Checkmite
Skepticifimisticalationist
No, but insisting that it must have been is.
Fair enough.
Now, what if it was?
No, but insisting that it must have been is.
I can't see that those are the questions epepke was talking about, but I'll let him answer for himself.Skeptic Ginger asked it not more than a dozen posts prior to this
Fair enough.
Now, what if it was?
Respectfully, it might be a good idea to back up and ask yourself why all of this is relevant.You can take the "facts" at face value, most of us have:
5 star hotel
elevator alone
4am
after leaving the bar
EG was in the bar
RW believes elevators in 5 star hotels in Dublin are places assaults occur
It's the conclusions you cannot take at face value, unless you think RW can read minds:
EG heard RW's panel talk and bar discussion
EG interpreted RW's words the way RW believed
EG only wanted sex
EG's actions amounted to sexist objectification of RW
McGraf's comments reinforce misogyny
Elevators in 5 star hotels in Dublin are actually places one should fear assaults occur
No, I did not. I simply didn't find the accuracy of her conclusions to be relevant in my criticism of Stef overreacting. I knew all along that perhaps he didn't hear her, perhaps he did just want coffee and a chat, perhaps it wasn't "objectification," etc. Again, irrelevant to my comment about Stef. Especially irrelevant is "McGraf's comments reinforce misogyny," as that did not happen until after Stef's original response - the one I was being critical of.Yes, you did and you continue to do so here unless you were EG. Otherwise you are assuming your imagined experience is the same as everyone would have had.
Perhaps we should first define "insist." I don't think it means the same as "claim." Anyhow, I don't see how this is a point worth discussing. If she only claimed it was for sex, which is all she did in the first video blog, we don't have to believe her, but I have no reason to call her "unskeptical" for making the claim.Can you find a single quote from RW where she did not insist?
I don't have a problem with her saying it, though.RW has excused herself a number of times by saying she didn't attack EG only his actions, and so on. It's disingenuous because it is not relevant.
Fine, and it remains her original video blog that I for one don't have a real issue with.It remains RW's conclusions here that people take issue with, not her social skills.
1) The guy did show bad judgment, not worthy of scorn, but...
2) Certainly worthy of RW's blog video of the incident. All I got out of it was, "Guys, here's a clue, don't do this." She didn't name him, either. And she's right, thus...
3) Stef and others overreacted to RW's reaction. That said, ...
4) RW didn't need to call out Stef by name. That showed poor judgment, too, but...
5) Not to the degree that people should be raking her over the coals for it. Disagreeing with her choice, even strongly so...well, sure. But gee whiz....
Who said or implied that? You REALLY missed the point here. BADLY.Riiight. Sexual attractiveness doesn't have anything to do with it.![]()
Nevermind.You know, after a couple of weeks, even the original stuff is seeming less and less important. Just in the past few days, an aggressive gay wino accosted me wanting a kiss. Oh, can I write a blog where I write, "Gays, don't do this?"
This.I think she was fine to complain about getting hit on, but basically everything after that has been one misstep after another.
Warning, don't read my venting if it is going to just make you angry. Feel free to skip it. I am frustrated and perhaps you are not responsible for being the last of many prior posters with the same straw man.....
If you're going to accuse me of constructing a straw man, then you'll have to show me where exactly I'm falsely attributing any argument to anyone. Otherwise, I'll politely request that you withdraw the accusation. As it stands now, I am in need of no correction on this matter because I have made no attempt at all to analyze actual events. I have only commented on RW's constructed example and the advice that should be drawn from that regardless of whether it is merely a construct, or an accurate description of an actual event.
The thing that initiated this debate included the initial video, the response by McGraf and and Stclairose in the blogosphere and RW's further discussion of the elevator incident in the Student Conference.
Were it simply RW's video and the couple blogosphere replies who disagreed with her take on the incident, it would have in all likelihood faded away at that point.
It was RW, who upon hearing this different opinion to hers, went on to make the whole thing about feminism, objectifying women, sexualizing women, and being common enough among our community to be affecting the attendance of women at formal events.
Watson on naming names at the CFI conference said:...approaching a single woman in an elevator to invite her back to your hotel room is the definition of “unsolicited sexual comment.” But those are unimportant details in comparison to the first quoted sentence, which demonstrates an ignorance of Feminism 101 – in this case, the difference between sexual attraction and sexual objectification. The former is great – be attracted to people! Flirt, have fun, make friends, have sex, meet the love of your life, whatever floats your boat. But the latter involves dismissing a person’s feelings, desires, and identity, with a complete disinterest in how one’s actions will affect the “object” in question.
It's important to stop here and read Stef McGraf's supposed dismissive comment RW quoted and was referring to:Watson on naming names at the CFI conference said:I hear a lot of misogyny from skeptics and atheists, but when ancient anti-woman rhetoric like the above is repeated verbatim by a young woman online, it validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another....
This is "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny"?Steph McGraf after seeing RW's original video said:My concern is that she [RW] takes issue with a man showing interest in her. What’s wrong with that? How on earth does that justify him as creepy? Are we not sexual beings? Let’s review, it’s not as if he touched her or made an unsolicited sexual comment; he merely asked if she’d like to come back to his room. She easily could have said (and I’m assuming did say), “No thanks, I’m tired and would like to go to my room to sleep.”
the rest of McGraf's comments said:Watson is upset that this man is sexualizing her just after she gave a talk relating to feminism, but my question is this: Since when are respecting women as equals and showing sexual interest mutually exclusive? Is it not possible to view to take interest in a woman AND see her as an intelligent person?...
...If you really want social equality for women, which is what feminism is, why not apply the same standards to men and women, and stop demonizing men for being sexual beings?
You should be capable of looking for it yourself. Especially since you don't really see it as relevant data. Linda commented on it. Try looking at her comments (fls) from the beginning. She hasn't posted that much so it will go quickly, and while you are at it, try reading what she had to say. It's well worth the effort if you want to understand this debate that you have thoroughly misconstrued.....I'd be interested in seeing that blog if anyone has a link, but it's not actually relevant to my point at all. Again, everything I've said rests on a purely hypothetical situation. Rebecca, and her followers, seem inclined to believe that that hypothetical is in accord with an actual event. Others question the congruity of the two. I don't care one way or the other.
So you don't have an issue with RW's absurd complaint that McGraf's simply seeing things differently made her an anti-feminist misogynist? Perhaps you should go back and re-read that blog. You seem to have missed the key points.....No. On the face of it, RW seems to be saying that guys should not behave as she believes EG was behaving. If I've missed something she's said subsequently to qualify that, then I will be happy to adjust my opinion of her position accordingly. But her "Naming Names" blog post seems only to corroborate my understanding.
You lost me here..Sorry, I often forget how sarcasm isn't so obvious in print as it sounds in my head. Perhaps, though, you missed where I said multiple times that which of those possibilities, or any others, which might be true are irrelevant to me because I'm only talking about a hypothetical construct.
Am I reading this correctly? Have you also come around to a different point of view? Didn't you start off on the other side of the argument?It would seem to me that referring to people who disagree with you as "not proper skeptics/feminists" or whatever the term may be for the case at hand, is out of line most if not all of the time, yes. I also tend to agree that not feeling uncomfortable for being hit on by a stranger doesn't justify being labeled as "self-hating", if that's what happened.
I was commenting that "perceived familiarity with an onscreen persona" was not the relevant issue in the Brad Pitt example. And the example was hypothetical, the relevant issue was what the point was about.Who said or implied that? You REALLY missed the point here. BADLY.
Am I reading this correctly? Have you also come around to a different point of view? Didn't you start off on the other side of the argument?
With rolleyes? Really?? You do realize that your "commentary" is not inconsistent with my preferring to eliminate any celebrity-safety effect don't you? Gee whiz. Yes, good looks is the relevant issue, which is why I prefer using a stranger in the hypo...to keep it the ONLY issue, to eliminate any possible "celebrity trust" excuse should this impossible hypo ever be tested.I was commenting that "perceived familiarity with an onscreen persona" was not the relevant issue in the Brad Pitt example.
Some people, such as myself, find it more important than you do. From my perspective, her conduct after her initial video blog was abhorrent and easily discerned once somebody sees the timeline and quotes. I just happen to find it little different than your average thread on countless discussion forums. It's the same mentality and approach. The only difference is the format (blogs) and the players (prominent people). Other than that, it's a snoozer for me.Yes, people are pointing out RW's false assumptions about EG, but even that is only a small piece of what sparked this gazillion post debate.

If we start considering people's potential negative reactions to the point of inaction, then what's the point ?
Nope, but as I explained in my responses to others EG's actual knowlege and intent are irrelevant. Rebecca's initial video was commenting on her perception of them, and her admonishment to all men was predicated on that perception. I don't believe she said anything at all about the appropriateness of EG or anyone else propositioning a woman they do know have such foreknowledge about. If RW was mistaken what EG heard or knew about her, then the actual event is just not a good example of the point she was making, but the point still stands.
I have none. I'm not arguing that RW's assesment of the EG's motives and foreknowlege is correct, only that, assuming they were correct, her response is entirely justified.
Not quite. Presuming that females who would not react badly to a proposition would not care anyway is just a reiteration of definition: they won't react badly to being asked (by definition), and they can't react at all to a non-stimulus. On the other hand, "Men who don't want casual sex will not care" is not an equal presumption, because the proposed action (hitting on them) is a stimulus, and there can be a reaction, and if they do not want casual sex that reaction may easily be negative. I, for instance, would be made uncomfortable by a stranger coming up to me and asking me for sex.
The point of the profanity example was just to provide another instance of a common societal behavior which has boundaries that may not be strictly logical. It was not meant to be a mirror of the stranger-sex thing in every aspect.
I find it humorous that you actually quoted my saying "That's not to say "you must never order fish ever because someone in the restaurant you don't know about may be sickened by the smell of fish", or "you must never tell the aristocrats joke ever because someone in the audience could be an abuse victim" - that's an argument from adverse consequences...", yet your actual response suggests you hadn't read it.
All right, fine. Which is worth more to you - having sex with someone you don't know, or avoiding the enmity of someone you don't know?
How about "because [action] makes People who matter to us uncomfortable, we should refrain when they're around".
In this case, TAM attendees we presumably want to interact with. It is a much smaller set than "everyone"; small enough that a handful of people become statistically significant.
...
Yes I am. In any case, it's not traditional to ask complete strangers for sex, either, making this particular tangent somewhat of an argumentative stalemate.
Has anyone suggested in all of this, that it was incredibly presumptuous of RW to think that anyone wanted to have sex with her ?