World Hunger

What? It doesn't grow income-per-capita, unless you're starting from scratch so to speak--like the US in the C18th-19th.
But is that how GDP increase is monitored?
I thought most economic indicators are aggregate numbers.
 
I have a suggestion: Since dann is clearly in favor of providing food to people instead of selling food to people, I cordially invite him to start by providing food to me.

I find working a day job to be tiresome and boring. I'd rather be at the beach, or walking my dog, or having a nice romantic dinner with my wife.

So how about this? I quit my job, and dann funds a nice romantic dinner for me and my wife (along with at least two more good meals every day), for the rest of our natural lives.

I imagine dann will have to work much harder, to provide food for me as well as for himself, but if he doesn't think that's a problem, I don't either... Anybody else want in on this?
 
I have a suggestion: Since dann is clearly in favor of providing food to people instead of selling food to people, I cordially invite him to start by providing food to me.

I find working a day job to be tiresome and boring. I'd rather be at the beach, or walking my dog, or having a nice romantic dinner with my wife.

So how about this? I quit my job, and dann funds a nice romantic dinner for me and my wife (along with at least two more good meals every day), for the rest of our natural lives.

I imagine dann will have to work much harder, to provide food for me as well as for himself, but if he doesn't think that's a problem, I don't either... Anybody else want in on this?

Sounds good to me......

What is amusing about dann is that he links back 90% of the time to that Old School Marxist website, and then gets angry when people assume he is an Old School Marxist.
 
Last edited:
Evidence, dudalb? A link to a single post where this happened? I know from experience that you don't like to answer questions like this so I won't wait up ...
 
Last edited:
I have a suggestion: Since dann is clearly in favor of providing food to people instead of selling food to people, I cordially invite him to start by providing food to me.

So how exactly do you get the idea that criticizing the ideology that the profit motive will provide starving people with the food that they cannot afford implies that I will provide you with food? The idea is just as childish as the notion that criticizing a society where the access to all material comforts depends on the money at your disposal would imply that the critic would want to give away all his money.

I find working a day job to be tiresome and boring. I'd rather be at the beach, or walking my dog, or having a nice romantic dinner with my wife.

Me too! (Well, I've seen neither your dog nor your wife ...) :)

So how about this? I quit my job, and dann funds a nice romantic dinner for me and my wife (along with at least two more good meals every day), for the rest of our natural lives.

And if he doesn't, his critique of capitalism has been disproved, right?! :)

I imagine dann will have to work much harder, to provide food for me as well as for himself, but if he doesn't think that's a problem, I don't either... Anybody else want in on this?

Well, the thing that is right about your childish attempt at criticizing me is that having to provide for others in this society is a burden, which, of course, is the reason why the state has created the noble institution of marriage and the obligation to provide for your (ex-)spouse and children who depend on your income. You don't seem to enjoy this obligation so you dream of circumstances where you'd be able to give up your tiresome day job and have somebody else do the work for you.
And you are probably not unaware that a minority of enviable people in our society are able to enjoy that kind of life, but it is entirely dependent on the capital at their disposal:
If you have enough of that, you can make other, less fortunate, people work for you. They may even compete among themselves for the privilege since the alternative could be starvation. That is the extortion of capitalism for you.
Theses on Work and Wealth
 
Last edited:
If you have enough of that, you can make other, less fortunate, people work for you. They may even compete among themselves for the privilege since the alternative could be starvation. That is the extortion of capitalism for you.
No, I'm pretty sure that's the extortion of the Will to Live.

All across this planet, creatures who have never heard of capitalism, and never will, compete tooth and claw every day with each other, rather than starve. Capitalism has nothing to do with it.

How much capital do you have at your disposal? How did you get it? Was it by working? Do you believe you were compensated fairly for your work? Do you think you should have received more? Do pay market rates for goods and services? Do you think you're being fair to those who provide them? Do you think you should be paying them more?
 
It's hopeless. Dann is simply too commited to the system that worked so well in the Soviet Union and Mao's China.
But his latest "Property is Evil" link just confirmed.
 
On another point...

So how exactly do you get the idea that criticizing the ideology that the profit motive will provide starving people with the food that they cannot afford implies that I will provide you with food?
Personally, I don't think any such ideology exists. People perform charitable works for reasons other than the profit motive--that's why it's called "charity".

As I understand it, people do work because they are motivated to do work. One motivation is "profit", which may also be understood as "survival", or "security", or "personal pleasure". It's not really so much an ideological thing as it is just a thing that animals do: work to survive.

Beyond that, people might do additional work for ideological reasons: feeding the hungry, for example.

But--and here's where I think you and I are disconnecting--feeding the hungry requires work. Somebody has to do it. Somebody has to acquire land, and till it. Somebody has to acquire seeds, and sow them. Somebody has to bring in the harvest, package it, and transport it to the hungry they wish to feed.

This is work. It's costly. It takes time. It takes energy. It takes resources. It prevents the person doing the work from doing something else for that same cost instead.

Now, some people will do this work for ideological reasons. But even people whose only motivation is profit will quite happily do this work for pay. One way to get this work done efficiently is to specialize in some area, so that you can get paid a lot for the work you do--more than enough to feed yourself. Then you can use your surplus capital to pay a food-production profiteer to produce and deliver food to the hungry, on your behalf. In this way, the profit motive, properly understood and ruthlessly exploited, can be used quite successfully to feed the hungry.

It'd be nice if everybody were motivated charitable ideology. But that's not the case. Some people are motivated by pure, unadulterated greed. My point is that it's possible to do good things in cooperation with greedy people. You just have to be willing to demonstrate how much you care about charity, rather than simply complaining that they don't care as much as you do.
 
No, I'm pretty sure that's the extortion of the Will to Live.

So it's come to this: If people don't care about dying, you cannot possibly extort them! Therefore they are not extorted by the extortionist but by their "Will to Live". Try using that argument as your defence in court ...

All across this planet, creatures who have never heard of capitalism, and never will, compete tooth and claw every day with each other, rather than starve. Capitalism has nothing to do with it.

It has actually come to this? To creatures all acreoss this planet??!
So since dogs chase cats and cats eat mice, having to work to earn money because not only the products you need to eat but also the means of production are the private property of somebody else is a law, not of capitalism but, of nature.

How much capital do you have at your disposal?
Not enough to live up to the name of capital.
How did you get it? Was it by working?
Mostly, yes, or inherited.
Do you believe you were compensated fairly for your work?
No, not really, but my beliefs won't affect anything anyway.
Do you think you should have received more?
Should have? So we're talking morals now ...
Do (you?) pay market rates for goods and services?
Yes, that's how you buy stuff, remember? And it has precious little to do with the laws of nature.
Do you think you're being fair to those who provide them?
Fair???! "those who provide them" are the capitalists who make a business out of this. They own the means of production and distribution and are therefore able to make a profit by selling whatever their employees produce. And sometimes these employees aren't even able to buy their own products, which they don't own. The employer does. This principle is called exploitation of the workers producing surplus value. It is not a very nice principle, but let's blame nature and the bloody Will of the workers to Live!
Do you think you should be paying them more?
I don't pay the workers. They work for their employers. And if I paid their employers more than they ask for their products, i.e. more than the price that they demand for their commodities, they would get even richer than they already are since they are the owners of the products. Their workers aren't.
But this is not the answer you want, is it? What you want, of course, is an occasion to tell me that if I worry about the workers not being paid enough, I should pay them more, right? But then you have left out of the equation that they don't work for me, they work for their employer. And I don't benefit from the exploitation of the workers. The capitalist (i.e. employer) does.
So your questions are based on an elaborate web of fiction, not reality.
And they have precious little to do with creatures all across this planet, but who would expect you to be able to distinguish between the laws of nature and the laws of capitalism when your whole purpose is to confuse the two?
 
But even people whose only motivation is profit will quite happily do this work for pay.

Thank you for the lesson in social studies, but I'm sorry: You seem to have completely misunderstood the way this society functions:
Profit is not a question of motivation, which is why the 'profiteers' usually profit without doing any kind of "work for pay". The people working for pay are the ones who create the products that their employers profit from. Get the idea?
 
Then I guess it shouldn't be an 'embedded assumption' anymore but a fact, so let's see all the evidence you've spent the last twenty years collecting.
When you can rig up a usb to dump my brain's contents onto this forum, you are welcome to it. Until then, your cop out is noted.

Likewise, your failures of synthesis continue.

I have spent the last fifteen years trying to improve mine. I read, I watch, I learn, I think, I arrive at a synthesis. Try it sometime. Analysis is only half the game. It's putting it all back together that makes it worth while.
Do you know how many Kenyans it takes to burn the amount of fossil fuels you do?
Irrelevant, since their problem is food, not fuel. You will note that your attempt to go OT, shift goal posts, and any number of other gutless tactics are blatant. IIRC, the topic on this thread is hunger. Feeding. Food. Eating. Comer.
I was about to say what you could do, personally, to contribute to easing the problem, but that would be a violation of the MA.
You are invited to create that popping sound and see daylight again. Or are the neck muscles too weak?
Do the math: How many of the seven children die prematurely - and not just from starvation?
It varies. Is Kenya in a civil war this week or not?
"mister"?! I was not aware that I was breeding the people I think deserve to eat ...
Over your head, again. No problem, and no surprise.
I don’t know what makes this so difficult to understand for you
Given that you seem unable to differentiate between beans and benzine, I suspect your might look to your own problems in comprehension first, mister.

DR
 
So it's come to this: If people don't care about dying, you cannot possibly extort them! Therefore they are not extorted by the extortionist but by their "Will to Live". Try using that argument as your defence in court ...
Last time I checked, asking to be compensated for the work I do, and soliciting competitive bids, was not a crime. What would I be in court for?

It has actually come to this? To creatures all acreoss this planet??!
So since dogs chase cats and cats eat mice, having to work to earn money because not only the products you need to eat but also the means of production are the private property of somebody else is a law, not of capitalism but, of nature.
Money's just a pointer. It can be food one day, shelter the next, a charitable donation the third. We're still working for survival--food, shelter, etc.--we just express it in terms of money because it's a lot more convenient than expressing it in terms of chickens and thatch.

And yes, "creatures all across the planet". We're creatures, too, right? Does the male Polar Bear extort the female and her cubs, when he pursues them across the arctic ice, forcing them to compete until one lags behind, and he eats it?

Not enough to live up to the name of capital.Mostly, yes, or inherited.No, not really, but my beliefs won't affect anything anyway.
Well, there's always the option of asking for a raise...

Should have? So we're talking morals now ...
Well, you've been talking about morals all along, I think. I.e., that it's immoral for people to expect compensation for their work, or some such.

Yes, that's how you buy stuff, remember? And it has precious little to do with the laws of nature.
Except, of course, that this "buying stuff" is just a method of working to ensure your survival. Which has quite a precious lot to do with the laws of nature.

Fair???! "those who provide them" are the capitalists who make a business out of this. They own the means of production and distribution and are therefore able to make a profit by selling whatever their employees produce. And sometimes these employees aren't even able to buy their own products, which they don't own. The employer does. This principle is called exploitation of the workers producing surplus value. It is not a very nice principle, but let's blame nature and the bloody Will of the workers to Live! I don't pay the workers. They work for their employers. And if I paid their employers more than they ask for their products, i.e. more than the price that they demand for their commodities, they would get even richer than they already are since they are the owners of the products. Their workers aren't.
But this is not the answer you want, is it? What you want, of course, is an occasion to tell me that if I worry about the workers not being paid enough, I should pay them more, right? But then you have left out of the equation that they don't work for me, they work for their employer. And I don't benefit from the exploitation of the workers. The capitalist (i.e. employer) does.
Well, you could always tip more, if that's how you feel.

So your questions are based on an elaborate web of fiction, not reality.
And they have precious little to do with creatures all across this planet, but who would expect you to be able to distinguish between the laws of nature and the laws of capitalism when your whole purpose is to confuse the two?
Law of nature: work or die.
Law of capitalism: work or die.

What's to confuse? Seems like we haven't come very far from nature at all (unless you count all the ways in which capitalism has made your standard of living and life opportunities so much better than those of the neanderthals--or the Soviet Russians).
 
Thank you for the lesson in social studies, but I'm sorry: You seem to have completely misunderstood the way this society functions:
Profit is not a question of motivation, which is why the 'profiteers' usually profit without doing any kind of "work for pay". The people working for pay are the ones who create the products that their employers profit from. Get the idea?
So you'd argue that the further up you rise in a corporation, the less work you have to do?
 
Irrelevant, since their problem is food, not fuel. You will note that your attempt to go OT, shift goal posts, and any number of other gutless tactics are blatant. IIRC, the topic on this thread is hunger. Feeding. Food. Eating. Comer.

So apart from the insults, this is all you've got?
Do you remember who suddenly wanted to talk about global warming? No, I guess you don't, so let me give you a hint ...
 
So apart from the insults, this is all you've got?
Do you remember who suddenly wanted to talk about global warming? No, I guess you don't, so let me give you a hint ...
If you don't understand the concept of "each cloud has a silver lining" then I can't help you.

Likewise, if you can't understand taht I am not obliged to feed anyone but my family, I also can't help you.

Try reading the opener, to clue up.

It's a local problem.

A local problem.

Turning them into foreign aid junkies is enabling behavior, like feeding analcoholic more whiskey, or giving a Wall Street Bank more money when it buggered the managing of the last five hundred billion it had. :p

DR
 
Law of nature: work or die.
Law of capitalism: work or die.

What's to confuse? Seems like we haven't come very far from nature at all (unless you count all the ways in which capitalism has made your standard of living and life opportunities so much better than those of the neanderthals--or the Soviet Russians).

Well, I'm not the one who's trying to use nature as an analogy to capitalism in order to make the latter appear to be abiding by the laws of nature, and therefore I'm not confused.
But just for the hell of it I would sure like to know: What is the analogy in nature to hedge fonds, futures and mortgages?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom