Many thanks to those who replied to my question, especially Rasmus, Lothian, Michael C, sol invictus and Lucky. I've always known that the gangsters have an edge but I never did figure out the math.
Let's get back to the 3 prisoner puzzle again. It occurred to me recently that although Tom learned nothing new about himself when the warden named Dick as the prisoner who will be freed, he did learn something about Harry, in that he knows Harry's chances of being executed are now doubled his. If I were Tom, that will make me feel better. Do you think it's silly to think such?
Let's get back to the 3 prisoner puzzle again. It occurred to me recently that although Tom learned nothing new about himself when the warden named Dick as the prisoner who will be freed, he did learn something about Harry, in that he knows Harry's chances of being executed are now doubled his. If I were Tom, that will make me feel better. Do you think it's silly to think such?