Black Coshosh: Another herbal cure proves worthless

ok, let's look at more stats linda:

Annual consumption of black cohosh fluctuates dramatically, as illustrated from 1998 to 2001. In 1998, approximately 700,000 lb of dried black cohosh root were consumed worldwide. In 1999, it dropped to about 183,000 lb and then rebounded sharply to approximately 420,000 lb in 2001. It is estimated that the demand for black cohosh will increase in the next three-to-five years. In 2001, it was estimated that the black cohosh market, in consumption dollars, reached $2.25 million. Projections of consumption well in excess of 500,000 lb per year are common. Black cohosh prices have been slowly increasing since the autumn of 1999."

source: http://www.ces.ncsu.edu/depts/hort/hil/hil-135.html

so, you can produce maybe 10 cases of liver issues with BC (most of which have concommitant factors, but i will give you it anyway), for an estimated 500,000 lbs (226,796.18kg) sold annually

here is the basic math, assuming 1:1 ratio:

clinical studies on remifemin have used an 80mg dose
and so given annual sales, that's exactly 2,834,952.3 doses

in other words, your risk is about 0.00000353% per dose of liver injury

statistically INSIGNIFICANT

Interesting. You still haven't bothered looking at the links I provided.

However, the problem with your math is this. You have no idea what your numerator is.

Linda
 
i posted three recent papers earlier that demonstrated efficacy of BC in menopausal sx in human clinical trials - read them, and get back to me - these directly challenge the assertion of the original author of the thread

take up THAT argument instead chasing windmills

its amazing how few of you actually read the entire thread instead of having knee-jerk responses and wild assumptions about what herbalists know or don't know

Only one of the three trials was placebo-controlled, randomized and double-blind. The other study was not placebo-controlled or blinded. The third study was not placebo-controlled, blinded or randomized.

The lack of a placebo-control, blinding and randomization means that reliable conclusions cannot be drawn about the source of any 'effects'. It could just as easily be wishful thinking as Black Cohosh.

The one trial that was placebo-controlled, randomized and double-blind used a treatment that has already been shown to have some effect on depressive symptoms (St. John's Wort) with the Black Cohosh. You cannot distinguish whether it was Black Cohosh or St. John's Wort, or both that had an effect from this study.

Your studies are not sufficient to demonstrate the effectiveness of Black Cohosh.

Linda
 
Last edited:
bullcrap - look at three most recent clinical studies that i posted
stop repeating things that aren't true - it just means you don't do your research and shows you up as an irrational fundamentalist

Unfortunately I did look at your trials, they were unedifying.
In order:
1) This was an open study, the patient and the doctor knew what the treatment was and there was no placebo. Worthless.
2) Again not blinded and no placebo. Worthless.
3) Claims statistical effect in a double blind placebo study. Eureka, you hit. Ah, not quite it wasn't BC being used but a BC St John's Wort mixture.

the samskaras are found in the extant Ayurvedic literature - just do a little research there bud
Que?:confused:

the "praying" thing (its not praying) has, in part, to do with timing of the different procedures, i.e. a particular mantra takes x minutes to complete, before moving on to stage two processing, etc. - but i will not debate the virtues or lack thereof for mantra because you would have to have some familiarity with its principles, practices and history before you could utter even a slightly intelligent comment about it
You are quite right, I couldn't utter an intelligent comment about chanting a mantra when a clock will do.

besides which, the fact that you CANNOT explain why it is less toxic demonstrates that you are running out of ideas - your response is irrelevant and quite frankly laughable

aconite is EXTREMELY toxic - the fact that you can purify it and then give it at doses 8 times the toxic doses WITHOUT ANY toxic effects speaks to the efficacy of the procedure - that is what was at issue, that traditional methods are used to render herbs less toxic

I gave you an explanation that is well within the realms of science, they didn't make the toxin less toxic, they extracted the toxin and threw it away.

this is a FACT, inasmuch as any "fact" can be said to be TRUTH

QED

deny it, and you become a fundamentalist skeptic just like all the others

Gosh I've moved from being an irrational fundametalist to being a fundamentalist skeptic in one post. Now where's that pocket I keep my real beliefs in, no that's the suspension of all belief pocket, ah here it is, funny, it says I'm just a skeptic, I feel mildly disappointed.
 
you said it was prescribed for menopause
is this true or not?

That's a confusing question, since the issue is about your reading comprehension, not about my claim.

It is not true that I said it was 'prescribed' for menopause. Please respond to what I actually wrote:

Black Cohosh is one of those sCAMs that recycles every generation. It was recommended as an herbal remedy for menopausal symptoms in the 1920s, didn't work, was recommended in the 1950s, didn't work, was recommended in the 1970s, didn't work, and came around again in the late '90s. My impression is that the '90s rehash had basically died out by 2005.

It is true that it was recommended as an herbal remedy for menopausal symptoms in the west for about 80 years now, in varying degrees of popularity.

My point was that herbal medicine is subject to fads, that these days such fads appear to cycle on a generational timeframe, and that black cohosh is a good example.
 
I want to add in another piece - this is from a respected colleague:

"The clearest, uncomplicated cases show elevated liver enzymes appearing within a few week in some cases of taking Remifemin, and then going away when it is discontinued, in women who are not taking any other meds. A number of other cases where statin drugs, which were previously tolerated well, began to show elevated liver enzymes when Remifemin was added. Of course none of us would suggest that anyone take black cohosh in doses of, say 40 drops, bid, long term, like -forever- which is how the MDs prescribe the Remifemin. Many other side effects are more common, especially muscle tension and pain and headaches"

That your colleague sees examples of hepatotoxicity in casual observation does not bode well for your claim about the insignificance of safety issues. It suggests a very large number of unrecognized (ETA: and recognized but not reported) cases.

Linda
 
Last edited:
classic bait and switch argument
the point was being made about purification, not efficacy

Wasn't trying to derail thread at all, just making a totally valid point.

if you want to start another thread on the efficacy of purified aconite start another thread and i will destroy your argument there are well
Please start one, and could you please give URLs for the references, it makes things so much easier.

as for your supposed skills on plant purification, that means nothing because since you know nothing about the actual clinical usage of the herb you wouldn't have a clue if the end-result would be efficacious

I haven't made any claims on plant purification. I wouldn't know how to purify a plant, holy water, eugenics?

I also do not profess to have a wide knowledge of the clinical and toxicological effects of administering unstandardised plant extracts to people. Therefore I wouldn't do it.

Unfortunately, the practioners of this art have no such scruples and as more herbalists appear on this forum the more they show they haven't a clue either.
 
Interesting. You still haven't bothered looking at the links I provided.

However, the problem with your math is this. You have no idea what your numerator is.

Linda

yes linda i looked at all your links

the thing is, the "precautionary statements" are more a political statement made by people that are as similarly biased and ignorant as you appear to be

if anyone is interested, read my posts under the quakbuster thread, in which i directly challenge the assertion that herbs are drugs

its very clear to me, that when you're a hammer, everything looks like a nail

once again, time for a paradigm shift
 
Wasn't trying to derail thread at all, just making a totally valid point.

it is an irrelevant point, as the thread is about BC, and may statement that possibility for toxicity increases when one fails to observe traditional methods of preparation and dosage

end of issue - as i said, stat another thread on ayurvedic samskaras, and i will invite some colleagues that know far more than i do to come in blow your little skeptical world apart

Please start one, and could you please give URLs for the references, it makes things so much easier.

i had tried to provide urls for all my statements except where they relate to my own opinion - please specify for which statement you require an url


I haven't made any claims on plant purification. I wouldn't know how to purify a plant, holy water, eugenics?

oh really - perhaps you were just channeling this statement then:

I can make ANY non-heavy metal containing herb safe in 10 minutes.

I also do not profess to have a wide knowledge of the clinical and toxicological effects of administering unstandardised plant extracts to people. Therefore I wouldn't do it.

and, by this same token, you are poorly equipped to have any relevant opinion either - thanks for finally pointing this out

you are now officially wasting bandwidth

Unfortunately, the practioners of this art have no such scruples and as more herbalists appear on this forum the more they show they haven't a clue either.

an irrelevant opinion based on nothing exception your own confusion and miscomprehension

so far i have determined that not only are self-proclaimed skeptics ignorant and biased, but they are duplicitous
 
That your colleague sees examples of hepatotoxicity in casual observation does not bode well for your claim about the insignificance of safety issues. It suggests a very large number of unrecognized (ETA: and recognized but not reported) cases.

Linda

are you a fortune teller now? perhaps you should consult an astrologer?

i have made several points, most notably the error of your logic in singling out BC for ADRs when many many more OTC pharmas present a much greater health risk to the general public, and yet, are still legally available

it seems to me that rationality should include fairness, but clearly in your skeptical world you are allowed to have double standards

instead of addressing this point, you conveniently ignore it and continue to chase windmills
 
That's a confusing question, since the issue is about your reading comprehension, not about my claim.

It is not true that I said it was 'prescribed' for menopause. Please respond to what I actually wrote:

Black Cohosh is one of those sCAMs that recycles every generation. It was recommended as an herbal remedy for menopausal symptoms in the 1920s, didn't work, was recommended in the 1950s, didn't work, was recommended in the 1970s, didn't work, and came around again in the late '90s. My impression is that the '90s rehash had basically died out by 2005.

"prescribed" or "recommended" - you are playing semantics

its clear skeptics conveniently play the semantic angle when they get tripped up on their own words - more evidence of duplicity


My point was that herbal medicine is subject to fads, that these days such fads appear to cycle on a generational timeframe, and that black cohosh is a good example.

underwear is subject to fads as well, as are handguns and condoms
is anything subject to the whims of consumerism therefore irrelevant?
actually, your point is irrelevant
 
Only one of the three trials was placebo-controlled, randomized and double-blind. The other study was not placebo-controlled or blinded. The third study was not placebo-controlled, blinded or randomized.

The lack of a placebo-control, blinding and randomization means that reliable conclusions cannot be drawn about the source of any 'effects'. It could just as easily be wishful thinking as Black Cohosh.

The one trial that was placebo-controlled, randomized and double-blind used a treatment that has already been shown to have some effect on depressive symptoms (St. John's Wort) with the Black Cohosh. You cannot distinguish whether it was Black Cohosh or St. John's Wort, or both that had an effect from this study.

Your studies are not sufficient to demonstrate the effectiveness of Black Cohosh.

Linda

wah wah wah - more hand-wringing

i simply posted the three most recent studies for someone who said there weren't any

do another lit search then linda, and you will see that there are still many many +ve studies for BC

as i pointed out, clinical trials are exceptionally costly
if you want them i suggest you write the grants and try to get the money

its not my fault the research community is so heavily tipped against herb research, but that is the reality, because as a herb cannot be patented their is little financial incentive

got a problem with this? go shout at mother nature
 
Vaidya,

In case you haven't noticed, you are the only one left posting here and you are talking to yourself.

-Ben

is that so ben?
thanks for taking the time to write in!
 
I haven't made any claims on plant purification. I wouldn't know how to purify a plant, holy water, eugenics?
oh really - perhaps you were just channeling this statement then:


I can make ANY non-heavy metal containing herb safe in 10 minutes.
so far i have determined that not only are self-proclaimed skeptics ignorant and biased, but they are duplicitous

You even requoted me and still didn't read the sentence. I said nothing about purification of plant extracts, which is what you presumably tried to say. I said I could make them safe.
Your example also makes one of them safe by extracting out the toxic steroids by a method that is reminiscent of alchemy, the only part that seems to be purified in this process is the toxin, which is then thrown away.

You have failed to show any convincing evidence that BC is efficacious and have refused to accept that BC can give people adverse affects that should therefore preclude its use. Your increased frequency of name calling has also been noted. Don't worry, most people who cannot come up with evidence also reach that point.

If the reason you started posting here was to convince us that BC is efficacious then that was a kind thought. However, having been shown that there is no proof of its activity in humans you might sit down and consider if it is ethical to sell somebody a preparation when you have no real idea if it is effective and knowing it could cause adverse effects.
 
are you a fortune teller now? perhaps you should consult an astrologer?

The adverse effects for Black Cohosh cannot occur in 0.00000353% of the doses if your colleague sees them on a regular basis. That suggests more like they occur in 1-10%. Not an insignificant problem.

i have made several points, most notably the error of your logic in singling out BC for ADRs when many many more OTC pharmas present a much greater health risk to the general public, and yet, are still legally available

Black Cohosh was singled out only because this is what the thread is about. As I stated earlier, I am able to be concerned about more than one thing at a time.

it seems to me that rationality should include fairness, but clearly in your skeptical world you are allowed to have double standards

instead of addressing this point, you conveniently ignore it and continue to chase windmills

Let me spell it out for you. I am concerned about any cause of preventable death, including but not limited to, adverse drug effects of acetaminophen and Black Cohosh.

Okay?

Linda
 
wah wah wah - more hand-wringing

Is this really the kind of behaviour that someone who claims to be a professional should exhibit?

i simply posted the three most recent studies for someone who said there weren't any

Shouldn't you have at least checked to see whether or not they actually were studies that demonstrated the effectiveness of Black Cohosh before you posted them as studies demonstrating the effectiveness of Black Cohosh?

do another lit search then linda, and you will see that there are still many many +ve studies for BC

I have looked and I'm not finding them. And frankly, based on your performance so far, I don't believe your vague assertions.

as i pointed out, clinical trials are exceptionally costly
if you want them i suggest you write the grants and try to get the money

its not my fault the research community is so heavily tipped against herb research, but that is the reality, because as a herb cannot be patented their is little financial incentive

got a problem with this? go shout at mother nature

I'm not interested in doing this. I prefer to spend my resources in areas that I think will be fruitful.

Linda
 
The lack of a placebo-control, blinding and randomization means that reliable conclusions cannot be drawn about the source of any 'effects'. It could just as easily be wishful thinking as Black Cohosh.

.. Your studies are not sufficient to demonstrate the effectiveness of Black Cohosh.

The three studies quoted here
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3307525#post3307525 show an obvious effect. Claiming "it could be wishful thinking" is not scientific, nor along the lines of evidence based medicine. This sort of blindness about scientific studies, where a conclusion is reached before looking at evidence, is the opposite of the scientific method.

Studies, especially ones that test the difference between two herbal formulas, do not exist in a vacuum. When research is done on differences, it is to examine what adding something does, not looking for an effect. Black Cohosh is already known to have an effect, the one study was looking at what adding another herb did.

Even a casual look at the wealth of data on Black Cohosh shows scientific evidence for having biological activity, that can both be measured, as well as understood.
The abstract of the paper you quoted is here.

... The paper shows that an alcoholic extract of BC can inhibit the uptake of a synthetic opioid in human receptors in hamster ovarian cells. This is interesting but to extend that as a mechanism for climacteric problems in humans is speculative to say the least. Before that mechanism can be proved lets look at the steps along the way.

Thanks for the link to the abstract.

http://pubs.acs.org/cgi-bin/abstract.cgi/jafcau/2006/54/i26/abs/jf062808u.html
These results demonstrate for the first time that black cohosh contains active principle(s) that activate hMOR, supporting its beneficial role in alleviating menopausal symptoms.

The double standard used by skeptics when it comes to science they don't like, is often amusing. Rather than admit a point, they want to move the goalpost, or focus on unrelated issues. A study that used the exact same method to determine the toxicity of a known drug, Taxol, wouldn't raise an eyebrow.

Taxol is a clinically active anticancer drug, which exerts its cytotoxicity by the unique mechanism of polymerizing tubulin monomers into microtubules and stabilizing microtubules. Our studies with ovarian (hamster CHO and human A2780) cells showed that taxol is a phase-specific agent that is much more cytotoxic to mitotic cells than interphase cells.
http://www.springerlink.com/content/u87p68017244m315/

See? Human ovarian cells in hamsters are used all the time to do testing. But when a result goes against your belief system, somehow it doesn't mean anything. Madness.

...
The problem with herbalists is that blithely ignore all these stages and just give the non-standardised preparation, without knowing a) what they are prescribing and b) what its action will be.

Such claims, while they sound good, are just something you made up. You don't actually know anything about the millions of herbalist worldwide, or how they think, work and research science. Your sweeping statement is simply woo. You have no research, no evidence, nothing to base your claim on. Yet such behavior is exactly what you purport to be against.

Even a cursory look at the vast amounts of research on medicinal herbs shows a keen interest in both establishing potency, standards, and finding ways to isolate and extract the active ingrediants from plants.

In the past, herbalist faced huge problems with obtaining and storing plants and their extracts. As well as knowing the potency of the product. This same problem exist today. Anyone who has bought a bag of herb knows the importance of determining quality, hopefully before the transaction. And you who have indeed bought and consumed a medicinal herb, might laugh along with us, when some skeptic tries to tell you that the effect might just be wishful thinking.... :wackywink:

Humans can become quite adept at evaluating the potency of an herbal product. Be it Coffee, or some other potent brew nature serves up, on a regular basis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom