Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
At that infinitesimal instant, the two magnetic field lines that are almost touching divide into four field lines that begin or end at the neutral point.

BZZZT! Epic fail part two begins.....

Honestly Clinger, you really do not comprehend even BASIC EM theory. Let me TRY AGAIN to straighten you out, just in case you are in fact interested in EDUCATING yourself.

Literally *NOTHING* begins or ends at the "neutral point" as you're calling it. The term "neutral point" relates to the plasma physics aspect.

In your experiment however (part four without plasma), it's nothing more than a NULL POINT, a region of spacetime where NOTHING HAPPENS. The B field lines (whole fields) "originate" in the four poles of your new graph, not the origin of your first image. See the problem yet? Nothing BEGINS at X. It's just "passing through" X without a penny it's pocket. At the "infinitesimal instant" as you call it, the continuous lines without a beginning or ending all simply "cross", they don't 'begin or end' at the X! There are four complete fields interacting at X (not actual lines), but nothing BEGINS, or ENDS at X. Do you understand this, yes or no?
 
Last edited:
Just to set the record straight, in part three you alleged (didn't "prove" at all) that "Origin" was the great "beginor and endor" of all B field lines in the B field line universe (in your experiment anyway).
Just to set the record straight: I have never alleged that "Origin" was the great "beginor and endor" of all B field lines. In fact, I said quite clearly that the set of B4's field lines that begin or end at the origin form a set of measure zero.

Since Michael Mozina cannot provide a link to any message in which I wrote the second third ("beginor and endor") quoted phrase, I assume he's just telling lies.

Until we get to the plasma bait and switch part of your presentation, I absolutely insist you stop name dropping individuals, institutions you've been involved with, and authors of books you're read. This is YOUR PERSONAL claim, not theirs. You aren't doing any of them any favors by dragging their names through the mud with you Clinger, trust me on this.
:dl:

Dropping names (Alfvén, Peratt, Birkeland, etc) and claiming to have read books (Cosmic Plasma etc) are the most convincing parts of Michael Mozina's arguments.

Here's what happens when Michael Mozina tries to make a real technical argument:

BZZZT! Epic fail part two begins.....

Honestly Clinger, you really do not comprehend even BASIC EM theory. Let me TRY AGAIN to straighten you out, just in case you are in fact interested in EDUCATING yourself.

Literally *NOTHING* begins or ends at the "neutral point" as you're calling it. The term "neutral point" relates to the plasma physics aspect.
In your experiment however (part four without plasma), it's nothing more than a NULL POINT, a region of spacetime where NOTHING HAPPENS. The B field lines (whole fields) "originate" in the four poles of your new graph, not the origin of your first image. See the problem yet? Nothing BEGINS at X. It's just "passing through" X without a penny it's pocket. At the "infinitesimal instant" as you call it, the continuous lines without a beginning or ending all simply "cross", they don't 'begin or end' at the X! There are four complete fields interacting at X (not actual lines), but nothing BEGINS, or ENDS at X. Do you understand this, yes or no?
All of the highlighted statements are false.

It's certainly interesting that Michael Mozina thinks magnetic field lines can cross, but that's about what we should expect from a guy who's never been able to describe the magnetic field of a current-carrying rod.
 
Last edited:
Well , let's take a look at what I said:



I showed you an animation to clarify my question (which you dodged and danced around -- as usual) and you accused me of claiming the animation was proof! As a debating tactic it was indeed fraudulent!

Go back and reread the whole dialog between us PS. I correctly told you that your image was an example of "solid magnet reconnection" right off the bat. I honestly TRIED and TRIED to go through your animation frame by frame trying to "see" what you seemed to see, specifically 'reconnection' of any lines. I could not see that. All I could "see" from my perspective were topology changes in the field lines related to magnetic flux changes. I literally had no clue what you were even 'seeing' in the image. All I could guess at is that you THOUGHT you saw a 'reconnection' of a couple of lines in that animation BETWEEN INDIVIDUAL FRAMES of that animation!

Had you properly read the website in the first place, or even cited the text or math from that website in the first place that you felt was related to 'magnetic reconnection' it would have been really helpful. You even avoided my direct questions while I was trying to figure out your confusion! By the time I handed you that cartoon PS, I was completely exasperated. I had no idea what kind of "evidence" you expected me to respond to at that point.
 
Last edited:
All of the highlighted statements are false.

Not a single one of those highlighted statements is false Clinger. You've essentially confused a NULL point in a line or a collection of lines as the "beginning and ending" of the line(s). You really don't have the first clue about basic EM theory. The fact that you're STILL trying to defend this nonsense says VOLUMES Clinger. You're only burying yourself deeper and deeper.

:eek:
 
FYI Clinger, only PHYSICAL THINGS "create" (not begin or end) magnetic fields, things like solid magnets and THINGS like moving charged particles, physical things like your the poles of your experiment. These PHYSICAL THINGS create magnetic fields. Vacuums and null points are physically incapable of CREATING, let alone "beginning or ending" magnetic fields. The field strength (line strength in your vernacular) simply fades to zero at that NULL point, the lines don't "begin" at the NULL or "end" at the null. No single line or collection of lines begins or ends at it's NULL point! Holy Cow!
 
Last edited:
That implies that the topology of the magnetic field lines must change as the current within the north/south rods is increased from zero to 1000 amperes.

As long as I'm helping you out....

In part 4 (without plasma) that would be called magnetic flux and that would create changes in the magnetic flux density in that region and everywhere in the field. The field topology will change. Without plasma however, nothing PHYSICAL is going to "reconnect" anywhere near that X. There's nothing TO reconnect yet. No E field will be induced without a plasma, and no electrical discharges are going to take place yet because you don't have a single electron to your name yet.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_flux

Again however, every single B "line" (it's actually a full field, not a real line) remains intact and continuous. Not one of them originates or terminates at the x.
 
Last edited:
Well Clinger...

As much as I'd love to see you 'graduate' from basic EM theory and move on to plasma physics, mostly so I can find out if you ever come out of the closet and admit that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares, I can't pass you in good conscience. Sorry. You're welcome to try again, but you may not proceed to part 5 yet.
 
MM: I have called you a liar becuase you have lied as documented in this post

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7734001&postcount=4556

It's hard to buy your claim about the "true haters" bit while you're calling me a liar and PS is calling me a "fraud" no less. Holy Cow!
I have (and will continue to) call you a liar while you continue to lie by quote mining (Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge!).

I have (and will continue to) call you a liar while you continue to lie about my attitude to you. I do not hate you.

I pity you for the state of ignorance of basic physics that you are demonstrating:
Michael Mozina's ignorance of high school science (the right hand rule)
Michael Mozina's delusion that permeability is inductance!
Michael Mozina's delusion about "*RECONNECTIONS* per unit length").

I pity you for your inability to learn physics, e.g. as in W.D. Clinger's very clear posts on magnetic reconnection in vacuum:
a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 4




  1. Part 1 and its erratum used one of Maxwell's equations to derive the magnetic field B around a current-carrying rod.
  2. Part 2 expressed that magnetic field in both cylindrical and Cartesian coordinates
  3. Part 3 demonstrated that the magnetic field around four current-carrying rods reproduces both of the figures in J W Dungey's 1958 paper, figure 3a in the survey paper by Yamada et al, and the still figure in Wikipedia's current article on magnetic reconnection.
  4. Part 3 also showed that magnetic lines can begin or end at a neutral point, which I later proved in more detail.

I pity you for your inability to understand the electrical discharges do not cause solar flares and your obsession with the obsolete use of the term 'electrical discharge' in magnetic reconnection: Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma

ETA
I pity you for your dependence on 'I see bunnies in the clouds' logic (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7753306#post7753306).
In another thread: the delusional nature of Michael Mozina's fantasy about the TRACE RD 171A movie!

I pity you for the arrogance of thinking that you know more about specific solar images than a scientist studying them:
the delusional nature of Michael Mozina's fantasy about the Kosovichev movie! (debunked by Dr. Kosovichev)
I applaud your honesty in quoting Dr. Kosovichev.

I pity you for not understanding that you are misrepresenting (to be charitable) Birkeland's work: Michael Mozina's delusions about Birkeland's work (citing his work on brass balls in support of an iron sun idea is especially amusing. And MM: Citations for Birkeland and solar energy sources.

I pity you for not being able to understand the magnetic reconnection is supported by observations:
Observational Signatures of Magnetic Reconnection as of 2003
and
Eric Priest, Terry Forbes, Magnetic Reconnection, Cambridge University Press 2000, ISBN 0-521-48179-1, contents and sample chapter online
Reconnection provides an elegant, and so far the only, explanation for the motion of chromospheric ribbons and flare loops during solar flares. At the same time, it also accounts for the enormous energy release in solar flares. The ejection of magnetic flux from the Sun during coronal mass ejections and prominence eruptions necessarily requires reconnection; otherwise, the magnetic flux in interplanetary space would build up indefinitely. Reconnection has also been proposed as a mechanism for the heating of solar and stellar coronae to extremely high temperatures
(my emphasis added)
​
 
Last edited:
As much as I'd love to see you 'graduate' from basic EM theory and move on to plasma physics, mostly so I can find out if you ever come out of the closet and admit that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares, I can't pass you in good conscience. Sorry. You're welcome to try again, but you may not proceed to part 5 yet.
And once again we get your your obsession with the obsolete use of the term 'electrical discharge' in magnetic reconnection: Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma

When W.D. Clinger gets to magnetic reconnection in plasma (a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 4 states in the next part), he will use the modern terminology that you are displaying an ignorance of. So there will be large current densities. There will never be a 'admission' of electrical discharges in plasma because he is not dumb enough to use Dungey's obsolete term.

And the last sentence is just stupid - in order to look at the large current densities in plasma, W.D. Clinger has to go onto magnetic reconnection in plasma :jaw-dropp !
There is no current density in magnetic reconnection in vacuum. The only currents are the ones in the rods that are applied in the experiment (constant at 1000 amperes in parts 1-3, varied in part 4).
 
And once again we get your your obsession with the obsolete use of the term 'electrical discharge'

That has to be the single most pathetic rationalization I've ever heard and that's saying something. I've talked to a LOT of creationists in my day. Exactly how was an electrical discharge in 1958 different from an electrical discharge in 2011?
 
Last edited:
MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0

Yes, I know. Haters always continue to attack the individual. That's why they are called "haters" in the first place RC. :)
No, you are deluded. I call you a liar because you lie.
I pity you for you many displays of ignorance, the commitment to not learn and your delusions.

I am not attacking you - I am pointing out the things that you, yourself have displayed in this forum. It would be very easy for you to fix this - stop displaying them! For example, demonstrate that you can learn.

Here's an easy thing to learn, MM
What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field is zero?
I will even spoon feed you the path to the answer: First look up a definition of magnetic field lines. Then see how their areal density varies with magnetic field intensity. Now put B=0.
 
That has to be the single most pathetic rationalization I've every heard and that's saying something. I've talked to a LOT of creationists in my day. Exactly how was an electrical discharge in 1958 different from an electrical discharge in 2011?
has to be the single most pathetic bit of ignorance I've every heard and that's saying something. I've talked to a LOT of physics cranks in my day.
The stupidity of thinking that I said that the process was different in 1958 that today is obvious - it is still magnetic reconnection.

It is that I am trying (obviously in vain) to stop you displaying your ignorance of physics by using an obsolete term (Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma).
This is as ignorant as someone calling an electron an cathode ray or a corpuscle (From Thompson's Corpusles to the Electron).
 
No, you are deluded. I call you a liar..

You call me a liar because you're a hater and that's about all you do know how to do. You certainly don't know squat about physics. You couldn't spot Clinger's BUSH-LEAGUE mistakes. You couldn't and didn't help him in any way. Your sole purpose in this thread is to spew hatred. That's your game.
 
No RC. You don't even know enough to know what is a lie and what is the truth. You don't take the time to find out either. Haters are all alike. The topic changes, but the hater behaviors are exactly the same.
Yes I do: MM: I have called you a liar becuase you have lied as documented in this post
  • Quote mining is a lie.
  • Claiming to know what I think when I have explicitly told you that I do not think that is a lie.
  • Calling me a hater is a lie.You need to call me a pitier of Michael Mozina.
Maybe you will understand this if I put it in your dialect:

No MM. You don't even know enough to know what is a fantasy and what is the science. You don't take the time to find out either. Physics cranks are all alike. The topic changes, but the physics crank behaviors are exactly the same.
  • Displays of ignorance of science
  • A determination not to learn science.
  • Fantasies about science
  • Going off on rants when their fantasies are challenged with actual science.
  • Obsessions with semantics rather then looking at the science.
  • A refusal to even look at questions which might teach them about science.
MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0
I do not expect you answer this given your record of ignorance about science in this thread alone and the dozens of questions that you have ignored in other threads over the years.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0

Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge takes place *IN* plasma.
You are really determined to record your inability to read.
Peratt gives no definition or examples of an electrical discharge *IN* plasma. Section 1.5 is about the generation of plasma using electrical discharges, e.g. in lightning.

Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge!
P.S.
MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0
 
MM: Plese do not lie about me denying Dungey's 'electrical discharge'

You're latching on to ONE EXAMPLE of *ONE KIND* of AN electrical discharge that takes place in the cosmos and using to that try to deny the fact that Dungey's electrical discharge in a flare ever happened. :)
Oh dear - almost 2 lies in one post :eye-poppi!

The implied lie: Peratt does give examples of ordinary electrical discharges that are impossible in plasma because they need the breakdown of a dielectric medium. But Peratt never gives any EXAMPLE of ANY electrical discharge that takes place in cosmic plasma. Section 1.5 does not have even have any non-terrestrial EXAMPLES.
The lie: I have never denied that fact that Dungey's 'electrical discharge' in a flare ever happened. I have read his paper and mentioned his obsolete usage of the term many times before:
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (10 months and counting)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection!
    8th November 2011
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom