Dann said:
The analogy expressed in "opium of the people" makes it obvious that people's need to believe gives rise to religion, which does not in any way imply that legislation would be a solution: We all know how well it works in the prevention of drug abuse.
You're confusing legislation Per Se with the specific type of legislation being tried in some countries. Have a look at recent drug legislation in Portugal. It's rather different from US legislation.
Dann said:
However, again you make the same mistake that BN has been making all along: Crimes committed in the name of religion really aren't religious crimes. Religion is merely abused as a pretence, "in the name of", and the real reason seems to be the "destructive" nature of (some) people,
as if, for example, homophobic hate crimes committed or the killing of abortionists by Christians had nothing at all to do with religion.
You simplify/distort both our positions, possibly accidentally. My position all along has been that things tend to be more complex than just "Religion made them do it". Naturally religious issues can be part of what motivates people to do evil things. But many people like to imagine religion is entirely to blame and ignore other factors. For instance, I've heard someone put forward the view that the English Civil War was a religious war. As a matter of fact, the causes were multiple, as this brief article explains:
The Causes of the English Civil War.
Equally, the causes of the Crusades, commonly assumed to have been religious wars, were multiple, as this article explains:
The First Crusade
... B.Intermediate Causes
Despite their growth, European society and economy were in a state of transition, and were unstable.
1. The aristocracy found themselves at relative peace, and were losing the importance they had enjoyed when they stood between Europe and its attackers. Their numbers were growing because there were no longer the losses in battle they had once sustained. They needed more land with which to endow their children and were beginning to fight with each other over the land that was available to them. ...
5. The middle classes were now aware of the profits of the eastern trade, and were searching for some way to bypass the middlemen of the eastern empire and to trade directly with the Muslims. They knew that they could become rich by cutting out the Byzantines and taking for themselves the profits that the Byzantine merchants had been making on trade with them.
6. The economic system was in a state of transition, with some districts specializing in some "industrial" crops to the point that they did not raise enough grain to feed themselves, and were doing so before the transportation and internal trading system had advanced enough to distribute consumer goods efficiently. So there were frequent local famines. At the same time, agriculture was improving so greatly in productivity that many people no longer had work. The peasants needed more food and more land to cultivate. In 1095, a famine and epidemic in northern France and the Lowlands was causing widespread misery and the lower classes were some miracle to deliver them.
7. Pilgrims returning from the Holy Land were bring home stories of the atrocities being committed by the Seljuk Turks, masters of the Levant, against pilgrims, and of the way in which they were desecrating the places holy to Christians. This caused great outrage, in part because the average western European was better acquainted with the Bible lands than any place other than their own villages and towns. The Holy Land was the Christians "other home." ...
It goes more into the religious issues as well.
One thing, Dann, which is obviously not your fault, is that you seem to have difficulty in understanding figures of speech like irony, where people don't mean quite what they say. Also it would help with that if you read the whole of a person's post before commenting. For instance, it appears that you opposed the argument you assume Whirligig to be making - that religion should be legislated away, which was actually posed as a question and not an argument at all, - only to discover in the next paragraph that Whirligig's saying something rather different - that religion shouldn't be legislated away. The question was obviously rhetorical.
You haven't actually explained as yet why you think it would be good for all religion to be eradicated, beyond saying it's a delusion. It seems a little strange that you haven't really explained further, given that the postulation that religion should be eradicated is the whole premise of your argument. You
believe religion to simply be a delusion. You will not even allow for the
possibility that God exists and that some religion is not a delusion, which makes your position reactionary and ideologue-like rather than skeptical - a true skeptic being one who critically examines evidence rather than just rejecting concepts they don't like without being able to give a good explanation as to why. Even when I have demonstrated that turning to Christianity has so changed some people's lives that they have turned from violence, shoplifting and other harmful behaviours, you still stick to your position that it needs to be eradicated because it's a delusion, without giving any explanation of why you believe that its benefits shouldn't be taken into account, or at least none in a language most of us can understand.

You haven't given any reason whatsoever for your outrage at Whirligig's suggestion that non-religious people should join religious organisations to influence people in positive ways. Your response was simply an outpouring of apparent horror with no reasoned argument behind it.
Further, you are limiting your own arguing options by trying to close the debate down to basically one of a simple adversarial nature - basically a "did" "didn't" style of argument. For example, I linked to testimonies of people who gave up lifestyles of violence and other harmful ways when they became Christians. If you'd argued more imaginatively, you could have seen that as a coup d'etat for your position - "Ha! Those testimonies demonstrate that people turn to religion when they're dissatisfied with their lives in some way!" Instead, your argument was a simplistic reactionary one - "I don't want to read any more of those! You're spamming the thread with them!"
I think it would be better if you reason your position through more and try to think more deeply about the opposition's points.
I'll answer a couple of points you made earlier that I didn't before. You wrote a long post in response to my question as to what you perceive as being wrong with the concept of moral living. I think I can summarise it by saying you believe morality is an abstract concept that can obstruct pragmatism, such as where Christians oppose handing out condoms to men in Africa because they don't want them to be promiscuous, when actually they're going to be promiscuous anyway and why jolly well shouldn't they be, and at least giving them condoms would reduce their chances of catching AIDS.
Actually that premise is not quite right, because the concept of morality is not always immutable, and where it is, it can actually inspire more efficacious policies.
For instance, researching with stem cells from embryos is considered by some to be immoral. But opponents can argue that it isn't immoral and in fact is more moral than not doing it, given that it's being done before the embryos develop enough to be fetuses that would actually feel pain, and the research is being done to benefit fully-developed humans who
are in a lot of pain and/or suffering a lot because of disabilities, so isn't trying to eliminate their pain and suffering the most moral choice?
It's also possible the controversy over morality can lead to research efforts being made on other types of stem cells which could actually prove very fruitful long-term. For instance, from the latest
news items on 'Stem Cell Transplantation'
(BBC 18/06/2009)
Discarded fallopian tubes from hysterectomies could be a good source of donor stem cells, say researchers. Work shows they are an abundant source of the immature cells that have the potential to become a variety of the body's tissues, like muscle and bone. The discovery offers another "ethical" route to creating stem cell treatments for diseases like arthritis without using embryos. Other sources include: umbilical cords, menstrual blood, teeth and fat tissue.
Some of these could possibly work better than embryonic stem cells in some situations, so scientists might be grateful for being pushed into exploring other avenues by the controversy. Certainly one benefit of taking stem cells from the person being treated, rather than using embryos from people unrelated to them, eliminates the risk of the cells being rejected by the body, though whether the ethical controversy had any impact on the avenues that scientists researching into the rejection issue explored, I don't know. They might have researched alternatives anyway. Still, some finds might not have been made.
Regarding AIDS in Africa, it's true that a dogmatically moral position that condoms shouldn't be handed out and education should consist entirely of abstinence-only teaching might have led to an increase in the prevalence of AIDS. That's especially if the same thing that's been happening in America has been happening there. From an
article about research findings on abstinence-only education vs comprehensive sex education:
In addition, while an abstinence pledge may work for some groups of young people as a way of delaying when they have sexual intercourse, the majority still have sex before they are married and when they do they report using condoms less often than 'non-pledgers' and are more likely to substitute anal or oral sex for vaginal sexual intercourse
Which kind of defeats the point, since anal sex is more risky as regards the transition of HIV than vaginal sex.
From Wikipedia:
Unprotected anal sex is a high risk activity regardless of sexual orientation. Research suggests that although gay men are more likely to engage in anal sex, heterosexual couples are more likely not to use condoms when doing so.
Anal sex is more risky than vaginal, since being very thin tissues of anus and rectum can be easily damaged during such sex activities as anal intercourse or use of anal toys. Even slight injuries can become "open gates" for various bacteria and viruses, including HIV. This implies that anal sex does require some certain safety measures. First of all, any partners who practice anal sex should be aware of the necessity of using a condom. The condom must be put on properly, otherwise it does not provide reliable protection. Users should keep in mind that oil-based lubricants damage latex. For this reason water-based lubricants should be used for anal sex.
So refusing information about condoms could do a lot of harm.
But it could be argued that it isn't "moral" to refuse information about contraception to people who might not be swayed by abstinence-only education and so put themselves and others at risk.
Also, it may be that sex education without the moral aspect - the teaching on the benefits of abstinence - could be just as harmful as education without information on condoms.
However, your points actually seemed irrelevant to the discussion, since my points were about ordinary people living more moral lives - in other words, lives that benefited their communities rather than harmed them. They weren't about the consequences of the decisions of a few people in the higher echelons of authority. If I were to argue the AIDS/condoms issue you raised along the lines of the previous points I'd made, I'd say it may be that more morality among the populace of Africa would have prevented AIDS reaching epidemic proportions or even getting a foothold, although there are several causes, not all of them to do with immorality.
Talking of morals, ... oh no this is a little different: the moral of a story.
Regarding that awful story in Judges 19 you quoted about the couple not stopping for the night in a foreign land but going on to their own native Israel - where the woman was abused all night and killed: I said the story had an anti-prejudice moral in it. You responded by reminding us one and all of what came next in the story - him doing what, in the absence of gory television pictures or even a media to speak of at all, was the next best way to rouse outrage among his countrymen - sending bits of her body to them and calling for them to make war on the tribe that had killed her. You commented that my "defence of the Bible" was becoming more "absurd". In other words, what you seemed to be saying was, "How could you possibly say anything good about such a story!" I'd like to point out that just because a story contains a moral, that doesn't mean that the entire story
is moral. Surely you learned that from the Hans Kristian Andersen stories you probably read as a child.
Dann said:
Yes, this is hardly a theme where we'll run out of examples in the near future. But even when religions don't keep people down for religious reasons, for instance when a psychopath uses and abuses credulous believers for his or her own purposes, it is obvious that they are exploited by means of their beliefs, i.e. if they did not feel the need to believe in a transcendent (ir)reality beyond the real world, the psychopath would not be able to take advantage of
their delusion. If you don't need to believe in angels or in communicating with your dearly departed, the psychopath can't to abuse your delusion by offering 'proof' that they are real.
That's a very good point. But as Whirligig suggested, if a destructive person wants to abuse someone, if one means is closed to them, they'll just find another. You can see that extremely clearly in the development of cyber-crime - when one type of software is developed to thwart it, the criminals move on to using new techniques. Why would the potential for abuse mean religion should be scrapped altogether? People should certainly be warned about ways people abuse others' beliefs. That's very important. But religion in itself doesn't make a person vulnerable to abuse. Believing in God doesn't necessarily make you vulnerable to the scam of someone telling you God's telling him you need to give him your money, for instance. Cliff Richard's a famous Christian. There's the story of how someone knocked on his door one day and told him God had told her he wanted her to become Cliff Richard's housekeeper. Cliff Richard said if that were true, he'd have heard about it himself, and in any case, other people had told him God wanted them to be his housekeeper. If they had all heard from God, what was he playing at?

Religion doesn't have to disable the critical thinking faculties.
This gets us back to points similar to some I made earlier - religious figures themselves have campaigned vigorously against abuses perpetrated by other religious figures, for instance, Martin Luther making a bold stand against the Catholic Church's exploitation of the common people by urging them to spend money many could ill afford on a document said to get them or their loved ones out of purgatory faster. It isn't an "us and them" thing.