Tree of Knowledge = "Knowing Stuff is Bad." Do Xtians realize this?

Now now, let's all take a step back, shall we? It's an interesting topic, and doesn't need to be derailed into personal attacks.

I think drkitten was trying to say that people who have no background or history in theology aren't qualified (note - not "have no right") to hold an informed opinion about theological subjects. And that is a true statement. It might possibly have been phrased a little better, but anyway.

We see the same thing whenever DOC tries to opine about abiogenesis, or when Jerome tries to critique the big bang theory. No-one is saying that they have no right to hold an opinion about the subject at hand, but they are correctly pointing out that an opinion formed without knowledge is invalid. I think drkitten was trying to say the same thing.

So let's just calm down, shall we, and get on with the subject.
 
I find the Gervais piece much more brilliant than any sermon or apologetics.

There was an earlier thread that questioned the role of humor in breaking through the "mind lock" of religious thinking... I think people like Gervais are a powerful weapon. I could have use some Gervais humor in my youth when I was trying to make sense of the stuff people were telling me was "the truth".
 
I find the Gervais piece much more brilliant than any sermon or apologetics.

There was an earlier thread that questioned the role of humor in breaking through the "mind lock" of religious thinking... I think people like Gervais are a powerful weapon. I could have use some Gervais humor in my youth when I was trying to make sense of the stuff people were telling me was "the truth".


He does a really good job of highlighting the absurdity of taking it literally...

Particularly with lines like "That means he made the heavens and the earth in the dark!".

And lines like "And perfect diction too, it's not a mumbling snake. And he speaks English" really bring home the fact that the Bible is just words written by men, regardless of what originally inspired or directed it.
 
Let's see how drkitten feels about being lumped in with DOC and Jerome. Should be fun.
I think you may have misunderstood. Drkitten is not doing the same thing that DOC and Jerome do - drkitten is doing the same thing we do when we confront DOC and Jerome.
 
Last edited:
You don't have to accept the traditional narrative, but for Pete's sake at least learn the real version of it. There is a strong tendency on this forum for people to post the most ridiculously straw-man versions of quite sophisticated theological arguments and then laugh at them. If I were to post something about "if monkeys turned into people, why are there monkeys left," I'd rightly be ridiculed for my ignorance. People would tell me, correctly, that I don't know enough about the theory of evolution even to frame a legitimate question.

But this forum has a tendency to do exactly the same in the opposite direction. Gumboot has it at least partly right -- banishment from the Garden was not punitive, but preventative (it even says so in the Book). But it's hardly an original discovery on his part, precisely because it's been known to every sophisticated theologian since well before the birth of Christ.
The shame isn't in asking a question which is naive. The shame comes in when one ignores well reasoned explanations as to why that question is naive.

But simply because there are old arguments explaining why the A&E story makes sense, doesn't mean those arguments are valid. People have used the bible to justify slavery for at least a century or two. Does that mean those arguments are valid? Or, as an alternate example, your "Why are there still monkeys" anti-evolution counter argument has been around for at least 100+ years. The fact that people still use it doesn't improve it's validity.
 
This right here, shows that there would be no way of Lucifier rebelling against God or be disobedient to God. So it shows the falsehood of fallen Angels.

I was trying to put the tree of knowledge story in the most literal terms possible.
There are other ways to look at it.
If you want to see it in a metaphorical light, you can.
The fallen angels can represent the affects of sin reaching into all aspects of creation, even to the point of bringing down the most powerful beings in it.
When they are cast out of heaven, that could represent earth and heaven being restored to the condition that it enjoyed, before the entrance of evil.
 
Welcome to the fora, Ethnikos. Can I introduce you to the concept of a paragraph?

I realize my post looks hard to read.
That was part of a longer post I wrote, a couple of days ago, for my blog.
I copied the part that seemed applicable to this topic.
It came out like that when I pasted it in here.
I decided to leave it because I did not want to hog up a bunch of space with something I doubted anyone would want to read anyway.
It comes out looking like I am making some sort of pronouncement from on high.
It was part of an answer to someone asking if Satan created evil.
How did Lucifer become evil if God created a perfect universe.
I was trying to say that a hypothetical knowledge of evil existed before Lucifer turned all the way to evil.
The serpent in the Garden was eating the forbidden fruit and telling Eve, "I am eating this fruit and I did not die. In fact, it has given me this ability to talk. If you eat it, you will become a god."
So, from this story, you have to conclude that Lucifer had consumed of this fruit before Man did.
So, he did not create evil, exactly, but appropriated it for his own uses.
 
Last edited:
SezMe said:
Welcome to the fora, Ethnikos. Can I introduce you to the concept of a paragraph?
I realize my post looks hard to read.
That was part of a longer post I wrote, a couple of days ago, for my blog.
I copied the part that seemed applicable to this topic.
It came out like that when I pasted it in here.
I decided to leave it because I did not want to hog up a bunch of space with something I doubted anyone would want to read anyway.
It comes out looking like I am making some sort of pronouncement from on high.
It was part of an answer to someone asking if Satan created evil.
How did Lucifer become evil if God created a perfect universe.
I was trying to say that a hypothetical knowledge of evil existed before Lucifer turned all the way to evil.
The serpent in the Garden was eating the forbidden fruit and telling Eve, "I am eating this fruit and I did not die. In fact, it has given me this ability to talk. If you eat it, you will become a god."
So, from this story, you have to conclude that Lucifer had consumed of this fruit before Man did.
So, he did not create evil, exactly, but appropriated it for his own uses.
A simple "no" would have been sufficient.
 
I suspect the original story was intended for a different reason that didn't mesh well with the new Christian faith regarding God. The Christian God is actually pretty abnormal for being of the "Loving" kind. Most Gods aren't - in fact historically talking most Gods were a menace to mankind - a horrific angry force that you had to placate.

I think originally the Tree of Knowledge was about answering the question "Why are we not like animals?" It would have been clear enough that there were both strong similarities between man and animal, and also strong differences. The solution was the Tree of Knowledge. And funnily enough in a very primitive way it's right.

The talking snake, the wrathful God, stealing a powerful benefit from the Gods and getting punished for it (Prometheus, anyone?) they're perfectly in keeping with early non-Christian beliefs.
I tend to think this story was written in opposition to the Sumerian genesis story, where the roles are reversed and the serpent is the Creator.
The Hebrew version want to represent a creator god who is just like us and that the serpent is bad.
We were perfect before the descendants of these first humans were corrupted into fallowing the false religion that became prevalent before Abraham was instructed to leave that region and seek the advice of his ancient ancestor, the king of Salem.
 
relply to PC apeman:
Alright. You are right. I suck at putting things into paragraphs. Sorry.
 
Last edited:
The shame isn't in asking a question which is naive. The shame comes in when one ignores well reasoned explanations as to why that question is naive.

Which is exactly my point.

But simply because there are old arguments explaining why the A&E story makes sense, doesn't mean those arguments are valid.

Yes. And I will cheerfully accept -- in fact, I do accept -- that that I can see flaws in those arguments; that I do not find them compelling. I am usually happy to discuss those flaws, precisely because there may be subtleties of reason that I'm not seeing, subtleties that negate the percieved flaws.

However, the problems with the arguments for a sophisticated reading of Genesis doesn't render the naive arguments against Genesis any less naive or wrong.

Or, as an alternate example, your "Why are there still monkeys" anti-evolution counter argument has been around for at least 100+ years. The fact that people still use it doesn't improve it's validity.

That's a good example, actually. There are a lot of bad arguments against evolution, and they're still trotted out, as though disproving evolution will somehow magically prove creationism. And creationists are very good at seizing upon genuine disagreements between evolutionary theorists as though that somehow renders the entire theory of evolution invalid.

Unfortunately, that still won't rescue their flawed arguments.

We've seen exactly that on this thread, though.

"God banished Adam and Eve from the Garden as a punishment!"
"No, He banished them from the Garden to prevent them from eating the Tree of Life. It wasn't a punishment, it was a preventative. It says so IN THE BOOK."

No further theological argumentation about the nature of the preventative will somehow make it into a punishment, no matter how you misquote.

Similarly, Danm suggested that "but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die" is a lie.

Is it? Again, theologians have looked at this, and, no, it isn't. Dying is a secondary consequence of the Fall; prior to the expulsion from the Garden, Adam and Eve had access to the Tree of Life and were permitted it (Genesis 2 states that EVERY fruit was available except one) and as a result could live forever. Once they were expelled, they no longer had access to it, and as a result were going to die. Telling people about important long-term secondary effects is hardly lying to them.

Aha, you ask. But why did God have to expel them from the Garden in the first place? Well, it says in THE BOOK that he did so precisely to keep them from the Tree of Life. But is this necessarily a bad thing. Some theologians have speculated that this was precisely to provide them with another path to immortality and eternal bliss via living and dying; after they've brought unhappiness into this world, the only way to provide them with perfect happiness is in another one (giving them a chance to work off their sins via redemption). Allowing people to live forever in this (unhappy) world would be a cruel act indeed; instead, they are forced to move from this one to the next.

Of course, you don't have to buy that. And not all theologians do, although I find it a very pretty argument. A more central argument is simply that you're not God, and therefore are neither required nor expected to understand His motivations, any more than my niece is expected to understand histamines.

I don't ask that you believe these stories. I simply ask that you understand them. If you're trying to convert the believers, it really, really helps if you don't present them with caricatures of their own beliefs. (Yes, this is a personal issue of mine. My sister is very deeply into a lunatic Jesus cult, along with the rest of my family, and she's dragging my mother down as well. I can't tell her why her beliefs are wrong unless I actually know what her beliefs are. This should be simple common sense, but it's astonishing how common sense actually isn't.)
 
Similarly, Danm suggested that "but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die" is a lie.

Is it? Again, theologians have looked at this, and, no, it isn't. Dying is a secondary consequence of the Fall; prior to the expulsion from the Garden, Adam and Eve had access to the Tree of Life and were permitted it (Genesis 2 states that EVERY fruit was available except one) and as a result could live forever. Once they were expelled, they no longer had access to it, and as a result were going to die. Telling people about important long-term secondary effects is hardly lying to them.


But Danm's quote says that they will die in the day that they ate it, which they didn't.
 
But Danm's quote says that they will die in the day that they ate it, which they didn't.

Death is a slow process. Perfect health is just the slowest possible way of dying.

It's called a metaphor, dude. Learn it, love it, live it --- or at least accept it.
 
"You will die the day that you eat it" is a metaphor for "you will die a long time after you eat it"?
 
"You will die the day that you eat it" is a metaphor for "you will die a long time after you eat it"?

It's a metaphor for "on the day that you eat it, you will set in motion a chain of events that will inevitably cause your death that could otherwise have been prevented."

God is a better writer than that. Hell, even I am a better writer than that. My lawyer is a better writer than that.
 
I don't ask that you believe these stories. I simply ask that you understand them. If you're trying to convert the believers, it really, really helps if you don't present them with caricatures of their own beliefs.
The only problem is that the sophisticated theological arguments very often amount to caricatures of the beliefs of many real-world in-the-pew Christians. Most Christians aren't theologians, and quite a few of them are not at all familiar with these arguments. A quick googling of the terms Adam, Eve, and punish will turn up many hits to Christian websites that seem to have no problem with the idea that what happened to Adam and Eve was punishment (and, admittedly, hits to sites which echo the theological arguments, and hits to all kinds of other things).

I agree that people should be aware of the sophisticated arguments, but it should not be forgotten that the simplistic view is so prominent because it actually is a widespread view among Christians themselves.
 
Similarly, Danm suggested that "but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die" is a lie.

Is it? Again, theologians have looked at this, and, no, it isn't. Dying is a secondary consequence of the Fall; prior to the expulsion from the Garden, Adam and Eve had access to the Tree of Life and were permitted it (Genesis 2 states that EVERY fruit was available except one) and as a result could live forever. Once they were expelled, they no longer had access to it, and as a result were going to die. Telling people about important long-term secondary effects is hardly lying to them.


Come on, drkitten! Theologians are obviously full of it ...

But let's reprase it, then, to mean:
'If you eat of the tree of knowledge, you'll get much too clever for me, and I cannot have that. You have to die, so I’ll bereave you of the only means of living forever by expelling you from the garden of Eden':

“"Behold, the man has become like one of us, knowing good and evil; and now, lest he put forth his hand and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever" -- 23 therefore the LORD God sent him forth from the garden of Eden, to till the ground from which he was taken. 24 He drove out the man; and at the east of the garden of Eden he placed the cherubim, and a flaming sword which turned every way, to guard the way to the tree of life.”
http://www.bibleontheweb.com/Bible.asp, p. 3

Referring to this as “important long-term secondary effects” is more than a little euphemistic, isn’t it?

The other examples were here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3944358#post3944358
 
The only problem is that the sophisticated theological arguments very often amount to caricatures of the beliefs of many real-world in-the-pew Christians. Most Christians aren't theologians, and quite a few of them are not at all familiar with these arguments.

But they don't need to be.

I don't need to understand quantum physics to be able to use a laser pointer (although several people have won Nobel prizes in the process of understanding and developing them). If my Aunt Margaret is happy thinking of God as a Great Beard in the Sky --- but as a result, obeys His strictures and acts according to His will, then God is happy with her and will reward her appropriately. That's the Christian story ---- but it's also the human story as well. Can you repair your own car? Can you fix your cell phone if it breaks? Do you know how chemotherapy works?
Do you need to?

The problem with the straw men that people like to erect is that they end up actually reducing the credibility of the atheist movement. Let's say that you go to Aunt Margaret and point out to her all the lame pseudocontradictions that adorn the Bible, and let's say further that she takes you seriously enough that she actually starts to think and question. Well, the first person that Aunt Margaret will be asking questions of is probably her local priest or minister, who is familiar with these arguments and has the pat answers honed by centuries of apologetics. He takes her gently by the hand into his library, shows her how these questions have all come up within the Christian tradition a long time ago, and how it's based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of God, Christ, religion, what have you.

In other words, you've now given the priest an (ahem) "heaven-sent" opportunity to demonstrate, not only the fundamental truth of Christianity, but also to show that atheists and rationalists really don't know what they're talking about, and that rationalism is a position taken only from ignorance. Thanks a lot. It was bad enough talking to Aunt Meg before, when she actually thought that people could be smart and atheist. Now she knows -- 'cause you proved it to her -- that only idiots are atheists, and she has no reason to take further arguments from them seriously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom