Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's interesting that Mozina never discusses the mathematics or even the actual physics involved in these discussions. Instead, his positions are based on what he thinks he understands from old papers written by dead physicists. What a pathetically impoverished way to understand science!
 
It's interesting that Mozina never discusses the mathematics or even the actual physics involved in these discussions. Instead, his positions are based on what he thinks he understands from old papers written by dead physicists. What a pathetically impoverished way to understand science!

Considering the fact that your last "scientific argument" was based ENTIRELY upon artwork and a complete misread of the website where you found it, that's quite funny!
 
It's interesting that Mozina never discusses the mathematics or even the actual physics involved in these discussions. Instead, his positions are based on what he thinks he understands from old papers written by dead physicists. What a pathetically impoverished way to understand science!

What the heck is there to discuss in terms of math? He hasn't presented any useful maths yet! I'm actually dying to see how he gets that *HUGE* energy release to occur WITHOUT a plasma.
 
It's a good thing we all agree that magnetic B lines do not disconnect or reconnect, magnet FLUX induces an E field that results in an electrical discharge that we call a "solar flare".


Oh, well that's nothing like what Dungey described.
 
Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection

Missed this:
Wow, you got something right! How high does the current get according to Dungey?
Wow - you read and misunderstood again something I wrote!
Current density
Current density is a measure of the density of flow of a conserved charge. Usually the charge is the electric charge, in which case the associated current density is the electric current per unit area of cross section, but the term current density can also be applied to other conserved quantities. It is defined as a vector whose magnitude is the current per cross-sectional area.

Oh dear - you are showing your ignorance of Dungey's work.
The Neutral Point Discharge Theory of Solar Flares. a Reply to Cowling's Criticism, Dungey 1958
"The defining feature of a discharge in this context is the existence of a large current density. The electrons must at least reach relativistic energies and the order of magnitude is given by j ~ nec; furthermore, constriction may increase n to a value substantially larger than in the surrounding gas.

We can add this to Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection.
Originally posted on 13th January 2011 by D'rok!
 
Let's distinguish the front and back of the box by saying the magnetic field lines enter at the back and leave at the front. That means the total flux through the box S is obtained by subtracting (the absolute value of) the flux that enters the back from the flux that leaves the front.

And you're ABSOLUTELY positive that you aren't confusing "magnetic flux" (with respect to your box), including directional components, with "magnetic reconnection"?
 
It is EXACTLY what he actually "described" in terms of the math and the physics. An E field is INDUCED and an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE is the result.


What Dungey described was magnetic reconnection. He even called it that. He never said anything about a cathode Sun (which doesn't act like any known cathode) with (physically impossible) giant lightning-like sparks for solar flares. There was nothing about Dungey's magnetic reconnection explanation that could rationally be mistaken for some kind of electric Sun conjecture.
 
Just for the record. The most likely ERROR that you're making Clinger is mistaking MAGNETIC FLUX for "reconnection". That's what EVERYONE seems to be doing, along with ignoring Dungey's claim about ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES and induced E fields. :)
 
Last edited:
It is EXACTLY what he actually "described" in terms of the math and the physics. An E field is INDUCED and an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE is the result.
You have still not cited Dungey stating this (MM: cite Dungey's "'electrical discharge' that releases all that stored EM energy").
However you are wrong because the result is not Dungey's ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE
  1. Magnetic reconnection happens causing
  2. An induced E field (changing magnetic fields!) causing
  3. Electrons to be accelerated (this is not Dungey's ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE).
Dungey's ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE is the squeezing of the plasma as the MR starts. This constriction increasess the current density in the current sheets within the plasma.
Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection!
Originally posted on 13th January 2011 by D'rok!
 
Magnetic reconnection happens

Based on that last website that you and PS couldn't read correctly, it's clear that you're both INTENT on confusing MAGNETIC FLUX with "reconnection". It's the MAGNETIC FLUX that induces the E field RC, not "reconnection". Oy Vey.
 
Last edited:
MM: Cite Dungey stating that the induced E field creates large current densities

Just for the record. The most likely ERROR that your making Clinger is mistaking MAGNETIC FLUX for "reconnection". That's what EVERYONE seems to be doing, along with ignoring Dungey's claim about ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES and induced E fields. :)
Just for the record: MAGNETIC FLUX is not magnetic reconnecting and so you are the ine making the.
What Clinger clearly shows is that the magnetic field lines can go through a neutral point. The fact that this jeans that they break is obvious:
  1. AT a neutral point the magnetic field is zero (B=0).
  2. When B=0 there are no field lines.
  3. And line entering a neutral point must end there.
  4. Any line leaving a neutral point must start there.
Just for the recored: You are lying again :). We are not ignoring Dungey or your inability to understand his work on magnetic reconnection: Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection!

Just in case your assertion that Dungey has induced E fields creating large current densities (what he called electrical discharges) is not part of:
Michael Mozina.
Cite Dungey stating that the induced E field creates large current densities (what he called electrical discharges).
 
Based on that last website you and PS couldn't read correctly, it's clear that you're INTENT on confusing MAGNETIC FLUX with "reconnection". It's the MAGNETIC FLUX that induces the E field RC, not "reconnection". Oy Vey.
Based on this post you are determined to obsess with random assertions about MAGNETIC FLUX.
Oy Vey.
That would be dumb because they are different things.
The post is especially ignorant because there are no E fields illustrated on the web site.
The post is even more ignorant because not one can read anything on that web site about magnetic reconnection beacuse it is not mentioned or described.

What people can do is look at the animations that show magnetic field lines breaking and reconnecting, e.g. two loops forming one loop.
There is nothing to confuse there.
 
Could you explain how any magnetic B line "begins" anywhere? I can see how a MAGNET can be thought of as a "beginning" point, or more accurately the "source of" a magnet field, by how could any magnetic field "begin" in a "vacuum"?
You're at a considerable disadvantage here because you never even tried to answer Reality Check's question about the magnetic field surrounding a single current-carrying rod. It looks like this:
[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure0.png[/qimg]

Now consider the contributions made to B4 at the origin by each of the four rods. For the east rod, its contribution is some particular intensity m in the southward direction. For the west rod, its contribution is that same intensity m in the northward direction, so the net contribution of the east and west rods to B4 at the origin is 0. Similarly, the net contribution of the north and south rods is 0. Hence B4 is zero at the origin; that's why Dungey calls it a neutral point.

Now consider the value of B4 at some point of the form <dx,-dx> where dx is very small but positive. For the east rod, its contribution is some intensity mE (which is very close to m but slightly greater) in a direction that's very close to southward but slightly east. For the west rod, its contribution is some intensity mW (which is very close to m but slightly less) in a direction that's very close to northward but slightly west. The east and west rods almost cancel each other's fields at <dx,-dx>, but their net effect is a very small resultant in the general direction of southeast. Similarly, the north and south rods almost cancel each other's fields at <dx,-dx> but their net effect is a very small resultant in the general direction of southeast. Adding those two very small resultants together, you get a very small magnetic field directed southeast.

For larger values of dx, the direction continues to be southeast but the intensity grows larger (up to a point, after which the intensity begins to decrease and continues to decrease all the way out to infinity). For smaller positive values of dx approaching zero, the direction of the magnetic field at <dx,-dx> continues to be southeast but its intensity approaches the zero value we calculated for the origin.

If you don't believe me, you can calculate the partial derivatives of B4 with respect to x and y at points of the form <dx,-dx> with 0<dx.

It's a good thing we all agree that magnetic B lines do not disconnect or reconnect, magnet FLUX induces an E field that results in an electrical discharge that we call a "solar flare".
That's absurd. Even if we ignore the fact that a B field's magnetic field lines can disconnect or reconnect at neutral points, a steady magnetic flux does not induce an E field.

Come to think of it, everything you have ever written about magnetic flux is wrong.
 
Based on this post you are determined to obsess with random assertions about MAGNETIC FLUX.

Random my *ss. PS HOUNDED me about the issue until I *FINALLY* got it, along with the fact that neither of you knows how to correctly read the website where the images originate. While the author does correctly talk about the MAGNETS reconnecting, the author also CORRECTLY describes the TWISTING and BENDING of the actual B and H field lines (flux not 'reconnection'). You two (Clinger makes 3) can't tell solid magnet reconnection from an electrical discharge in a plasma!
 
Last edited:
Come to think of it, everything you have ever written about magnetic flux is wrong.

How ironic considering the fact that everything you've said about "reconnection" is wrong, wrong, HORRIBLY wrong, starting with the fact that solar flares occur in PLASMAS, not "vacuums".
 
What Dungey described was magnetic reconnection. He even called it that.

He also called it an electrical discharge too. When did you intend to get off the denial-go-round?


Here's the rest of what I said... Dungey never said anything about a cathode Sun (which doesn't act like any known cathode) with (physically impossible) giant lightning-like sparks for solar flares. There was nothing about Dungey's magnetic reconnection explanation that could rationally be mistaken for some kind of electric Sun conjecture.
 
Here's the rest of what I said...

I don't care what the rest says. You're in PURE DENIAL of the fact that solar flares are ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES. There's no point in worrying about anything else since you've demonstrated conclusively that your beliefs are IRRATIONAL and based on PURE IGNORANCE and irrational hatred.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom