Scientific paper claims unreacted nanothermite found in WTC dust-implying demolition

metamars

Graduate Poster
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
Messages
1,207
A paper has been published in the Open Chemical Physics Journal, a Bentham Open Access peer reviewed journal, concerning red/gray (or red/metallic) chips found in the WTC dust. The authors claim that the red part of the chips are unreacted nanothermite.

Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe
pp.7-31 (25) Authors: Niels H. Harrit, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley, Bradley R. Larsen
doi: 10.2174/1874412500902010007


Abstract

We have discovered distinctive red/gray chips in all the samples we have studied of the dust produced by the destruction of the World Trade Center. Examination of four of these samples, collected from separate sites, is reported in this paper. These red/gray chips show marked similarities in all four samples. One sample was collected by a Manhattan resident about ten minutes after the collapse of the second WTC Tower, two the next day, and a fourth about a week later. The properties of these chips were analyzed using optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), X-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy (XEDS), and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The red material contains grains approximately 100 nm across which are largely iron oxide, while aluminum is contained in tiny plate-like structures. Separation of components using methyl ethyl ketone demonstrated that elemental aluminum is present. The iron oxide and aluminum are intimately mixed in the red material. When ignited in a DSC device the chips exhibit large but narrow exotherms occurring at approximately 430 °C, far below the normal ignition temperature for conventional thermite. Numerous iron-rich spheres are clearly observed in the residue following the ignition of these peculiar red/gray chips. The red portion of these chips is found to be an unreacted thermitic material and highly energetic.

Keywords: JScanning electron microscopy, X-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy, Differential scanning calorimetry, DSC analysis, World Trade Center, WTC dust, 9/11, Iron-rich microspheres, Thermite, Super-thermite, Energetic nanocomposites, Nano-thermite
Affiliation: Department of Chemistry, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, DK-2100, Denmark.


A large but highly spammed thread was begun on this subject, in the JREF 911 conspiracy theory forum, here. It was closed because of the huge number of off topic posts, but is worth going through to extract the signal from the noise.

A second, moderated thread was begun here, in which Sunstealer,who has relevant experience in forensic analysis, has contributed to. Unfortunately, he seems like the only person posting on his thread that has a lot of domain expertise. I am beginning a new thread in the science forum, partly because of a poll I saw here which indicated that 48% of respondents were "qualified scientists". See also this JREF thread:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=140115

Recommended background reading are two theses on nanothermite:

COMBUSTION CHARACTERISTICS OF A1 NANOPARTICLES AND NANOCOMPOSITE A1+MoO3 THERMITES

MODELING THE MELT DISPERSION MECHANISM FOR NANOPARTICLE COMBUSTION

Also, please read through this thread on the911forum.freeforums.org. Dr. Greening (posting as 'Dr. G.'), who also has relevant domain experience, has been highly critical of the Thermitic Material paper.

Because this thread is likely to get spammed, I expect to request moderation. However, I want to see how things go without moderation, initially.
 
Last edited:
A paper has been published....Because this thread is likely to get spammed, I expect to request moderation. However, I want to see how things go without moderation, initially.
Nanotermites!
 
A paper has been published in the Open Chemical Physics Journal, a Bentham Open Access peer reviewed journal

Wrong... Bentham is a vanity publisher. You pay to publish. Not very different from publishing online, except that the latter is cheaper.

So no, it was not peer-reviewed.

As for the content, pure drivel.
 
Wrong... Bentham is a vanity publisher. You pay to publish. Not very different from publishing online, except that the latter is cheaper.

So no, it was not peer-reviewed.

As for the content, pure drivel.

source for your claims?

The Open Chemical Physics Journal is a peer-reviewed journal which aims to provide the most complete and reliable source of information on current developments in chemical physics. The emphasis will be on publishing quality papers rapidly and freely available to researchers worldwide.

http://bentham.org/open/tocpj/
 

While the journal that the article appeared in is somewhat relevant, the reason that I am posting in the Science forum is to get scientists commenting on the science in the paper - good, bad, and questionable.

Please refrain from discussing the Bentham Journal in this thread. You are more than welcome to start another thread on that subject.

One way to think about that (which some people have done, already), is "What would I say and do, if I was a peer reviewer of this paper, for any given technical journal suitable for its subject?"

Just to be clear about things - nobody cares what you would do if you are ignorant of the scientific issues involved. I'm sorry, but if anybody just wants to entertain themselves, they can post in the 911 conspiracy theory forum. I hate to sound snobby, but not everybody has such a background (including myself).
 
strange, you link to the same source that say it is indeed a perr-reviewed journal.

care to explain?

I'll write this slowly.... vanity publishing and peer-review are mutually exclusive.

If your work can muster peer-review, you don't pay to publish it. If someone is charging for publishing and claiming the paper will be peer-reviewed, they are most probably lying.

Much in the same way diploma-mills claim to be accredited universities.
 
I have just requested moderation

Again, I want posters to focus on the science in the paper - good, bad and questionable.
 
I'll write this slowly.... vanity publishing and peer-review are mutually exclusive.

If your work can muster peer-review, you don't pay to publish it. If someone is charging for publishing and claiming the paper will be peer-reviewed, they are most probably lying.

Much in the same way diploma-mills claim to be accredited universities.

dunno why you have to say it arrogant, slowly was fine, but leave away your arrogance pls :)

but i respect metamars request and will leave the topic :)
 
One way to think about that (which some people have done, already), is "What would I say and do, if I was a peer reviewer of this paper, for any given technical journal suitable for its subject?"

Sure. My quick review:

The manuscript submitted has grave and insurmountable methodological flaws.

The sampling of material is most irregular. The analysis of material collected 6 years before by "private citizens" makes it impossible to assert the provenience of the samples. Also, there are numerous documented samples of material form the WTC, which could have been used as a comparison, but weren't.

The XEDS analysis is inconclusive, and managed to prove that the material analyzed was, in fact, the material analyzed. Throughout the manuscript there are several spectra of the material collected, but none is given for direct comparison. Later in the article the authors suggest that the material is an undetermined explosive that could be painted on a surface. However, the authors made no effort to compare their samples with paint samples retrieved from the collapsed building. The measure of resistivity and comparison with "paint coatings we found tabulated" is a mockery of the scientific method.

The authors seem to think that an explosive can be painted on a surface and destroy it. An explosion is a very fast combustion, and thinly spreading an explosive over a surface will only manage to warm that surface.

Also, the authors seem to conflate the energy release of a substance with their potential as an explosive. Analyzing a chocolate bar might have taught them something.

The manuscript is pseudo-scientific tripe trying to pass for a scholarly work. The authors should be hit with a large fish until they see the error of their ways.
 
I didn't think Thermite is, or is required to be, particles of nano size. Thermite has been used for a over a century, long before nano was invented. It's a mix of iron and aluminum filings. No high-tech nano-ness required.

My guess is that the residue is a by-product of the catastrophe, not a cause. Lots of iron in the building, lots of aluminum trim too. Plus a whole airplane or two. I don't know if WTC panels were the ones made by using a plastic filled with aluminum powder, but that type of panel is used a lot, architecturally.

I suspect there's carbon in the residue too- like could be left from Napalm? naa, couldn't be from jet fuel, could it? But then, why fuel the CT'ers. ;)
 
Please refrain from discussing the Bentham Journal in this thread. You are more than welcome to start another thread on that subject.

You posted here because of the high percentage of JREFers in this forum that are, in your words, 'qualified scientists'. A lot of us are very familiar with the peer review process, and like it or not, we do feel that the quality of the journal and the nature of its peer review are very pertinent issues.

You can't label a paper as peer reviewed and then demand silence when the quality of that peer review is questioned. Especially when, in this instance, it is so very questionable.

I think people should be aware of the problems with Bentham and this journal in particular. So if you don't mind, here are a few bullet points:

  • To publish an article in the journal will cost between 600 and 900 dollars.
  • If anyone here wanted to write a scholarly response to this article and get it published in The Open Chemical Physics Journal, it would cost them at least 600 dollars.
  • You can offset that cost by becoming a paid up member of Bentham Open (for 1600 dollars!). This encourages pay-to-publish, and surely puts pressure on editors to push papers through peer review if the author is a member of Bentham Open. After all, people want their money's worth.
  • The editorial board has an extraordinary number of members. Why? Because Bentham spams researchers with repeated requests to join a board, and then will not remove their names when they request to leave it.
  • Open Chemical Physics Journal has a total of two volumes to its name, and no impact factor.
 
You posted here because of the high percentage of JREFers in this forum that are, in your words, 'qualified scientists'. A lot of us are very familiar with the peer review process, and like it or not, we do feel that the quality of the journal and the nature of its peer review are very pertinent issues.

You can't label a paper as peer reviewed and then demand silence when the quality of that peer review is questioned. Especially when, in this instance, it is so very questionable.

I think people should be aware of the problems with Bentham and this journal in particular. So if you don't mind, here are a few bullet points:

  • To publish an article in the journal will cost between 600 and 900 dollars.
  • If anyone here wanted to write a scholarly response to this article and get it published in The Open Chemical Physics Journal, it would cost them at least 600 dollars.
  • You can offset that cost by becoming a paid up member of Bentham Open (for 1600 dollars!). This encourages pay-to-publish, and surely puts pressure on editors to push papers through peer review if the author is a member of Bentham Open. After all, people want their money's worth.
  • The editorial board has an extraordinary number of members. Why? Because Bentham spams researchers with repeated requests to join a board, and then will not remove their names when they request to leave it.
  • Open Chemical Physics Journal has a total of two volumes to its name, and no impact factor.

This has been discussed extensively in the the 911 conspiracy theories forum, and was mentioned quite a bit in the thread I linked to. If you think the peer review was so bad, don't tell us in general terms what was so bad about it, tell us in specific, scientific terms where the Bentham people screwed up. Please.

Ah, but if you did that, you'd be answering my call for a discussion about the science in the paper, good, bad and questionable, now, wouldn't you?
 
What the hell is "nanothermite" anyway? Thermite is thermite.
 
What the hell is "nanothermite" anyway? Thermite is thermite.

No, it absolutely is not. In the theses that I linked to, aluminum particles in the nanopowders are spherical, and of nanometer dimensions. There is a very strong effect of scale on the speed of reaction, ignition temperature, etc.

Did you read any of the references? It would appear that you have not.
 
This has been discussed extensively in the the 911 conspiracy theories forum, and was mentioned quite a bit in the thread I linked to. If you think the peer review was so bad, don't tell us in general terms what was so bad about it, tell us in specific, scientific terms where the Bentham people screwed up. Please.

Ah, but if you did that, you'd be answering my call for a discussion about the science in the paper, good, bad and questionable, now, wouldn't you?

Okay, then I guess you did mind my bullet points.

Still, I do think that information will be helpful to people. Personally, I think the quality of a paper is an important consideration, so if I had stumbled across this thread without knowing any of the background story, those are the kinds of things I would want to know.
 
Hi, I can see this is going to be a stupid thread at the start.

Duh, claiming something is peer reviewed when it is not is specious to start off. And part of being science is being accurate.

Does this involve electric stars by any chance?

Metamars, welcome to the Science forum, you better get used to it fast. If you don't want people to review the status of calling something peer reviewed then don't post here. It was part of your OP and therefore open game. It is also a large amount of the discussion here.

Are any of the papers peer reviewed and what process was there in the peer review?

This is germane to the Science forum.
 
Last edited:
This has been discussed extensively in the the 911 conspiracy theories forum

So has the science. You even linked to the current thread that is discussing the science, which has scientists working in relevant fields actively participating. Why are you so desperate to focus on one thing that has already been discussed over another? The simple fact is that the "paper" is a joke published in a magazine dedicated to publishing jokes. It doesn't matter where you start threads, reality is not going to change.
 
... tell us in specific, scientific terms where the Bentham people screwed up. Please.

Ah, but if you did that, you'd be answering my call for a discussion about the science in the paper, good, bad and questionable, now, wouldn't you?

Anxiously awaiting your reply to Megalodon...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom