3 prisoner puzzle

Many thanks to those who replied to my question, especially Rasmus, Lothian, Michael C, sol invictus and Lucky. I've always known that the gangsters have an edge but I never did figure out the math.

Let's get back to the 3 prisoner puzzle again. It occurred to me recently that although Tom learned nothing new about himself when the warden named Dick as the prisoner who will be freed, he did learn something about Harry, in that he knows Harry's chances of being executed are now doubled his. If I were Tom, that will make me feel better. Do you think it's silly to think such?
 
... Let's get back to the 3 prisoner puzzle again. It occurred to me recently that although Tom learned nothing new about himself when the warden named Dick as the prisoner who will be freed, he did learn something about Harry, in that he knows Harry's chances of being executed are now doubled his. If I were Tom, that will make me feel better. Do you think it's silly to think such?

Yes... but I see what you mean. :) (You're feeling twice as good as Harry now instead of equally as good as Dick or Harry.)

I imagine the prisoners in two 'virtual' cells.

Tom in cell A is 1 person. So the hangee will come from cell A 1/3 of the time.
Dick and Harry in cell B are 2 people. So the hangee will come from cell B 2/3 of the time.

Only one person will be hung, so at least one person in cell B must go free. (This in no way affects the 2/3 probability for cell B.)
The guard 'frees' Dick.

Tom is still in virtual cell A. The probability for cell A is still 1/3.
The probability for cell B is still 2/3. The fact that there's only one person in there now, Harry, instead of two, shouldn't make Tom feel any better. Just Harry feel worse.
 
Last edited:
So the key would be the main prisoner never finds out if he is set free until the end in the original scenario, though he does have a possibility of being the first reveal (set free) in the one I posted.

The fact that he finds out another person is set free in both scenarios has no value if that person can't be him.

On a related note, it seems the wording of the original tends to lead me to think an answer was given to the first question, instead of "no answer". Thus making me forget that in repeated trials he would always get a "no answer" to the first question; not being a "yes/no" situation. Semantics make a word puzzle.
 
Last edited:
So the key would be the main prisoner never finds out if he is set free until the end in the original scenario, though he does have a possibility of being the first reveal (set free) in the one I posted.

The fact that he finds out another person is set free in both scenarios has no value if that person can't be him.

And he knows it, yes.

On a related note, it seems the wording of the original tends to lead me to think an answer was given to the first question, instead of "no answer". Thus making me forget that in repeated trials he would always get a "no answer" to the first question; not being a "yes/no" situation. Semantics make a word puzzle.

No discussion of a puzzle is complete without an argument over the wording :D.

Inevitably, discussions of Monty Hall tend to center on ambiguity in the wording. In order for switching to be a better strategy, some things need to be clear:

  1. Monty knows where the car is.
  2. He will never show it to the contestant.
  3. He will always open another door.
  4. He will always offer the option to switch.
  5. The contestant is aware of all of this.

1 & 2 are necessary to know that Monty isn't giving the contestant any information. 3 & 4 are necessary to keep it from being a psychology question rather than a probability problem (eg. "Why would he offer the chance to switch unless I had already chosen the car?"). 5 is necessary because he can't act on any of that information unless he has it.
 
The forum seams to have come to the conclusion that Tom's chance of dying remains 1/3 despite what the warden says about Dick or Harry. So you should all be ready to play the game.

There are 3 prisoners, Tom, Dick and Harry. One day, the warden comes up to their cell and says, "One of you will be hanged tomorrow morning, the other 2 will be set free". Naturally, all 3 prisoners become very anxious.

Tom who's the most anxious of all, managed to pull the warden to one corner and asked him privately, "Please tell me if I'm the one who will be executed tomorrow?". The warden refused to tell him the answer. Tom, who does not give up easily, asked again, "If you won't tell me if I'm the one, then please at least give me the name of one of the other 2 who will be set free tomorrow?" The warden thought for a while and said, "Tomorrow, Dick's life will be spared".

I will play the warden and somebody else can play Tom. If you are set free I will pay you $1. If you are executed you will pay me $1.

If the odds for Tom are really 1/3 you'll win 2 out of 3 times. If the odds for Tom are 1/2 it will be even.

Who wants to be Tom?
 
Last edited:
The forum seams to have come to the conclusion that Tom's chance of dying remains 1/3 despite what the warden says about Dick or Harry. So you should all be ready to play the game.

Those odds are correct.

I will play the warden and somebody else can play Tom. If you are set free I will pay you $1. If you are executed you will pay me $1.[/abbr]

If the odds for Tom are really 1/3 you'll win 2 out of 3 times. If the odds for Tom are 1/2 it will be even. Who wants to be Tom?

I volunteer so long as you don't actually execute me as well as making me pay $1 :).

Can we play 1,000,000 times?
 
Last edited:
The forum seams to have come to the conclusion that Tom's chance of dying remains 1/3 despite what the warden says about Dick or Harry. So you should all be ready to play the game.



I will play the warden and somebody else can play Tom. If you are set free I will pay you $1. If you are executed you will pay me $1.

If the odds for Tom are really 1/3 you'll win 2 out of 3 times. If the odds for Tom are 1/2 it will be even.

Who wants to be Tom?

I'll go one better. If I'm set free, you give me $9, if I'm executed I'll give you $10. If the odds for Tom are 1/2 that should put it in your favor.

Bring your checkbook.
 
The odds are correct.


I volunteer so long as you don't execute me :).

Tom will be executed. You just have to pay the $1.

Can we play 1,000,000 times?

I think you will give up soon enough after you see it isn't getting you anywhere. But if you still want to play again after other forum members have had a chance, we can play until one of us gets bored.

And just to eliminate any possibility of breaking any gambling laws, any dollars I win should be donated directly to support the forum.

Sol will play Tom first.

Warden: Tom, Dick, Harry; One of you will be hanged tomorrow morning, the other two will be set free. If there are any questions, I'll be over in the corner (with the heavily armed guards).
 
Tom will be executed. You just have to pay the $1.



I think you will give up soon enough after you see it isn't getting you anywhere. But if you still want to play again after other forum members have had a chance, we can play until one of us gets bored.

And just to eliminate any possibility of breaking any gambling laws, any dollars I win should be donated directly to support the forum.

Sol will play Tom first.

Warden: Tom, Dick, Harry; One of you will be hanged tomorrow morning, the other two will be set free. If there are any questions, I'll be over in the corner (with the heavily armed guards).

I'm stating right up front that if you're picking Tom to be executed more than 1/3 of the time it isn't the same problem.
 
Sol will play Tom first.

Warden: Tom, Dick, Harry; One of you will be hanged tomorrow morning, the other two will be set free. If there are any questions, I'll be over in the corner (with the heavily armed guards).

This is creepy. But hey, it's the internet!

And more importantly, I'm going to win some easy money (all to be donated to the forum, of course).

"Warden Dan, please tell me if I'm the one who will be executed tomorrow? And if you won't tell me if I'm the one, then please at least give me the name of one of the other 2 who will be set free tomorrow?"
 
I'm stating right up front that if you're picking Tom to be executed more than 1/3 of the time it isn't the same problem.

It doesn't matter so long as it's less than 1/2. And if it's more, I'll just switch to one of the other two.
 
Here's an explanation that I think may help some people. Tom asks the warden, who tells him that Dick will be set free.

Surely everyone can see that Harry's probability of dying has just gone up to 2/3? That seems pretty intuitive to me. And if Harry's probability is 2/3, that only leaves 1/3 for Tom.
 
I'm stating right up front that if you're picking Tom to be executed more than 1/3 of the time it isn't the same problem.

I'm following the script exactly as in the OP. If you want to argue a different problem, you should probably take it to a different thread to keep from creating confusion.
 
I'm following the script exactly as in the OP. If you want to argue a different problem, you should probably take it to a different thread to keep from creating confusion.

My concern is that you are choosing Tom for execution more often than the other two (before the reveal). If they aren't equally likely to be chosen for execution, it is a different problem.
 
This is creepy. But hey, it's the internet!

And more importantly, I'm going to win some easy money (all to be donated to the forum, of course).

"Warden Dan, please tell me if I'm the one who will be executed tomorrow? And if you won't tell me if I'm the one, then please at least give me the name of one of the other 2 who will be set free tomorrow?"

Warden: "Ah, I am prohibited from telling you wether you are the one to be executed. But one of the other two is going to be set free". (the warden flips a shinny new dollar coin in the air) "Tomorrow, Dick's life will be spared".
 
Last edited:
I'm following the script exactly as in the OP. If you want to argue a different problem, you should probably take it to a different thread to keep from creating confusion.
If you have control of choosing who will be the executed prisoner at the start of each trial, and you choose Tom 90% of the time, that would be a vastly different puzzle from the one we're talking about. If you're the one doing the picking, you need to randomize it so that Tom will be picked initially about 1/3 of the time. (And if he's picked initially 1/3 of the time, that right there is your answer, isn't it?)
 
If you have control of choosing who will be the executed prisoner at the start of each trial, and you choose Tom 90% of the time, that would be a vastly different puzzle from the one we're talking about. If you're the one doing the picking, you need to randomize it so that Tom will be picked initially about 1/3 of the time. (And if he's picked initially 1/3 of the time, that right there is your answer, isn't it?)

I agree, and just to clarify my concern, the question the problem is asking (and the part Dan_O left out of his challenge) is:

"Alas", cried Tom, "Now that I know it won't be Dick, it would mean it's either Harry or me who will hang tomorrow. My chances of dying has gone up from 1/3 to 1/2".

Here's the question: Is Tom correct to say that? From his perspective, has his chances of being executed really gone up?

It isn't about whether Tom's original estimate of 1/3 is correct. It's clearly about whether the information the warden has given him gives him any reason to revise it to 1/2. Choosing Tom to be executed more than 1/3 of the time doesn't prove anything and is just playing silly buggers.
 
My concern is that you are choosing Tom for execution more often than the other two (before the reveal). If they aren't equally likely to be chosen for execution, it is a different problem.

Could you quote the part of the OP that you believe I am not following?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom