August 2007 Stundie Nominations

FYI

http://forum.prisonplanet.com/index.php?topic=289.0

28th Kingdom has started a thread at the PP forum that "will be our answer to the Stundies"

An excellent nomination resulted, unintentionally, by one of the board's members.

[QUOTE='The Decadent Traveller' (sic)]

Some member on the LooseChange forum noticed that there was a group of posters with low registration numbers (meaning they were amongst the first to register on the forum) that were contunually disrupting threads, naysaying everything in order to cause arguement rather than debate, thus killing the topic, sometimes even getting it locked.

This member, researching his reply to a topic, found that a lot of the important topics were being copied and pasted on the JREF forum where they would be analysed and the best responses, by their opinions, to the topic taken back to LooseChange. He was able to establish, by repeat phrasing and posting style, which JREF members were on the LooseChange forum and what their usernames were.

This is where it got interesting. Nearly all of their usernames seemed to be a reference to the Illuminati and things related to them.

One of their leaders, TotoVader, who is all over Youtube spamming the comment section of 9/11 truthseekers videos has an interesting username: Toto = Dorothy's dog from the Wizard of Oz and Vader is, of course, the main villain from Star Wars. Anybody with knowledge of Monarch Mind Control, will know that the Wizard of Oz and Star Wars were both used in the Monarch Mind Control experiments on young boys and girls. I'm sure Alex Jones's Websites have information about this.[/QUOTE]
 
nicepants said:
[QUOTE='The Decadent Traveller' (sic)]

Some member on the LooseChange forum noticed that there was a group of posters with low registration numbers (meaning they were amongst the first to register on the forum) that were contunually disrupting threads, naysaying everything in order to cause arguement rather than debate, thus killing the topic, sometimes even getting it locked.

This member, researching his reply to a topic, found that a lot of the important topics were being copied and pasted on the JREF forum where they would be analysed and the best responses, by their opinions, to the topic taken back to LooseChange. He was able to establish, by repeat phrasing and posting style, which JREF members were on the LooseChange forum and what their usernames were.

This is where it got interesting. Nearly all of their usernames seemed to be a reference to the Illuminati and things related to them.

One of their leaders, TotoVader, who is all over Youtube spamming the comment section of 9/11 truthseekers videos has an interesting username: Toto = Dorothy's dog from the Wizard of Oz and Vader is, of course, the main villain from Star Wars. Anybody with knowledge of Monarch Mind Control, will know that the Wizard of Oz and Star Wars were both used in the Monarch Mind Control experiments on young boys and girls. I'm sure Alex Jones's Websites have information about this.
[/QUOTE]

TotoVader's in charge of the NWO? Who knew? Great cover!

All hail TotoVader! (But where does that leave Gravy?)
 
Equations? Analysis? Who needs that!

In an effort to avoid complicated equations and analysis, I’ve been looking for an easier explanation. Here is my thinking.

The towers collapsed at near free fall speed; therefore it must have been controlled demolition.



And now, in tribute to our most recently banned annoyance, I will now perform my newest Logical Feats of Daring, and debunk this Stundie Nomination! I call this one, "Hey, Billy, Here's How It's Supposed To Be Done!"


qarnos has nominated this bit as a potential Stundie:

In an effort to avoid complicated equations and analysis, I’ve been looking for an easier explanation. Here is my thinking.

The towers collapsed at near free fall speed; therefore it must have been controlled demolition.


Now, I acknowledge that, in isolation, this appears to be a funny bit of assuming the consequent. However, it seems to me that qarnos has, unintentionally, taken this quote out of context. Consider the entirety of the original post:


I’m sure this has been discussed, ad nauseam, but recently I thought of an angle that I haven’t read before and I was hoping someone could expand upon it and/or point me toward a discussion I my have missed.

I’m having a hard time wrapping my brain around the fact that the WTC towers collapsed within a time period only slightly faster than an object in free fall. The argument being that the individual floors would have provided some resistance and slowed the whole collapse down.

In an effort to avoid complicated equations and analysis, I’ve been looking for an easier explanation. Here is my thinking.

The towers collapsed at near free fall speed; therefore it must have been controlled demolition.

Why is that? Do buildings that are demolished using controlled demolition normally collapse at near free fall speed?

According to http://www.jnani.org/mrking/writings/911/king911.htm they do, but it is entirely due to explosives on the lowest floors, initiating the collapse, and then gravity takes over for the remainder of the building. Any explosives used in the upper part of the structure are primarily used to direct its fall.

The problem with this is that the upper explosive could be helping to speed up the collapse.

My question: Is there an example of a building being demolished using controlled demolition where the only explosives used were the ones on the ground floor, and did that building collapse at near free fall speed?

If so then I would think it is game over for those who cling to the idea that near free fall speed equals controlled demolition. An example of this sort would easily illustrate to even the densest conspiracy theorist that the floors that were not blown also did not provide any significant resistance to the speed at which the building fell.

Anyways, that’s my thinking. I hope it goes somewhere…


While the formating of the post does leave itself open to misinterpretation, it seems to me that the line, "The towers collapsed at near free fall speed; therefore it must have been controlled demolition" is intended merely as a summation of a hypothesis that furrod is trying to analyze. Reworded, he is asking, "Is a free-fall descent actually evidence of a CD or not?", as evidenced by his next line, "Why is that? Do buildings that are demolished using controlled demolition normally collapse at near free fall speed?"

Having established what it is he seeks to determine, he proposes a method to try and answer this question: a comparison to other, known CDs. However, he also notes the problem that most CDs include explosives on several levels of the building, and so he seeks information on CDs which use explosives exclusively on the lowest levels of the building. He then argues that, if such a CD were known to exist, a comparison to the collapses on 9/11 could determine if such "freefall" collapses are indicative of CDs or not.

This is similar to certain types of proofs used in mathematics and physics. When asked to prove that X does not equal Y, it is often easier to assume that X does equal Y, and then show that this assumption leads to conclusions that we know are false, which allows us to conclude that, contrary to our assumption, X in fact does not equal Y.

As such, this is not a Stundie, it is, in fact, a well-thought out, although perhaps not so well-written, good idea.


Here Endeth The Lesson.


May Billy Rest In Peace.


You May Now Attack Me With All Vigor.


:)
 
Originally Posted by Heiwa
Thanks for your intelligent contributions to the discussion. As you know by now I find it intriguing to speculate about how 9/11 was actually done and my present stand is CD - at WTC 1,2,7 and pentagon and no planes. Same at Shanksville but no CD ... and no plane, of course. Keep it simple.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=87437&page=18

Because it is just so simple, seriously simple.
 
William Rea is banned.

So this is what it feels like...funny, I thought I'd miss him maybe a little, like you miss an old punching bag. But nope, nothing.

Party time!

On another note, 28th Kingdom really took me well out of context with that post, didn't he! I especially like the imaginary conversation that follows...
 
William Rea is banned.

Don't be sad, Moby. If it makes you feel better, I'll stick my head into the Stundie thread a few times a month, make claims that the stundie nominations don't say what you think they say, then warn you that the stundies are dying. ;)
 
....make claims that the stundie nominations don't say what you think they say, ;)



Oh come on! I've already posted an entire post of Logical Daring-do, and It Gets Ignored?


I might as well go woo!


teh-stundies-are-flawed.png



Now do you see what happens?

:)
 
Last edited:
Don't be sad, Moby. If it makes you feel better, I'll stick my head into the Stundie thread a few times a month, make claims that the stundie nominations don't say what you think they say, then warn you that the stundies are dying. ;)

Hehe - ooh, we could take it in turns, could be a kind of tradition. Like when the Japanese dress someone up as an evil spirit and then chase them away - it's symbolic!

Horatius already had a go for this month! :D

Oh come on! I've already posted an entire post of Logical Daring-do, and It Gets Ignored?


I might as well go woo!


teh-stundies-are-flawed.png



Now do you see what happens?

:)

Naughty bad Horatius. Naughty naughty.

Although you're right, I did predict that one. I wonder if I get the million dollars yet?
 
Oh come on! I've already posted an entire post of Logical Daring-do, and It Gets Ignored?


I might as well go woo!


[qimg]http://static.stripgenerator.com/generated/horatius/strip/2007/08/11/teh-stundies-are-flawed.png[/qimg]


Now do you see what happens?

:)

Hey, that's Ron's character!!!

OMG, you killed Ron! You bastard!
 
Here's my nomination from 9/11 CT's Euro Ace.

Heiwa said:
Two-four. I think the gangsters did it with CD everywhere. That's the easy part. The planes and hijackings were deceptions with the whole US air force + armed forces around exercizing with planes flying around. And the media played its part of course. Not too difficult ... with some planning and exercizing. The visual witnesses are the easiest to manipulate. What a cynic I am. But I have seen similar things on a smaller scale and nobody seems to care.

Amazingly Heiwa just keeps getting dumber and dumber....
 
I'd like to nominate your signature:

People I now have permanently on ignore: Undesired Walrus, TAM, funk de fino, Pardalis, Anti-sophist, Sword_Of_Truth, Totovader, Enigma

Remember, you can nominate this again next month, as it will be twice as long by then.
 
More comedy gold from out resident JFER'er/truther Lyte Trip.

First he admits that his "A" witness isn't so strong.

Then, he seems to take offense that if his fantasy of the Pentagon 'north side' claim ever went to court that the opposing attorney wouldn't be on his side.

Lyte trip at lcf

I will admit that out of context, Lagasse's account alone could be torn apart by a lawyer (who is uninterested in truth) as you just did.

But the typical and irrelevant embellishments, mistakes, and deductions in his account would not have an impact on the north side claim detail that has been scientifically proven via independent corroboration.

http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=13663
 
More comedy gold from out resident JFER'er/truther Lyte Trip.

First he admits that his "A" witness isn't so strong.

Then, he seems to take offense that if his fantasy of the Pentagon 'north side' claim ever went to court that the opposing attorney wouldn't be on his side.



http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=13663

What "independent corroboration" scientifically proves the north side claim? His other 2 (3?) faulty witness testimonies?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom