Review of Gravy's film at ABOVE TOP SECRET

And if you want to claim that silent explosives that do not disturb the air around them were used, you'll need to provide evidence that such things exist.

On this point I think Tony is taking a page from the CIT's new playbook where Ranke is now using this gem.

"But I do know that the suspect in question has access to the most advanced weaponry in the world including unknown technology."

See, they don't have to prove it because they "know" the gubmint has sooper sekret explosives that defy physics.

So there.
 
As we know,
There are known knowns.
There are things we know we know.
We also know
There are known unknowns.
That is to say
We know there are some things
We do not know.
But there are also unknown unknowns,
The ones we don't know
We don't know.
 
The charges would have only needed to be on the outer central core columns, to remove enough support and allow the weight of the building to then cause a collapse. This which would have left some of the inner columns standing.

And here we have a classic example of inflation.

The more we question your theory, the more ridiculous it gets. It's not much of a theory, then, is it?

Besides, I'm still waiting to hear how those exterior columns bowed for tens of minutes beforehand. You can't run from that knowledge forever.
 
As we know,
There are known knowns.
There are things we know we know.
We also know
There are known unknowns.
That is to say
We know there are some things
We do not know.
But there are also unknown unknowns,
The ones we don't know
We don't know.

Ah, leave it to Rumsfeld to clear things up for us.
 
And here we have a classic example of inflation.

The more we question your theory, the more ridiculous it gets. It's not much of a theory, then, is it?

Besides, I'm still waiting to hear how those exterior columns bowed for tens of minutes beforehand. You can't run from that knowledge forever.

Is there any evidence proving the bowing wasn't caused by the initial impact and explosion?
i.e. photos of the area immediately after impact that do not show the bowing and then after the alloted time, photos showing the bowing caused by weakening of the structure?
 
In an earlier post I gave an example using the highest ultimate shear strength A36 steel could have. As it's greatest ultimate tensile strength is 80 ksi then .577 x 80 ksi = 46.16 ksi.

you have correctly calculated the shear capacity based on the tensile strength, according to code, and then....

Taking the energy in a one pound block of C-4 again 17.3 x 10e6 inch pounds, and dividing by the fracture energy required per square inch of 46,160 inch pounds/sq. inch

oops, since when is the fracture energy of a cross section equal to the shear capacity of the steel its made from?

I just asked you to explain this, and you gave me this crap answer, which was just to repeat your mistake.

So I'll try again, justify that the fracture energy of the cross section is equal to the shear capacity of the steel, or demonstrate that a pound inch and a pound are the same thing.
 
The core columns could have been destroyed with a couple of pounds of C-4 each not the monstrous amount that Mark Roberts wants to imply was necesary and that would have been obvious.

Let's assume, for the sake of arguement, that the equation given by JMarshall is not valid and wildly over predicts the amount of high explosive needed to cut a cross section, and the engineers of the world have huffed enough glue to believe that a pound inch is no different that a pound.

The fact remains that the collapse initiated on the fire and impact floors, so then the explosives on these floors would have to survive fire and impact. Explosive material can ignite when subjected to rapid shear, and a linear shaped charge could be completely destroyed by impact. Explosives will also be rendered inert by heat decomposition, even at temperatures lower than the fires in the towers.

How does this fit into your speculations?
 
The fact remains that the collapse initiated on the fire and impact floors, so then the explosives on these floors would have to survive fire and impact. Explosive material can ignite when subjected to rapid shear, and a linear shaped charge could be completely destroyed by impact. Explosives will also be rendered inert by heat decomposition, even at temperatures lower than the fires in the towers.

And don't forget the wires to the detonators. No way on earth insulated wire would survive fires that would melt aluminum.

Don't say radio-controlled detonation. No bomb tech in his right mind is going to install blasting caps into a charge in a building with a bazillion cell phones in use over the course of a day, or that huge antenna array on the roof.
 
I didn't realize before just how much of the south tower cores were still standing after the perimeter collapsed. So much for bombs in the basement or mini-nukes, right?
 
And here we have a classic example of inflation.

The more we question your theory, the more ridiculous it gets. It's not much of a theory, then, is it?

Besides, I'm still waiting to hear how those exterior columns bowed for tens of minutes beforehand. You can't run from that knowledge forever.

I would call it convergence and there is a basis for the outer central core columns being the only columns that would have actually needed to be cut in a demolition.

If you disagree and don't refute anything then it is only your opinion. That is all you are stating here as you haven't refuted anything.

As for the exterior columns bowing in beforehand I have asked for a video showing them bowing inward for minutes before the collapses and nobody here seems to be able to produce anything but a video of the South Towers perimeter columns bowing in during the last few seconds, just before the collapse.
 
you have correctly calculated the shear capacity based on the tensile strength, according to code, and then....



oops, since when is the fracture energy of a cross section equal to the shear capacity of the steel its made from?

I just asked you to explain this, and you gave me this crap answer, which was just to repeat your mistake.

So I'll try again, justify that the fracture energy of the cross section is equal to the shear capacity of the steel, or demonstrate that a pound inch and a pound are the same thing.


In this case it is the strain energy at failure that I think you are asking for. It is the area under the stress strain curve. It is essentially stress x strain. So you have force/area x strain. That is what I gave in the form of inch pounds/sq. inch using the ultimate shear stress.
 
Last edited:
Let's assume, for the sake of arguement, that the equation given by JMarshall is not valid and wildly over predicts the amount of high explosive needed to cut a cross section, and the engineers of the world have huffed enough glue to believe that a pound inch is no different that a pound.

The fact remains that the collapse initiated on the fire and impact floors, so then the explosives on these floors would have to survive fire and impact. Explosive material can ignite when subjected to rapid shear, and a linear shaped charge could be completely destroyed by impact. Explosives will also be rendered inert by heat decomposition, even at temperatures lower than the fires in the towers.

How does this fit into your speculations?

Strain Energy in the form inch pounds/sq. inch is valid. I have shown you that.

As for where the collapses initiated I think you should take a look at where NIST puts the failure initiations. They are at the 82nd floor on the South Tower and the 98th floor on the North Tower. Then take a look at the damage studies of those floors. There was some damage on the 82nd floor of the South Tower, but not significant. There was almost no damage on the 98th floor of the North Tower. I don't know about the explosives being rendered inert by the heat. I will have to look into that.
 
In this case it is the strain energy at failure that I think you are asking for. It is the area under the stress strain curve. It is essentially stress x strain. So you have force/area x strain. That is what I gave in the form of inch pounds/sq. inch using the ultimate shear stress.

That's how tensile/compressive strain energy works, unfortunately, it's not that simple for shear strain energy. But again, you still can't keep your units right. Force/area x strain with units is equal to force (lb) / area (in^2) x strain (in/in) = lb/(in^2) or psi which is NOT lb*in/sq.inch. Even that's still moot, since you never even showed what strain the steel would fail at.

Again, I recommend you look at:

http://me.queensu.ca/courses/MECH422/Lecture13.ppt or another classical source of energy methods. If this is so simple you should be able to find literature examples of the METHOD that you used to calculate shear strain energy.
 
Last edited:
I have shown here that the core columns in the Twin Towers could have been easily taken out by a couple of pounds of C-4 each, with gravity doing the rest of the work due to impulsive loads, and you have not been able to refute that.

You haven't shown that at all... THE FACT IS: A couple of pounds of explosives can not do it!

You claiming your math, and equations, and all that other crap, can prove my expertise and experience wrong is, in my eyes insulting!

I gave you the best way for calculating the explosives needed to cut any structural steal over 2 inches thick... In my example it would take roughly 16 pounds (C4) to cut the 14"x4" piece. Now are you really insinuating that I don't know how to do my job?

Oh wait... I know, since it was the government behind 9-11, they purposely misprinted all of the FM 5-34 Engineer Field Data books ever printed, and trained every Combat Engineer the wrong procedures! That must be it!

To keep things civil, I really suggest you rethink your claim of the 1-2 lb charge theory...

A scan of page 9-9, in FM 5-34:
Image removed just so there is no chance I get thrown in jail, for the information...

The fact that you can't find this book, or get your hands on it is good, because it contains classified information (I made sure none of the information on this page was classified; I don't want to go to jail by any means!) and as such would be a great tool for terrorists, and enemies, you remember them right? The ones that flew the planes into the buildings!
 
Last edited:
That's how tensile/compressive strain energy works, unfortunately, it's not that simple for shear strain energy. But again, you still can't keep your units right. Force/area x strain with units is equal to force (lb) / area (in^2) x strain (in/in) = lb/(in^2) or psi which is NOT lb*in/sq.inch. Even that's still moot, since you never even showed what strain the steel would fail at.

Again, I recommend you look at:

http://me.queensu.ca/courses/MECH422/Lecture13.ppt or another classical source of energy methods. If this is so simple you should be able to find literature examples of the METHOD that you used to calculate shear strain energy.

Care to tell me how the area under the shear stress vs. strain diagram doesn't equal the shear strain energy just as the area under the axial load stress vs. strain diagram does.

As for the strain energy at failure it can be expressed as inch pounds/unit area. I have shown you that. The GE paper was just one I plucked off of the Internet. There are many examples.

What you said about the units is basically a circular argument in case you don't realize it. You basically said psi = psi and claimed the strain has nothing to do with it.

What units do you get for strain energy when you take the area under the stress vs. strain curve?
 
Last edited:
You haven't shown that at all... THE FACT IS: A couple of pounds of explosives can not do it!

You claiming your math, and equations, and all that other crap, can prove my expertise and experience wrong is, in my eyes insulting!

I gave you the best way for calculating the explosives needed to cut any structural steal over 2 inches thick... In my example it would take roughly 16 pounds (C4) to cut the 14"x4" piece. Now are you really insinuating that I don't know how to do my job?

Oh wait... I know, since it was the government behind 9-11, they purposely misprinted all of the FM 5-34 Engineer Field Data books ever printed, and trained every Combat Engineer the wrong procedures! That must be it!

To keep things civil, I really suggest you rethink your claim of the 1-2 lb charge theory...

A scan of page 9-9, in FM 5-34:
[qimg]http://i206.photobucket.com/albums/bb68/T3KN1K4L/img028.jpg[/qimg]

The fact that you can't find this book, or get your hands on it is good, because it contains classified information (I made sure none of the information on this page was classified; I don't want to go to jail by any means!) and as such would be a great tool for terrorists, and enemies, you remember them right? The ones that flew the planes into the buildings!

That looks like a military field manual you show, but what we don't know is what level of overkill they are using. The energy equations do say that most of the twin tower columns could be taken out by a couple pounds of C-4. Even given the probable extreme overkill present in this manual it still doesn't call for what Mark Roberts video tries to imply would have been necessary. Nor does it make the case that there were no explosives in those towers.
 
Last edited:
Care to tell me how the area under the shear stress vs. strain diagram doesn't equal the shear strain energy just as the area under the axial load stress vs. strain diagram does.

Show me a shear stress vs. strain diagram. When you figure that out, you'll probably also figure out how to correctly calculate strain energy.

As for the strain energy at failure it can be expressed as inch pounds/unit area. I have shown you that. The GE paper was just one I plucked off of the Internet. There are many examples.

Show me papers that show how to calculate shear strain energy to failure. Please!

What you said about the units is basically a circular argument in case you don't realize it. You basically said psi = psi and claimed the strain has nothing to do with it.

What units do you get for strain energy when you take the area under the stress vs. strain curve?

No, what you said is moronic. Let's revisit your earlier post:

It is the area under the stress strain curve. It is essentially stress x strain.

The area under a stress-strain curve (in tension or compression) is the integral of f*u*du. Where f is the stress and u is the strain. In no world does that equal f*u. Are you getting the basic concept yet?


This is a more correct way to calculate ELASTIC strain energy. It does not include the energy required to fracture however.

shearstrainvf6.jpg


You know nothing about what you are talking about.
 
Last edited:
http://www.fortliberty.org/military-library/fm5-250/fm5-250.shtml

That link goes to FM 5-250 Explosives And Demolitions... In it you will find a section that talks about charges to create an Abatis. In an Abatis the goal is to fall trees along the side of a road, without cutting all the way through the trunk of the tree... What does this have to do with things? Well, we use C4 to do this, and if your math were correct the C4 would blast right through the trunks leaving no parts still attached, unless we used a very small amount... Lets check the equation out, shall we?

P=0.02(D squared)

P is pounds TNT
D is diameter of tree

1 lb of C4 would be able to cut a tree approximately 8 inches in diameter, granted this is for a test shot, since all trees have different physical properties. But if what you are saying is correct then that one pound charge would blast all the way through the tree and thus rendering it completely useless for an Abatis.

The Military doesn't like it's Combat Engineers to "overkill", we are taught to use the bare minimum.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom