I will make an overall comment, then reply to specific points. Overall comment is that you seem awfully interested in
me, as opposed to my arguments. You thus reveal a bias of your own which in no way makes you a better candidate as a rational critic of the Harrit paper.
We are not talking about different types of thermite, because the Harrit et al paper specifically talks about Al + Fe2O3. Their own SEM data shows Fe2O3 crystals approximately 0.2µm in size in the red layer.
Can you show me where they claim that Al and Fe2O3 is present in stoichiometrically correct proportions? Didn't think so.
There are only two other constituents that they identify, one an aluminosilicate (which has the correct morphology and EDS spectrum that matches Kaolinite closely) 1µm
And a DSC that doesn't match that of raw kaolinite. You dismissed this as "chalk and cheese", but didn't bother explaining. Also, I've made an effort to understand the differences in readings generated by the micron level DSC vs. a regular DSC. Have you? Excuse me if my confidence in your kaolininte theory is less than complete. Since you are so fixated on Harrit, et. al., not having dotted every i and crossed every t, I'm sure that you'll eventually dot all of your i's and cross all of your t's.
Correct? Actually, I doubt that you will dot every i and cross every t, which is why I hope to get a hold of somebody who
will answer these basic questions. Posting in the Science forum didn't help, either. I am, frankly, beginning to doubt if the poll that showed that 48% of respondents were qualified scientists has any significance.
and greater in size and a carbon rich matrix. Talk of anything else is pointless. You can speculate all you like about nano-this and nano-that, but we don't observe any particles that small and we don't observe any particles of Al.
You may well be correct on this point. Too bad you haven't proven it, yet. (Which is not to say that Harrit, et. al. have proven that the platelets
are rich in elemental Al).
So why are you desperately googling for any any term with nano-thermite in and throwing it into the mix?
Desperately? Compulsively, maybe, (it's not like I don't have real work that I should be doing), but I am not "desperate" as regards the final disposition of what the red/grey chips are, one way or the other. So, why would I "desperately" google for nano-thermite to "throw it in the mix"?
This is yet an example of where you are making a personal argument.
You've also reminded me of a question I've now put to you twice. Here goes the third time.
Are you, or are you not, going to write a coherent, ad hominem free report on the Harrit paper which we could print out and show to domain experts, along with the Harrit paper? There is no need for you to "desperately" do this - if you took, say 3 weeks, that would be no skin off of anybody's back. See, no need for me to frame you as a "desperate" debunker, although your numerous ad hominems don't cast you in a favorable light.
I've seen absolutely zero work from you regarding what I am saying, although in your defence no other truther has bothered to try and they are letting the official moderated thread die - it's no surprise they won't tackle it head on because they don't even know where to start from.
It took a long time to find the references I did. Some ended up only here at JREF, some went to Harrit, et. al. - where, in the case of the LIBS method, Jones expressed warm appreciation.
Why are you spending all of your time on the thermite side and not looking to see whether conclusions, based on available data, are correct?
It makes you look like a truther.
Too bad. And by the way, I am a "truther", which doesn't mean that I buy all of the arguments embraced by various individuals in the truth movement, or I have some sort of pathological need for red/gray chips to turn out to be nanothermite, as opposed to paint chips, or anything else.
It looks to everyone like you are trying to defend the paper.
Again, with the personal stuff. As for "defending the paper", was I defending it when I
posted
Speaking for myself, I am particularly interested in what scientists with relevant domain expertise have to say about the use of XEDS in the thermitic paper, as well as some detailed suggestions for other methods (hopefully not too costly) which would yield more definitive results. If there is insufficient elemental Al in the Jones chips, then they are not thermite.
Was I "defending the paper" when I emailed Harrit, et. al., a verbatim copy of Dr. Greening's
most significant (as far as I could tell) criticism?
If not then where is the balance? Why are you not also spending time looking for things that explain the paper without reference to thermite and then weigh your own evidence?
Again with the personal stuff. It's really none of your business how I prioritize my time. (And to be perfectly honest, I often question myself as to why I spend all the time I do on this stuff. No good answer, yet! )
As ElMonndoHummus points out in post #25, the experiment is flawed and no conclusion of a thermite reaction can be claimed. So why are you not acknowledging this massive failure and see it as a black mark against the paper?
Sometimes it pays to read a thread carefully, before you post something that is contradictory to what you're claiming, only a few posts back. I do this, myself, so I'm not going to beat you over the head for this. However, I again will point out that you are asking a personal question.
E.g., I haven't asked you why
you didn't bother to look up kaolinite DSC's, and why
you didn't bother to see if silicon platelets can be manufactured. Also, why
you didn't bother to debunk the nonsense put forth by other debunkers, such as thermite being 70% titanium*, or nano-thermite being just like classic thermite, just faster reacting, or, as you can see in this very thread, the total energy released from nanothermite is the same as from non-nanothermite?
Too busy writing your coherent paper, which truthers and debunkers could take to domain experts, along with the Harrit paper, to try and quickly identify problems with both their paper and your counter-arguments? I like to think that's true, but as you've avoided answering my question about your wonderful rebuttal, I assume that you ain't gonna bother. Funny, that.
If they failed in such a basic matter why doesn't that make you suspicious of their other claims?
Yes, it does.
Could they also be failing in other basic areas?
Absolutely! And that, once again, is a reason to take their paper to domain experts, who will more readily see failures and defects that I can.
You go on and on about the Al. You continue to make claims based on reactions that contain Al. For this to happen you NEED particles of Al, whereby Al is the dominant element with only O present as would be expected. Where is this Al? Show me the Al? Show me the particles? Point to them in this photo!
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=916[/qimg]
I see no aluminium particles. Does anyone else?
If there's elemental Al in their sample, you know where it is. And by the way, speaking of platelets, you claimed that the Harrit paper's platelets showed a hexagon morphology. Perhaps you'd be good enough to to a highlighting of the edges that appear in the Harrit pictures, and point these hexagons out. Anything hexagonal looks few and far between.
Why do we see massive amounts of Si, O and C let alone Na, Fe and K in these platelets if we require particles of commercially pure Aluminium >99% which is available off the shelf by the thousands of tons for either the thermite reaction or reaction with O2 from air?
As you know better than I, you can't do a simple translation of peaks in the XEDS sprectra to quantitative ratios.
Correct? If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me, and tell me what the ratio is of Si to Al.
Si is used to help make a eutectic with Al, at about 11%, IIRC. If it's 50%, then I'd start to wonder. Is it?
One reason I have trouble with your statement is because of another statement of yours, viz.,
EDS/EDX/XEDS basically will tell you what elements are present - and that's about it really.
So, you cast doubt on the Harrit claims of elemental Al, because they are using a line of evidence that can't be relied on to give you proportions, but somehow we
can use XEDS to determine that there is "massive amounts of Si...".
So, which is it? Can we use Harrit's data to claim equal parts Al to Si (an example of a "massive" amount of Si, I trust), 11% Si, or neither, because "XEDS basically will tell you what elements are present - and that's about it really".
As for the rest of those "massive amounts", do us a favor and tell us what those "massive amounts" are, quantitatively, also. If you can't do that, you should be eager for more rigorous tests, to conclusively confirm or contradict the claims of Harrit, et. al. At least, that's what I would have expected of a real scientist, who is looking at this objectively, as best he can.
If there's no Al particles there is no thermite reaction or with air.
Yup. And this is what I posted at 911blogger, for all the world, and 911 truth community, to see. Nothing new about that.