Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

He has the power to shut down free elections now.

I am not really sure of that.

But, if he has, well, he could be labeled as a " potential " dictator, yes.

Still, until he keeps on free elections, he can not be labeled as dictator, potential or not.

And there are good elements to say that he will never shut down free elections, being him in good terms with Lula, Kirchner and many others..
 
Is it possible to elect a dictator? Of course. If a leader has absolute power other than his ability to halt elections then he is a dictator.

I do not get it.
You say a person can be a dictator, even if he still keeps up free elections?

Chavez comes awfully damn close. When a leader can seize businesses and close key opposition channels then I think it is unreasonable to argue the person isn't in many ways a dictator. Hell, at least the guy is a dick.

Well, " seize businesses ", means, " nationalize them ", which is quite different, if I got what you think..
" Close key oposition channels ", well, that is bad too, but, please, remember that, when Berlusconi was in power, in Italy, he was the owner of 3 of the 6 national TV channels ( Canale 5, Rete 4, Italia 1 ), and, as head of the government, decided who was in the board of the other 3 national channels ( Rai1, Rai2, Rai 3 ).
So, directly or indirectly, he controlled all the 6 national TV channels.
This did not make him a " dictator ", did it?
 
Matteo, my point was that dictators and demagogues can either be left- or right-handed. There are numerous similarities in their actions, speeches and policies. Chavez is making moves that we, in Latin America, have seen before in right winded and left-winded governments. When it comes to the economy, they never worked in the long term, despite the fact that the crowds supported them, at least at the beggining. And when it comes to democracy and freedom, they were always a sign of worse things to come.

OK.
If you have the feeling that he may becoming a dictator, this is fine.
But, you can not call him a dictator, so far ( IMHO ).
About the economy, there are plenty of example, in South America too, where market economy has led to a 5% of the population being extra wealthy, and 95% of the population being poor.
So, market economy has also problems.
And I am not sure that, that the Venezuelan economy is collapsing, right now.

Let me remind you that dictatorships do have elections... We had elections in Brazil under the millitary and countries that are not exactly prime examples of democracy do have elections. The totalitarian governments just help you by previously deciding on who you can vote and eventually fixing some "distortions" or "problems" in vote numbers... Totalitarian governments do not need to ban elections, they just have to controll them. And they do so. And they quite often use them to legitimate themselves. "I was re-elected by the will of the people!"

I was speaking about free ( and fair ) elections, not just of elections.
So far, elections in Venezuela have been regular.
 
What's rather ironic is the degree to which people defend Chavez while attacking Bush. Yet, can you imagine the outrage if Bush did what Chavez has done? Me too.

I hope you do not include me in those " people ".
I am not defending, by any means, what Chavez is doing.
I am just saying that he is not a dictator, so far.
As always, I would like not to be misunderstood, if I criticize Bush, and say that Chavez is not a dictator ( so far ), this does not mean, in any way, that Chavez is better than Bush.
Please, remember this.
I just find that people here are bashing Chavez little bit biased, and sometimes the same people are not enough critic of the current U.S. Administration.
But that, does not mean in any way, that the U.S. political situation ( under this administration too ), can be remotely compared to the Venezuelan - meaning that the current US administration is, by far, much more freedom, fair elections, etc. - oriented
 
Of course dictatorships are considered good by a certain population of any group of people living under a dictatorship. I think that misses the point. One could make a similar argument that slavery = bad and freedom = good is not always right.

“I freed a thousand slaves I could have freed a thousand more if only they knew they were slaves.” -- Harriet Tubman

If it is possible to make the argument that freedom is preferable to slavery then it is possible to make the argument that democracy is preferable to dictatorship.

Exactly.
If I had to choose to live like a slave, but, treated with humanity and having food and shelter, or to live like a free man, with nothing to eat, in a situation of constant danger, I would maybe prefer the former.
About democracies: example with China, many bad things are happening in China, but the economy, apparently is growing much faster than in many democracies in the Third World.
So, at least in economic sense, economies in not-free countries, can perform better than economies of democracies.
 
We will know sooner or later if he is going to become a dictator. Some smaller moves he may make in the near future will likely be abolishing independent review of elections, reporter assassinations like what's been happening in Russia recently, outlawing any civilian groups opposed to him, and a lot of smaller things that in and of themselves are bad but not necessarily dictator status.

I think that abolishing independent review of elections may be considered as changing the country status into " dictatorship ", or, very close to it.
 
I can not agree with the sentence " stupid people vote Democrat "..
Then you disagree with the Democrat Party, who claimed their supporters couldn't figure out how to punch a hole in a piece of paper.
 
Last edited:
Then you disagree with the Democrat Party, who claimed their supporters couldn't figure out how to punch a hole in a piece of paper.

All of their supporters?
BTW, I read that much has to do with the weird machines put in place to vote..
 
All of their supporters?
BTW, I read that much has to do with the weird machines put in place to vote..
Those "weird machines" had been used for many years, they were not some novel thing.

Basically, I say that, if people want to change, they will do it whatever the press will say..
But lacking information on other views, how will they ever learn enough to know they want change?
 
I do not get it.
You say a person can be a dictator, even if he still keeps up free elections?

Well, " seize businesses ", means, " nationalize them ", which is quite different, if I got what you think..
" Close key oposition channels ", well, that is bad too, but, please, remember that, when Berlusconi was in power, in Italy, he was the owner of 3 of the 6 national TV channels ( Canale 5, Rete 4, Italia 1 ), and, as head of the government, decided who was in the board of the other 3 national channels ( Rai1, Rai2, Rai 3 ).
So, directly or indirectly, he controlled all the 6 national TV channels.
This did not make him a " dictator ", did it?

When, precisely does day become night?

You are trying to create a false dichotomy, there is none. Elections are only significant if there is a real chance that the individual can be turned out of power.

Chavez is acting like a dictator. You say he's not. That's fine. I don't need to split hairs. Let's see what the future holds.

Did Berlusconi seize businesses like Cavez has done and threatens to do like many other dictators have done?

See, there is a gradient and not a simple dichotomy. Chavez in the twilight of his dictatorship. Let's see if day turns into night.
 
Those "weird machines" had been used for many years, they were not some novel thing.

OK.
I keep not agreeing with " stupid people vote Democrat "

But lacking information on other views, how will they ever learn enough to know they want change?

Is it complete lack of other views?
Is there absolute lack of freedom of press, in Venezuela?
Can be the people be fooled to think that they live in a free-press society, when they are not?
 
When, precisely does day become night?

You are trying to create a false dichotomy, there is none. Elections are only significant if there is a real chance that the individual can be turned out of power.

Chavez is acting like a dictator. You say he's not. That's fine. I don't need to split hairs. Let's see what the future holds.

Did Berlusconi seize businesses like Cavez has done and threatens to do like many other dictators have done?

See, there is a gradient and not a simple dichotomy. Chavez in the twilight of his dictatorship. Let's see if day turns into night.

OK.
I agree that there is no clear line between being a dictator or not.
But, I still contest the sentence " Chavez is acting like a dictator ", as, at the moment, he is not.
About Berlusconi, he had attacked judges, called " a*****s " the people who were voting for the opposing party, had hired people involved with Mafia, has a number of trials going on in Italy ( and abroad? ), which he escaped because he managed to pass the term of conviction or, when he was Prime Minister, he changed the law by which he was accused, he has a number of member of his own party who are been sentenced as guilty of curruption, Mafia, and other by the Italian justice in a definite way, and those guys, from Berlusconi` s party, are still there sitting in the Italian Parliament, when he was president, he sistematically attacked the few media sources which he did not control, he had a big conflict of interest, as he was, in the same time, entrepreneur ( having lots of financial, real-estate, etc. companies ), media mogul ( controlling basically all the private TV sector in Italy, and many newspapers ) and Prime Minister, and he got along for years with this conflict of interests, and so on..
And, you complain about Chavez..
 
OK.
I agree that there is no clear line between being a dictator or not.
But, I still contest the sentence " Chavez is acting like a dictator ", as, at the moment, he is not.
Then we have a point of disagreement. When a leader unilatiraly closes opposition sources and threatens to seize businesses by fiat that is a clear example of acting like a dictator. IMO. I've been wrong before.

We can disagree.


About Berlusconi, he had attacked judges, called " a*****s " the people who were voting for the opposing party, had hired people involved with Mafia, has a number of trials going on in Italy ( and abroad? ), which he escaped because he managed to pass the term of conviction or, when he was Prime Minister, he changed the law by which he was accused, he has a number of member of his own party who are been sentenced as guilty of curruption, Mafia, and other by the Italian justice in a definite way, and those guys, from Berlusconi` s party, are still there sitting in the Italian Parliament, when he was president, he sistematically attacked the few media sources which he did not control, he had a big conflict of interest, as he was, in the same time, entrepreneur ( having lots of financial, real-estate, etc. companies ), media mogul ( controlling basically all the private TV sector in Italy, and many newspapers ) and Prime Minister, and he got along for years with this conflict of interests, and so on..
And, you complain about Chavez..
Please don't get me wrong, I'm not excusing Berlusconi, if he was acting like a dictator then fine. I don't have a problem with that.
 
Then we have a point of disagreement. When a leader unilatiraly closes opposition sources and threatens to seize businesses by fiat that is a clear example of acting like a dictator. IMO. I've been wrong before.

We can disagree.

That is a problem of definition.
My point with Berlusconi, is that you do not have a black and white situation, between being a dictator or not.
And, you would find examples of leaders trying to " closes opposition sources and threatens to seize businesses " in countries not usually listed as dictatorships too.
About Chavez, I do not support him, but, I would not call him a dictator, for what he has done so far, and, I think that, until the population is with him, as it seems it is, I think that the will of the majority of the people of Venezuela should be respected.
 
My point with Berlusconi, is that you do not have a black and white situation, between being a dictator or not.
No, that is my point.

I make no such claims. On the contrary.


And, you would find examples of leaders trying to " closes opposition sources and threatens to seize businesses " in countries not usually listed as dictatorships too.
Not a good argument but that's fine.


About Chavez, I do not support him, but, I would not call him a dictator, for what he has done so far, and, I think that, until the population is with him, as it seems it is, I think that the will of the majority of the people of Venezuela should be respected.
Venezuela should not be immune to criticism. If I start daily threads like Oliver does against America then you might have a point. As it is I'm simply voicing an opinion.
 
On January 31, 2007 the Venezuelan National Assembly approved an enabling act granting Chávez the power to rule by decree in certain areas for 18 months
On August 15, 2007, Chavez called for an end to presidential term limits to extend his rule and consolidate a self-styled socialist revolution in Venezuela. He also proposed eliminating central bank autonomy, strengthening state expropriation powers and giving himself control over international reserves as part of an overhaul of Venezuela's constitution
Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_Chávez

If you still don't understand, try:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_idiot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom