatives from your graduation photos while your at it.

You're a freaking uber-denialist. If you want to accuse an innocent person of fraud you have to do better than that.

Innocent until proven guilty, now shut the **** up. :mad:
 
Last edited:
Swing Dangler Swings and Misses

Nope. If I said that you were a baboon, I would not be a primary source. I have no evidence. Neither do they.
Will you please stop attacking the character? It sheds poor light on your level of education.
:p My level of education? You failed to comprehend what I wrote. To wit, nowhere in that quote did I attack your character. Try reading it carefully next time.

Let me help your research skills:

Lee Purbaugh first call - 03/27/07
http://www.glownightclub.ca/audio/lee_purbaugh_032707.mp3
Lee Purbaugh second call - 03/28/07
http://www.pumpitout.com/audio/lee_purbaugh_032807.mp3
Kelly Leverknight - 03/07/27
http://www.pumpitout.com/audio/leverknight_032707.mp3
I'll address this at the end of the post.

It's a doozy.

I think you spelled unpredictably wrong, but I'm not an expert.
Perhaps, who cares?

Please point out in your above quote the relative speed you were referring to in the litany of airplane crashes you were referring to?
Or are you suggesting that 93 was a low speed crash? I think you caught in your own quotes trap.
Point stands.
This is barely coherent. At no point did I suggest Flight 93 was low-speed. I said that, in aircraft crashes, vegetation damage from ensuing fires tends to be light (dry brush conditions excepted, of course, but not relevant here). It just so happens that this is true for any speed of impact. You interpreted this as saying since Flight 93 affected vegetation similar to low-speed impact pictures (which it does, but not just low-speed impacts!) that all the other features would also be similar to low-speed impacts.

This is a logical fallacy. I can't make it any clearer than that. Your point is rejected, and your continued inability to understand this is unfortunate.

The historical record shows that the FBI is not infallible and that they do make mistakes. Point stands. Can you prove the FBI is infallible? I can prove they do make mistakes. Its called the historical record. You have no way to prove how the FBI examined the authenticity of the photograph, nor do I. Point stands.
The point is that you are speculating. This is sophistry. No agency and no person is infallible, therefore by your standards, I can't rely upon anything.

Idiocy. You have no point.

You mean I can't argue the point so I will result in attacking the character. Point accepted.
Read for comprehension, please.

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/06218/711239-85.stm This isn't proof that she donates the profits to charity, but it is evidence. You have no counter-evidence. Point for me.

As far as Mrs. McClatchey retaining some money for expenses, you'll note I said that profits were donated. Expenses don't count against profit. You can whine and cry about how I also said "all money" was donated if you want, I don't care. My intent was clear, as is your willingness to quote-mine and ignore everything except what you want to read.

Until you prove the validity and falsifiability of the metric, it means nothing.
Um... you were the one who claimed my metric said something about your hypothesis, not me. And it appears you didn't even use it, and it's certain that you didn't use it properly. Did you forget that part?

You didn't ask.

I don't have to ask. The burden of proof lies upon you, remember?

How could I be convinced?
1. The original digital file was analyzed by an expert and proven to be valid.
2. The primary source statements who viewed the event and the photo recanted their statements.
What would convince you it was a fraud or is it a religious belief?
I'd be convinced it was fraudulent if:
  1. Any of the major parties confessed
  2. The FBI found significant digital artifacts in the photograph
  3. Other photographs bitwise similar to the photo were found, supporting a compositing argument
  4. Physical calculations based on the other evidence were sharply at variance with the photograph's contents
However, none of this has happened. Quite the opposite. The FBI is satisfied with it, there are no photos anywhere that appear to be source images, and the physics matches to a T.

Looking at your answers, you're in trouble. Both conditions are satisfied. As you already know, the FBI put experts on it and concluded it was genuine:

Pittsburgh Post-Gazette said:
Special agent Jeff Killeen, of the FBI in Pittsburgh, confirmed that the photo of the barns and the smoke plume was "a very legitimate photograph."

"We consider that a photo that was taken moments after Flight 93 crashed to the ground," Mr. Killeen said. "It's a remarkable shot. It's remarkable that someone had the wherewithal to snap a photo of the crash. This is a one-of-a-kind. We really don't know of anything else."

As for the second, the "primary source" folks you're talking about don't say what you think they said, as I will demonstrate below. Uh-oh.

Great. The physics match the photo. That does nothing to prove the validity of the photo. Unless you have the original digital file, the analysis is inconsequential.

:D This is a lot more damaging to your case than you realize. You've admitted that the image contents are correct and will withstand forensic scrutiny. You've accepted that the only way to falsify the image is through analysis of the underlying code, i.e. individual pixels, file fingerprints, etc.

Since you admit this, you also admit that your "primary sources," none of whom are photo experts and none of whom could have accessed the original image, can claim it is false. They are only going by a view of the image. As you admit, the view is correct. Therefore, you cannot accept their criticism as valid.

Neither do I. However, as we will soon see, they didn't criticize the image at all.

Unless the most qualified expert in the world in digital photography files and analysis has the file itself and examines it, then Dr. Shepherd's assessment is meaningless.

Says you. By that standard, so is your assessment, so is Killtown's. By your own argument, you are doing nothing but speculating. Speculation is not evidence. Ergo, you have no evidence. You've bet the farm on your phone calls, which we will now examine.


And now we get to Swing Dangler's attempt to support his argument.

I downloaded and listened to all three of these, roughly an hour of recorded telephone conversations -- with the infamous "Jeff" from Sault-Ste. Marie. Yes, him. That is Swing's "evidence."

Let's suppose I didn't already know about "Jeff" and what a hoser he is (are you him??). What makes you think this is evidence? Like you say, people lie, people do bad things. You think they always tell the truth on the telephone to random jokers from Canuckistan? Furthermore, you're complaining that the photo might have been digitally altered, even though real experts say otherwise -- but you don't think these MP3 files might have been edited, or even fabricated from whole cloth? What kind of double standard is that?

Regardless, I actually listened to these. I invite other readers to download them as well, to see just how ridiculous Swing Dangler's case really is. Be aware, there is colorful language, the fact that these calls are downloadable may be an illegal invasion of privacy (!), and "Jeff" himself is highly reminiscent of "The Great White North." I outline all of the relevant excerpts below. Times are approximate and quotes are paraphrases -- I see no reason to examine these in detail.

In the first of the three recordings, "Jeff" speaks primarily to Mrs. Purbaugh. She is understandably agitated about those seeking to profiteer from the events of Sept. 11th, and also irritated at those sensationalizing the news with false and exaggerated reporting (sound like any Movement we know?). The question of Val McClatchey's photograph comes up four times:
  • Approx. 2:00: "It's bull[rule 8]!" At this point, Mrs. Purbaugh is clearly referring to the larger issue of profiteering, and not commenting on the technical merit or accuracy of the photo. Even if she was, she gives no reasoning whatsoever.
  • 5:15: "Now she's rich as can be." No discussion of the photo itself, merely commentary on her allegedly ill-gotten gains. None of this is supported, of course.
  • 16:30: Led by "Jeff"'s question of "how would we prove it's fake," she speaks of looking through archives to see "if a paper was marked up." Clearly she is thinking the photo was embellished by a news organization. She does not realize that the image on the camera's memory card was analyzed directly by the FBI.
  • 26:00: Discussion of Val's personality and motive, revolving around money, again focused on the larger media circus. No discussion of the photo itself.
Hmm, no evidence of a fake photo. Indeed, no evidence that Mrs. Purbaugh even thinks the photo is fake, unless you apply an extremely literal reading of the phone call. And even if she does, she gives no reasoning, no explanation at all.

The next phone call is strictly with Mr. Purbaugh. The photo is not even mentioned. Mr. Purbaugh, however, indicates that his position was directly upwind of the impact, and thus his view would be quite a bit different than Mrs. McClatchey's. Oh, if you're listening, feel free to skip the first 11:45 since it's nothing but "Jeff" rambling on about minutiae and the terrific "Truth Movement."

The third and final telephone call, to Ms. Leverknight, does make an isolated claim about the photograph, but one that is easily understood. This is also the funniest of the three, as her contempt for "Jeff" is palpable:
  1. 3:20: "It was a fake photo, it didn't have a mushroom cloud." Um... Val's photo clearly does contain a "mushroom cloud," or more correctly a smoke ring. It's not clear that Ms. Leverknight knew what photo "Jeff" was talking about, or if she did, that she had actually seen it. This cannot be viewed as credible. She also indicates elsewhere that she was a student (high school?) at the time of the event!
  2. 4:50: [Jeff] "How could they say the only photo of the crash that exists be Val McClatchey's?" [Ms. Leverknight] "Because they're idiots?" Here she is referring to pictures her mother took at the crash site substantially after impact. There are tons of such photos. The smoke in those photos is residual smoke rising from the wreckage, not the smoke of impact. Apples and oranges.
  3. 7:00: Ms. Leverknight makes her feelings about "Jeff" plain -- and he doesn't get it at all. Hilarious.
  4. My favorite exchange takes place at about 8:00: [Jeff] "Why doesn't nobody do anything about Val McClatchey's photo?" [Ms. Leverknight] "Cause-- it's called freedom?"

So that's it, Swing Dangler. That's the sum total of your evidence. You have a few vague, distracted comments made to a known troublemaker who cold-called them on the telephone and asked a barrage of leading questions. Even taking the most favorable reading possible, there is no reasoning whatsoever as to why her photo is wrong, except one that is flatly and obviously incorrect.

You have nothing.

Even if you did, by your own admission, these amateur observations are not proof of anything. So why should I be swayed? Why should I listen to you any further?

Perhaps I won't.

ROFLMAO! Is that the school bell ringing?

Yup. School's out.

To my friends from Canada, a beautiful and civilized nation, rest assured I am well aware that "Jeff" is not representative. No insult to the rest of you is intended, and if I have given offense, you have my apologies.
 
Last edited:
Beachnut, I'm not looking for confrontation.
Two separate news articles state the plume is gray, one of the articles reporting on the current lawsuit is one of those. So not only does the plume smoke look gray to me, but two other reporters who published descriptions as well.

I haven't used a single quote from Killtown, thankyou. The hearsay is not hearsay at all but the direct statements of at least two individuals who saw the region shortly after the impact, with one who saw the impact and a third who was nearby and saw no smoke at all in the sky, hence my continuing referral to these people as primary sources.

Black is a darker shade of gray?
Black: lacking hue and brightness; absorbing light without reflecting any of the rays composing it.
Gray: of a color between white and black; having a neutral hue; Of or relating to an achromatic color of any lightness between the extremes of black and white.
Source: dictionary.com

You see black in Val's photo, I see gray. I see black in your two photos on the right, I see gray in the photo on the left.
You see no differences, I do.
You loose again, newspaper never get anything right. Three plumes of jet fuel burning. They all look like jet fuel burning to me, and as an expert accident investigator, they are all three jet fuel fires. Funny how they all look the same.

After reviewing the three photos and checking the optical depth of the smoke to be the same as the wavelengths found in jet fuel fires. Verified and certified by an air force investigator. The jet fuel in all three photos attenuates the visible region nearly equally. Gee I wonder why, oh, it is jet fuel in all three photos, that burning made the smoke. I was looking at the 400 to 700 nm wavelengths. What do you think? Got any input now to refute the judgment made here. Proof Val's photo is jet fuel from flight 93 burning and forming a classic mushroom cloud seen by many who have see aircraft accidents. Smoke proves Val's photo is real.

I have to say your hearsay evidence is cute but you will need to get the people to explain what time they made their observations and more. I expect you would want your evidence to be called hearsay, I bet it is manufactured, and just false. But based on what you reported from those witnesses, not a thing they said makes Val's photo fake. Why would they single out Val's photo in the first place? Sounds fishy to me. What do you think? You should have checked the attenuation of the smoke first for what could make it. What in the heck does Val's photo have to do with 9/11 and the terrorists?

Val's photo does not help the official story, gee, DNA and FDR say it all. Come on you want to tell us your whole story. Tell us what it all means? Drop Val's photo and what do you have? You do not even believe an engine can be out of the impact crater. I have to tell you I have been in charge of aircraft impact accident sites, and we found instruments from the cockpit, ejected to over 100 yards, but most of the cockpit was buried deep in the ground. How did it happen? No the plane did not blow up before it hit the ground, it hit the ground in one piece, so to speak. You need to get some education and learn. I have over 34 years experience with flying and accidents involving planes. I also understand physics, and fine if funny you could not figure out the smoke from jet fuel.

Or see above --- http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2698364#post2698364
 
Last edited:
Your contention over the colour of the smoke is ridiculous. There will always be a wide range of variations dependent on camera exposure settings and white balance. If you read the thread in which we discussed this matter with Killtown, you will see that there are numerous examples of aircraft crash photos with a range of various shades of gray, from very pale to as dark as to constitute black.

-Gumboot

3617467651bba2490.jpg
 
I'm not associating myself with killtown. Killtown doesn't think a plane crashed at Shanksville. I do. I do however think the photo is fraudulent. My opinion on the photo has nothing to do with a plane crash or a non-plane crash.

Ok, TAM, I will play.


I do accept your point at my error in the appeal to authority. However in the context of the post, your request (is that a better term?;) ) for an authority appeared to be in response to the valid points I made as a non-authority especially in response to the primary sources and the evidence I considered valid to show the photo appears to be fraudulent.

Can I ask why you believe a statement when an authority on digital files has not verified the photo in question, but will only accept evidence of fraud from an authority?

I would also request an authority as stated below to verify not the photo but the original digital file to put the matter to rest. As this, to my knowledge, has not happened, the premise that the photo is a fraud still remains valid.


The amount of money going to the foundation is 18 out of the 20 dollars. The amount Val charged news outlets is $250 to $350. Now TAM, don't you think it would be a point of emphasis in the article within the same paragraph within the context of charity donations to point out Val was donating several hundreds of dollars to the charity gained from the profits as a result of marketing the photo to press outlets?
Come on now?;)
There is no need to speculate when the article tells you where the money is going. Unless further evidence is provided, the money from the sales to news agencies is in all probability going to Val. And of course she has every right to make money off of the alleged photo as it is her photo.

RMackey is wrong as he stated ALL of the money was going to charity. 2 dollars out of every 20 that she sold to private individuals is not going to charity but into her pocket. This figure of course doesn't take into account her sales to news outlets. Therefore, ALL of the money is not going to charity. It's ok TAM to say Rmackey is wrong when he indeed is wrong. And you don't have to admit to anything TAM, the facts speak for themselves. Val is making money off of the photo.


1. I accept a persons account on a matter in good faith if it does not contradict the prevailing story/account of things. I agree, to put the matter to rest, a photo analyst should evaluate the photo.

2. the $20, $18 was donated, the remaining was said to be spent on Lawyers fees etc...

3. The question of the 250 -350 fees for media outlets, is the big one. Does she donate that or not. If not, does she give it away or keep it for personal wealth.

TAM:)
 
This apparently is your prerogative as I suspect you have voted for right wing Republicans most of your adult life.

That's dangerously close to an ad hominem.

The plume seems disconnected from continually burning jet fuel.

Who said it burned continuously ?

And how did that forest get scorched? Burning jet fuel, correct?

Flashing jet fuel, actually.

I don't consider them "stupid" when primary sources state the photo is a fraud.

"Primary" sources ?

2. Two relatives of people who were first on the scene and one which saw the plane crash state the photo is a fraud and that Val is doing it for money.
Does this prove anything about Flight 93? Not in my opinion. Does it prove the photo is a fraud? I believe so.

How so ? How does the opinion of two persons prove anything ?

Let the photo speak for itself.

I thought you let the two relatives speak for the photo ?
 
R.Mackey; said:
Let's suppose I didn't already know about "Jeff" and what a hoser he is (are you him??).

Oh no jooh di unt!

R.Mackey; said:
You think they always tell the truth on the telephone to random jokers from Canuckistan?

It's the accent, we lull them into a false sense of security, and then WHAMO! smack down with an absurd question hoping to catch them off guard. Works every time.

R.Mackey; said:
[snip] and "Jeff" himself is highly reminiscent of "The Great White North."

Oh jess jooh di!

Ha! Running a disclaimer in fine print is not sufficient. As it stands this is an informal declaration of war. Vancouver, 2010, you're going down. Being a civilized nation, the winner will of course be decided by overall medal count. In the event of a tie there will be a pairs freestyle skate off. And the stakes? We're going wager, um...our Quebec to your Alaska. Good Luck.
 
If I didn't know better I'd say R. Mackey has an opinion on us Cannucks. I am a bit surprised. Then again, perhaps his comments relate strickly to "Jeff" and not Canadians in general.

TAM;)
 
If you were to actually listen to the phone calls, you'd understand.

"Jeff" is such a perfect fit to the negative stereotype, it's almost enough to make me think he's not really Canadian at all.

ETA: Oh, by the way, the USA and Canada are facing off in the Gold Cup semifinals. Perhaps that will do to settle our little tussle? :D
 
I dunno. If aint hockey, it doesnt count. I was a good soccer player in my day though, perhaps if we ever meet we will settle it on the soccer pitch, and later in the ICU...lol

TAM:)
 
Really? See this history of aviation accidents and the pictures of airplanes hitting the ground and the their characteristics. Point defeated.

How many full-speed crashes have you analysed ? Point defeated.

The FBI has individuals that make errors.

Yeah, that makes your theory a whole lot more credible, doesn't it ?

People who saw the impact and then saw the photo apparently disagree that the photo is genuine. Who is more likely to be correct?

People who know how analysing photographs works.

The picture should convince me. It doesn't.

Yeah, that's really unfortunate. Do you have actual evidence or just your opinion ?

True. They saw the event and then saw the photo, and concluded it was a fraud.

Wow... that just proves nothing.

Does a mushroom cloud change in appearance if it is viewed from different directions? Place a mushroom cloud and take photos from 4 different directions. Does it look different? Not to my knowledge.

Your knowledge is lacking, then.

Until you find evidence, and facts to prove Val made up the photo as she handed to police that day, then you are a person who makes up ideas about 9/11 with no facts or evidence.

Why should we assume that the picture is a fake ?

Will you please stop attacking the character?

He wasn't. I think you failed to grasp his point.

How could I be convinced?
1. The original digital file was analyzed by an expert and proven to be valid.
2. The primary source statements who viewed the event and the photo recanted their statements.

And since #1 happened, and #2 simply can't, you're safe from that annoying process known as learning.
 
Great. The physics match the photo. That does nothing to prove the validity of the photo. Unless you have the original digital file, the analysis is inconsequential.

So the fact that it looks genuine means nothing ?

Plane crashes were quite frequent on 9/11.

Now you're just being obtuse.

So is it black or gray?

Before or after it disperses ?

You see black in Val's photo, I see gray. I see black in your two photos on the right, I see gray in the photo on the left.
You see no differences, I do.

So... what ? The plume should remain black until it suddenly vanishes ?
 
The word "Hoser" should be stricken from the Canenglish language.

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom