Criticalist
Thinker
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2007
- Messages
- 158
I have had a quick look at the full article (Homeopathy in HIV infection: a trial report of double-blind placebo controlled study, Br Homeopath J. 1999 Apr;88(2):49-57.) I'm unable to post links yet, but the abstract is in Linda's post above mine.
This is not my field of expertise, but there are some obvious comments which spring to mind.
Firstly this is a small study. Two groups of 50 were studied, with the results from one being claimed to be significant. From this group, 12 patients dropped out (7 placebo, 5 treatment) leaving 18 patients receiving placebo, and 20 on active treatment.
However, the main issue is data interpretation. The trial comprised of randomising the patients and giving them either individualised homeopathic treatment or placebo. The outcome measurement was the CD4 count. Now, in this group, at the end of the trial the CD4 in placebo was 452 (SD 158 - units are not given) and in the treatment group 534 (SD 278) with a p value of 0.52 !!
The study is negative - there is no difference between placebo and treatment groups!
You may wonder then how the authors have managed to claim it as success for homeopathy. This assertion is based upon an increase in the CD4 count in the treatment group over the course of the trial, from 433 to 534 (again, no units provided.) The authors claim a p value of 0.008 using the Wilcoxon matched pairs Signed Rank test. Im afarid my stats knowledge is rudimentary so maybe others can help - but that does not strike me as the appropriate test for this sort of data - isn't Wilcoxon non parametric?
Overall, Im afraid this study strikes me as similar to others in this literature - the authors have such a bias to believing in homeopathy that they twist the results to produce the outcome they want. How you can publish a study with no difference between placebo and treatment groups and claim it is effective is just beyond belief.
This is not my field of expertise, but there are some obvious comments which spring to mind.
Firstly this is a small study. Two groups of 50 were studied, with the results from one being claimed to be significant. From this group, 12 patients dropped out (7 placebo, 5 treatment) leaving 18 patients receiving placebo, and 20 on active treatment.
However, the main issue is data interpretation. The trial comprised of randomising the patients and giving them either individualised homeopathic treatment or placebo. The outcome measurement was the CD4 count. Now, in this group, at the end of the trial the CD4 in placebo was 452 (SD 158 - units are not given) and in the treatment group 534 (SD 278) with a p value of 0.52 !!
The study is negative - there is no difference between placebo and treatment groups!
You may wonder then how the authors have managed to claim it as success for homeopathy. This assertion is based upon an increase in the CD4 count in the treatment group over the course of the trial, from 433 to 534 (again, no units provided.) The authors claim a p value of 0.008 using the Wilcoxon matched pairs Signed Rank test. Im afarid my stats knowledge is rudimentary so maybe others can help - but that does not strike me as the appropriate test for this sort of data - isn't Wilcoxon non parametric?
Overall, Im afraid this study strikes me as similar to others in this literature - the authors have such a bias to believing in homeopathy that they twist the results to produce the outcome they want. How you can publish a study with no difference between placebo and treatment groups and claim it is effective is just beyond belief.