Black Coshosh: Another herbal cure proves worthless

Interesting stuff, this Black Cohosh.

A July 24 review article published in the Archives of Internal Medicine (2006;166:1453-1465) concluded that alternative and complementary therapies are generally ineffective for treating menopause-related symptoms. Among the biologically based studies, only one on Remifemin(R) out of the four black cohosh studies reviewed, was shown to be effective.


"A single large trial showed a benefit for vasomotor symptoms with the black cohosh Remifemin(R) (Enzymatic Therapy Inc., Green Bay Wisconsin) and is consistent with older German studies," the reviewers wrote, indicating that the remaining three studies showed no benefits from black cohosh.
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/48394.php

So I check out Remifemin -

Each Remifemin tablet contains 20 mg. of black cohosh extract (root and rhizome). We recommend taking one tablet in the morning and one tablet in the evening. Black cohosh has been shown to significantly reduce hot flashes, night sweats, mood swings, irritability and related occasional sleeplessness.

Remifemin is a unique, proprietary, clinically tested formula. It has been the subject of over 90 scientific papers demonstrating its safety, efficacy and quality. Remifemin is the number one recommended menopausal symptom relief product by obstetricians and gynecologists (OB/GYN) doctors. No other black cohosh extract has been proven effective in as many clinical studies as Remifemin.

What does "standardized extract" mean?
"Standardized" means that every dose will have the same amount of active ingredient.

How do you know Remifemin® is safe?
Remifemin® has been the subject of numerous placebo-controlled clinical trials as well as open clinical monitoring trials in physicians' practices in women with menopausal complaints. Over 20 clinical trials have been done spanning more than 40 years with over 3000 subjects. In addition, its efficacy and safety has been demonstrated by market acceptance for over 40 years.

No drug interactions have been observed; adverse events have been limited to mild, transient stomach upset. Over 1.5 million women have taken Remifemin® since it was introduced and more than a billion tablets have been sold around the world.

Seems like them German scientist have done a lot of scientific research on this herb.

Interesting that a standardized extract, and safety information, are both provided by Remifemin®
 
Last edited:
robinson said:
The lack of a placebo-control, blinding and randomization means that reliable conclusions cannot be drawn about the source of any 'effects'. It could just as easily be wishful thinking as Black Cohosh.

.. Your studies are not sufficient to demonstrate the effectiveness of Black Cohosh.

The three studies quoted here
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3307525#post3307525 show an obvious effect. Claiming "it could be wishful thinking" is not scientific, nor along the lines of evidence based medicine. This sort of blindness about scientific studies, where a conclusion is reached before looking at evidence, is the opposite of the scientific method.

I explained why those studies did not remove the effect of wishful thinking. Evidence-based medicine is about removing the effects of wishful thinking, since if you already know that wishful thinking is having an effect, how can you tell what part, if any, is due to the drug? If they were performed on any other pharmaceutical, EBM would exclude them from consideration in a systematic analysis.

Studies, especially ones that test the difference between two herbal formulas, do not exist in a vacuum. When research is done on differences, it is to examine what adding something does, not looking for an effect. Black Cohosh is already known to have an effect, the one study was looking at what adding another herb did.

Black Cohosh is not known to have a clinical effect, though.

Even a casual look at the wealth of data on Black Cohosh shows scientific evidence for having biological activity, that can both be measured, as well as understood.

Yes. And you can use that information to form a plausible hypothesis about what kind of clinical effect you might see. But you don't know whether your hypothesis is correct until you test it. And this is not a trivial matter. Hypotheses at this stage of the game are often demonstrated to be false.

The abstract of the paper you quoted is here.

... The paper shows that an alcoholic extract of BC can inhibit the uptake of a synthetic opioid in human receptors in hamster ovarian cells. This is interesting but to extend that as a mechanism for climacteric problems in humans is speculative to say the least. Before that mechanism can be proved lets look at the steps along the way.

Thanks for the link to the abstract.

http://pubs.acs.org/cgi-bin/abstract.cgi/jafcau/2006/54/i26/abs/jf062808u.html
These results demonstrate for the first time that black cohosh contains active principle(s) that activate hMOR, supporting its beneficial role in alleviating menopausal symptoms.

The double standard used by skeptics when it comes to science they don't like, is often amusing. Rather than admit a point, they want to move the goalpost, or focus on unrelated issues. A study that used the exact same method to determine the toxicity of a known drug, Taxol, wouldn't raise an eyebrow.

You misunderstand. Out standard for determining toxicity is different from our standard for determining efficacy. We are generally more worried about causing harm than we are about losing a potentially effective drug.

Taxol is a clinically active anticancer drug, which exerts its cytotoxicity by the unique mechanism of polymerizing tubulin monomers into microtubules and stabilizing microtubules. Our studies with ovarian (hamster CHO and human A2780) cells showed that taxol is a phase-specific agent that is much more cytotoxic to mitotic cells than interphase cells.
http://www.springerlink.com/content/u87p68017244m315/

See? Human ovarian cells in hamsters are used all the time to do testing. But when a result goes against your belief system, somehow it doesn't mean anything. Madness.

You picked the wrong kind of evidence to demonstrate your point. In order to make it comparable you would need to show that we went ahead and started to use Taxol as a chemotherapeutic agent without testing it in humans first. I'll save you the trouble. The evidence shows that you are wrong.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Seems like them German scientist have done a lot of scientific research on this herb.

Interesting that a standardized extract, and safety information, are both provided by Remifemin®

Except there is no legal reason for them to tell you the truth on this under current US law as I understand it. I would have to get all of those studies they refer to and see if they; 1. Exist. 2. Say what they are claimed to say. 3. Are scientifically valid.

I once did a web site for a weight loss product that made all sorts of clinical claims. And the stuff itself was harmless. And if you followed their recommendations with respect to diet and exercise you would get more fit and lose weight. But the recommendations alone would have done that for you without the "supplement." And who knows, maybe the stuff helps somewhat? But you couldn't show that from their clinical trials which all were constructed to look only at compliant patients.
 
The adverse effects for Black Cohosh cannot occur in 0.00000353% of the doses if your colleague sees them on a regular basis. That suggests more like they occur in 1-10%. Not an insignificant problem.

there is nothing to suggest that number - you are just making that up

i have used BC - in formulation - for over 15 years and have not observed a single ADR


Black Cohosh was singled out only because this is what the thread is about. As I stated earlier, I am able to be concerned about more than one thing at a time.

well, there are great many more things that pose a much greater risk to human health than BC, not to mention your precious pharmaceuticals, OTC and prescription - but where are the threads on this on the randi forum - NONE!

i suggest your time is better spent investigating these - the only possible reason you would chose to go after BC is because you have a pre-existing bias against CAM as evidenced in your tag

in other words, going after a plant apparently makes you feel superior
 
Tat tvam asi.

namo bhaga-vate bhaiṣajya-gurave vaiḍūrya-prabha-rājāya
tathā-gatāyārhate samyak-saṃbuddhāya
tad yathā bhaiṣajye bhaiṣajye mahā-bhaiṣajye samudgate svāhā
bhaiṣajye bhaiṣajye mahā-bhaiṣajye bhaiṣajya-samudgate svāhā
bhaiṣajye mahā-bhaiṣajye samudgate svāhā
 
Quote: Studies, especially ones that test the difference between two herbal formulas, do not exist in a vacuum. When research is done on differences, it is to examine what adding something does, not looking for an effect. Black Cohosh is already known to have an effect, the one study was looking at what adding another herb did.

Black Cohosh is not known to have a clinical effect, though

how can you possibly say this when there clinical studies that demonstrate a clinical effect? i posted a few, but there are many more if you choose to look

you might not like the studies, you may say that don't attain some arbitrary standard you have established, but you cannot say that the evidence does NOT exists - unless- gosh, unless you are just plain retarded
 
Except there is no legal reason for them to tell you the truth on this under current US law as I understand it. I would have to get all of those studies they refer to and see if they; 1. Exist. 2. Say what they are claimed to say. 3. Are scientifically valid.

I once did a web site for a weight loss product that made all sorts of clinical claims. And the stuff itself was harmless. And if you followed their recommendations with respect to diet and exercise you would get more fit and lose weight. But the recommendations alone would have done that for you without the "supplement." And who knows, maybe the stuff helps somewhat? But you couldn't show that from their clinical trials which all were constructed to look only at compliant patients.

however, there is in Germany, where Remifemin was developed
see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commission_E

in fact, the Comm E recommends BC in "neurovegetative complaints of premenstrual, dysmenorrhea, or climacteric origin

oh but the Comm E is something we herbalists hate because its far too reductionist - but in this case however, it is pablum for skeptics like linda and others who need to do a little more research
 
Interesting stuff, this Black Cohosh.

http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/48394.php

So I check out Remifemin -
...In addition, its efficacy and safety has been demonstrated by market acceptance for over 40 years.

Seems like them German scientist have done a lot of scientific research on this herb.

So that's what you'd call scientific research, huh?

Just to add, I am quite capable of believing that some constituent in Black Cohosh may have a pharmacological and therefore a clinical effect, be it as a phytoestrogen, or action on opiod receptors, or whatever.

What is needed is evidence of efficacy - and as we have seen, trials have either been poorly conducted (Vaidya's studies) or with mixed results (Prof Yaffle's studies - 2 negative and one positive). We also need some index of clinical relevance - a preparation may "significantly" reduce the number of hot flushes per day from say 6 to 5, but this may be of little practical consequence to the person suffering from them. We need to know what outcome the patients would deem to be relevant and use this as on outcome measure or treatment goal.

What is not needed is Vaidya's bland and uncritical acceptance of BC's efficacy and, more worryingly, of safety. There is sufficient evidence pointing to possible toxicity problems. These type of effects are, as Linda says, very often under-reported and unrecognised.

Vaidya's attempts to deflect criticism of a herbal remedy by pointing to side effects of conventional drugs like acetaminophen (when taken in deliberate overdose) speaks volumes about his own scientific and ethical philosophy.

<...Remember people, it's "natural", so it's safe>
 
Last edited:
People who do not understand what they are doing with herbs should go and see a fully qualified and registered medical herbalist who will take a full case history from them and perform a clinical examination if needed. They will then prescribe a personalised herbal formula suitable for that particular client. Personalised formulas are best, as they suit that individual.

What training does a fully qualified and registered medical herbalist actually constitute?
 
Well, if it's anything like a friend of ours, it's a 3 year BSc in Phytotherapy at a former Poly, with modules featuring conventional medicine but all taught by alt med lecturers.
 
there is nothing to suggest that number - you are just making that up

I am making it up. But I'm trying to figure out a reasonable range based on what your colleague said. We would need to know how many people he places on Black Cohosh and how many cases he has seen of elevated liver enzymes. Does he put 100 people on Black Cohosh and see a few case? A thousand? Twenty?

You can help me by filling in the blanks.

i have used BC - in formulation - for over 15 years and have not observed a single ADR

Do you routinely test liver enzyme levels?

Linda
 
What is needed is evidence of efficacy - and as we have seen, trials have either been poorly conducted (Vaidya's studies) or with mixed results (Prof Yaffle's studies - 2 negative and one positive).

Do you have me on ignore or something? I've posted multiple links to both studies as well as Medical papers showing results, and the reasons for them. Ignoring stuff can make you look dumb you know. :wackywink:
 
CONCLUSION: This isopropanolic extract of black cohosh root stock is effective in relieving climacteric symptoms, especially in early climacteric women.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/...ez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum

CONCLUSION: The efficacy of iCR (medicinal product Remifemin) is as good as tibolone for the treatment of climacteric complaints, even for moderate to severe symptoms, whereby iCR is clearly superior regarding the safety profile. This iCR containing medicinal product is an excellent option for treatment of climacteric complaints which has now for the first time been verified in Asian women.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/...med.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVAbstractPlus

CONCLUSIONS: This study provides evidence that 12 weeks of TMN-1 therapy is a viable alternative treatment to consider in perimenopausal women with hot flashes, particularly in those with palpitations, emotional disturbance, and insomnia.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/...med.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVAbstractPlus

The isopropanol extract of C racemosa was found to be effective in the alleviation of menopausal symptoms.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/...ez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum

A July 24 review article published in the Archives of Internal Medicine (2006;166:1453-1465) concluded that alternative and complementary therapies are generally ineffective for treating menopause-related symptoms. Among the biologically based studies, only one on Remifemin(R) out of the four black cohosh studies reviewed, was shown to be effective.


"A single large trial showed a benefit for vasomotor symptoms with the black cohosh Remifemin(R) (Enzymatic Therapy Inc., Green Bay Wisconsin) and is consistent with older German studies," the reviewers wrote, indicating that the remaining three studies showed no benefits from black cohosh.
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/48394.php
 
Last edited:
how can you possibly say this when there clinical studies that demonstrate a clinical effect? i posted a few, but there are many more if you choose to look

The question is whether or not the differences that were found were necessarily due to the Black Cohosh or could have been due to something else. In all of the studies you referenced, there were other things present that we already know will lead to differences (bias, other treatments). So while it's plausible that Black Cohosh was responsible for the differences, it's just as plausible that it was something else.

you might not like the studies, you may say that don't attain some arbitrary standard you have established, but you cannot say that the evidence does NOT exists - unless- gosh, unless you are just plain retarded

When we talk about evidence or proof, what we are looking for is the kind of information that excludes other plausible explanations for the differences, so that the only thing left to explain the difference is the treatment under consideration.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom