Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
WTF? That is not MY claim, MM. Holy cow. You cannot even think about the implications of your own BS.

You claim that 'electrical discharges' happen in solar flares because you can cite a 60 year old paper where the term 'electrical discharges' was used for the large current density caused by the MR that causes solar flares.
But this term is no longer used in the modern papers about MR as a cause of solar flares. So 'electrical discharges' no longer happen in solar flares. The term has been replaced by large current densities.

Belz, would you like to take the time to explain the irony of that last post to RC? Are you sure I can't just blow an irony meter and be done with it? :)
 
Mm: Quote Gekelman, et al stating that what reconnects are "field aligned currents"

What exactly don't you understand about the word "current"? They are clear that what "reconnects" are "field aligned currents".
What exactly about the sequence of events in the sentence you picked out can you not understand?
A reconnection event is triggered by the collision and the electric field induced in this event generates a field-aligned current, which is the first step in the development of a fully three-dimensional current system.

I also can read English so we have
  1. A reconnection event
  2. the electric field induced in this event generates a field-aligned current
  3. and then the development of a fully three-dimensional current system.
There is no way in hell that you cannot understand that there is no reconnection of field-aligned currents in that sentence.
There is a reconnection event that induces an electric field. The electric field generates a field-aligned current.

The "Summary and Conclusions:" makes this even more explicit:
Two carbon laser-produced plasmas with initial density that is orders of magnitude greater than an ambient helium plasma were produced such that they collided in the center of the plasma column. The collision process occurs in two stages. In the first, two magnetic “bubbles” collide. The collision produces turbulent local magnetic fields. The morphology and wavenumber spectrum of this turbulence will be the subject of a future paper. The collision of the lpps results in an early magnetic reconnection event (Fig. 4). This creates a short-lived induced electric field parallel to the background magnetic field and drives a large field aligned current. After about a microsecond, the magnetic bubbles collapse but the cross-field collision continues. In the final state, the two plasmas coalesce and stream along the magnetic field away from the impact point.
(emphasis added to match my emphasis in the abstract)
 
Since he's riding Dungey's coattails, handwaving away like crazy, talk to me again when he produces an electrical discharge from his vacuum contraption and he provides us the additional math we're waiting on.
Since he is supporting Dungey's paper with valid physics, we will talk to you again when you understand the experiment instead of making up fantasies about it.

It is idiocy to think that a large current density (Dungey's 'electrical discharge' term that is no longer used) in plasma in an experiment that has no plasma (is in vacuum) :jaw-dropp!
Originally Posted by W.D.Clinger
In part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, I proved that Dungey's X-shaped magnetic field can occur within a vacuum, with no plasma present and with virtually no electrical field.

And it looks like the next part will not have any plasma in it either

In part 4, I will describe a simple variation of the experiment I've been suggesting to Michael Mozina and prove that the topology of the magnetic field changes during that experiment. As Yamada et al explain in their appendix, that change in the topology of the magnetic field is what we mean by magnetic reconnection. ...
[SIZE=+1]References[/SIZE]

[Dungey 1958] J W Dungey. The neutral point discharge theory of solar flares. A reply to Cowling's criticism. Proceedings of Electromagnetic Phenomena in Cosmical Physics, edited by Bo Lehnert. International Astronomical Union number 6, Cambridge University Press, page 135.

[Yamada et al 2010] Masaaki Yamada, Russell Kulsrud, and Hantao Ji. Magnetic reconnection. Reviews of Modern Physics volume 82, January-March 2010, pages 603-664.
 
Last edited:
What exactly about the sequence of events in the sentence you picked out can you not understand?

There is no way in hell that you cannot understand that there is no reconnection of field-aligned currents in that sentence.
There is a reconnection event that induces an electric field. The electric field generates a field-aligned current.

The "Summary and Conclusions:" makes this even more explicit:

(emphasis added to match my emphasis in the abstract)

Anyone can parrot the term "reconnection" RC. The term is technically "magnetic reconnection", not "magnetic B LINE reconnection". Nobody disputes the fact that magnetic field FLUX can INDUCE (not reconnect) E fields which result in electrical discharges in plasma RC (except you). Nobody has shown any math to demonstrate that B field lines "reconnect".
 
Last edited:
Anyone can parrot the term "reconnection" RC.
Stop calling Gekelman, et al parrots :rolleyes: ('reconenction event'is their term).

MM: Quote Gekelman, et al stating that what reconnects are "field aligned currents"

Nobody has shown any math to demonstrate that B field lines "reconnect".
You are lying - W.D. Clinger has. He has used math to describe the physics of the EM fields generated by current carrying rods.

W.D. Clinger has demonstrated that you can have a magnetic field topology that matches Dungey's and Yamada et al 2010.
 
Stop calling Gekelman, et al parrots :rolleyes: ('reconenction event'is their term).

I didn't call them parrots. They UNDERSTAND and explained the process clearly and BEAUTIFULLY. It's you that keeps parroting the term "reconnection" without any understanding of what you're talking about. They are talking about induced E field and field aligned current reconnection. You're still clueless because you believe that B field lines 'disconnect' even though they have no beginning and no ending. Evidently you also buy Clinger's BS about them "beginning" and "ending" in a "vacuum" no less. Talk about ditzy beliefs.
 
Last edited:
Which of your MATHS show a magnetic B line "reconnection" Clinger?
I have not yet proved that the magnetic field lines of a B field can reconnect. That will come in part 4 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

Which one results in an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE in a vacuum?
Although I have explained how the B fields shown in Dungey's two figures can be replicated by the simple experiment I suggested to you last December, I have not yet explained their relevance to increasing current density at the neutral point (which is what Dungey meant by electrical discharge). I will explain that in part 5 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

All you've done so far is wave around a little circuit theory, wave around a couple of diagrams related to PLASMA physics and you've shown no actual B field line reconnection that might explain million degree solar flares,
Although I might be capable of discussing a little circuit theory, I don't recall having done so in this thread.

Thank you for acknowledging that all of the B fields I have diagrammed are relevant to plasma physics.

In part 4 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, I will prove that the magnetic field lines of a B field can reconnect. As I am not a physicist of any kind, I will not try to show that magnetic reconnection can explain hot solar flares. I'm just trying to counter some of the denialist noise by posting a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection as discussed by Dungey, Yamada, and the current Wikipedia article on magnetic reconnection.

nor have you shown that any field BEGINS in your X point nor ENDS in your X point.
Although I have shown computer-generated graphs of the B field and some of its magnetic field lines, including the four magnetic field lines that begin or end at the neutral point of the X-shaped field in Dungey's figure 1, it is true that I have not shown every single step of the calculations that prove those lines begin or end at the X point.

On the other hand, I have stated all of the relevant equations, and I have explained how you can complete the proof yourself by calculating B's partial derivatives along the diagonals. That seems like a trivial calculation to me, but I can understand how it might be impossible for you.

So far the math you have provided is CHILDISH.
I'm saddened but unsurprised to hear you are having so much trouble with the high school algebra and first-year calculus I've been using.

FYI, Clinger also convinced him that solid magnet reconnection was the same thing as an electrical discharge in a plasma too.
:confused:
Deliberate misrepresentation of others' conversations is a form of lying.

The term "reconnection" relates to an inducement of an E field due to FLUX and an ensuing electrical discharge. It has NOTHING to do with reconnecting B lines!

Nobody disputes the fact that magnetic field FLUX can INDUCE (not reconnect) E fields which result in electrical discharges in plasma RC (except you). Nobody has shown any math to demonstrate that B field lines "reconnect".
If you knew anything at all about the subject in which you're pretending to be such an expert, you'd know that an unchanging magnetic flux does not induce an E field.
 
You are lying - W.D. Clinger has. He has used math to describe the physics of the EM fields generated by current carrying rods.

So what? He's never demonstrated that B field lines "reconnect" nor that they have a 'beginning' or an 'ending' inside of a VACUUM no less. He's buried himself in BS handwave claims that he can NEVER demonstrate mathematically.

W.D. Clinger has demonstrated that you can have a magnetic field topology that matches Dungey's and Yamada et al 2010.

Nope:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7742349&postcount=4723

Until you and/or Clinger has answered EVERY SINGLE ONE of the questions from that last list of questions, you two have done absolutely NOTHING in terms of showing "B field line reconnection", not to mention any of those BS claims about magnetic lines beginning and ending in a vacuum.
 
I have not yet proved that the magnetic field lines of a B field can reconnect. That will come in part 4 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

Lovely. I can't wait. I guess it will explain that confusion with the arrows at the X and it will explain how magnetic lines "begin" in a vacuum too I presume?

Although I have explained how the B fields shown in Dungey's two figures can be replicated by the simple experiment I suggested to you last December, I have not yet explained their relevance to increasing current density at the neutral point (which is what Dungey meant by electrical discharge).

Your arrows at the X are FUBAR to this point in time since you have no plasma as Dungey did and no mathematical explanation for them. I have idea how you intend to justify your two directional arrows. I'll have to wait and see I suppose.

I will explain that in part 5 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

Oh, so part 5 is one gigantic goalpost shift where you try to HIDE the fact that you finally realize that you NEED a plasma and your experiment doesn't actually WORK in a VACUUM as you first claimed? Is that it? Ah, the back-peddling and rationalizations have already begun I see. How sadly predictable.
 
Last edited:
MM: Quote Gekelman, et al stating that what reconnects are "field aligned currents"

They are talking about induced E field and field aligned current reconnection.
Duh - I read and quoted the authors talking about induced E field and field aligned current!

You are still ignoring the reconnection event that comes before the field aligned current is created.

You are lying - there is no "field aligned current reconnection" unless you can answer:
MM: Quote Gekelman, et al stating that what reconnects are "field aligned currents"
 
If you knew anything at all about the subject in which you're pretending to be such an expert, you'd know that an unchanging magnetic flux does not induce an E field.

Strawman. I didn't say a damn thing about "unchanging", you did. In fact you painted yourself into a corner by changing dB/dt slowly, remember?
 
Last edited:
So what? He's never demonstrated that B field lines "reconnect" nor that they have a 'beginning' or an 'ending' inside of a VACUUM no less.
So what - you are lying.
W.D. Clinger has demonstrated that B field lines have a 'beginning or and ending inside of a VACUUM.
Demonstrating reconneciton is coming

All of the MATHS ends up almost showing a magnetic B line ending and beginning. He left the last step to you in the mistaken assumption that you have the knowledge to do this trivial calculation. I will leave it as a learning experience for you (remember learning MM :D?).
I have already sketched a geometric proof that Gauss's law holds for the magnetic field generated by a single current-carrying rod. That result is confirmed by starting from its equation and calculating the divergence. By linearity, Gauss's law must therefore hold for the magnetic field around four such rods. That result can also be confirmed by starting from the equation for B4 and calculating its divergence.

As for your fantasy that there is plasma in his experiment to create Dungey's outdated term for large current density:
It is idiocy to think that a large current density (Dungey's 'electrical discharge' term that is no longer used) in plasma in an experiment that has no plasma (is in vacuum) :jaw-dropp!
 
Lovely. I can't wait. I guess it will explain that confusion with the arrows at the X and it will explain how magnetic lines "begin" in a vacuum too I presume?
The confusion with the arrows is all yours. It has been explained previously.
That magnetic field lines begin and end in in the magnetic field configuration (that happens to be in a vacuum) is easy so see - no field lines at the neutral point = they have to begin or end there.
 
Strawman. I didn't say a damn thing about "unchanging", you did. In fact you painted yourself into a corner by changing dB/dt slowly, remember?
Not a strawman.
It was you who have constantly neglected to mention a changing magnetic flux. Instead you have been going on about 'magnetic flux' and not stating that it was changing.
It is obvious that in magnetic reconnection, magnetic fields are changing and so magnetic flux through a given surface can be changing.
But Faraday's law of induction is
55fc248faaa06562e59736f59a584870.png
and inducted E fields are generated from changing B fields.

Your last sentence displays some ignorance.
Magnetic flux is not dB/dt. It can change when B changes but does not enter into the induction of E fields.
Magnetic flux "(most often denoted as Φm), is a measure of the amount of magnetic B field (also called "magnetic flux density") passing through a given surface (such as a conducting coil)."
 
So what - you are lying.
W.D. Clinger has demonstrated that B field lines have a 'beginning or and ending inside of a VACUUM.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7743145&postcount=4747

Although I have shown computer-generated graphs of the B field and some of its magnetic field lines, including the four magnetic field lines that begin or end at the neutral point of the X-shaped field in Dungey's figure 1, it is true that I have not shown every single step of the calculations that prove those lines begin or end at the X point.

Who's lying RC?
 
You are: W.D. Clinger has demonstrated that B field lines have a beginning and ending inside of a VACUUM.
I did not say that he showed every step. The last step is trivial.

ETA
MM: Quote Gekelman, et al stating that what reconnects are "field aligned currents"

ETA2
If by 'demonstrated' you mean 'detailed every step so that a child can understand it' then W.D. Clinger (and no one else) will ever be able demonstrate it.
If by 'demonstrated' you mean 'detailed every step so that Michael Mozina can understand it' then W.D. Clinger (and no one else) will ever be able demonstrate it because you have an displayed an abysmal ignorance of the physics and mathematics required to understand it.
Michael Mozina's ignorance of high school science (the right hand rule)
Michael Mozina's delusion that permeability is inductance!
Michael Mozina's delusion about "*RECONNECTIONS* per unit length").
If by 'demonstrated' you mean 'detailed every step so that Michael Mozina can accept it even if he cannot understand it' then W.D. Clinger (and no one else) will ever be able demonstrate it because you have an displayed an obsession with not accepting MR, e.g. ignoring or misinterpreting the scientific literature on it.
 
Last edited:
You are: W.D. Clinger has demonstrated that B field lines have a beginning and ending inside of a VACUUM.
I did not say that he showed every step. The last step is trivial.

If it's so "trivial", do your good friend a very trivial favor and do it for us yourself. Tick.tick.tick....
 
Last edited:
You are: W.D. Clinger has demonstrated that B field lines have a beginning and ending inside of a VACUUM.
I did not say that he showed every step. The last step is trivial.

If it's so "trivial", do your good friend a very trivial favor and do it for us yourself. Tick.tick.tick....
Oh my goodness. Is Michael Mozina really suggesting that Reality Check or I might have the slightest difficulty with a calculation he is utterly unable to perform?

To complete a rigorous proof that two magnetic lines of B4 end at the neutral point, and another two magnetic lines begin at the neutral point, we need only calculate the partial derivatives of B4 along the diagonals and draw the obvious conclusions.

Here's the definition of B4:

[latex]
\[
\begin{align*}
\hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} &= \hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} (x, y, z, t) = \hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} (t) (x, y, z) \\
&= \frac{\mu_0}{2 \pi} \frac{I^{(p)}(t)}{(x-x_0)^2+(y-y_0)^2}
\left( - (y-y_0) \, \hbox{{\bf e}}_x + (x-x_0) \, \hbox{{\bf e}}_y \right)
\end{align*}
\]
[/latex]​
where ex and ey are the unit vectors in the x and y directions.


[size=+1]Magnetic fields around multiple rods[/size]

Applying that equation to our four rods, we define

[latex]
\[

\begin{align*}
p_E &= \langle 1, 0 \rangle \\
p_W &= \langle -1, 0 \rangle \\
p_N &= \langle 0, 1 \rangle \\
p_S &= \langle 0, -1 \rangle \\
I_E(t) &= I^{p_E}(t) = \hbox{{1000 amperes}} \\
I_W(t) &= I^{p_W}(t) = I_E(t) \\
I_N(t) &= I_S(t) = - I_E(t) = - I_W(t) \\
\hbox{{B}}_E &= \hbox{{B}}^{(p_E)} \\
\hbox{{B}}_W &= \hbox{{B}}^{(p_W)} \\
\hbox{{B}}_N &= \hbox{{B}}^{(p_N)} \\
\hbox{{B}}_S &= \hbox{{B}}^{(p_S)} \\
\hbox{{B}}_2 &= \hbox{{B}}_E + \hbox{{B}}_W \\
\hbox{{B}}_4 &= \hbox{{B}}_E + \hbox{{B}}_W + \hbox{{B}}_N + \hbox{{B}}_S
\end{align*}
\]
[/latex]​
To calculate ∂B4/∂x and ∂B4/∂y, Reality Check and I would have to know how to
  • calculate the partial derivatives of a sum
  • calculate the partial derivatives of a quotient
  • calculate the partial derivatives of a composition (using the chain rule)
  • calculate the partial derivatives of a low-order polynomial
To us, that looks like a trivial exercise in first-semester calculus. No wonder it looks so hard to Michael Mozina.
:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom